Neville 'embarrassed' by his performance

, Liverpool Echo , 11 March, 133comments  |  Jump to most recent
Phil Neville has labelled his performance in the shock FA Cup defeat to Wigan Athletic as 'embarrassing'. Neville's woeful backpass gifted Wigan their second goal as Everton conceded three times in just over three minutes on Saturday.

"It was more than disappointing," he said.

"It was a disastrous weekend for us. It was a disastrous performance and there is no hiding away from that.

"I was embarrassed with my own performance, it wasn't good enough as captain.

"We can't hide from that. We take our medicine now and take the criticism that comes our way."

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo



Reader Comments (133)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
1 Posted 11/03/2013 at 16:52:10
He's gotten one hell of a lot of shit on here for things he's said to the local press in the past, so I salute his honesty and culpability in this instance: well said, Pip!
James Morgan
2 Posted 11/03/2013 at 16:57:31
Here's and idea then, Phil, do yourself and us all a favour by retiring and admitting you can no longer perform at this level. Your brother knew when to pack in, now it's your turn.
Phil Walling
3 Posted 11/03/2013 at 16:57:25
Well, we`ve learned today that our captain, at least, is big enough to admit to and apologise for his own frailties. What a pity his manager can`t do similar!

I admire your honesty, Phil.

Brian Harrison
4 Posted 11/03/2013 at 16:56:51
Well it wont change the result but glad to hear the apology I think irrespective of what you think of Neville as a player he never hides in games unlike some. Rumour has it that there were some harsh words said in the dressing room after the Wigan game, well maybe some really do care about the performance on Saturday. Hopefully it will make sure that on Saturday against City there will at least be maximum effort from everybody in a blue shirt.
Tony Hanlon
5 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:03:02
Thanks for your honesty , now fuck off
Ian McPherson
6 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:12:03
I have been embarrassed with his performances for longer than this game.
Tony J Williams
7 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:13:01
"Hopefully it will make sure that on Saturday against City there will at least be maximum effort from everybody in a blue shirt" - Just the 1-0 defeat then?
Ian McPherson
8 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:12:03
I have been embarrassed with his performances for longer than this game.
John Crossley
9 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:12:40
He has openly said that he wants to win a cup for Everton before he retires or moves on, there is no chance now, but fair play to him in apologising for his dire showing. Like Tony Hanlon 070 posted now fuck off.
Phil Sammon
10 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:17:50
Hasn't he also said that a top 10 finish is a good season for Everton? Not seen it myself but there's a few rumours he's spouting shit.
Richard Reeves
11 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:08:37
Just saw the interview on Sky Sports News.

Personally I couldn't give a fuck about his honesty, he always talks from a script supplied by Moyes and Kenwright, even when the shit has hit the fan.

But what got my blood pressure up was his comment on how the whole squad wants Moyes to stay and that Moyes has brought stability to the club.

The whole squad? Really? Of course all Moyes's favourites want this as they get a game but I'm sure others don't agree...

And as for stability, ffs, Neville, Moyes has been here for 11 years so that would be the very least that we would expect. How about ambition? Just fuck off, Neville, and take that headmaster with you.

Craig Walker
12 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:29:02
I don't want to see platitudes in the press. I want to see performances on it. Pip talks a good game but doesn't play one.

Another thing. I don't want to see the sections of the ground applauding because one of our players is going over to take a corner in front of them. Even worse is when that player applauds back. Let's applaud goals and attempts and good play and give credit where it's due.

Chris Regan
13 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:30:31
He wasn't too bad, if he had been playing for Wigan his defence splitting pass for their second would have been world class! However, he plays for us so it was total shite - FUCK OFF Neville! According to the wife I shout that in my sleep, have done for years.
Max Murphy
14 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:35:10
As echoed by other contributors, he has been an embarrassment to the team and club for a long time. Phil you should hang up your boots and hang Moyes while you're at it.
Paul Holden
15 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:39:19
We're gonna get battered by Citee - even Anichebe's giving it some and I've seen circus elephants with better ball control!
Phil Sammon
16 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:37:03
That's bollocks, Craig.

Surely if you want the players to play for the shirt then we should be trying to encourage a bond between the players and the fans.

The Goodison crowd should be more concerned about being out-sung by every visiting team this season. It's a morgue until we score.

Paul Gladwell
17 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:43:05
It's on talk sport him and his top ten quote, gobshite.
Patrick Murphy
18 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:47:15
I wonder what our fellow Blue Mr. Kenwright thinks about Saturdays events, if silence really was golden, he'd be minted.

Phil Neville 'Now that's what I call Inspiration....13' out now in your local record shops, including the hit 'Top 10 and we know we are'

Barry Rathbone
19 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:49:04
"top 10 for this club is great" paraphrasing but in essence this is his latest call to arms. He's the voice of the manager on the field, is it any wonder the word "bottlers" figures heavily?

It's the complete lack of awareness that gets me, no wonder he gets in a strop when the lower Bullens tell him to pass to a blue shirt - "who do you think you are?" his visage demands.

If only you knew young Phil.

Peter Leslie
20 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:49:19
Stick your platitudes up your fucking arse Neville.
I defended the twat yesterday when someone made a personal remark about him (sorry dude, you were right),
Now our Captain (spit) declares that for EFC to average a top ten finish every year is an amazing achievement...

Get to fuck, you shitty washed-up excuse for a lousy wanker of a player, you've pissed on your own chips.

Zaid Omar
21 Posted 11/03/2013 at 17:45:16
There is ZERO chance of Everton getting a top 6 finish!!we still have spurs , pool, city, chelsea and arsenal to play, and the Very best we can hope for in any of those games is a hard fought draw!! And thats being optimistic!! Liverpool are playing with such confidence and if we were to play them next week at Anfield it would be another open embarrassment.. Neville must stop this bulshit talk of bouncing back and ending the season on a high.. The OPEN consistent weaknesses in defence over the last few weeks coupled with opposing teams successfully nullifying the baines/Pienaar threat down the left , mean that we are just hoofing everything up front at any opportunity!

I honestly fear the worst for this weekend.

Patrick Murphy
22 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:02:23
Bill Kenwright if you are a true blue and really do love the club, get these clowns out of here, send them to a circus and put in charge someone who knows what the fans want and a Captain who demands excellence, no wonder SAF got shut of him.
Andy Meighan
23 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:01:45
Not.as embarrassed as I was, Philly Boy. Close the door on your way out and hang your boots as high as you can. Talk is cheap.
John Crossley
24 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:10:20
There is a MOB ( Moyes Out Brigade) protest what about a NOB Neville Out Brigade?
John Shaw
25 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:11:58
Patrick 121 - sorry but you're talkin rubbish!!

Kenwright should be out the door BEFORE any player or the manager, him and his cronies have been like a cancer eating away at the club drom the inside out for over a decade, he's a charlatan who should be kicked up and down Goodison Road for what he's done to the club since taking charge.

Ray Roche
26 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:17:28
John Shaw

Nail. Head. Hit.

John Shaw
27 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:17:30
*from
Robbie Muldoon
28 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:13:19
It's Moyes that is picking Nevill. It is Moyes who is to blame. Neville is not going to turn round and say, nah I don't think I should be playing boss. The manager is for all his efforts over the years, a liability. He is the main weak point in this Everton team, he is worse than Neville.
Kunal Desai
29 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:21:38
Take your shitty soundbites and stick it where the sun don't shine you fucking circus clown!
Tony Cheek
30 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:13:54
If you are a with a club like Everton, then every player in the squad should want to play in every game played by the club. That, mentally is the way it should be.

Phil Neville, being the captain and always trying his best (don't laugh) is the same as the rest. He wants to get out there and do his bit. You cant take that away from him.
Now, David Moyes job is to put the team together, to see who is good enough and put a team together that will do a job.
If every bleeding Evertonian can see that Nev is past his best, a plodding carthorse, no pace, and really not a PL player anymore, then why cant our overpaid manager see it.

I say, do not blame Phil Neville, as he will always do his best. Blame David Moyes, he picked him, found him worthy of a place in the team on saturday, gave him a job to do and now stands and says we were not good enough on the day. No sir, YOU were not good enough on the day. YOUR FAULT, NO ONE ELSES!

Graham Mockford
31 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:15:12
Paul Gladwell #107

Where is the Top 10 Phil Neville quote? Just curious like

Phil Sammon
32 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:21:05
Before we pour on the paraffin can I just say that I've still not seen any actual evidence of Neville saying those words.

And you know what, he actually does care about this club more than 90% of the other players that have pulled on that blue jersey over the last 15 years.

He's faults are twofold:

1) He is unquestionable loyal to Moyes

2) He's shit at football.

So yes, he may come out and tow the party line...but what else can he do? He's at least been man enough to admit he's had an awful game.

I know he is a massive problem, but can we forget Kenwright for now? We have more immediate problems at the club. An arrogant Jock with the stubbornness of a particularly stubborn mule. Thank you DM, now please may we have our club back.

Jeremy Benson
33 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:39:02
He's certainly been quiet on twitter since the game...
Peter Cummings
34 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:24:45
There should be a blanket apology from everyone on the field and the board — not only for this shambles of a game but for the shaming of Everton worldwide by the refusal of Kenwright and his cohorts to provide funds for Moyes to give us a team worthy of our great club.

I say worldwide because as a lifetime Evertonian now living in Canada, we can see every EPL game live all over the globe and, true to form, the City game live at 7:45am on Saturday which could also be a huge embarrassment...

Richard Dodd
35 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:36:17
Well,at least our skipper knows we shall expect more from him this weekend.I suspect he`ll be at full-back with Coleman further forward.
Adam Baig
36 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:39:43
He did say it, I saw it on sky sports news. I do agree with tony and graham though - he doesn't pick himself. I have defended him before today, but what he said was way out of order.

Top down, root and branch reshuffle required - no chance of getting one though.....

Paul Gladwell
37 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:45:35
Graham, he's being getting ribboned on talk sport for it, my mate rang me as he was listening to it.
Graham Mockford
38 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:48:36
Adam

When did he say it in Sky news?

Paul David
39 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:44:11
Phil

Is he man enougho admit he's had an awful game?

He's awful most weeks and this is the first time i've heard him say it and he opens his mouth every week.

Phil Sammon
40 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:48:26
Richard Dodd

No fucking way will he be in the side on Saturday. If he is then I'm leaving before K/O.

Plus Coleman has been good at RB. He's certainly better there than RW - despite being poor against Wigan. In fact I think he's been one real positive this season.

Paul Gladwell
41 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:53:39
Some great comments coming out from Southall on twitter I think, having a go at Kenwright, defensive football and the brown nose ex players who work for the club ( his words) its on another Everton site.
Robbie Muldoon
42 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:48:51
Does this mark the Everton Spring?... No chance. Too many fans fear change and are too comfortable with the current fragile set up. Too many fans are apathetic towards the future of Everton, a whole generation of blues raised watching Champions League football without Everton's involvement has lowered a collective self worth and blunted ambition. The fan base has been split by Kenwright a few years back since the Kirkby project and turned supporters against each other in a way never seen before and hasn't completely healed... this can be seen in the current split between peoples opinions on Moyes, and the heated arguments that usually occur between blues with opposite views on the manager. This can be put down to misplaced loyalty, some people are being too loyal to an employee of the club, and I'm not talking about Moyes to Neville.

Then we have the media, who probably can't get there head around the fact that some Evertonians don't think MOyes should be in charge anymore. You probably won't hear any pundit suggest Everton can do better than Moyes.

So all we have got left with now is David MOyes, deciding whether he can be arsed with a few more years at Everton. It's he who is calling all the shots, he has got the entire club by the balls.

Thomas Windsor
43 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:58:11
I don't blame you, Phil Neville, I blame the dope that picks you and expects you to play in midfield at 36 when you're nowhere good enough.

Shane Corcoran
44 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:54:28
Some of the shite that mentioned above is a disgrace. Let me pick you out one by one.

Max Murphy, hang Moyes. What the fuck?

Peter Leslie, don't you have homework to do rather than typing that last paragraph?

And finally Kunsai, you're pretty consistent with the bile you throw out. Grow up.

Neville is past it and was particularly bad on Saturday but he was picked and has to go out and play the game. Did he play shit on purpose? I doubt it.

Rob Smith
45 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:57:59
MOB, NOB and don't forget OOB ( Osman out brigade ).
Colin Glassar
46 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:07:03
I've been insulting you for years neville but all I'll say today is HANG UP YOUR BOOTS if you've got any sense of shame. Your brother knew when he was making a fool of himself, you've been doing it for years now. Just go.
Nick Waters
47 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:08:03
Neville's basically correct. It would be a magnificent achievement for ANY team to have a top10 finish..........with him starting most games.
Tony Cheek
48 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:09:04
I say MOB and OOB IN, and NOBS out!
Ste Traverse
49 Posted 11/03/2013 at 18:58:43
The guy is a phony. Thank god he's out of contract this summer.

Never want to see him in a Blue shirt again. Piss off Neville and take your rallying crys with you.

Tommy Meehan
50 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:10:51
and HOB, Rob (can fit two or three players under that acronym)
Harold Matthews
51 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:08:52
Yes, he was interviewed on Sky just after six. Only caught the last part when he said we would beat City and hopefully go on a long winning streak. Nine wins would do the trick.
Ray Robinson
52 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:17:11
I agree with Tony #140. Neville is a very limited footballer but it's Moyes who continues to pick him. He is obviously a genuine, professional and decent bloke and has at least apologised for an abysmal performance (not just him, mind you). Despite his Manc background, I'm willing to bet that he thinks more about the club than a certain Mr. Fellaini for instance.

Yes, I agree, I don't like the platitudes and the soundbites that emanate from his mouth but give the guy some credit for apologising.

Patrick Murphy
53 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:21:14
Beating City would be a start but it's no use if we go back into our bad old ways in the remaining fixtures. Does it really need such a poor performance for the team to be motivated? It's happened before remember Blackburn away in the LC and Wigan away in the league a few seasons ago.

Mark Tanton
54 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:34:24
Replace 'performance' with 'season' or even 'career'!
Nick Waters
55 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:25:19
After that performance on Saturday, an apology is welcome but hardly worthy of credit. The man earns 50 thou a week! He WAS shite - everyone knows it, and got dragged off at half time. The only reason he wasn't dragged off after 35 mins was because either Moyes dithered as usual or because Moyes spared him the indignity of the hook whilst on the pitch instead of the safety of the dressing room, (and if so then credit the manager for sensitivity towards someone who has had a remarkable career - though I doubt if someone like Mourinho would have been as forgiving).

I will give Neville credit, not for apologising, but if and when he calls it a day at this level because he knows he cannot contribute to the team on the pitch.

Patrick Murphy
56 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:44:17
Neville - Sky text - also says that Europe was the target at the start of the season. Pity the Manager didn't tell them before Saturday that getting to the Cup Final may have resulted in EL qualification
Jonny Flynn
57 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:40:07
We all know Phil's limitations as a footballer but Moyes with his Neville tinted sunglasses on continues to pick him so hes to blame. No-one can doubt his commitment and professionalism if half the other players on our team played every game with his effort we'd be a lot better off than we are now. He's a great motivator but sadly from the sideline is the safest place.
Andy Walker
58 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:53:39
Interesting that Neville who usually tweets several times a day, has not sent one since the match. Seems to have gone into hiding.

Was the above statement put out by EFC PR team?

John Shaw
59 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:54:14
I still haven't seen or heard Neville say that top 10 would be a good season! Where is the interview?
Phil Friedman
60 Posted 11/03/2013 at 20:11:49
I can't stand the way he's playing, but at least he looked in the mirror and was honest about what he saw. As opposed to Fellaini, who canceled his autograph session. He's probably sitting in his flat in Manchester, waiting for the phone call from Chelsea that looks less and less likely. Here's a hint, Marouane: play better now, maybe they call. Continue like you have, it's back to Belgium with you.
Paul Johnson
61 Posted 11/03/2013 at 20:11:00
This one takes the biscuit – HOB NOB.
Christopher Kelly
62 Posted 11/03/2013 at 19:56:59
How can anyone blame a shit player for playing like a shit player?? This to my knowledge is not news.

His apologizing and raising his hand will not make his performances any better in the future. Commitment and desire aren't his problems. Talent is.

Ross Kerry
63 Posted 11/03/2013 at 20:32:44
He's nothing to apologise for, he's past it and his manager should have moved him on when there was money on the table for him.
Neville is a good man and as much as I hate a lot of the captain soundbites, this bloke has been good for the club and deserves a bit of respect.
Not a premier league player anymore; he might not be able to see it, but by now the coaching staff should have taken that decision outof his hands as far as Everton is concerned.
Jimmy Rowell
64 Posted 11/03/2013 at 20:39:44
Whilst I agree that his time is up I've got to say that I've rarely witnessed a better professional. Handles himself very well in all aspects and will be great servant to the club should he find another role at goodison.
Ian Bennett
65 Posted 11/03/2013 at 20:46:02
Who won the golden rallying call. "The phl Neville rallying call was at 16:57".
Willy Russell
66 Posted 11/03/2013 at 20:47:12
He's obviously well past his best but, as many have pointed out,he doesn't pick the team. What's he supposed to do – refuse to play? The personal vitriolic abuse on here for a guy who has always played in the interests of the team is a disgrace. Save your bile for Fellaini who doesn't give a flying fart for anything or anyone associated with the club.
Christopher Kelly
67 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:01:44
If the team got goals for professionalism, then Neville would be a top scorer.

Unfortunately the league table doesn't work like that. Production counts, not much else.

Breaking point is fast approaching. We're going to need some wise decisions to be made pronto on a lot of levels ...

Max Murphy
68 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:00:23
Shane @163, I was talking figuratively - I'm not really Albert Pierrepoint.
If you've not sussed out that Neville is well past his sell-by-date then you've not been watching Everton, or you cannot understand what a bad player is.
I agree with many on here - we cannot blame Neville for his terrible performances - but we can blame David Moyes who picks him. This is what baffles supporters and makes them very angry.
Nick Armitage
69 Posted 11/03/2013 at 20:48:09
Jimmy Rowell - I suppose he would make a great Toffee Lady.
Mike Hughes
70 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:20:55
It's not the hope that kills us Evertonians; it's the post-match sound-bites.

They really do take us for mugs at times.

Beyond the Ronaldo tackle, he's done very little of any note with his feet; only with his gob.

Andy Veitch
71 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:27:02
At least he has come out and said something.

No mention about the bloke that gave up with his back against the run of play, flapping his arms around then... Or has everyone forgotten? Fellaini isn't fit to wear the shirt!

Mike Hughes
72 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:28:09
Ross@225 we're paying someone £4million a year to make those decisions.
Ross Kerry
73 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:32:47
We are Mike, and we could pay someone a lot less and they would.
Peter Laing
74 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:31:12
Thanks for the honesty Phil Neville, one game too many time to call it a day.
Ian Bennett
75 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:37:16
Yep - phil, get a season ticket. Should be loads available.
Dennis Shaw
76 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:43:15
Neville - a tip for you when we go one down and you have the ball moving forward on the attack DON'T what ever you do turn back and pass a dangerous ball into our box something you should have learned as a kid!
James Morgan
77 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:39:09
Peter Laing, ONE game too many?
That's like Ozzy Osborne having one too many lines.
Ian Bennett
78 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:48:50
It's going to be really interesting for the starting X1 in the next game. No Howard or jags, so Heitinga and Mucha play.

Does he play fellaini, Gibson, Osman, jelavic after that? You'd expect a reaction with jags and Howard, but without Moyes or round have a big challenge on Saturday against city. An away game like OT last season might have helped, but Goodison will not be forgiving again this weekend.

Adam Baig
79 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:50:11
Graham, he was interviewed at a lancs cricket function and he basically said that to finish in the top 10 in 9 of the last 11 seasons was ' massive for a club like Everton '. I was nearly sick.

He's just an extension of the moyes bill love in

Paul David
80 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:57:36
Ian

I don't think it will be interesting at all. I predict 1, 2 changes at the very most. Moyes doesn't recognise form so it will be the same players as usual.

Peter Laing
81 Posted 11/03/2013 at 21:58:25
Against City Moyes needs to drop Heitinga, Neville, Osman, Fellaini and Jelavic. In should come - Duffy, Barkley, Gibson, Anichebe, we are unlikely to win with any permutation, he needs to send a clear and distinct message to the players who let the fans down so badly and the remaining 10 games should be about looking to the future.
Ian Bennett
82 Posted 11/03/2013 at 22:04:12
We will see Paul. Goodson is not too forgiving. Fans will expect changes.

An early goal for city, and it could get ugly.

Paul David
83 Posted 11/03/2013 at 22:08:38
Ian

I totally agree with you but I also know how stubborn/arrogant Moyes is.

Robbie Shields
84 Posted 11/03/2013 at 22:01:43
Nick #181......"The only reason he wasn't dragged off after 35 mins was because either Moyes dithered as usual or because Moyes spared him the indignity of the hook whilst on the pitch instead of the safety of the dressing room, (and if so then credit the manager for sensitivity towards someone who has had a remarkable career - though I doubt if someone like Mourinho would have been as forgiving)."

Three points

1) Moyes is paid 4million a year to make tough decisions like that for the good of Everton Football Club, not to protect an astonishingly below average player who is now 36
2) Moyes didn't show a young and talented kid by the name of Ross Barkley when he tracked back, made a miss timed tackle in the box and conceded a penalty did he
3) if Moyes had taken decisive action we might still be in the Cup

Mark Pierpoint
85 Posted 11/03/2013 at 22:28:05
I respect him for saying it but you can say all of the right things until the end of time Phil, ctions speak louder than words.......... time to call it a day
Tony Cawson
86 Posted 11/03/2013 at 22:08:53
JAMRAGNOBHEDNOB!!!!
Johnnie Anichebe Mucha Round Apostolos Gibson Naismith Osman Bill Howard Elstone Davie Neville Out Brigade!!!
Andy Meighan
87 Posted 11/03/2013 at 23:37:36
Peter (#290) — great shout, mate. But you and me both know it's not going to happen, is it. Why would the stubborn bastard break the habit of a lifetime?
Roman Sidey
88 Posted 11/03/2013 at 23:25:43
Ian Bennett @295. I think it would be uglier if Everton score an early one.
Ken Morgan
89 Posted 12/03/2013 at 01:38:32
NOB OUT BRIGADE. Where do I sign up?
Peter Thistle
90 Posted 12/03/2013 at 03:43:56
It's not just one game Phil, You are always shit.
Susong Hermawan
91 Posted 12/03/2013 at 04:04:48
Oi Pip, your time as a player has finish...its time for you to retire. You can move to chinese, MLS or lower league at abroad. Just piss off Pip!
Anto Byrne
92 Posted 12/03/2013 at 05:27:47
C'mon it was just ANOTHER of the many "off days". Neville has been a great servant to Everton and a true professional. He makes a mistake and gets slaughtered on here. I agree his best days are behind him but he is the club captain and on field leader. He makes sure everyone is back for a corner and puts Jelavic on a post with Baines at the other. Its great to see him shouting and screaming instructions and pointing out his missus in the stand. Ossie is getting stick but he is an England international and a Messi clone for heavens sake. Isnt it obvious to all that Davy is going to play these guys. They will be on the team sheet for the City game and of course we can expect another off day surely not?
Brian Williams
93 Posted 12/03/2013 at 08:06:06
The scarey thing about it is that Neville seems to have been "groomed" by Moyes (no, not in that way, although that might explain him getting picked regularly) and when Moyes leaves at the end of the season guess who might just be our next manager.......another one with a great relationship with our illustrious chairman!

Scarey, scarey though!

Nelly Verdonghan
94 Posted 12/03/2013 at 09:07:09
SO HE FUCKION SHOULD BE !!!!!!!

But will he be embarrassed enough NOT to sign a new contract in the summer....great pro.....good capt....nice bloke he maybe.... but premiership level midfield player he certainly is NOT and IMO NEVER has been !!

Nelly Verdonghan
95 Posted 12/03/2013 at 09:07:09
SO HE FUCKION SHOULD BE !!!!!!!

But will he be embarrassed enough NOT to sign a new contract in the summer....great pro.....good capt....nice bloke he maybe.... but premiership level midfield player he certainly is NOT and IMO NEVER has been !!

Gavin Ramejkis
96 Posted 12/03/2013 at 09:15:17
Not as embarrassed as the poor bastards like me that paid good money to watch the clown fuck it up then have the gall to look at the Park End asking why we were giving him shit. One word Chuckle Brother - retire
Nelly Verdonghan
97 Posted 12/03/2013 at 09:07:09
SO HE FUCKION SHOULD BE !!!!!!!

But will he be embarrassed enough NOT to sign a new contract in the summer....great pro.....good capt....nice bloke he maybe.... but premiership level midfield player he certainly is NOT and IMO NEVER has been !!

James Stewart
98 Posted 12/03/2013 at 09:40:47
So he should be. I have never liked him being captain of everton. The worst player to captain us in all my time of watching
Antony Matthews
99 Posted 12/03/2013 at 10:36:52
Cant imagine what the reception will be when they announce his name next time he plays at Goodison. Altogether now. BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.
Ray Roche
100 Posted 12/03/2013 at 10:51:32
Some of the childish comments on here make me embarrassed to be an Evertonian. Neville may be gash now, but he has been a good player for us in the past, and the personal and childish attacks on him here do us, as a fanbase, no credit at all. The fact that he is no longer worthy of a place in the side but is still being picked is not down to him. He doesn't pick the team.
We seem to have a trait that is firmly in our DNA as supporters. And that is to turn on our own as soon as they fail to reach the expectations that we place on them. Reid, Harvey, Kendall, Sharpe, even the Golden Vision himself, have all seen fans boo and ridicule them as the inevitable loss of ability drains from them with the passage of time. . Age doesn't come alone. Make your point. It's what free speech is all about, but leave the personal and vitriolic attacks to the Shite across the Park.
James Martin
101 Posted 12/03/2013 at 10:53:19
That's it Anthony boo the club captain who has been the only one from player or management to apologise for their performance. We all know that at times this season he has been well below par (the beginning of the season was not one of these times when he wa spart of a team playing well and getting results) but he is not picking himself, he's never going to refuse to play if the manager calls him is he? He could retire but then again we've had injuries all season and he was needed at times, he'd probably feel like he was letting the side down retiring mid season.

I know who I will be booing at the next match, a player apparently with the ability to actually do something about Saturday's result, one who has spent the whole season pushing for a move to a different club, one who hasn't turned up for 2 months, one who was too cowardly to face the fans after this match. One who takes more money in wages than any of our players yet gives half the effort. I will boo him like I do every match. Neville is just a symptom of the problems within the playing squad at this club but in no way is he the root, if he's not here next season and nothing is added to the squad then these same problems will appear regardless of whether he's there or not. Very short sighted just to always look to blame one or two (Osman is usually best bet for this position) for the failings of the entire 11. When does the searchlight go towards the big players and the uncomfortable questions start getting asked of their performance?

Antony Matthews
102 Posted 12/03/2013 at 11:01:22
James, I was only saying what I fear most morons will be thinking about. I certainly wont be one that gets on anybodys back . I reserve my boos for people like Nick Barmby who was the traitor of all traitors
Paul David
103 Posted 12/03/2013 at 11:01:53
Ray

The thing is a lot of supporters have never believed Neville has been a good player or come close to meeting expectations. I resent him being our captain, playing every game, being one of our biggest earners ect. During his time at Everton he should have nothing other than a squad player for right back only at best. Some people praise Neville for his professionalism but the way I see it, I have no respect for a player who is a shinning example of how far you can get in the game but have no talent.

Ray Roche
104 Posted 12/03/2013 at 11:15:18
Paul,

We are all entitled to an opinion. Neville, in my opinion, has been an excellent player for us. But not for the past year or so. His affect on the team has far outweighed his actual talent, and, yes, he brings a level of experience and professionalism to a side that has been lacking a true leader for long enough. People with more footballing nous than we have are unanimous in their appreciation of Neville as a man and a footballer. He isn't , or shouldn't be, a target for personal abuse.
As for your lack of respect for a player who has got "as far as you can get in the game but have no talent" you don't win 6 Premier League titles, 3 FA Cups and 1 Champions League medal if you are, at best, average.
Don't get me wrong here, my heart sank when I saw the midfield partnership of Osman and Neville last Saturday and I predicted a tough game as a result of that, but, surely, as a club and a set of fans we are above the sort of comments that appear on here with relation to Neville, Osman etc.?

Antony Matthews
105 Posted 12/03/2013 at 11:26:40
Oh and Joleon Lescott too. Lets leave the hatred and anger towards ratboy, Stevie la and the redshite too. We are Everton and as such should conduct ourselves with dignity and pride.
Paul David
106 Posted 12/03/2013 at 11:29:44
Ray

The people with more footballing nous than us have a personal relationship with Neville, the fans don't and only have his performances to judge him on.

Also there have been a few average players on Utd's books that have won everything in the game. Butt is one from the time of Neville that springs to mind, he played a lot for Utd and England but when at another club was average.

One thing I think we can all agree on is Neville should be no where near the first team now.

Ray Roche
107 Posted 12/03/2013 at 11:41:18
Paul,

We support a TEAM. Not a bunch of individuals. Neville, Butt etc., were part of a team and as such were worthy of whatever success came their way. Following a thread elsewhere on this site I recently considered my best team from all the players I had actually seen play for us since I started going the match in 59-60. The team of "best players" in each position would not get the better of the best team".
At least we agree on one thing. Phil Neville is now past his best and shouldn't get in the first team now.

James Martin
108 Posted 12/03/2013 at 11:40:21
You are right Paul but so is Ray, he shouldn't be in the team now but don't let that revise histrory for what he has done for us. Unfortunately it says everything about both our squad and our mental fragility that he is still getting a lot of games. Tae him out the team and we are usually a rudderless wreck with players often incapable of even doing the basics right. He's often in the team because we don't have enough players to cover holding midfield or right back. Our first choice right back has missed the whole season. Our first choice holding mid is Darron Gibson who's missed about half of it. Considerignt hat Coleman also misses a lot of games is anyone surprised to see Neville playing regularly? Saturday was the first time that he's been picked ahead of Gibson (no one knows if it was a fitness issue, attitude issue, tactical call, who knows what was going through Moyes' head) and it was a terrible mistake. At other times this season though there's sadly been no option but to play him, and liek the team his formhas nose dived since January. It was remember the Osman Neville partnership that helped tear apart Swansea away from home, and dominated the Liverpool midfield in a way unseen under Moyes' tenure and the stats back that up, with Pienaar missing Fellaini unfit and Mirallas hobbling off we still had a lot more possession than them, more passes and more shots. There's been plenty of times when our supposedly star midfields of Arteta/Rodwell/Fellaini/Gibson have just been completely anonymous in derbies and big games. If you play a 36 yeard old every game of the season thought his nosedive of form is bound to happen. That is Moyes' fault and at the root of it the boards for not making funds available to strengthen the squad.
Paul David
109 Posted 12/03/2013 at 11:48:42
James

We do know why Neville played ahead of Gibson, Moyes said it was a tactical decision. Which I think shows Neville is still held in high regard by Moyes and I really don't believe Neville has played nearly every game due to injuries, he would have played anyway.

Gavin Ramejkis
110 Posted 12/03/2013 at 11:50:59
Ray you quote Neville's past as if its a good enough reason for him to be on the pitch, Christ you could use the same argument as an excuse to bring Kendall Mk 4, he doesn't chose to be picked for the squad but he has chosen to carry on playing, and not retire, how much money does anyone need?
Gavin Ramejkis
111 Posted 12/03/2013 at 11:50:59
Ray you quote Neville's past as if its a good enough reason for him to be on the pitch, Christ you could use the same argument as an excuse to bring Kendall Mk 4, he doesn't chose to be picked for the squad but he has chosen to carry on playing, and not retire, how much money does anyone need?
Andrew Laird
112 Posted 12/03/2013 at 12:10:25
Neville should be embarrased, he should be made to watch every appearance he has made for Everton for the last 2 years and then asked if he thinks he is still capable of performing a role/ any role in playing Premier league football.

If he can honestly say yes then the man is about as honest as our dear leader.

Graham Mockford
113 Posted 12/03/2013 at 12:36:12
Compare his reaction to that of Fellaini who yesterday cancelled a pre arranged autograph signing because he was worried about the fans reaction, pretty spineless I would concur.
Ray Roche
114 Posted 12/03/2013 at 12:47:29
Gavin.

No, Gavin, that's not what I'm saying. Referring to Nevilles' very successful career I was merely pointing out the obvious. You don't win all those trophies if you're crap. If you read what I also wrote you will see that I say, and I quote, "Phil Neville is now past his best and shouldn't get in the first team now." Just like Kendall.
Consider this. Neville may be continuing to play because He loves the game. (I can empathise with him. I had my last 11 a side game when I was 50!)
And maybe Moyes has said he needs him. I doubt if money comes into it. As you say, how much does he need. I imagine his nest is sufficiently well feathered to make the amount he earns neither here nor there.( Please, I don't want someone getting up on his hind legs and crowing "Well why doesn't he play for nothing". If he'd play for nothing Kenwright would have him playing until HE'S 50.)

Patrick Murphy
115 Posted 12/03/2013 at 13:25:12
Spot the difference, one Captain says, we are probably too far off CL and hope we can achieve EL, another Captain says we have to be perfect to gain CL place and we hope it's not too late.
Both are probably correct in thinking it's too late for a tilt at CL place, but which one may inspire their current team-mates. Yet the first Captain's team has a game in hand and a perfect run-in may well guarantee a CL place. I think it's this being cautious regardless of what sort of form we are in that annoys me as much as anything else.
Ernie Baywood
116 Posted 12/03/2013 at 13:46:26
If it wasn't for his mansion and hefty bank account I'd almost feel sorry for Phil Neville.

At 36, he gets selected in a position he couldn't play even at his peak. Then, when he's shit, the club sticks him in front of the media and he stands up and takes it on the chin.

There must be one hell of a job planned for him. Would you take that shit unless you were set for a big role at the club?

Antony Matthews
117 Posted 12/03/2013 at 14:39:08
I'd like to see the crowd chant "THERES ONLY ONE PHIL NEVILLE", What a boost that would be to the team. Dont see many team members getting behind Phil unless they are going to save their angst to take it out of city. To be perfectly honest id like to see him in the crowd and if we score the winner the whole team run to him and gesture( no two fingers please)
James Martin
118 Posted 12/03/2013 at 15:07:26
Anthony it would be great to see that, to be honest after the Wigan game they don't really deserve it but there's only going to be one reaction from the fans that generates any sort of performance from the players on the pitch. I'm yet to see a team that has been booed continuously play well during a game. When Man United concede a goal the whole ground starts chanting 'United United', this is the reaction of a crowd thats used to watching champions, the team obviously has a massive amount of credit in the bank with the fans so this type of reaciton is a bit easier to muster than it would be for us but nevertheless the principle is still the same. If the crowd don't make any noise until we concede the first goal and then boo the first bad otuch after it then the team is only going to go one way unfortunately. Against Southampton earlier in the season when they scored everyone in the gorund knew we'd get it back that it was only a lsight aberration, I even had that feeling when Liverpool were 2-0 up, can't believe the crowd has been lost so quickly in a course of a season. Of course the players are mostly to blame but I don't think we've been the best crowd this season either. In years ogne by we've had terrible teams and roared them on most games, this seaosn we've had until recently a decent team but they seem to have been on the end of stick as soon as there's even the slightest hint of it all going wrong. Perhaps its just the inevitability of 11 years of growing frustrations. Perhaps the patience finally has run out. It would be nice to think we had enough in us to make it last until the end of the season but I imagine that the first goal or mistake in the Man City game will soon show how its going to be from here until the end.
Kevin Jones
119 Posted 12/03/2013 at 16:33:42
He also said "I'd like 246 other offences, to be taken into consideration"

Paul Johnson
120 Posted 12/03/2013 at 16:45:28
Just because the guy has had the temerity to admit he was shit doesnt make him a saint. Do you think he has the balls to say to Moyes "listen gaffer I am past it give young Ross a go" never in a million years .

He wants to carry on playing slide rule passes through his own defence to allow the oppostion to run onto.

No sentiment at the top, should never ever play centre mid for our great club again. And I do blame the manager he natural central midfield options but chooses an average, ageing right back ahead of these choices.

He must have some serious photo's of Moyes in compromising positions.
Ray Roche
121 Posted 12/03/2013 at 17:10:42
Quality,Kev!
Gavin Ramejkis
122 Posted 12/03/2013 at 18:09:55
To be fair James I think the general apathy shown by the fans is reflected in mausoleum Goodison Park with a lot of the shite on show, we've seen plenty write on here that its suddenly the fans fault it's quiet but there's sod all to get excited by most of the time. when they do pull their collective tripes out they do get a response, it's the old adage that you have to earn respect and the players should have the humility to know it, sound bites and other twaddle don't count for jack shit if its just lip service.
Si Cooper
123 Posted 12/03/2013 at 18:27:05
What does he mean 'wasn't good enough as captain'?

It wasn't good enough full stop.

I don't get the impression that either Pip or the manager think he should be preparing to hang up his boots any time soon.

Gavin - the Goodison crowd have forgotten that audience participation is part of the overall enjoyment. Trying to get a chant going spontaneously is nigh on impossible.

Paul David
124 Posted 12/03/2013 at 18:45:26
Si

I think what Gavin is getting at is if the team are producing boring slow football then its hard for the fans to get excited. I'm sure the noise in the ground would increase if the fans had something to shout about.

Is it the crowds job to raise the team or the teams job to raise the fans?

In the main I think its the players resonsibility to get the crowd going.

Brian Harrison
125 Posted 12/03/2013 at 18:49:19
Might have been nice if Fellaini had apologised to the fans. Mind he probably treats us with the contempt he showed us on Saturday. Sooner he gets his move away the better, gives the impression that he cant be bothered. I think he might be surprised on how few teams in the Premiership would be interested in him.
Joe Bibb
126 Posted 12/03/2013 at 19:00:36
The world's largest glove puppet operated by the hand of Moyes.
David Evans
127 Posted 12/03/2013 at 20:11:06
Brian 379 said what I have been thinking for ages - when Moyes leaves, Neville will surely be someone Billy boy will consider on the basis he won't cost any compensation and already knows the score concerning lack of transfer money and MF wanting out. Very scary thought! Also see today that Davie Weir is wanted by a Scottish team as their manager which would remove the second choice Billy would have to 'Promote from within'
Si Cooper
128 Posted 12/03/2013 at 20:11:53
I understand that argument Paul, but it is not the whole story by a long chalk.

Although I fully understand why we have them, I think the all-seater stadium and the instructions not to stand dampen down the crowd. I remember when whole sections would make noise all the way through a game irrespective of what was actually happening on the pitch.

It may be hard to do, but (IMO) it would help if the crowd took it on themselves to vocalize their support en masse rather than waiting for the players to give them something to shout about.

John Keating
129 Posted 12/03/2013 at 20:31:14
Really pisses me off when I hear about players being tired, squad rotation and all that piss.
Our shower have played 30 odd games look and play like their knackered
Lampard went about 5 seasons and never missed a game.
Just watching Barcelona.
Messi, Xavi and Iniesta have played about 700 games this season and are like spring chickens.
We're just shite !!!
Christopher Kelly
130 Posted 13/03/2013 at 06:39:12
I agree John.

If they're tired, sit out a day in practice. WTF is the problem with that?? These are young men in their prime physical shape. Fatigue should NOT be an excuse at ALL.

We're all tired of the excuses and apathy. Great, the worst starter on our team puts his hand up and says his performance was embarrassing. What's he going to do about it?? He's incapable of playing well at this level (except maybe at RB) so I don't know how he's going to make amends? Maybe he can take the ball of Seamus' foot again and try to shoot from a near impossible angle?? What a complete joke.

Fuck his yoga, fuck whatever supplements he's on, get out of the team already. rant over....just checking.... shit, he's still our captain

Chris Perry
131 Posted 13/03/2013 at 06:57:33
So he fucking well should be. But we hear this shite every time from him after a poor display. He is crap, end of.

When you go at the end of the season, take Osman Moyes and Kenwright with you.

Gavin Ramejkis
132 Posted 13/03/2013 at 12:51:45
Si the away fans are seated just as we are but are generally louder (away supporters do tend to be loud, I know our travellers are) but I do go back and stick by my stance that if they want my passion and respect they need to earn it first.
Ross Edwards
133 Posted 13/03/2013 at 19:07:44
He has the bare faced cheek to say that 10th every season is good, who does he think we are, we are EVERTON, NSNO and School of Science not a lower mid table side like Sunderland. He is Moyes' puppet so it isn't wise to believe anything he says seriously. He was probably scripted by Davey to say the whole squad was behind him. I bet that behind the scenes, players like Mirallas, Baines Pienaar and definately Oviedo and Barkley must be wanting this negative, park the bus, inept, bottling, delusional idiot out. And you can forget Neville as manager next season, that would be like Moyes MkII.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads