COLUMNIST KEVIN SPARKE

West Brom — Football's 'Upside-Down' Cake

By Kevin Sparke :  01/03/2009 :  Comments (7) :
Watching Saturday?s game I couldn?t helped but be impressed with the intricate interchanges, the fluid way that defence was turned into attack, the way that long and short range passes nearly always found a man and the wealth of chances on goal — well done West Brom, you?re playing football the way the game is meant to be played and I hope you stay up.

Now, for all their passing finesse and good footballing credentials West Bromwich Albion find themselves almost consigned to a long drop to Championship oblivion, when if there was any justice in the game they?d be looking at playing Inter Milan or Barcelona for Champions League glory. This isn?t going to ever happen but it leads to interesting observations about our club and the nature of the football we normally play.

For the last six seasons the type of football that Everton have played has quite often been dour and at times it?s been really dire. True, we?ve had flashes of inspiration in short periods, but our default mode seems to be nervousness in possession and short of ideas when moving the ball forward; with the loss of Arteta from the middle we seem to be quickly reverting back to that style of play.

Now, I?m a Moyes supporter, an apologist if you like. I see Moyes? management as the difference between Everton?s natural position in the top half of the Premier League table and the middle of the Championship. I believe he?s a defensive coaching genius; he has air of class about him, particularly in his dealings with the press and normally he has an eye for a bargain in transfer dealings, particularly from the Championship. But, I have to admit that after 6 years at the helm his sides take very little to knock their confidence from retaining possession with good accurate and crisp passing and they seem to very quickly lose faith in the midfield area of the pitch, with the inevitable consequence of the appearance of the dreaded hoof-ball. I?m forced to question why is this?

Now, we've not exactly been passed over by the 'injury fairy' and have a patched up look about us... but don't the players all train together, they should be able to find a man with short passing more often than not? I used to put our sometimes erratic performance in possession down to lack of quality players and have cited the gulf between the spending power of the ?big four? plus Spurs, Newcastle and Villa as the reason we hardly ever play exciting attacking passing football — but if Tony Mowbray can get a team costing less than 10 million to play attractive passing football? why can?t David Moyes?

We won on Saturday, we won with two moments of class finishing and very poor defending from the opposition but make no mistake about it we won despite our failure in the aesthetic football department and not because of it.

Reader Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Andy Morden
1   Posted 02/03/2009 at 19:56:57

Report abuse

Slightly off topic perhaps, but you have to acknowledge West Broms passing game. Being from that area I have a number of friends who are baggoes fans so I pay attention for their results and games for banter purposes. Two of their players have particulalrly impressed me this season - Robert Koren and James Morrison. both move well off the ball, are comfortable on it and can create. Indeed, Koren would be a decent back up for Arteta in the middle. If West Brom go down, I think moyes should perhaps do what he did with Jags - snaffle the better players from relegated teams on the cheap. Forget looking to spend big money all the time, use the formula that has worked so well up until now.
Anthony Dyer
2   Posted 02/03/2009 at 19:45:42

Report abuse

It?s the old problem of what to do? Man United in their games against Spurs and Milan played some great passing football but failed to score a single goal. Arsenal this season have again played good football but have failed to win as many games as they would have hoped to. Chelsea and the other lot hardly play expansive football but once again their defences are usually so mean they rarely lose many games.

The pressure for results means that luxury players cannot find a place in the higher reaches of the PL. What both these teams and Everton have in common is mean defences. If you don?t concede you won?t lose. However, I would rather we continued to attempt to play the ball on the ground as this will return more good results than not. However, due to ill-fortune with the injuries to key players we are probably going to have to re-adopt our percentage game.

Speaking of injuries, I think that referees are failing to protect the better players this season, petty fouls are almost always punished with yellow cards but man-handling players and outright thuggish tackles are being ignored.

Every team in the PL has a solid game plan and a strong work ethic even those in the lower reaches are capable of stopping the top sides from beating them. I think the last couple of seasons in the PL have been poor from a football purists point of view. I honestly believe that Moyes has realised that the percentage game if played for all 38 games will at best get you 50 or so points.

I wish more teams would adopt Mowbray's philosophy if not his naive defensive tactics. A good defence will get you a long way but you still need that extra bit of flair in order to win trophies. Everton always make you feel that they have more to offer, but at the same time the belief in their own ability is quite often lacking.

Rome wasn?t built in a day but we are when everybody is fit a decent side to watch. However, we do all too often withdraw into our shell and fail to dominate midfield especially away from home. COYB

Brian Waring
3   Posted 02/03/2009 at 20:13:08

Report abuse

Have to agree Kevin, it would be a shame if West Brom went down.
I enjoy watching them on the telly, because as you say, they play the game how it should be played.

The thing missing for them is luck, they could have easily turned us over Saturday with a bit of luck on their side, but luckily for us, it wasn’t.
Neil Pearse
4   Posted 03/03/2009 at 10:03:18

Report abuse

West Brom are going down not because they are "unlucky", but because they have a mistake-prone defence, no organisational discipline, no backbone, and no goalscorers. Pretty passing without these things is simply indulgent. If I was a West Brom fan I would tell Mowbray to stop flouncing around and start fighting to stay up. Compare with Stoke who might just avoid the drop. Is Pulis a worse manager than Mowbray?
Matthew Mackey
5   Posted 03/03/2009 at 09:51:57

Report abuse

I would agree with the general feeling here that West Brom are a pretty good footballing side and that it would be a shame, if not inevitable, that they go down at the end of this season. Like Andy Morden, I too am an exiled Evertonian living in the West Midlands and so like to keep an interest on the local teams. and enjoy a bit of pub banter with them (except majority of Villa fans who seem to think the world owes them a favour!)

Anyway, here?s a question for you. Which would be more pleasing upon the eye and perform better in the PL.....(a) The West Brom team they put out against us last weekend but remove the two centre backs and replace with the Jags and Lescott or (b) An Everton side which includes the West Brom players Robert Koren and James Morrison?

An interesting one I think!

Kevin Sparke
6   Posted 03/03/2009 at 12:30:01

Report abuse

Matthew, both Koren and Morrison look very nice tidy players, they both seem to have plenty of confidence with the ball and have quick football brains - if I was Moyes I’d be considering a couple of cheeky bids if WBA do go down.
Matthew Mackey
7   Posted 05/03/2009 at 10:48:31

Report abuse

Kevin........................it’s the right answer!

My thinking is the same as yours. I think DM should make those "cheeky" bids!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to Column articles, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.



© ToffeeWeb