Premier League: Everton 2 - 2 Manchester Utd
-sm.jpg)
Everton host Manchester United in the Premier League on Sunday for their third game of the new season.
But it looked like Man Utd had done enough despite a brilliant strike from Tyrique George, with goals from Mbueno and Sesko about to give them the win. That was until the last kick of the game, a tremendous strike from debutant Ainsley Maitland-Niles.
The mood of the Blues fans today will be febrile, to say the least, with anger at the hierarchy over the transfer window fiasco giving way to possible expressions of support for the players and the team we do still have, with David Moyes left to pick them up and put them together into something that can challenge the mighty Red Devils.
Team News
Jack Grealish and Ainsley Maitland-Niles have not been sufficiently integrated into Moyes's squad so both are only on the bench where Braiden Graham comes in... but will he get time on the pitch?
The visitors are unchanged from last week's win over Ipswich.
First Half
Kick-off by Dewsbury-Hall was a bit different, not going back to Pickford immediately. But Barry was bashed into by Maguire who hurt his nose inside the first minute. It was 3 minutes more before Maguire jogged off after treatment and the game resumed.
Everton worked the ball around but could not penetrate effectively. A simple build saw Shaw easily get behind Rohl and Fernandes smashed the cross off the Everton bar with Pickford nowhere near it.
Everton got forward and George's cross was deflected up in the air, Barry trying to trap and falling over, The Blues fans demanding a penalty but there was no foul on him.
Everton repelled another attack but George was cynically pulled back by Dalot, an obvious yellow card... but only a talking to by John Brookes. A terrible giveawy by Dewsbury-Hall saw Armstrong strong-arm Fernandes, and he got a straight yellow... Sly Six favouritism???
Everton were doing well to win the ball back but lacked confidence in what to do with it, eventually punting it up in the direction of Armstrong, playing where you'd expect Barry to be. Armstrong did well to win the ball back but the possession pathway only led all the way back to Jordan Pickford.
Man Utd countered and Tielemans fired at Pickford from a long way out. After a walking-pace build-up, a Fernandes shot was deflected up and behind, Dalaot smacked the cleared corner back into the crowd, Tarkowski blocking.
A really scary Man Utd move saw Rashford dance around Rohl and play it across for Cunha to sidefoot his shot over the bar. Everton countered with a great pass out from Armstrong to Rohl, but he slowed up, passed back to Armstrong, who would not shoot, and back to Dewsbury-Hall, who was closed down. Chance lost.
Shaw and Rashford again showed up Rohl's weakness at right-back, but this time no clear chance developed. Garner won the ball back well but Everton were far too tentative in possession, going all the way back to Pickford eventually.
The Blues built again, but far too slowly, Barry dropping deep. Mykoleno almost got a good cross in to Barry but it was blocked and the Red Devils were building slowly again. A tremendous Rashford cross was read superbly by Branthwaite.
Everton got forward quicker this time but the cross in didn't find Barry. Dewsbury-Hall put Lammens off and Everton almost profited but again were too hesitant with the second and third balls.
Johnson tried to stop Cunha coming down the left side again, and took his man out with a poor tackle: yellow card. The free-kick was cleared, also the workaround, but Everton were living very dangerously.
Rohl and Mykolenko swapped sides, but they were still given the runaround, Man Utd winning a corner. Branthwaite fell awkwardly but Armstrong was wrestling a little.
Mbueno fouled George; Garner's free-kick flicked on and behind by Barry. Everton won a steal in midfield, but Dewsbury-Hall's low cross was poor.
Everton did get the ball back, Barry trying a shot that was blocked back to him, and then did an utterly bizarre non-cross! But a fabulous cross in from Rohl, Barry got into the right spot but could only head powerfully over the bar.
Armstrong tried a clever one-two with Barry that failed. Man Utd attacked and Mykolenko did well, back on the left. Everton had a much better spell, but still did not get close enough for a decent shot, winning only a long throw. It eventually fell to Branthwaite but he could only shoot straight at Lamens.
Man Utd streamed forward with a tremendous move at the end, firstly a superb tackle from Branthwaite on Rashford to stop him shooting, but the ball went out to Shaw, his shot blocked out again by Branthwaite. Absolutely first class defending from the big guy. Half-time: 0 - 0.
Second Half
No changes after the break. Mbueno was allowed to run in from the right side and drive beyond Pickford into the far corner. Shocking. 0 - 1.
Rohl tried to run the ball out of defence but lost it. Dewsbury-Hall put in a great cross but Johnson seemed to duck underneath it rather than leap to head it in. Mykolenko had a shot wide left that would have been better as a cross.
Barry spun his man and looked to advance into the area but thought he could play in Johnson who was easily stalled.
Everton built slowly again, Graner standing on the ball, George playing it back... but eventually he went forward, Dewsbury-Hall playing in Johnson, his shot was blocked and Armstrong's shot also blocked.
But George ran at Dalot again and won a corner, although nothing came of it.
But Armstrong played a great ball through Johnson whose shot was deflected just over the bar. Man Utd surged forward from the corner and it needed a great rearguard tackle from George.
Johnson picked up the ball and drove all the way to the penalty area before inexplicably giving up the ball!
Barry did really well to get int the area but his shot was blocked to Dewsbury-Hall who could only pass it back to Lamens.
Rashford drove in and seemed to eat everyone except Branthwaite, and it needed a great tackle by Tarkowski on Cunha, who went down and wanted a penalty. As Rohl broke away, a really cynical foul by Shaw got him a yellow card.
Rohl rolled Rashford and he saw yellow. From the free-kick, Fernandes sliced his shot well high and wide. Another Man Utd surge saw Tielemas's shot blocked behind by Tarkowski. The corner saw Shaw drive his shot wide and Johnson was replaced by Grealish.
His first involvement saw Mykolenko force a corner, played short for Grealish, Dewsbury-Hall rolling a shot to Lamens, nowhere near a hard enough strike.
Everton won a free-kick in midfield as Carrick made a couple of changes, Garner's lopping lob bouncing off the top of Tarkowski's head.
Everton worked their way forward down the left, Dewsbury-Hall's strike hitting Barry, Armstrong's weak shot dribbling behind. A poor mistake by Garner gave the ball away but Mbueno was stopped. Hackney replaced Rohl.
Garner moved to right-back but then went down hurt after trying to win the ball, Maitland-Niles coming on for him, a right-back at right-back!
Grealish tried to beat Dalot but lost the ball. Fernandes went down in the centre circle after Tarkowski clipped his foot but the referee missed it, Maguire booked for protesting.
Grealish brilliantly drew the foul from Dalot, yellow card! Free-kick glanced on by Branthwaite forcing a punched save from Lamens. But a terrible effort from Mykolenko. But Hackney got the ball out to Tyrique George (83') and he absolutely lashed a screamer past Lamens, a fantastic strike to put Everton back level.
Man Utd tried to respond, with the cross Sesko glancing his unmarked header wide. Another Man Utd attack, Shaw beating Maitland-Niles, and Sesko's header from his cross not fully saved by Pickford as it bobbled over the line.
Grealish tried to drive in a shot but it was blocked as 5 minutes of added time were shown. Barry got the ball through to George but he was yards offside and Lamens pushed his shot behind this time.
Grealish tried to work his way in again, setting up George, but back out to Hackney and his shot was driven over.
Everton attacked again, Dewsbury-Hall winning a very late corner, but it was cleared; however, it was somehow worked around until it was rolled way out to the advancing Ainsley Maitland-Niles (90+6'), who belted an absolutely gorgeous curling strike that Lamens could only watch helplessly fly into the net behind him. What another fantastic strike.
Incredibly, it finished 2 - 2.
Confirmed Lineups
Everton: Pickford; Mykolenko, Branthwaite, Tarkowski, Rohl [Y:64'] (75' Hackney); Garner (77' Maitland-Niles), Armstrong [Y:13']; George, Dewsbury-Hall, Johnson [Y:34'] (66' Grealish); Barry.
Subs not Used: Travers, Keane, O'Brien, Dibling, Alcaraz, Graham.
Manchester Utd: Lammens, Dalot [Y:81'] (84' Yoro), Maguire [Y:79'], Martinez, Shaw [Y:62'] (90+1' Mazraoui); Tielemans, Mainoo (84' Santos); Mbeumo, Fernandes, Rashford (70' Dorgu); Cunha (70' Šeško).
Subs not Used: Darlow, Heaven, Mount, Zirkzee
Reader Comments (60)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()
2 Posted 06/09/2026 at 12:49:09
3 Posted 06/09/2026 at 13:15:26
Look forward to seeing Grealish in the 2nd half, happy to see Armstrong retain his place as he has started the season well. Decent midfield options from the bench, let's hope Barry is at peak fitness!!
4 Posted 06/09/2026 at 13:46:36
Would have liked to have seen O'Brien next to Branthwaite rather than Tarkowski but I suppose that will only come about with an injury unfortunately.
5 Posted 06/09/2026 at 13:49:34
6 Posted 06/09/2026 at 14:52:10
7 Posted 06/09/2026 at 14:52:40
Johnson and Rohl repeatedly getting torn to shreds down their left.
Hmmm... wonder if we actually bought a right-back in that shambolic transfer window???
8 Posted 06/09/2026 at 14:52:47
We seem to get as far as the edge of the opposition penalty box and run out of ideas and players in the box whereas United quite often look to have at least 2 or 3 choices, we have to get men in the opposition's penalty area even if it's just for the cross and hope.
9 Posted 06/09/2026 at 14:53:50
Apart from that, we played well. As for Branthwaite, he is world class... will end up playing for Real Madrid. What a player.
10 Posted 06/09/2026 at 15:56:14
11 Posted 06/09/2026 at 15:57:30
Please send oxygen and heart meds
12 Posted 06/09/2026 at 15:58:22
13 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:00:17
14 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:04:42
George and Hackney are going to be great signings
It just shows with 3/4 players in the window and were right up there, so frustrating.
Very pleased for the Manager and the long suffering fans who have been through the ringer of emotions over the last few weeks
15 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:04:52
Showed real determination & togetherness, impressed with Hackney when he come on, made a difference.
Sometimes advertisty brings you together, players show more, run more, they really wanted it today, even if we lacked quality at times, they made up for it in effort.
16 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:07:12
Brilliant subs.
17 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:08:53
18 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:10:41
Didn't understand Moyes substitution of Rohl who looked to be having a good game when Garner just doesn't look fit enough which is something we might be glad of given the equalizer, but Hackney must surely be a starter and O'Brien must replace Tarkowski if Moyes doesn't play favourites.
A lot to be sorted out on that display.
19 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:12:41
Trademark miss by Barry - as predicted that man will lose us a ton of points this season - lost us 4 points already in last 3 games!
20 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:14:01
21 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:15:04
22 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:16:16
The quality of the goals in a comeback effort is enough to convince me of a new era. This is a different collection of players that have some real determination and grit. Armstrong chasing down the backpass to their keeper in the 94th showed me that.
23 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:22:45
THE BAD: Way too easy for Mbuemo to cut through us on that first goal, we seemed a bit sleepy there starting 2nd half. Pickford maybe should have had their 2nd, was he wrong footed for it? First half hour or so, we seemed reluctant to have a shot or put a cross in, content to knock it about and inevitably go backwards. Dalot's yellow should have been his second.
THE OTHER: Was curious how Moyes would handle Barry, can't see him playing 90+ minutes week in week out and wondered what the substitution would be. Still up in the air.
Anytime you come from behind to get a point, it's a good point, and the end of the match was thrilling. Welcome aboard Ainsley, COYB!
24 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:22:49
25 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:23:33
26 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:29:24
Two excellent goals got us what could be a very valuable point.
Good games from Hackney when he came on and he urged some good attacking play with his energy and passing, provided the assist for the first goal well struck by George and was involved in the second goal.
Maybe it was the tactics but we looked poor passing and picking up the second balls in midfield and those two goals will give fans some belief that the season might not be as bad as we think it could be.
27 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:31:55
28 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:33:27
29 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:34:59
Grealish and Hackney were also very good when they came on. They might be short of players but the team never gives up. We looked better wth Armstrong at 6, Dewsbury-Hall at 8 and Hackney at 10. Dont think Jimmy Garner is fully-fit.
I wish the manager would start games on the front foot though. When we took the initiative we were the better team.
30 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:54:03
31 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:54:36
33 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:57:10
Barry: He missed a great chance, but at least he provides an outlet and is in the middle of things. he also created a couple of opportunities for KDH, which he fluffed. We need to be patient with Barry. But he desperately needs back-up.
Brennan Johnson - I thought he had a poor game. He doesn't deserve to start based on his reputation. Dibling should be ahead of him.
George - what a strike! Incredible.
Dewsbury-Hall - uncharacteristically ineffective in front of goal. He should have buried at least 1 of the chances he got. But he is the heartbeat of Everton.
Armstrong - I am SO, SO grateful that we didn't sell him. On a yellow card for the majority of the game, he still had a terrific game.
Garner - was brilliant in the 1st half, but started fading, and substituting him was the right decision
Grealish - I agree with the comment above that probably the most effective role for him will be to come on with about 30 minutes to play. But knowing Moyes, the next game, Grealish will start left and George on the right, and one cannot have too many complaints about that.
Hackney - was extremely bright when he came on, and created the equalising goal.
Rohl - he is not very good at defending and Rashford repeatedly broke through him with ease in the 1st half especially. But he has pace to burn and his cross that Barry headed over was a peach.
Tarkowski - I sense that he is coming back to his best. He typically takes a few games to warm up, and if he is fit, he should be ahead of O'Brien.
Branthwaite - he exudes confidence and solidity at the back, but our back 4 need to tighten up.
Mykolenko - a solid left back performance. I think he is enjoying himself now with players like Grealish, George playing in front of him. I don't remember a single cross coming in from his side.
Maitland-Niles - what a way to announce himself to the Everton fans. Ironically, Moyes has a selection headache on his hands now!
Pickford - should have done better with the second goal.
Michael, you do a great job with your match reports, but give it a rest with your negative headlines, will you?
"Two fantastic Everton goals steal a point from the jaws of defeat"
"Late Tarkowski strike steals a point at Bournemouth"
"Blues ride their luck to chalk up a good opening win"
But a great day to be a blue. The team must be feeling confident now. Onwards and upwards.
34 Posted 06/09/2026 at 16:57:47
35 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:09:34
I agree Tarks played well, he was solid, but Mykolenko is so frustrating, he did get some good tackles in but still made quite a few fuck ups
36 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:13:50
But if Tyrique plays like that consistently and stays fit we won't miss Ndiaye.
37 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:23:51
He wanted to put ‘Jimmy Garner right back even though he conceded that Garner is not up to full fitness.
Forced into the move - AMN saves the day with a wonderful goal.
Its bizarre decision making once more from Moyes. In his head he thought a less than fit central midfielder was a better option for us to get anything from this game.
Without Garner going off wed have lost this game for certain.
Well done AMN for showing this manager what youre all about - when clearly he doesnt rate you “we need to get to know more about him”.
And well done to Hayden Hackney who I think also entered the field with a point to prove. I dont think hes done anything wrong to be dropped for Garner - and probably neither does he.
38 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:24:20
39 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:26:22
Amazing analogy.
He also tracked back closed that Mbueno flank.
But the Cobra was there, he was bouncing and smiling. He was as sharp as a tack.
Man U defended stoutly but turned inside out. In the last 15 minutes both Myko and the amazing Hackney (in 12 months a £100m player) went on overlaps and they know the Cobra will hold the ball and feed them.
CEO, TFG, Moseyiah and players deserve a big pat on the back despite the big errors at the end of window.
40 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:27:12
41 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:27:25
I don't know from that outing whether the very affordable AMN is the solution at RB but he's already paid back a decent % of that meagre fee with the injury time equaliser. Only his second ever goal apparently. Good timing...
42 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:31:46
I like those who see the best in people but a pat wasn't the thing I'm tempted to apply to the backs of our CEO and TFG...
43 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:34:25
Ndiaye who?… imagine how good we would be with a striker on the pitch? Could be top 4…
Also Maitland-Niles only came on because Garner got cramp, or he would have kept Jimmy at right back!!! Fucking insane!!!
Also great to see the south stand sucking the ball into the net just like the Gwladdy used to do 🥹
44 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:34:33
We have a right full back who scores goals in Maitland-Niles and that's a bonus.
45 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:35:51
Johnson was a worry today, I thought hed be better. Barry was as expected.
Poor game from Pickford, and Mykolenko was his usual fully committed, but useless self. Left back is a way bigger problem than right back in my humble opinion!
46 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:46:17
47 Posted 06/09/2026 at 17:52:59
I am starting to be interested in him. Before, it was just too up and down.
48 Posted 06/09/2026 at 18:01:24
Hopefully nothing too serious.
What I liked about Hackney, was positive forward passing.
49 Posted 06/09/2026 at 18:02:51
Not sure your angle, may be it is stab in the back innuendo? Not sure unless we are having a chat down the pub, will see what you really mean.
Ive been going the match since 1965, we all need to get behind everyone at the club.
Hope you are more a supporter to our great club than a detractor against our club, hope you are more the former than latter Sir
50 Posted 06/09/2026 at 18:11:54
51 Posted 06/09/2026 at 18:26:57
I think thats what you get with Johnson. He has the pace and the ability to get in good positions but the quality is lacking. I think hell get an ok return of goals in our team because he is a threat. But hell never be a great player
52 Posted 06/09/2026 at 18:48:12
Moyes accepts the plaudits
53 Posted 06/09/2026 at 18:53:02
Great goal by Maitland Niles, but needs to do a lot more to stop the Shaw cross. I thought that was poor full back play, ditto Mykolenko on the first.
54 Posted 06/09/2026 at 18:57:11
Ive just seen his press conference also and I have to say - his comments on AMN to be are a thinly veiled dig at the board.
Its fine and well that he might not have the right back in that he wanted and he wants to make a point about it.
But he should give credit where its due and leave it at that. The lad has come in and taken his chance.
Rohl has done well for us but is less of a RB than AMN. Today it showed as Rashford had the beating of Rohl every time. But thats no sleight on Rohl, Rashford is a top player.
The point is that Moyes was extremely reluctant to give AMN his opportunity today - and when hes taken it all Moyes can do is be semi negative about it.
Then balance that with the realisation that Kenny Tete seems to have been Moyes number 1 target for the last 18 months - Im very glad, even before today, that he didnt get his man
55 Posted 06/09/2026 at 19:05:34
56 Posted 06/09/2026 at 19:08:16
No point singling out Rohl, Garner, or maitland Niles, when George could embarrass Shaw or Dalot when ge felt like it.
It goes both ways.
57 Posted 06/09/2026 at 19:13:08
58 Posted 06/09/2026 at 19:17:44
If Hackney can play like thst, I can see him playing centre mid with Armstrong, and Garner playing right back. 3 good footballers that all have something to offer in a blue shirt.
There is a bit of choice in there, as there isn't a huge drop off to AMN & Rohl. Comes down to freshness, impact and state of the game.
59 Posted 06/09/2026 at 19:24:10
60 Posted 06/09/2026 at 19:40:10
61 Posted 06/09/2026 at 20:07:33
I think we have the makings of a very good side with young players showing now that we can expect even better in the future. Hackney and George are proving a steal for the money we paid for them, Hackney especially is I think a top player in the making.
As Alan @ 31 says we missed an opportunity in the window to make this side that bit better and really have a very good season.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
How to get rid of these ads and support TW


1 Posted 06/09/2026 at 12:47:19
Let's go!