Skip to Main Content
Members:   Log In  |  Sign Up
NewsRumoursReportsVideoTalking PointsArticles
Text Size:  A  A  A
Season 2011-12
The Mail Bag

Pienaar, come or go?

 17 Comments: First  |  Last

I?m just wondering what the next move is going to be with regards to Steven Pienaar.

David Moyes is in a difficult situation: he never should have sold the guy in the first place. Spurs' style of football currently doesn?t suite him, he needs to be surrounded by ball players.

It would make perfect business sense for Moyes to push for another loan deal, but I?m almost sure Spurs would not entertain the suggestion. My guess is they?ll sell for about £4.5M.

Then there?s the salary issue as well. What he?s currently earning at Spurs he can easily get elsewhere. Should he sign for us, this would cause havoc within the camp with regards to salary structures.

Any way this is looked at, Everton ultimately looses. Questions will need to be asked: Why was he not given an improved contract in the first place instead of now having to cough up a wage increase and massive transfer fee?

Ricardo Humphries, Cape Town, South Africa     Posted 25/04/2012 at 06:57:39

back Return to the Mail Bag  :  Add your Comments back


Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Jon Ferguson
376   Posted 25/04/2012 at 14:28:35

Report abuse

I think Pienaar has been excellent for us since he came back. He runs his heart out, looks for the pass, keeps the ball moving and creates chances. I would love for him to come back.... but not for more than 2 mil. We simply can't afford to sign a 30 year old, who will only have 2 possibly 3 more seasons playing at the same level as he is now, with no sell on value at the end. If we can't get him for 2 mil or less we need to look at someone younger.

We desperately need wingers for both sides of the pitch though. They should definitely be our priorities in the summer (should we have any money).
James Stewart
385   Posted 25/04/2012 at 15:01:52

Report abuse

He was sold because he wanted to leave! There was no contract we could have offered him to make him stay. He wanted CL football.

For whatever reason it didn't work out for him at spurs. My guess is he will end up here next year. I think if Spurs do go for Rogers though that might put a spanner in the works as he rates Pienaar highly.
Ryan Holroyd
386   Posted 25/04/2012 at 15:06:43

Report abuse

Everton have already agreed a deal for £3M. He will sign for next season.
Chris Matheson
388   Posted 25/04/2012 at 15:08:48

Report abuse

The main question that needs to be asked is WHY we are in such dire financial straights that this becomes an issue at all. It is not as though he is asking for wages at the top end of the Prem League range; nor do we have a large squad to pay.

John Crook
407   Posted 25/04/2012 at 16:07:25

Report abuse

As far as I'm aware, Pienaar was offered £60k a week during October/November time, 2010-11 season. He and his agent kept stalling. The fact that Pienaar didn't sign basically said he wasn't going to stay but was going to leave on a free in the summer of 2011.

It was Spurs who took the gamble of paying £3m in January 2011 (considering they could've had him for free 6 months later) and give pienaar £70k per week which he accepted and knew he was in for European football, something EFC can't offer.

Spurs have every right to recoup their money and considering he still has 3 full seasons on his Spurs contract we won't be able to get him on the cheap Everton-style prices. My guess is he will return to Spurs' pre-season camp, have a word with their manager, and tell him he wants to come back. My guess is we could have him back for what we paid and put him back on the contract we originallly offered him. I think it would suit everyone.

He can't get in Spurs team, we need him, he needs games. He's a top player, I hope he's back here in time for August. And just to agree with the above, there will be no continual loan agreements (as was the case with Jo).
Brian Waring
409   Posted 25/04/2012 at 16:25:32

Report abuse

James, he left because we weren't prepared to offer him the contract he was after.
Richard Dodd
410   Posted 25/04/2012 at 16:20:43

Report abuse

The answer to that one,Chris,is simple.In order to keep in the top half of the Prem,the Club has constantly expended more than it takes in.Players`wages is the main drain but if you wish to compete you have to pay competitive salaries.
The Board has found it beyong them to generate funds by building a new ground or developing the old one.They have also failed to attract a buyer or substantial investor.
As I say,simples.....and I can see no sign of that situation changing.
Chris Matheson
412   Posted 25/04/2012 at 16:30:55

Report abuse

Doddy you are right - you are now asking and answering the right questions, many supporters still havent got to the WHY bit.

Incidentally you did not answer the question from another thread (which is a genuine question by the way), which is what made you change your mind?
Richard Dodd
413   Posted 25/04/2012 at 16:34:54

Report abuse

Sorry for delay in replying to that one ,Chris.I will do so but wanted to build my response into a meaningful piece which,as yet,I haven`t had time to complete.
Brian Harrison
416   Posted 25/04/2012 at 16:35:14

Report abuse

I think most supporters would like Pienaar to stay, but supporters dont have to deal with the complex issues of running a football club.

Like all bar 3 or 4 clubs in the Premiership most clubs are trying to balance the books and in most cases failing. The demand on clubs by supporters to always buy new players, irrispective of whether the club can afford it must be a problem for most chairmen.

Moyes understandably has asked for funds to buy players early in the next transfer window, but seeing as the banks have refused to lend Everton any money for transfers I am not sure how we make the funds for new transfers available.
Yes we could sell to buy, but someone has to want to buy your players for that to happen. Probably only Baines,Fellaini,Jelavic and possibly Rodwell would bring in sufficient funds to make it worthwhile.

But as a manager who has spent years putting the squad together doesnt want to see his best players sold. So there lies the problem, I am glad its a problem I dont have to deal with. Because whatever decision is made the fans will crucify you for it.
Kevin Jones
422   Posted 25/04/2012 at 16:53:47

Report abuse

If Harry gets the England job, probable, Moyes could, and I stress the word could, be the next Spurs boss. Would he sell Pienaar to Everton ? I doubt it very much, his main concern would then be Spurs, and he wouldn't sell a player he clearly likes.

Apparently the FA are going to announce the new England manager before the end of the season, so we probably won't have long to wait to find out.

It could be a Managerial Merry Go Round in the summer, with someone replacing Harry, someone replacing whoever replaces Harry and so on and so forth.
Jeremy Benson
423   Posted 25/04/2012 at 17:10:19

Report abuse

I don't think spurs would go for moyes, and I don't think moyes would go to spurs.

There's only two clubs in the country that I think he would go to, where he could actually be given time to build as he has at everton, which would be a genuine improvement;

Man Utd, Arsenal.
Howard Don
428   Posted 25/04/2012 at 17:14:50

Report abuse

Doddy, I read an interesting article recently about how Newcastle have finally found a way of running that Club that works. Basically they recruit young talent and refuse, point blank, to pay silly money. Players who want it get moved on. So far this season it's worked a dream and could get them in the CL, so it's not absolutely essential to pay top dollar. The potential flaw in that, of course, is you have to keep the supply of young talent coming through which aint easy, if it was everyone would be doing it.
Richard Dodd
451   Posted 25/04/2012 at 18:28:10

Report abuse

That may well work at Newcastle, Howard, but their gates are now 15 to 20 thousand higher than ours and they have a modern ground with very well developed facilities generating huge additional income. They also have a wealthy, excellent businessman in the chair who has paid off £millions of inherited debt.

Having said all that, I`m not sure how someone of his ilk would go down with Evertonians, though!
Eric Myles
534   Posted 26/04/2012 at 03:14:36

Report abuse

James #385, Pienaar left because we couldn't offer him pay parity with Arteta who at the time he was just as good as.

Why couldn't we offer pay parity? 'Cos we're skint and run like a corner shop by our board.
Eric Myles
535   Posted 26/04/2012 at 03:19:31

Report abuse

Richard #410 "the Club has constantly expended more than it takes in.Players`wages is the main drain"

Don't forget the 23% of "other operating costs"
Eric Myles
536   Posted 26/04/2012 at 03:25:08

Report abuse

^ooops, that should be 30% spent on 'other operating costs'

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.

© ToffeeWeb

About these ads

Latest News

Bet on Everton and get a deposit bonus with bet365 at

Recent Articles

About these ads

Talking Points & General Forum

Pinned Links


We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.