20/09/2024 11comments  |  Jump to last

Sean Dyche has stressed that he won’t put Jarrad Branthwaite back into the first team until he is completely ready so as not to risk the player’s long-term welfare.

Branthwaite is yet to kick a ball in anger for the Blues this season after undergoing a hernia operation over the summer and then suffering a set-back in his recovery.

The 22-year-old’s absence has been keenly felt — last season, Everton had one of the best defensive records in the division but four games into 2024-25, they are the worst team in all of Europe’s top five leagues where that metric is concerned, having shipped 13 goals already.

That has increased the anticipation around Branthwaite’s return, which now appears to be imminent with he and Nathan Patterson scheduled to turn out for the Under-21s this weekend.

Article continues below video content


Then it will be a case of assessing their respective readiness, with Dyche strongly averse to rushing them back.

“I believe this because my history in the game from the age of 16 has pretty much shown that every player that does that very rarely comes through it and continues playing,” Dyche said in The Mirror.

“So there has to be some sense… and for the player don’t forget. People forget [Jarrad’s] had one season — one big season — in the Premier League, and we have to be fair to the player.

“I have to find fairness and putting players on the football pitch who are either ill or not well or not in the mental state or physical state to play… I have a responsibility of care as well. I won’t do that and I haven’t done that.

“When I speak to a player, I check their stats and facts and see how they are mentally, how they are with their family, check everything: ‘Right how are you feeling?'

“Look at it a different way, why do we do six weeks’ pre-season if every player could just play? There would be no point to it.

“We have a player who’s been out 13 weeks and people say, ‘why aren’t you playing him?’ How does that make sense? Why have six weeks off and six weeks training? You might as well have 11 weeks off and one week’s training.”

Quotes sourced from The Mirror



Reader Comments (11)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()


Mark Taylor
1 Posted 21/09/2024 at 01:02:58
The focus on Jarrad's long-term welfare might also be connected with the possible need to sell him in January to pay the bills, if we don't have a new owner. Or maybe even if we do.

It appears to me that Tarkowski and Mykolenko have been playing through minor injury but they don't have so much transfer value, so it doesn't matter so much.

James Flynn
2 Posted 21/09/2024 at 01:16:02
Mark, "The focus on Jarrad's long-term welfare might also be connected with the possible need to sell him."

I'd replace "might also be" with "is definitely connected". It's about wanting Jarrad at the £70M fitness level.

Still, I hope he's fit soon so we can have him playing a few more months.

Sean Kearns
3 Posted 21/09/2024 at 01:28:16
I couldn't care less about anyone's welfare, just results in the short term.

These men are gladiators going into a pit against lions, when one is torn up we drag him out for another poor soul to step up next. I'm baying for blood so don't give me the “long term welfare” jargon!

If it wasn't about getting £70M for him, then he would be given a pain-killing injection and sent out to battle. It's clearly about keeping him in good enough shape to get big money for the lad.

Jay Harris
4 Posted 21/09/2024 at 03:56:10
Sean, that's an interesting comment because Harry Catterick used to tell the players to get out there and play. He didn't want to hear them complaining about injuries.

But I suppose in these modern times of “player welfare”, the fitness coaches have the last say.

Mark Wynne
5 Posted 21/09/2024 at 11:39:06
I never thought I’d ever see the words “Dyche” and “Rush” in such close company.
Paul Rattle
6 Posted 22/09/2024 at 07:17:18
I thought that's why we signed a deal for £16M to bring in a 6ft-6in centre-back with European experience?

Maybe I'm just not following the storyline… lol.

Robert Tressell
7 Posted 22/09/2024 at 16:44:56
It is only because Dyche showed some patience with Calvert-Lewin that we don't have Beto up front. It's important to make sure Branthwaite is properly fit rather than play him for a couple of matches half-fit and then lose him for another long stretch.

I assume we have O'Brien because he shows promise but, as you might expect for someone who was playing fourth-tier football in England recently, he's still pretty raw. Yes, he's had a breakout season in France, but the standard is lower.

These days, £16M is a pretty low fee for a Premier League player – equivalent to, say, the £4M we paid for Oviedo. I expect the plan is to develop him over the course of the season – but it's not a huge surprise that it's a bit too soon for him to get a run of first team appearances.

"But why didn't we buy players for now?" – I hear people cry!

We quite possibly did. The reason we have the players we have is because they didn't have better offers – and because we could afford the fee and the terms.

O'Brien may yet prove to be a good signing – but it can take some patience.

Andy Crooks
8 Posted 22/09/2024 at 20:43:32
Sean Kearns and Robert Tressell.

Get into the arena and sort your debate out like gladiators!!

John Daley
9 Posted 22/09/2024 at 22:05:36
“We have a player who's been out 13 weeks and people say, ‘why aren't you playing him?' How does that make sense?”

Is he actually suggesting people have been saying that? Because they haven't been at all, have they? If a player is injured, he's injured. Nobody has been pointing a finger at Dyche and questioning why he's been playing Keane and not Branthwaite… because Branthwaite has been injured.

I can't tell with Dyche lately. Is he just speaking hypothetically, or is it another example of him being unable to answer a simple question without needlessly injecting some fictitious ‘noise' (like ‘the story' about his contract that wasn't a story until he brought it up himself, or the claim that all the chatter amongst fans at Goodison last season was about Everton getting into Europe this year) to paint himself as a sole voice of down-to-earth realism amongst a veritable sea of fickle fans?

————-

Off screen voice: “What do you want for your dinner, Sean? Frey Bentos and mash mountains, Frey Bentos and jacket potato, or Frey Bentos and roasties?”

Dyche: “Think I'll have mash please love, but patted down and flicked up slightly with a fork so it kind of resembles waves rather than mountains.

"Fair enough, I may have gone for mash again but there's no need for people to say “you can't just live off potatoes, Sean”, when it's clear as day that I don't. I don't do that. Potatoes is just a side dish. Potatoes is the secondary accompaniment supplementing the main part of the meal… the meat and potatoes of the meal, if you will… that is doing the majority of the heavy lifting when it comes to maintaining my appetite levels and my ability to cling to life. I don't see where the confusion comes from.

"Even then, it's not like it's just potatoes I put with stuff, you know what I mean. It's not like I can't see beyond a spud. Imagine how bland your diet would be? Sometimes, when I'm not in the mood for potatoes, I might crack open a tin of Peppa Pig spaghetti and sometimes I have chips”.

Soren Moyer
10 Posted 22/09/2024 at 23:44:07
File it alongside "lastminute.com". Or was it .org!?
Jeff Armstrong
11 Posted 23/09/2024 at 05:49:22
So, from Dyche's comments, Branthwaite is 4 weeks away from the first team.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.



How to get rid of these ads and support TW

© ToffeeWeb