What a difference a week makes. There is nothing intrinsicly wrong with Keeping it Tight (KIT) ? Fergie will be berating his players for not KIT.
The trick is how you approach the other bit of it, how you get your 1 or 4. You can fluke 1 or 2 and Fergie might say we had 4 flukes, but hand on heart it's pretty hard to fluke 4... you've got to buy the tickets to win the raffle.
When Moyes gets it right, especially the initial team selection and then subs (Hibbo vs City) the more Moyes inclined (MMI) then berate the less Moyes inclined (LMI)... and the reverse happens when circumstances change, as they did on Sunday. It's an interchangeable batton to whack each other with.
The MMI seem happy with the status quo of KITAP1... swings and roundabouts, 7th or whatever 50-something points and wonder "Why all the fuss, why change?"
The LMI are driven crazy by the odd glimpse of how good it could be, the inconsistantcy, mostly thought to be self-inflicted and think "Why can't the bugger(s) do it, or at least set out to do it, EVERY week???"
So, Dave Wilson not withstanding, it's still no good to, of your own choosing, sitback at 1-0 and try and play rope a dope; again WE have to be lucky ALL the time, they just need the odd mistake.
While United are most times a better team than Liverpool, they are not the force they were 3 or 4 yrs ago. But the two games just gone are still pretty much for comparison terms Apples vs Apples.
So why the two vastly different performances; is it "Shit happens" vs "We had a good day at the office"?
Is it "Can't" or "Won't"?
Will the Real David Moyes STAY STOOD UP.
And put one of those fingers on each hand UP.
And be proud to be outta your mind and outta control.
And one more time, loud as you can, how does it go?
"Cause I'M THE REAL DAVY, yes I'M THE REAL DAVY!!!"
And maybe the real Davy will STAY stood up. (For more than one or two games...)
Derek Thomas, Posted 23/04/2012 at 02:12:15
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
850 Posted 23/04/2012 at 15:04:04
Maybe it's also because Man U and Liverpool couldn't be more different. Man U let you play football, they're normally better than you so will outscore you but players like Scholes and Carrick give you room to play.
Liverpool don't; they run all over teams and suffocate them to death. Suarez aside, everyone of their team are 6 foot, fast, and built like machines. Why else do talented players like Maxi and Bellamy only get cameos?
I worry whenever they play big teams because teams like Man U and Arsenal try and play with the ball and Liverpool just smash them off it and go on the counter. We didn't have the pace or power to compete with them on Saturday and with Pienaar out and Arteta no longer on the books we don't have the guile to negate this.
We could never beat the Chelsea of old for this same reason and only beat them this season because they played more expansively, allowing us to play a bit more. It's a clash of styles.
Liverpool get undone by it when playing lesser teams who just get men behind the ball and boot it long (and don't pass back), then they can't break them down. We're much better at that but then suffer against teams like Liverpool. In an ideal world, you need a team like the Arsenal of old who combined power with flair.
881 Posted 23/04/2012 at 16:51:37
For me the moment of the match was when it went from being 5-2 (and game over) to 4-3 (and game on) in the space of 30 seconds. Evra contrives to dive and head against the post, and, having seen us waste 2-3 chances to clear the ball when Welbeck scored, I watched agog as we played the ball out from the back, up to their end, and not a Utd player touched the ball until Fellaini was challenged and the ball broke for Jelavic to slot for 4-3.
For me that was when the players believed they could get something, and Utd started to doubt themselves.
883 Posted 23/04/2012 at 17:11:01
926 Posted 23/04/2012 at 19:31:52
012 Posted 24/04/2012 at 02:31:33
That game probably gave a lot of fans a really good feeling about going to Wembley only to be let down badly by the tortoise going back into his shell.
We don't do the backs to the wall defending as well as we did a couple of seasons ago, instead we always seem to make mistakes or get beaten by deflections in a crowded box. Yet against Sunderland and United we have shown what can be achieved with the exact same players.
014 Posted 24/04/2012 at 03:29:16
019 Posted 24/04/2012 at 05:04:52
It is a problem when KIT is your aim before a ball is kicked.
021 Posted 24/04/2012 at 05:17:10
All in all even if you DO approach the game in the right manner, it can still bite you in the bum. Untd so nearly made it 5-2 but hit the post and we, without a untd player getting a proper touch on the ball, went down the other end and scored, 4-3 and it's untd brown trouser time.
2) Re A League Final, Perth were robbed penalty-wise. My 1st reaction was ( watching on tv )penalty, but on a closer look...Dive ! That the trouble, on a closer look which the reff didn't have. You see it every week in the AFL, reff draws a box in the air 2mins later ( max) it's all sorted, they wasted 2 mins protesting. But in all honesty with 10 men and 6 yellow cards you would've run out of players by the end of extra time.
032 Posted 24/04/2012 at 08:43:41
'Keep it tight' (KIT) is a valid and reasonable manner to approach SOME games
'Going for it' (GFI) is a better formula for other matches
The great manager alters his approach for different games and will often play 2 up front (or even 3) as and when the situation dictates
Anyone that says Moyes is a bad manager is an idiot. Anyone that thinks he's a great manager cannot see what might have been.
Moyes is a very good manager, make no mistake about that. But he is NOT a great manager. He is not flexible enough nor adaptive enough. He has one default outlook and that is invariably we are underdogs and invariably we need to Keep it Tight
I hope he can become a GREAT manager by more readily altering his approach to matches and build a superiority complex against those over the park.
They may have spent more but we are better than them. We should be proving it
089 Posted 24/04/2012 at 13:41:38
Now living in West Oz I cannot describe the locals anger over that non penalty. I would not though call it a dive. The Brisbane striker swung a foot at the ball missed it by several feet and his momentum spun him off balance.
The Australian authorities should hang their collective heads in shame for picking a home town ref with a missus works as a publicist for Brisbane FC.
The farce continued before a 55,000 crowd and millions of viewers when MotM was presented to the wrong player. Honestly, you couldn't make it up.
205 Posted 24/04/2012 at 21:19:32
I always had you down as an older fella. I weren't expecting you to be quoting Eminem lyrics on TW.
224 Posted 24/04/2012 at 22:26:46
226 Posted 24/04/2012 at 22:38:22
Marshall Mathers...yo bitch It would be like signing a new player * gobs on Kenwright's onion rings *
232 Posted 24/04/2012 at 22:49:16
And never mind Eminem. What about Essiness? Sandie Shaw won the Eurovision Song Contest that very night in 1967, I remember sitting through it after getting back from Nottingham.
Going to bed now, I need my rest!
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.