Season › 2024-25 › News Pickford beaten in goal as England lose to Greece Michael Kenrick 10/10/2024 66comments | Jump to last England 1 - 2 Greece Jordan Pickford had an erratic performance in goal as England fell to an embarrassing home defeat to Greece in this Uefa Nations League Group B2 game at Wembley on Thursday night. England interim head coach, Lee Carsley, named a really attacking team with John Stones named captain. Carsley says John Stones "deserves" to be picked as captain with regular skipper Harry Kane not fit to start. "It's a brilliant achievement for John, something he deserves," said Carsley. Article continues below video content He hinted when he announced the squad that the height and width of the team would come from the wide players and not the full-backs meaning that he would have the chance to play the trio of Jude Bellingham, Cole Palmer and Phil Foden in one team. But in the first half, it hadn't clicked for England. The fluidity and the understanding aren't there. Saying that, they've had chances. Defensively it's slightly worrying. If we were playing against one of the superpowers of football, then we'd be going in behind. And within a few minutes of the restart, Pickford was beaten far too easily by Vangelis Pavlidis and the England All-Stars were behind to Greece at Wembley for the first time ever. And a second goal a few minutes later was embarrassing but ruled out for offside. England huffed and puffed but the attacking lineup just couldn't do what was needed, while Greece got the ball past Pickford four times in all — three goals disallowed. But a late strike by Jude Bellingham spared Everton blushes before the end. But in added time, more embarrassing defending saw Pickford beaten again and this time it was not going to be ruled out, giving Greece a famous win. England: Pickford, Alexander-Arnold, Stones, Colwill, Lewis, Rice, Bellingham, Saka (51' Madueke), Palmer, Foden (72' Solanke), Gordon (60' Watkins). Subs: Pope, Henderson, Walker, Livramento, Guehi, Jones. Gallagher, Gomes. Reader Comments (66) Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer () Neil Tyrrell 1 Posted 10/10/2024 at 20:02:16 Not a great first 10 minutes or so for Pickford v Greece, hope he gets all the mistakes out of his system on the international break! Brendan McLaughlin 2 Posted 10/10/2024 at 20:05:46 Neil,How fecking long is this international break then? Neil Tyrrell 3 Posted 10/10/2024 at 20:10:24 Good one Brendan, made me laugh Is that Andy Warhol managing Greece? Luke Welch 4 Posted 10/10/2024 at 20:14:53 Honestly I have no idea how Gordon gets in the England team. Brian Williams 5 Posted 10/10/2024 at 20:17:50 Carsley's experiment not working at the moment, unless he's told Gordon to play shit. Luke Welch 6 Posted 10/10/2024 at 20:21:26 Doesn't McNeil assist and score more than Gordon? Neil Tyrrell 7 Posted 10/10/2024 at 20:24:04 Yeah but Gordon is Neymar level when it comes to rolling around after any contact Luke Welch 8 Posted 10/10/2024 at 20:26:18 This true! Carsley will realise that Gordon does score at some point. Nigel Scowen 9 Posted 10/10/2024 at 20:56:09 Stones was poor there. Luke Welch 10 Posted 10/10/2024 at 21:05:34 Terrible perfomance this! Carsley won't stay in the job if it carries on like this. Robert Tressell 11 Posted 10/10/2024 at 21:13:51 This is pitta-ful from England. Luke Welch 12 Posted 10/10/2024 at 21:16:33 Defence looks worse than ours! And that's saying something. John Keating 14 Posted 10/10/2024 at 21:34:38 England have been direGod only knows whats up with Pickford tonight? Brian Williams 15 Posted 10/10/2024 at 21:40:01 What a comedy off errors. Greece have had the ball in the net five times.Absolutely shocking. Barry Rathbone 16 Posted 10/10/2024 at 21:49:07 "Where have all the good men goneAnd where are all the gods?Where's the streetwise HerculesTo fight the rising odds?Isn't there a white knight upon a fiery steed?"No Bonnie there isn't. And the sooner people understand how ordinary English players are, the sooner the delusion will stop. Robert Tressell 17 Posted 10/10/2024 at 21:53:06 I do wonder sometimes why coaches over complicate things.Also - Greek puns much harder than I expected. Luke Welch 18 Posted 10/10/2024 at 21:53:07 I doubt Carsely will get many more games… Brent Stephens 19 Posted 10/10/2024 at 22:02:04 Hellas - other people. Tony Abrahams 20 Posted 10/10/2024 at 22:05:04 We are all born equal, Barry, which makes me question how the English kids have always been taught how to play the game. Neil Tyrrell 21 Posted 10/10/2024 at 22:05:19 Someone on here (maybe Barry R?) suggested during the Euros that it wasn't all Southgate's fault, that English players just aren't that good when removed from their club-level international teammates. Based on today's evidence, I tend to agree. Experimental lineup or not, there was a lot of England's prime attacking talent on the pitch there and they basically created the square root of fuck all. And the defence was even worse! Absolutely woeful performance. John Graham 22 Posted 10/10/2024 at 22:22:06 A bunch of individuals who all wanted to win the game on their own.Pickford was awful. Too casual and panicking at every cross.Hopefully Carsley will learn it's not about just putting your better players on the pitch. Anthony Jones 23 Posted 10/10/2024 at 22:28:08 That side was so imbalanced. All these attackers trying to do a Rambo. No orchestration. No cohesion.England need a Rodri. Or even a half-Rodri. Tom Bowers 24 Posted 10/10/2024 at 22:31:16 Carsley has as much idea as Southgate which isn't much.He has a bunch of players running around like headless chickens.Sure a few have some real talent but without a Rooney or Shearer it's all a waste of time.He continues to play a right back as a utility player all over the pitch but achieving nothing of note like he did under Southgate who was heavily criticized for it.No starting place for Walker, Madison or Eze which baffles me but average players like Gordon get to start.Sorry Lee but your tenure will be brief.Bring back Big Sam (chuckle) Derek Thomas 25 Posted 10/10/2024 at 22:40:47 We 'all know'...Pickford is having a 'Gordon West post Championship / Keflavik lack of confidence season'. Stones always has a mistake in him.Alexander Arnold can't defend properlyFoden only looks good with City's stars around him.Bellingham is over ratedAnd both seem to be England's Lampard & Gerrard Mk IISolanke only got picked because he's at a sky 6 cluband Gordon is a diving rs no mark.Thus England come A-cropper-lis Mike Price 26 Posted 11/10/2024 at 00:27:34 Roy Keane sees the same Pickford I do. Pete Gunby 27 Posted 11/10/2024 at 00:30:45 Beware of Greeks bearing gifts. And also of over-rated, under-achieving English players. George Stuart 28 Posted 11/10/2024 at 02:08:11 I only watched the highlights(Highlights?)because, you know.That was fucking hilarious.I liked Carsley. I like Pickford.I never hated Gordon but seriously.On Gordon, he's over rated. He scores some reasonable goals but not many and wastes loads of good chances. Jay Harris 29 Posted 11/10/2024 at 04:19:46 Lets be honest although Pickford was a bag of nerves the defence and MF was a shambles.Bellingham, Rice, Foden and Alexander Arnold havent approached the standards that got them into the England team.Stones and Colwell were totally exposed and inadequate. Where was the defensive MF.An awful team selection Lee with no preconception of Greece's strengths. Kieran Kinsella 30 Posted 11/10/2024 at 05:07:20 Funny thing is I saw the Spurs team the other day and they had five attackers and one real midfielder. They also lost. And as tonight, before that game, I thought the coach had lost his mind. Shame though as I'd have liked to see the old Evertonian do well but I can't see Carsley bouncing back from this. Paul Ferry 31 Posted 11/10/2024 at 06:03:52 I don't know what was inside the hard-boiled egg's skull with that totally tipsy unbalanced line up. Why didn't he start Solanks or Watty? However lip lickingly tempting, you cannot start (accommodate) Foddy, Belly, Saks, and Palms in an 11. Lewis is nowhere near this level. I have never said a single bad word about our Jordan that was not deserved. Never. But with a new gaffer knocking on the door, I fear that JP's England days are numbered. He was so poor. That throw for the last disallowed goal summed it up, sadly.Carsley will not get the job. I'm sick and tired of hard-boiled eggs anyway.I'm struggling to come up with something saka/moussaka jokey and failing badly. Paul Hewitt 32 Posted 11/10/2024 at 06:48:16 The Italy against Belgium game that I watched was a far better game by the sounds of it. Why people continue to watch England and expect to be entertained is beyond me. A set of average players who only look good when they playing for there club sides. Neil Lawson 33 Posted 11/10/2024 at 07:07:32 Dyche for England. Derek Thomas 34 Posted 11/10/2024 at 07:09:03 Re. Pickford;Both for his sake and The Clubs sake...which, upon quick reflection is or should be, the same thing...and given that 'everything' will be reset / year zero with the advent of the new TFG regime.As both his Club and International bosses positions are, at the moment - for different reasons in a state of flux.Also, Didn't we just 'lose' a Goalkeeping Coach who had been here a number of years??Pickford should seriously think about taking an International 'Gap 6 mths' - or even a 'Gap Year'...he could add the proviso that should 'duty call', he's only a phone call away.He should 'Include himself Out', let the 'noise' die down, stick to his 'day job', concentrate on his own form...work on his swing in golfing terms.Carsley has maybe just had his - 'Alf Ramsey in his early days who lost 5-2 to France*' moment.I think he'll get 1 reprieve, but I'm not sure how many more.*Labone thought he got saddled with a lot of the blame for that one, but he went on to win the League in 63 and Cup in 66.Later on he too went through a rough period of form, so much so that he told Catterick he wanted to retire right there and then. Catterick convinced him (no doubt bricking it because he had no real replacement) to stay on until the end of the season.The decision made and thus the pressure off, his form returned and he went from strength to strength all the way to Mexico. Paul Ferry 35 Posted 11/10/2024 at 07:14:29 Paul H, stop being silly.While there are average or averagy or less good players, the players v Greece are nowhere being average. Brasil would lick her lips to have their Saka, Jude, Palmer, or Foden. The problem Paul is that they don't often play as a team and behind every Bellingham v Greece there was a Lewis, Pickford sadly, and fucking Guehi who I each night get on my knees and pray to the higher being that Liverpool buy. Robert Tressell 36 Posted 11/10/2024 at 07:14:30 All very strange, because only a few weeks ago Carsley was obviously a much, much better manager than Dyche. Paul Ferry 37 Posted 11/10/2024 at 07:16:53 Hard-boiled eggs, Robert mate. There's something about hard-boiled eggs with Everton ties. We need hair mate. We could do worse than the Greek gaffer Andy Warhol. Eric Myles 38 Posted 11/10/2024 at 07:18:09 Robert #17,"Also - Greek puns much harder than I expected."It's a feta complis that someone will make a cheesy pun. Mark Murphy 39 Posted 11/10/2024 at 07:38:28 Never seen so many comments on an Ingerlund game before.Personally, I didn't even know the game was on until I looked on here for Everton stuff. Colin Glassar 40 Posted 11/10/2024 at 07:44:14 No point trying to cover it up, Pickford was awful last night. He was all over the place, pointing, screaming, miles outside his area, demanding the ball at every opportunity etc… I like Jordan but last night all his worst traits came to the fore. His madness affected the defence which was already stuffed with defenders who can't defend.As for Carsley. What was he thinking? His team selection was like that of a 9-year-olds list for Father Christmas Danny O'Neill 41 Posted 11/10/2024 at 07:56:29 Same here Mark.I didn't see it, but interesting seeing Carsley's interview this morning. Saying he hopes he can go back to U21s.When there were suggestions for him to be Everton manager, my son did say that hes happier at development level.Not that I'm too fussed, but curious as to who England would go for. Paul Ferry 42 Posted 11/10/2024 at 08:01:07 Eddie Howe England gaffer, Danny mate; Lee Carsley back to the U21s.Hope you're doing well, Danny. Andrew Merrick 43 Posted 11/10/2024 at 08:05:00 Lee tried an experiment, it was obvious by 20 minutes it was a fail.The test of a manager really comes into focus when presented with such a circumstance, is there a plan b, if not why not...And surely you come up with plan b by half time...He put his hands up to his failed experiment, but didn't fix it, so a big learning moment we hope.Individual players, phew, no one shone, Jordan was at his random worst, but Greece just ran into spaces created by England having 7 or 8 attack coached players with glory in their eyes, they punished England repeatedly.22 men on the park, but only one team, and they won. Tony Abrahams 44 Posted 11/10/2024 at 08:15:32 Greatest manager we ever had was baldy, but looking back I dont think Jose Mouriniho has ever been the same since he decided to get a skinhead one summer! Danny O'Neill 45 Posted 11/10/2024 at 08:41:08 Not a bad shout, Paul.I'm all good. Sisters and cousins fussing over me. Suggesting I should give Everton a miss.Not a language I understand. Paul Ferry 46 Posted 11/10/2024 at 08:45:53 “I'm all good. Sisters and cousins fussing over me.” And so they should be, given all that has happened. I'm glad to hear it.But we know what your medicine is. Jimmy Salt 47 Posted 11/10/2024 at 08:58:14 Typical Ingurlaand team selection.Very good players shoe horned in instead of the players for the position dictated by a strategy to get the best out of the sum of its parts.Been like this since Lampard, Slippy, Beckham and Scholes.Never mind, as long as we keep selling them tv rights and merch to the far east. Dave Cashen 48 Posted 11/10/2024 at 09:38:28 People who see the likes of Saka, Palmer, Fodden, Lewis regularly and still call them "ordinary" cant possibly understand what they are watching.Despite playing for an ultra conservative coach for years These are supremely talented individuals have still manage to keep getting to finals and semi-finals of the WORLDS major tournaments ? They only come up short against better teams.All my life I have seen world class individuals beaten by better coached, better organised teams. Does that make the individuals less talented ? If England want to take the next step and actually win a tournament they have to change something. Carsley (who doesnt want the job) was experimenting. How do we know that ?...Because he told so.Those of a certain vintage will remember a Mario Zagallo "experimenting". The "Mad bastard" played five number tens in the same team. He was abused, ridiculed and even faced death threats. The press murdered him. The fans screamed for his removal. He ignored them all and went on to produce arguably the greatest football team of all time - The benefits of not listening to the self-proclaimed coach.Experiments don't always work, but they are essential. How else do you turn a group of talented individuals into a great team ? Carsley (who says he is looking forward to going back to the under 21's ) was in a position to experiment. unfortunately the reaction will almost certainly put the next permanent manager off trying it.The Greeks were the better TEAM last night, fair play to them. Barry Rathbone 49 Posted 11/10/2024 at 09:53:23 A massive problem with modern football is coaches and many fans over complicate what is the simplest of games. The greeks were no great shakes but played with freedom they weren't complicated by possession football hence hoofing it when necessary and running purposefully at that woeful England back line when they could.By contrast England players play formula footy the thought process is almost audible - "I get in this zone pass sideways to bad haircut boy who trundles it to posturing Herbert before aimlessly passing back to the keeper to start again".When England equalized there was a 5 minute spell when the shackles come off and they played "proper" football just like the stuff you played on the park. Yes, it can make you more vulnerable and that horrendous defense let another in but my bet is you win more than you lose playing with freedom and with decent players you win stuff.The biggest example is the crew across the park. Since Shankly they've got at teams from minute one with the simplest of hard running games doing the basics and have won everything bar the grand national.Everton take note. Andy Crooks 50 Posted 11/10/2024 at 10:29:55 When I collected football cards as kid I used to put them into teams and had the eleven best players, regardless of any teamwork.I can remember way back Wales having three big centre forwards. Toshack, Ron Davies and Wyn Davis. If all three were fit, they started.I honestly think that Alf Ramsey is the only England coach who didn't shoehorn players into the team.Was it Ron Greenwood who alternated Shilton and Clemence? Great coaches don't do that. Ian Jones 51 Posted 11/10/2024 at 11:00:33 I don't usually watch England games outside of World Cups and Euros but I sat down last night to watch the game last night as I was interested to see how Lee Carsley set the team out. Ok, the result might have been disappointing to those who like to see England playing well and winning, but, as the manager has indicated, he tried something different after a very short period of practising it in training. The players would have probably only arrived at the England camp on Monday, so there were only 2 full days to assess the players available, say bye to the injured ones and plan for the game.I think Lee Carsley deserves some plaudits for trying something different. The fact that it didn't work so well could be down to not having some players available for it to be fully put into practice and lack of preparation.Better to try something in games which don't necessarily have much importance and in the absence of friendlies, the Nations League is the next best thing.Players need to get used to Lee Carsley and vice-versa. Am sure he would love to be appointed England national team manager and his comments about being 'hopeful' of return to U21s are borne out of a realisation that however well he does as the interim manager, he may not get the job so hopes he wouldn't be overlooked when going back to U21s.Just heard that Spain's current manager lost his 2nd game in charge 2 nil to Scotland. Imagine Spain are pleased they kept him. Denis Richardson 52 Posted 11/10/2024 at 11:44:19 Didnt watch the game and even just thinking about the Nations League makes my eyes glaze over. However, I see the rabid press are frothing at the mouth about the result and performance. Ultimately Carsley tried something new, it didnt work, end of. No one died. The game and ‘tournament is pretty meaningless in any case. I hope he doesnt get the job, he clearly doesnt want it in any case. Let someone else deal with the usual round pegs in square holes thats been the England team for about the last 20 years. The ‘96 side for me was the last one that really had balance and quality all over the pitch - Darren Anderton excepted. When does the real football start again? Do we really need THREE international breaks from September to November? Theres way too much international football. Even the group games in the major tournaments have become boring, never mind the Nations League and friendlies. Kevin Molloy 53 Posted 11/10/2024 at 12:03:31 Sheeesh!Jordan won't be pleased with that one. John Keating 54 Posted 11/10/2024 at 12:29:56 I like Pickford and over the last few years he has really showed his worth when needed.It might be time to give him a stint on the bench. Maybe it might help him to refocus as so far this season has not been his best.All players go through a dodgy period. Thoughts vary from drop him to play through it. That may be fair for an outfield player, however, at Premier League level, playing without the whole 11 playing at 100%, especially goalies, only ends in one way. Jimmy Hogan 55 Posted 11/10/2024 at 12:37:25 How do you shoehorn all of England's best players into the team? The answer is you don't. When Jack Charlton said to Sir Alf Ramsey, "Gaffer, why am I in the team? There are better players than me available", Ramsey replied, "I don't want you to play. I want you to stop them playing". Nigel Scowen 56 Posted 11/10/2024 at 13:02:05 John @54,He was one of the best players against Newcastle? Ron Sear 57 Posted 11/10/2024 at 13:04:14 Nice to see the Ingerland fans getting the Everton supporter experience. John Keating 58 Posted 11/10/2024 at 18:12:44 Nigel 56, Fully agree. Saving the penalty was brilliant!Jordan has been fantastic for us since he's came. I will not fault him.However, now and again, best going outside the firing line. Bill Gall 60 Posted 11/10/2024 at 21:02:56 Pickford has a bad game and right away the knives come out. Derek Knox 61 Posted 11/10/2024 at 22:02:15 Bill G, could have been a lot worse, if the forking spoons got involved too ! :-) Tim Greeley 62 Posted 12/10/2024 at 02:24:17 Some of the comments are so English… Ya'll have been to quite a few world-class international finals and semi-finals in the past 6 years (but lost, admittedly 😜) so it's hard to really agree that English players only look good next to their (insert any other nationality) teammates in the Premier League. Like the talent is there…maybe you just need an American manager or something? George Stuart 66 Posted 12/10/2024 at 07:35:51 That was terrible. If Pickford is to have an appalling, keystone cops game, let it be for England.I've heard about Big Jack Charlton, that Sir Alf Ramsey was asked why him? Alf replied, because he doesn't trust Bobby Moore. Bobby Moore was the smoothest, one of the best defenders I have ever seen.Imagine a John Stones that made a mistake every three years instead of three mistakes every game. Michael Kenrick 67 Posted 12/10/2024 at 08:34:46 Pickford provides his considered post-game analysis of the England performance:“Sometimes in football it becomes a bit weird because a couple of scruffy passes actually gets you out and gets us countered quite quickly - and Greece did that a few times.“They played the long ball and won probably second balls more than we won and that might have been the difference. But the football we played was good. We weren't far off. It was only two or three transitions in which we got caught. Apart from that, we controlled it.“We knew they were going to have transitions and it's about us getting back into shape. And we did it for large parts of the evening and a couple of times we got caught.“It's never nice for a player or staff to get beat at Wembley. The manager picked the team and we've just got to try and execute the game plan.“We've not had long to get ourselves ready. People played Sunday so they had to recover properly because everyone's played a lot of games over the last month."We didn't get it fully right and we got beat. Now we've just got to go and win away on Sunday against Finland and then the next camp in Greece away and Ireland at home.”The only thing missing is "Fine margins". Paul Kossoff 68 Posted 12/10/2024 at 09:20:48 The England team played Hydra and go seek. But like Polyphemus they couldn't find anyone,they were fleeced. Paul Kossoff 69 Posted 12/10/2024 at 14:14:41 My son was happy England were beaten, he called it a Greek tragedy, mind you his name is Jason. I thought they played like a one Sandaled men. I'll get me coat. Paul Ferry 70 Posted 13/10/2024 at 08:13:25 Bobby Mallon 68: "Why the fuck we don't tell these players to pretend they are injured so they don't go is beyond me."Spot on, Bobby, because they take no fucking pride in playing for their shitty countries who clearly rank well below Everton in their loyalties. Don't they?Beyond you? Well that probably says something about you Bobby.File under knobhead post. Paul Ferry 75 Posted 13/10/2024 at 18:28:48 Kim (72), that's how they taught us to be at Bowker and King mate. Took no prisoners, the Bowker and King lads. Add Your Comments In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site. » Log in now Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site. How to get rid of these ads and support TW © ToffeeWeb