Season › 2013-14 › News
Martin Samuel on his loan bandwagon again
» Read the full article at Daily Mail
Reader Comments (46)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 09/04/2014 at 03:49:12
Virtually none of the Satellite Channels gave any mention of the Everton - Arsenal game at the weekend apart from giving the result but the RS and Man Utd games were given extended coverage on the Sports reports. The meejah it seems just does not like Everton but, then when its full of so many ex-RS pundits, why should we be surprised?
3 Posted 09/04/2014 at 07:25:07
4 Posted 09/04/2014 at 10:04:32
If it makes you feel any better about the Daily Mail and its scaremongering ilk just imagine a stewing, sodden haired Noel Edmonds sat there in open bathrobe and blobby slippers with his ballsack nestly on bracingly cold leather, nodding his head furiously before finally snapping and sending his sugar puffs soaring through the air at the fucking scandal of it all.
Anyway.....
If the whole (and strangely sudden) problem with loan signings is the principle of it then why is it always, specifically, Everton theyre aiming a potshot at? Sunderland have brought more players in on loan than Everton this season but never even merit a mention.
Basically, it comes across like the loan system is fine and dandy if the players concerned are shite and incapable of making the slightest bit of difference to the status quo. Use the market smartly though, bring in players capable of making a significant difference to your season, and its suddenly fundamentally flawed and a bigger affront to fair play than POW Michael Caine sneakily fielding a speedy short-arsed Argie and a bicycle kicking Brazilian with boner difficulties against a team of Teutonic Nazi bastards.
5 Posted 09/04/2014 at 10:39:43
He hasnt invested a fucking bean into the club – Ha!
6 Posted 09/04/2014 at 10:34:25
How Samuel manages to link the Welfare State, Immigration and Everton FC into the opening parts of the story fully explains why he is employed by the Mail – all that was missing was Duncan Ferguson somehow being involved in the demise of the Peoples Princess.
Would Uefa dare to change the rules on entry to the CL to only include clubs with x amount of loanees in their first team? Another co-efficient type hogwash that protects their rich clubs – I wouldnt put it past them.
The real problem is this silly FFP situation and how it will keep the rich clubs rich and those clubs like us being unable to compete or improve even with a new rich owner.
I have always objected to the loan system and find it ridiculous that Chelsea for example can bulk buy players and then loan them out. There should be a rule that if you sign a player on a permanent transfer you cant loan him out until he has completed 50% of his contract that would stop player hoarding overnight. There should be a limit to the number of players that a club can send on loan and there should be no loans to clubs in the same division.
The loan system is a gateway for the rich clubs to have undue influence on smaller clubs – not so much in Evertons case but certainly it has happened at other clubs and it is both unseemly and fraught with problems which compromises the games integrity – if it has any left that is.
Dominic King writes a nice piece about Martinez in the same paper – but notice that the more complimentary articles are focussed on Roberto and not necessarily on Everton FC. We have another manager who the media are building up with the hope that he will move to a club more deserving of his talents – it is starting to annoy me how this routine campaign to poach, coerce and ultimately undermine Everton FC is seen as acceptable, whilst the cheating, diving and other horrible elements of some of the chosen clubs is ignored if not openly adored by the same media outlets.
7 Posted 09/04/2014 at 13:11:59
Martin Samuel uses the majority of his Daily Mail column on Wednesday to rail against a loan system that has allowed Everton to bring Romelu Lukaku, Gareth Barry and Gerard Deulofeu, under the headline Everton fairytale has us hooked - shame its built on £50m loan sham.To begin with, Samuel compares Evertons loans to the welfare state and open-door immigration, something Mediawatch thinks is such a surefire way to get Mail readers onside that were surprised it isnt compulsory in all articles.
What would Lukaku cost Everton? Lets say upwards of £25m, writes Samuel.
Deulofeu is a rising star in the Barcelona academy who has represented Spain at every level from Under 16 through Under 21, and was voted the Golden Player at the UEFA Under 19 European Championship. He wouldnt come cheap.
Then there is Barry, a squad player at Manchester City and now 33, but even so he might have commanded £6m as a permanent transfer in the summer. Total: somewhere north of £50m, maybe as much as £60m.
There is certainly an argument to be had regarding the fairness of the current loan rules in terms of avoiding FFP measures, but we cant help feeling that Samuels view rather gets lost in the necessity to hoover up the clicks, hence making it a fairly personal attack on Everton.
There is no mention of Sunderlands five loans this season. Or Fulhams five. Or West Hams four. Or Hulls three. Or Stokes three. Or Aston Villas two. Or Newcastles two. We could go on. Presumably Samuels rule is that loans are fine as long as those players dont turn out to be any good.
Mediawatch doesnt remember West Broms climb to eighth last season being labelled as a sham with Lukaku at their club, nor Uniteds two Premier League titles achieved when Carlos Tevez was on his two-year loan from West Ham, or Christophe Dugarry and Jurgen Klinsmann helping Birmingham and Spurs survive relegation struggles.
The loan rule could well be altered, although we dont actually see any issue when the rules are the same for all, but to turn that into an undermining of Evertons achievements this season seems pretty cheap.
8 Posted 09/04/2014 at 15:26:16
Newspapers like the Daily Mail are quick to jump on any bandwagon whether it sport or politics and are more right wing than Stanley Matthews was. We are not breaking any rules and working within the Uefa rulebook, so Martin Samuels can go and kiss Mikel Artetas arse.
9 Posted 09/04/2014 at 15:30:47
Samuel should cut down on the pies and look at some of the real issues affecting the game: like how the finance rules are manipulated by the likes of Man City (again legally) to keep the rich clubs ahead of Clubs like ours.
10 Posted 09/04/2014 at 16:01:09
It’s Martin Samuel FFS!
11 Posted 09/04/2014 at 16:03:48
12 Posted 09/04/2014 at 16:19:08
13 Posted 09/04/2014 at 16:12:14
14 Posted 09/04/2014 at 16:35:40
What would Lukaku cost Everton? Let’s say upwards of £25m.’
How about we don’t say £25m? How about we say £20m, which is what people have been quoting as his value for most of the season. Or, seeing as we’re talking about last summer (before he banged in another 13 League goals), £17m, which is what Chelsea would have wanted to sell him for based on what they paid Anderlecht and would owe them for add-ons.
’Deulofeu is a rising star in the Barcelona academy who has represented Spain at every level from Under 16 through Under 21, and was voted the Golden Player at the UEFA Under 19 European Championship. He wouldn’t come cheap.
He wouldn’t come cheap now, no. Not after he’s shown what he can do at Premier League level but only after a careful and patient introduction to one of the world’s toughest leagues by Roberto Martinez.
When we signed him, he was a 19 year-old kid with an ego who’d just played in the U20 World Cup. He would not have cost the £19m that Samuel suggests he would. Not even close.
’Then there is Barry, a squad player at Manchester City and now 33, but even so he might have commanded £6m as a permanent transfer in the summer. Total: somewhere north of £50m, maybe as much as £60m.’
Yes, he might. City might also have offloaded him for £3m just to get rid of him, seeing as Pellegrini clearly didn’t rate him all that highly. All supposition to get Samuel to a vastly inflated, patently ridiculous figure of £50m to £60m.
Finally, while I’m ranting. Arsene Wenger has no right to moan. He could have bought (or loaned) Lukaku, Deulofeu and Barry for £40m last summer himself if he wanted because his club has the money. He blew that amount on Mezut "Hot and Cold" Özil instead.
15 Posted 09/04/2014 at 16:51:41
TEXANS ARE THE LIVING PROOF THAT RED INDIANS HAD IT AWAY WITH BUFFALOS!
17 Posted 09/04/2014 at 16:59:11
18 Posted 09/04/2014 at 17:06:36
Oh dear they just can’t believe that "Little old Everton" to quote OFM has actually got some very good CONTRACTED players with the hunger drive and confidence to have a go and win against the elite
I for one am loving it whatever happens in the rest of the season
It’s like the rare occasions when Miliband gets one over on Posh Boys 1&2
Onwards and Upwards Blues we have class!
19 Posted 09/04/2014 at 17:23:19
20 Posted 09/04/2014 at 16:56:50
Deulofeu is mentioned as one of the brightest prospects in Barcas academy, but would it also not have been topical to mention how is parent club are facing a transfer embargo due to the methods and rule breaches concerning how they gather Europes brightest young things in the first place?
Lukaku worth £25M. Yes, quite possibly he is. Thats of course based on the fact that he was a fledgling 17-year-old striker who was plucked from his first professional club for a fee rising somewhere in the region of £17M. Shouldnt that strike some sort of chord? The richest clubs being able and perfectly willing to dump vast sums of money on young players theyre not even sure they want to use? Chelsea potentially paid more than our record transfer fee for an unproven teenager.
As for Barry, yes we could probably have afforded him, but again issues such as how Man City are able to just stockpile and mis-use players that would otherwise be prominent for other BPL clubs are ignored as is the fact that even our loan deal for Barry was complicated by the fact that Man Citys fringe players are on £100k+ a week.
So to summise, Samuel might have a point that on some levels, the current loan system is flawed. What he doesnt bother to address is how clubs like ours are supposed to succeed when the monied clubs use their vast resources to hoover up the best young talent, stockpile average senior (often international level) talent on massive wages and due to the laughable FFP, can still blow 90% of their competition out of the water when it comes to transfer fees for new, better players. Thats without mentioning the ever increasing sums of TV and sponsorship revenue that continues to prop them up.
No, us borrowing a couple of over-valued young players and an under-utilised former England international are clearly the biggest problem facing the game right now.
21 Posted 09/04/2014 at 17:37:58
Let’s face it, we’ve never been given credit in the media. I remember days in the 80s when we’d win titles and the BBC news would show a few goals from a game. Every Saturday it would be LFC. Never us.
We’re only interesting to the media when one of their favoured clubs is sniffing round our players or manager.
This season, twice I’ve listened to 5-live whilst driving. Once was back from the Spurs game at Goodison. It took me 5 hours to get home that night. Each time I heard the news bulletin, it lead with the same headline "Spurs miss the chance to go 2nd with draw at Goodison". Completely neglecting the fact that we too would have gone 2nd with a win. The other Sunday I had 5-live on and their headline was "Fulham slump to another home defeat". No mention of it being Everton’s 5th win on the bounce.
Half-time on Sunday and Redknapp and Souness (was it?) stated that our 2 goals were bad defensively from Arsenal and that our 2nd goal had a player obstructing the ’keepers view in an offside position. Their first thought was to cover the half from an Arsenal perspective irrespective of Everton’s dominance and brilliance. It makes my blood boil but if I’m honest, I quite like it that nobody fancies us.
The biggest media character who irritates me is Alan Green. I can’t abide the RS-loving cretin. At least the other RS obsessed media personalities are open about their links to the RS.
23 Posted 09/04/2014 at 17:24:53
Its all about the status quo and the Sky 6. How dare Everton overstep the mark and threaten to dump Man U and Arsenal out of next years CL? Especially when we use (dare I say it?) loanees!!! Dont forget that it will cheapen the brand if we stay above Man U.
The media dislike us, probably due to the RS leaning presenters/pundits/commentators that dominate all forms of it whether its tv, radio, red top or broadsheet. Theyve done the arent Arsenal rubbish thing since the weekend, while giving us virtually no credit for our performance. Were plucky little Everton punching above our weight season after season. This time though were a bit too close for comfort. They have tried touting our players at every opportunity, now they are complaining as we have used loan players extremely well. I cannot remember them complaining about Landon Donovan, The Straq, Drenthe or Thomas Hitzlsperger.
I see that it is Clattenberk refereeing the RS v City match at the weekend. As I said before the Man U v RS match the other week when I heard he was the ref then - Expect penalties to the RS and a red card in their favour.
25 Posted 09/04/2014 at 18:40:48
27 Posted 09/04/2014 at 19:39:36
I didn’t see anything there that was a criticism of us; he said we’d done nothing wrong, merely been better at utilizing a flawed system than our competitors, and that FFP was forcing this kind of behavior.
In fact I found it a surprisingly well argued and reasonable article; shocking giving the writer and the publication.
We’re starting to get a bit precious about the whole loan thing. There have been some unfair criticisms; this isn’t one of them.
28 Posted 09/04/2014 at 19:27:31
The daily mail isn’t worthy of being bog roll and it always amazes me when I read that it is sadly the most popular tabloid in the UK - really says a lot for the country!
Fuck#em
29 Posted 09/04/2014 at 19:37:48
Which club has the least number of players to ship out on loan? Which club is struggling to keep up with City, United and Chelsea. Which club is practically being handed the title? Which clubs fans were among the first to complain about Lukaku et al?
Its not difficult to work out as they arent that far away from here. They have an unedifying fan base who will along with their celebrity ex-players try every trick in the book to undermine Everton FC and push their club forward as some sort of paragon of virtue - remember that ridiculous tag attached to them when they had a change of owner - "LFCs long-suffering fans" and the campaign to remove the previous owners and the campaign to get into CL in 2005. They have some powerful allies and if we had an independent media we would hear about some of their dirty washing.
How anyone can watch Sunday Supplement for more than one episode a year is beyond me - they have been trotting out the same old cack since it began which must be going on for 15 years.
I also note that Robert Elstone and a few of the top-flight clubs are having to fight to keep a 15% allocation for away fans in cup-ties and that most of the top-flight clubs want to cut that allocation and do the same for PL games as well. I wonder which clubs they are as it would be silly if clubs like Fulham who get more away fans at some matches than home supporters. No it will be the usual suspects who can afford to treat other clubs supporters as surplus to requirements.
30 Posted 09/04/2014 at 20:17:02
Also, I doubt very much that they would have enjoyed and contributed so much for any other manager. No, Martin Samuel needs to sell newspapers and have an easy life liaising with local London clubs. Prick.
31 Posted 09/04/2014 at 19:47:55
Chelsea, Utd, Madrid, Barca, City etc can buy all the players in the world, then buy up all the young talent and loan them out til good enough.
Smaller clubs thus lose their best players for buttons at 16/17/18.
All clubs should have a squad limit...that would improve the situation. X number of players on full-time contracts. Therefore it would be beneficial, both professionally and financially for a young talent to stay at a smaller club on a pro contract that a rich club as an apprentice.
32 Posted 09/04/2014 at 21:05:08
33 Posted 09/04/2014 at 21:30:24
Funnily enough no-one gave 2 shits when we were loaning the likes of Jo (remember him?), Stracq and Hitzlsperger. But suddenly now we have a manager that can attract the top tier of players to the club the loan system is ’"unfair" and we’re "exploiting the system". Absolute bollocks.
Don’t even get me started on the "it’s all a master plan from Mourinho to take points of his rivals" tin-foil hat nonsense...
34 Posted 09/04/2014 at 21:38:26
Add to that the £50m-60m valuation is a complete load of bollocks; Barry was 32, not in the city team and going into the last year of his contract, Delboy was a teenager who had hardly played any top flight football so valuing him last summer at £20m+ is just garbage. Lukaku may have brought Chelsea £20m if sold last summer. A fair valuation for all three last summer would have been nearer £25-30m not the ridiculous £50m-60m being spouted.
The loan system is flawed but has been around for a very long time so coming out with this article now just smacks of bitterness because we’ve managed to make good use of it.
£50m scam my arse! No-one was complaining when Tevez helped Man Utd to two titles and the CL whilst on loan!
35 Posted 09/04/2014 at 21:55:50
36 Posted 09/04/2014 at 21:56:06
Obviously his valuations were wrong, but so what - the principle is still true. Journos and other media types will always take the part of the "big" clubs simply because they have such a big telly fanbase, and global popularity. Let’s not get all bitter about it – just support EFC and see what happens. If Atletico Madrid (relegated 10 years ago) can do it, so can we!
37 Posted 09/04/2014 at 21:32:59
He’s not blaming the club for having loan players, he’s arguing that the system is flawed, there’s a good few on here that agree with his point of view.
I can appreciate where your objections are coming from, in regard that because 1 of the wealthy clubs, namely Arsenal, might get their noses put out, it suddenly becomes unfair.
Personally I’m not against the loan system, anything that gives the ’less cash rich’ clubs such as ourselves a chance of competing on a more level playing field, I’m in favour of.
The media always play the numbers game, they tell the majority of their readers what they want to hear!
38 Posted 09/04/2014 at 22:13:32
39 Posted 09/04/2014 at 22:30:13
40 Posted 09/04/2014 at 22:19:55
But and it’s a big BUT, we have to accept that unless loans continue to be allowed, the Premier League is just a 4/5 team league determined by the wealth of predominately foreign owners.
Yes, the likes of Everton will trouble this cartel from time to time but that’s all. We can never be a real force without the money to really compete and even if we manage to break the mould this season, that cartel will soon agree to take loans to our club off their mutual agenda.
41 Posted 09/04/2014 at 22:20:20
Its another example of the rich getting their own way.
Money is a powerful persuader!
42 Posted 09/04/2014 at 22:25:43
If we win the remaining games 6-0, the opposition were shite and if we didn’t have the three loanees we would’ve lost ’em all; apparently Baines, Coleman, Distin, Stones, Barkley et al are only there to make the numbers up.
43 Posted 09/04/2014 at 23:02:36
Open it up any day and any right minded person would be offended my it’s content.
Even the crossword is shit.
44 Posted 09/04/2014 at 23:11:53
45 Posted 10/04/2014 at 00:16:18
How some Blues see the article in any different way beggars belief. If we were sitting in the bottom 3 at the moment does anyone really believe the piece would have been written?
46 Posted 10/04/2014 at 01:49:50
If Uefa gave a shit about the game, they would stop teams like City and Chelsea amassing squads of 50 players and sitting on them. But Uefa doesn’t give a shit about the game, only it’s vested interests, which includes Arsenal but not Everton.
47 Posted 10/04/2014 at 01:54:37
48 Posted 10/04/2014 at 04:52:36
I don’t like rich clubs buying beyond their needs and then loaning out the excess. This hikes prices as the supply of good players is less in the market and are overpriced by rich clubs not counting the pennies. This is where the problem lies.
Deulofeu clearly fits into the first.... You could even argue Lukaku does because of his age.
So I think there is an issue there... But haven’t tried to solve it conceptually yet.
49 Posted 10/04/2014 at 13:10:06
50 Posted 11/04/2014 at 13:51:42
Along those lines, the idea of the loan system is entirely foreign to American sports and seems much too complicated to be boiled down by the Daily Mail.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 09/04/2014 at 01:16:37
In regulatory terms theyre fine, obviously, and completely within the rules. Everton have been very smart in exploiting the nuances of the player market and good luck to them in that. Sam Allardyce kept Bolton Wanderers afloat due to his astute manipulation of temporary transfers and the club have missed his keenness since.
So it is not that Everton have contravened any regulations or dealt underhandedly to secure the services of Lukaku, Gareth Barry and Gerard Deulofeu on loan this season. It is just that the loan system is an anomaly in these days of financial fair play, because the two concepts are idealistically incompatible.