This article may have been recategorised and is therefore no longer available at this URL.

You can try to find the updated link in the article archive.

Share article:

Reader Comments (57)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kunal Desai
1 Posted 08/01/2017 at 07:19:30
"The board getting targets quickly" – That would require a total shakeup at board leve, Ken. I would not get any hopes of 3,4 or 5 players arriving in this window by those responsible for recruitment.

Have no expectations and you won't be disappointed. January is also a difficult window to bring players in.

Dan Egerton
2 Posted 08/01/2017 at 07:40:05
Highlights

http://www.fullmatchesandshows.com/2017/01/07/Everton-vs-leicester-city-highlights-2/

Dave Abrahams
3 Posted 08/01/2017 at 09:14:14
After the game, the anger and upset didn't last long for me, there was no real surprise that we had lost again with the present squad.

I think Koeman is right to demand we get some players in quickly but think he should have a look at what he is achieving with the squad; not a lot I admit, but to expect an 18-year-old lad to do the bulk of the midfield defensive work was a lot to ask of Tom Davies.

Cleverley should have been used at some point of the game and Gareth taken off after we had scored, his legs have gone, he struggled throughout the match.

No team can have THREE players in the side who pull out of fifty fifty balls, Deulofeu, Barkley and Mirallas and to add insult to their performances they all gave silly petty fouls away enabling Leicester to waste time taking the resultant free kicks.

Like you, Ken, I'll be back next week for more, it will be a long job getting Everton to where we want to be but, with Mr Moshiri running things, we will eventually get there.

Thanks for your report; as usual, spot on.

Geoff Williams
4 Posted 08/01/2017 at 10:56:44
I have absolutely no faith in the manager. It took Martinez a season and a half to make me feel as disillusioned as I am now after four months of Koeman.
Rick Tarleton
5 Posted 08/01/2017 at 11:37:11
Ken's review is as ever fair, balanced and reasoned.

I feel Koeman thinks he was offered a far bigger budget than the amounts now being talked about and he's making his point. We fans tend to talk about an extra £50 million as a bagatelle, a gentleman on Radio Merseyside when I was driving home said £50 million's not enough. What is? We could have billions and pair Ronaldo and Messi up front, but it's fantasy world.

I like one quote of Ken's in particular, "However, I do wonder if our manager could not have been expected to get more out of the players he inherited. I understand he has a preferred way of playing but could he not have adjusted it a little to find a way with what he has got?"

Exactly! The art of management in any field is to get the best out of your workforce, not just long for a dream team. If Koeman spends big and it works, well and good, as long as it doesn't incur excessive debt, but if it doesn't work under this manager, do we get a new one and give him too an unlimited pot?

Moshiri's funds are finite not infinite and we need a new ground and a new business plan which are very expensive. I just wonder what Koeman was promised and what he expects.

Dave Williams
6 Posted 08/01/2017 at 11:50:05
Very valid point from Dave there about us having too many who pull out of a tackle. We also have too many who only perform when they feel like it the same three players – and no team can carry players who are like that – Chelsea couldn't do it last season and we won't do it this.

Rightly or wrongly Ron has decided it is his way or nothing and has persisted in playing a pressing game unsuited to all but 2 or 3 of the squad rather than adapt the style to the players. I think this is wrong but he clearly wants to reshape the squad so it can play the way he wants and he doesn't look like he will compromise.

Looks to me like we are at an important point of his tenure and it reminds me a bit of HK2 and Joe Royle where the board refused to back them in the market so they quit. Rons anger yesterday appears directed at the haggling over the fee for Schneiderlin which I can understand. His buys so far have been iffy – Gana is excellent, Bolasie unfortunately injured with the jury out, Williams strangely up and down and likewise Stek.

Ron appears to be blaming his underwhelming summer window on a lack of preparation so this one is crucial. Will the board back him to the extent he wants and if they do will he then establish a system of playing which is good to watch and shows some guts and abrasiveness to really stamp some authority over other teams and as much as anything go to Anfield without fear?

Barry Pearce
7 Posted 08/01/2017 at 12:03:50
Good balanced report as usual, Ken.

Likewise by a few others, that I believe most open-minded Evertonians feel the same way about, with what's going on at the moment.

John Raftery
8 Posted 08/01/2017 at 12:17:29
Ken, you have hit the nail on the head regarding Koeman and his failure to get more out of the players than he has done. We all know the squad is low on quality, pace and energy but Leicester were there for the taking yesterday. Too much safe passing in the first half played into their hands allowing a significantly weakened team to settle into the game.

In the minutes after we scored, the alarm bells were ringing with our team strung out all over the pitch showing a lack of organisation, application and concentration. While the players share some of the blame for that surely the manager cannot escape culpability.

It is his job and that of his coaching team to drill into the players some simple methods for maintaining focus in a game in which they have just taken the lead. We want to hear less from the manager bemoaning the inadequacy of players and see more action to remedy some of the weaknesses.

For the longer term, I am uneasy, we will spend many millions strengthening the squad but still under deliver with a manager who thus far seems to lack the motivational skills of his counterparts in the top six.

At the moment he can to an extent hide behind the lack of ability among his players but once the Board have spent serious money on new signings the pressure will be on Koeman to deliver significant improvement on the pitch. Winning two consecutive matches seems beyond him and the team at present.

Patrick Murphy
9 Posted 08/01/2017 at 12:35:49
Gordon Lee said a couple of relevant things, which perhaps still resonate today, on a recent visit to Goodison:-

“You have good days, bad days, ups and downs. But Everton are still a stable, sensible club.

“They always were and I think that's important with so much at stake these days. If you make too many mistakes it can be disastrous – but they have maintained a good standard. It's still a great club, it's still one of the best. Whether they can marry that with being successful against the big money people I don't know.

Talking about his criteria for picking his teams, Gordon said,

“When I used to pick the team on Friday night, I'd go to bed and know exactly how nine of them would do.

“If I knew how nine players were going to do I'd know I'd have a good chance. If I only had seven I knew about, and four I wasn't sure about, I'd be struggling.

“I'd think ‘Would I like him to marry my daughter?' or ‘If I was in a rowing boat and it was leaking would he save me?

“You'd get an answer to your question. Players like Mickey Lyons … he would dive in and save you. But I look at some of them now and they have so much money, they can do what they want.”

Lee returns to Goodison

Derek Thomas
10 Posted 08/01/2017 at 12:47:53
Well done as usual, Ken. Another poster stated that there was a 4th man – Holgate, who pulled out of a 50/50, was promptly berated by Koeman and didn't come out for the 2nd half... anybody confirm this? – not the didn't play the 2nd half thing, that's fact.

Deulofeu was back to his 'first season/best' form, with a move in the offing up goes the effort, most strange.

When The Stek first played he looked the almost the real deal, people marvelled at the bargain, then the form dipped... or was it the effort and level of application that dipped.

2 cases (more, much more, by the looks) of – Not can't, but won't??

Tony Hill
11 Posted 08/01/2017 at 12:53:40
Very interesting link thanks, Patrick. Except that it has got me annoyed again about that semi-final.

I have a lot of time for Lee and what he says about having 9 players committed in any given match echoes something very similar said to me by Billy Bingham a long time ago: that if you had 8 or 9 players of decent talent who were prepared to play for each other then you had the makings of a trophy-winning side.

I suspect the numbers in the present set up don't quite reach that threshold.

Graham Mockford
12 Posted 08/01/2017 at 13:00:10
Derek Thomas

I think the incident you refer to was more a misjudgement on Holgate's part rather than pulling out of a 50/50.

Coleman was free to his right. As Holgate and the Leicester player came together it was probably 70/30 in his favour. He gambled on being able to dink it away and free Coleman rather than going full blooded into the tackle. Unfortunately he made the wrong choice and lost the tackle.

I think his general lack of effectiveness as an attacking option was more the reason he was replaced and it was a good call.

Replacing Barkley at 2-1 was much more difficult to comprehend given that the game was passing Barry by.

Dick Fearon
13 Posted 08/01/2017 at 13:07:28
Another spot on report, Ken.

Your palpable dismay at the performance or lack of mirrors that of a growing Blues army and Koeman expressed as much himself. What concerns me is his oft stated Incomprehension of why things are amiss. He is paid handsomely to deal with such matters.

Also of concern is his complete dependence upon the incoming of very expensive signings. If those signings are not forthcoming, what then?

Jay Wood
14 Posted 08/01/2017 at 13:08:37
I can't comment on the game as I've not seen it, not even highlights, so thanks for the report as always, Ken.

Thanks also to Patrick and the link to the Gordon Lee story. He makes some good observations about sending out teams knowing what you are going to get out of 'x' number of players and how that determines what you are likely to get out of the game.

As Tony @ 11 observed, "I suspect the numbers in the present set up don't quite reach that threshold."

Never nice to have all cup interest for the season done and dusted in January.

Darren Hind
16 Posted 08/01/2017 at 13:09:54
Very fair report.

Derek, That incident caused quite a stir around me. My take on it was that it was not quite 50-50, Holgate would have being going for a ball that wasn't his. I think he just didn't want to sell himself by diving in.

I didn't notice Koeman's reaction, but having a half-time drink, My lads mate said he wasn't happy and didn't think we would be seeing him in the second half.

Andrew Cunningham
17 Posted 08/01/2017 at 13:17:12
This team are starting to get on my nerves. How about trying this lads?

You get paid very well ,much more than the average punter. How about putting in a full shift, I know it must be hard running around for ninety minutes kicking a ball but...

You lot make politicians look honest.

Alan Bodell
18 Posted 08/01/2017 at 13:40:17
The true positive out of this season so far is that at last we have the money to get ourselves a decent squad and Koeman will have been working on that from quite some time back. It obviously wont happen overnight but if we had this squad and 'no' money we'd probably be down come May.

I'm looking forward to an almost total clearout and replacements that at least look like they give a fuck.

Phil Walling
19 Posted 08/01/2017 at 14:00:38
The problem is that there is no guarantee Koeman will be any better at inspiring his winter signings than he has been with those he got in the summer and the ones he inherited.

Holgate was sacrificed to prove his point about the U23s and will likely never be seen again as he gets Moshiri to 'do a Villa'by blowing a fortune on unknowns and other clubs' failures without realising the real problem is the managers he employs.

Trouble ahead, I fear, however much is spent in the window!

Gerard Carey
20 Posted 08/01/2017 at 14:10:16
This is probably Koeman's biggest managerial job to date. Is he up to it? At Southampton, 6th or 7th was being a success. Rightly (or wrongly), Everton expect better: a Cup win or Champions League place is what would be seen as successful. And then to grow on from there.

For some reason, as this season has been progressing, Koeman's style of management has reminded me of Roy Keane's management career. Keane at Sunderland often berated his players as not being good enough etc etc..., same at Ipswich. Maybe a level lower than what we expect at Everton but, at some stage, Koeman has to show he can manage.

Most of his players are internationals... time for Ron to start managing. Roy Keane was a great player but a poor manager; Ron was a great player, time will tell about the other!
Jay Wood
21 Posted 08/01/2017 at 14:10:37
Phil @ 19

"Holgate was sacrificed to prove his point about the U23s and will likely never be seen again."

Out of interest Phil, do you genuinely believe some of the things you post, or do you just write them to get a reaction?

Phil Walling
23 Posted 08/01/2017 at 14:12:54
Jay, the proof of the pudding, etc etc.
Michael Lynch
24 Posted 08/01/2017 at 14:14:05
I've had no beef with Ron so far, on the basis that he's clearly a top manager who has a decent track record, realistic aspirations to manage at the very highest level, and has inherited a directionless squad of mostly ageing players. But I do find myself nodding my head when I read Ken's reasonable and measured criticisms at the end of this report.

Yes, we need new players – many new players – but I would expect Koeman to be getting a little more out of the squad he inherited, and be astute enough to tweak the style to do that. On the other hand, while we all tend to agree that we've looked pretty shite all season, we are still 7th... which ain't bad considering how much we've all slagged off the team?

Whatever our feelings, I think it's pretty clear (and correct) that Koeman is going to be given at least another year and two more transfer windows before the board start assessing where we are.

Alan J Thompson
25 Posted 08/01/2017 at 14:20:47
Tried to follow the game via BBC Radio but the commentator and Leon Osman seemed more interested in having a conversation about anything other than what was happening on the pitch.

For Lukaku's goal, Osman was interrupted in his assessment of how important a new ground would be. For the equalizer, he was going on about Moyes and, for the winner, his worst loss, 4-0 across the park but it wasn't his fault as he only came on as sub.

Which brings me to my point. In your report, Ken, you refer to Deulofeu as "reverting to the frustrated over-playing man". It was mentioned on radio that Leicester brought on Fuchs to double mark as Chilwell(?) was getting a roasting off Geri. Was that the case?

Alan Bodell
26 Posted 08/01/2017 at 14:24:26
Phil (#19), I don't think the players he signs will need the inspiring that those he inherited seem to. Players naturally are drawn to those that believe in their ability, so let's give him time to build 'his' team' as we surely now have enough wonga to do that.
Phil Walling
27 Posted 08/01/2017 at 14:37:16
I share that hope with you, Alan. Trouble is, hope is all we've been fed on for the last 30 years!
Ken Buckley
28 Posted 08/01/2017 at 14:51:11
Alan J @ 25,

He had no trouble outpacing his markers; it was what he did next that infuriated. When he kept it simple, we scored. When he didn't, we lost the chance.

Alan J Thompson
29 Posted 08/01/2017 at 14:56:24
Ken (#28); Thanks for that.
Jay Wood
30 Posted 08/01/2017 at 15:04:34
Phil @23

"Jay, the proof of the pudding etc etc."

So, it is your categoric belief that as long as Koeman is at the club, Holgate will never again be selected for the 1st team and similarly, the current crop of U-23 players will also never pull on the royal blue jersey for the 1st team?

Thanks for clearing that up.

Let's revisit this at the end of the season and see if you are correct on the times the likes of Holgate, Davies and Calvert-Lewin (amongst others) are selected by Koeman.

Dave Pritchard
31 Posted 08/01/2017 at 15:06:27
The absence of any fighting spirit once we went behind was very noticeable to me. No player seemed to be urging the others on and we never had a period of sustained pressure which you would expect from a home team trying to stay in the Cup.

This lot are not a team but a bunch of individuals who don't seem to care very much at all.

Graham Mockford
32 Posted 08/01/2017 at 15:09:55
Alan J Thompson

It is traditional to say WTF Osman.

There is something quite reassuring about Leon getting stick on a matchday thread even after he's retired.

Patrick Murphy
33 Posted 08/01/2017 at 15:54:30
Now that I've come to terms with yet another trophyless season, I do hope that Leicester City go on to win the FA Cup in May. I'm not a great lover of the Foxes, however, I can't remember the Champions of England being so disrespected by the TV companies et al.

When rich clubs are at home to minnows, they shouldn't be covered live on TV en masse should they? Surely the reigning champions would expect to be covered? Anyhow, good luck to the Foxes and shame on the media for ignoring them, regardless of how good or bad their form has generally been this season.

Alan Bodell
34 Posted 08/01/2017 at 16:00:25
Graham (#32),

I don't know what goes on in some Blues heads, the lad I go the game with never could admit Ossie had a good game but then he wanted us to sign Kenwyn Jones some years back and now he's on about Wilfred Zaha.

I guess that's what we Blues do, he doesn't rate Besic either and I love the guy so we do well to stay out of the A & E most weeks.

Christopher Timmins
35 Posted 08/01/2017 at 16:11:30
Folks, this is going to take time and the manager and Steve Walsh deserve time and support in the work their are undertaking.

After every game on this forum, it's either "all duck" or "no dinner".

Darren Hind
36 Posted 08/01/2017 at 16:13:38
Phil Walling,

I think the fact that Williams is pulling heavier caravans every time we see him, Funes Mori's decision-making and distribution is still lamentable, and Jags seems to have fallen off a cliff will ensure Holgate will play again.

I'm still wondering why he was substituted yesterday; Williams knows the counter attacks are coming, but seems unable to do anything about it. Funes Mori's feet are quick enough, but his brain is miles behind.

the heart of our defence is a dream for counter-attacking teams. How can we possibly play a pressing game when we are in deep shit the minute they leave a bit of grass behind them?

Clive Mitchell
37 Posted 08/01/2017 at 18:24:31
Interesting. In the game I saw, Everton huffed a little but were flat and uninspired, never looked like scoring and were at no point looking secure at the back. Deulofeu provided the only sparks of real potency and excitement all day.

The better team won fairly easily and had at least six players who would start for us every week. Holgate's performance made it no surprise at all that he was substituted at half-time, whether or not he bottled that tackle.

We've made a big mistake with Williams and Funes Mori isn't up to it. And it's hard to think of anything positive to date that can be put down to the fact that Koeman is our manager.

Pete Edwards
39 Posted 08/01/2017 at 18:37:36
Does anyone think that Koeman is getting the most out of the squad though?

Feels to me that too many of them are simply not as good as people maybe thought or think they are themselves.

It's been said a million times and will be said another million but a big clearout is needed over this and the summer windows.

Rick Tarleton
40 Posted 08/01/2017 at 19:35:43
It is a fact universally acknowledged that a team in need of players in the January window will find it very hard to do business. Koeman's noises are making it even harder. Clubs do not usually want to sell half-way through a season and if they do sell it will be at inflated prices.

Koeman's job is to get the best out of the present squad, not constantly moan at the the quality of the players he inherited.

Mike Owen
41 Posted 08/01/2017 at 19:42:27
At least the Queen has come out in sympathy, wearing her Everton hat and coat to church this morning.

Not St Luke's... The one at Sandringham.

Ian Hollingworth
42 Posted 08/01/2017 at 19:44:32
The club is riddled with losers from top to bottom. It has been for years and this is why we are constantly let down. We are very nice but nobody in the football world thinks we are competitors for anything.

We need Kenwright and Elstone out of the club and hopefully replaced by hard nosed tough businessmen preferably hand-picked by the Russian guy who pulls Moshis puppet strings.

That then needs to be followed by recruiting some players who are winners and actually give a shit. Too many words for too many years and zero action.

Brent Stephens
43 Posted 08/01/2017 at 20:20:51
I wonder if Holgate was subbed because he was injured yesterday? I noticed him first-half indicating an injury of some sort.
Jim Wilson
44 Posted 08/01/2017 at 20:38:20
Koeman is shite. Changing the team around and formations (back to 3 at back after Chelsea fiasco) is so naive, blaming players all the time and having no clue of how to get the best out of a decent squad.

A great impression of Moyes or worse with his dull and primitive football. He must go, and now is the ideal time to bring in a bright positive manager who has half a season to get this club moving in the right direction and ready for next season.

Brent Stephens
45 Posted 08/01/2017 at 20:51:58
"Changing team around and formations (back to 3 at back after Chelsea fiasco) is so naive".

I thought we'd reverted to 4 at the back before shipping the 2 goals.

Joe O'Brien
46 Posted 08/01/2017 at 21:43:27
I'm losing patience with Koeman. It remains to be seen what type of owner Moshiri is, is he one to wield the axe quickly? Kenwright is not one to be sure.

Howe would be my pick, but I don't think he's the high profile manager Moshiri would go for, neither would Unsy.

Jim Wilson
47 Posted 08/01/2017 at 22:30:27
Sorry Brent, I should have said ...and then back to 4 at the back.
Changing formations before games and during is a disastrous tactic, that is the point.
John Raftery
48 Posted 08/01/2017 at 22:41:57
Jim - We played with three at the back at Leicester and won 2-0.
Peter Mills
49 Posted 08/01/2017 at 22:50:06
Brent (#43), you are right. Holgate hurt himself whilst in the Park End penalty area; it looked like a twist or strain.
Dennis Stevens
50 Posted 08/01/2017 at 22:50:18
I'm afraid the cynic in me wonders whether Koeman is starting to lay the foundations for his own voluntary departure a little further down the line, citing lack of support at Board level as his reason for jumping ship.
Brent Stephens
51 Posted 08/01/2017 at 22:51:41
Jim - got it, thanks.

Peter, I've seen nothing since so guess Holgate being taken off might have been a precaution.

Joe O'Brien
52 Posted 08/01/2017 at 23:13:09
Dennis (#50), there won't be any voluntary departure from Koeman. All managers these days will hang on until they get the boot to ensure they'd get fully compensated. No way will he walk.
Dennis Stevens
53 Posted 08/01/2017 at 23:54:59
Joe (#52) – I think that rather depends on their long-term goal. Failure at Everton resulting in the sack might be more lucrative in the medium term, but walking away from an impossible task might be more beneficial in the long run.
Joe O'Brien
54 Posted 09/01/2017 at 00:08:29
Maybe so, Dennis, I would hope you're right, but what contract is he on? I actually don't know myself – could be the bones of £20-30 mil to walk away from. Sacked managers get jobs so easily it amazes me, big Sam being the obvious one.
Dennis Stevens
55 Posted 09/01/2017 at 00:29:44
Aye Joe, very true – but it may also depend on which jobs they're hoping to get in the future. Anyway, hopefully all this cynical hypothesising will be rendered moot by the considerable success we will enjoy during Ron's tenure!
Joe O'Brien
56 Posted 09/01/2017 at 01:17:25
Hope so, Dennis, mate... that's what we all want.
Mick Davies
57 Posted 09/01/2017 at 01:43:50
Michael @ 24, I've had no beef with Ron so far, on the basis that he's clearly a top manager who has a decent track record...

Premier League Manager of the Month: September 2014, January 2015, January 2016.

Alan J Thompson
58 Posted 09/01/2017 at 04:45:42
Graham (#32); Sorry, you most likely didn't have to listen to BBC Radio but World Tennis Fe..... sorry, WTF Osman, interestingly, said that he had many a heated argument with Lukaku about his efforts on and off the ball and on another occasion came to blows with Fellaini.

Obviously punched above his weight off the pitch.

Bob Parrington
59 Posted 09/01/2017 at 05:40:23
On the pitch we have very close to no changes of personnel compared with last season. So, how can we expect wholesale changes in attitude and hence results?

Koeman inherited the lazee-boy attitude inspired by Martinez. As I've said previously, only wholesale change of players will get rid of the rotten attitude.

Peter Murray
60 Posted 09/01/2017 at 12:11:57
I agree 100% Ian – being a totally frustrated 60-year blue... I just hope I'm still breathing when the Redexcretia are relegated and we consistently "turn up" for our matches – some hopes!!! I always believed they only can play as well as we let them!!!

The Board are rubbish & nothing nowadays changes my mind on this, with or without our new muscle – especially along with Coronation Street Bill, get rid please– how can you possibly tolerate this obvious charlatan as a business person???

COYB - please?


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads


, placement: 'Below Article Thumbnails', target_type: 'mix' });