Season › 2024-25 › News Kevin Thelwell issues classy farewell statement to Blues 10/03/2025 25comments | Jump to last Kevin Thelwell has issued a classy farewell statement to Blues fans as he summarizes the challenges and triumphs of the last 3 years as Everton's Director of Football: Dear Evertonians, I would like to start by saying what a privilege it has been to serve as Director of Football for the past three years. This is an incredible club with so many good people working for it and supporting it. I am proud to have been given the opportunity to work here. Despite the difficulties we have faced over this period I have loved every minute of it, even in the most challenging of these times. Clearly, we have had some tough obstacles to overcome, and it has not been what any of us would have hoped for or wanted for our club. With a backdrop of PSR commissions, points deductions, relegation fights, takeover attempts and a financial reality that necessitated tough decisions on player transfers and significantly reduced team investment, it has not been easy to keep our heads above water and retain our Premier League status. Navigating the last three years, whilst building a magnificent new stadium, hopefully provides some pride for you and gives everyone associated with our club and the city the opportunity to look forward to a brighter future. I feel that I leave with the Club in a much better place than when I arrived, both on the pitch and off it. Being consistently outspent by every team in the league has not been easy but it was a necessity to ensure the survival of our club – and that is something that I’ve always been honest and open about. My goal has always been to manage with the multiple immediate challenges, without jeopardising the long-term future of the Club. As a result, we are in a much stronger financial position, and I am excited about where we are on the pitch. From a football perspective we have had to be creative through player trading. Whilst we have received £225m in player sales over the last three years, our circumstances have only allowed us to spend £145m across six transfer windows. Whilst we haven’t got every move right, to build a team capable of competing at Premier League level against that landscape, having to be pragmatic in moving on some of our best players and future talent in the process, is an incredible achievement. We have some outstanding professionals here and the experience of Seamus, Jordan, Tarky, Gana and Doucs in particular have helped to keep our ship steady in the most difficult of times. We also have a core of outstanding young talents that have the potential to play key roles in Everton’s future in Jarrad, Jimmy, Dwight, Jake, Tim, Yousseff, Harrison, Nathan and of course Iliman. I look forward to seeing them do us proud in the games to come. Finally, I would like to thank David and his coaching team for an excellent job so far – long may it continue! Also, thank you to the dedicated staff at Finch Farm who have worked so hard and sacrificed so much to keep the wheels turning, and to TFG who we all hope will take the Club back to where it belongs! And last but certainly not least, I would like to thank you. Every Evertonian has played as significant a part as anybody at the Club during what has been the toughest and most uncertain of times. The unstinting backing for the players and staff at Goodison, and on the road, has been humbling and amazing to see every week. I am eternally grateful to have seen and felt your support and passion. Thank you again for that support, and best wishes for the future. Kev. Quotes sourced from Association of Sporting Directors Reader Comments (25) Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer () Paul Hewitt 1 Posted 10/03/2025 at 14:55:02 He did a decent job. But he did buy Maupay. One of the worst signings in our history. Ian Burns 2 Posted 10/03/2025 at 14:55:56 What a wonderful way to sign off - first class, and some.Somebody remind me again - why is he leaving? Christy Ring 3 Posted 10/03/2025 at 15:00:47 I think hes done a fantastic job in probably the worst 3 years in the clubs history. Imagine trying to do a job with both hands tied behind your back, bringing in players with no money to spend upfront. I wish him all the best. Nigel Scowen 4 Posted 10/03/2025 at 15:25:55 All the very best to you Kevin Thelwell, thank you.Ian@2Unless he has made the decision to leave himself for a new challenge which I doubt Ian then I would be guessing that its because he is part of the old regime and TFG want their own man. For me though this is the worst decision that TFG have made so far.Paul@1Maupay is a classic example of what this guy was having to deal with in the market Paul. He cost about £12 million I believe. If you spend £12 million on a striker then you get a £12 million striker. Bog all in EPL terms. Danny O'Neill 5 Posted 10/03/2025 at 15:26:15 If he was a player, that is top drawer.The honesty about the shit sandwich he was dealt oozes out of his statement.I can't help but think that he must be envious that he won't get the chance to have taken us forward under the new ownership and the new Everton Stadium.But, the owners clearly have different plans on our future direction.Good luck and best wishes Mr Thelwell. I for one, believe you done a good job with your hands tied, which you openly explain. Raymond Fox 6 Posted 10/03/2025 at 15:26:40 He should be staying, whoever has made the decision have made a mistake.It might be the owners, maybe its Davy, who if there is to be a DoF wants his own man or maybe wants to go it alone.We will probably find out in time. Sam Hoare 7 Posted 10/03/2025 at 15:26:49 Paul@1, he did better than a decent job. Maupay was probably his only real dud and even then is not that close to 'One of the worst signings in our history' mainly because he cost so little and actually we almost broke even on him after his several loan fees.The likes of Bolasie, Tosun, Klaassen, Sigurdsson, Koldrup and Scheniderlin all cost more relatively than Maupay and all left for peanuts.I think he has proved a canny operator and we will do well to improve on Thelwell. Mike Gaynes 8 Posted 10/03/2025 at 15:35:47 "Classy" is the appropriate word... particularly the final acknowledgement of the fans' support for the club and players in these difficult times. Too often the supporters get thanked only with a dry de rigueur statement that seems to come out of a phrasebook. This one is clearly from the heart.Ian #2, I wish he wasn't. I think he's done a hell of a job. But TFG has every right to put its own people and system in place.PH #1, guess you've run a complex business operation without making a single personnel mistake. Congratulations. Ken Kneale 9 Posted 10/03/2025 at 15:43:21 His contribution to ensuring both our top flight status and our very existence I think will be viewed better by history than some judge him right now.The whole Kenwright and then the Kenwright/Moshiri period has seen a watering down of the club status, the sale of our assets on and off the pitch and a collapse of the footballing status we enjoyed for almost all of our previous pre Kenwright history - instead we had directors and shareholders feeing us untruths about everything from investment to physical attack. I am thankful we survived and i thank everyone who assisted - some I acknowledge may not have got near Everton in the role they held at one time, but in trying times Thelwell and several others did a good job.Good luckl to him. Kieran Kinsella 10 Posted 10/03/2025 at 15:44:58 Be interesting if Thelwell ever decides to write a book on his time at the club. Jerome Shields 11 Posted 10/03/2025 at 15:46:45 Thewell did a Ok job, but was able to employ a lot of staff without accountability.The Chief Executive at that time absolving all accountabilty or just know any better, which is more likely, even announcing the number of extra staff that Thewell had employed as if it was a plus.When TFG conducted their 100 days review this would have come up like a sore thumb..The easiest solution was to get rid of Thewell and restart and restructure with a new Chief Executive who would be accountable.It is a attempt to tackle one of Gerald McKean's (who worked at Everton) 'Little Empires'.Hopefully it is the beginning and the other 'little Empires' that have plagued Everton follow suit.Really good news for the future of Everton. Paul Hewitt 12 Posted 10/03/2025 at 16:00:21 Mike@8. It was tongue in cheek mate,like I said he's did a decent job. And I've made plenty of mistakes. John Raftery 13 Posted 10/03/2025 at 16:01:13 Arguably the best appointments Moshiri made in his nearly eight years tenure were his last two; Thelwell and Dyche. We were fortunate they were competent to deal with the situation in which they found themselves. Mike Gaynes 14 Posted 10/03/2025 at 16:16:41 John #13, I'd nominate Dan Meis and Colin Chong as good Moshiri decisions as well. PH #12, sorry about that, I can't always spot satire. Guess I need a winkie emoji or something. Mark Murphy 15 Posted 10/03/2025 at 16:20:04 Tbf Maupay was brought in to work with a target man, not be the target man. I recently spoke with “Billy the bee”, the Brentford podcast bloke, who interviewed Maupay and said he was actually a really nice fella but hated our fans for the way they treated him and his team mates, especially that time on the railway station. Colin Crooks 16 Posted 10/03/2025 at 16:20:48 A lot of people have come in or a lot of flack at our club in the past couple of seasons. I believe it to be unjust.They didnt create this shitstorm. They were simply tasked with keeping us afloat while we went through it. They did it. Job done Jay Harris 17 Posted 10/03/2025 at 16:50:40 I love the way he quietly went on with his job and now pens a heartfelt letter.Very genuine and classy man. Bill Gall 19 Posted 10/03/2025 at 17:34:47 Well thank you Mr.K.Thelwell for a job well done under difficult conditions. As Director of Football I guess that there is more to it than just transfers of players, of which most supporters seem to think that was all you done. Congratulations for what you achieved in one of the most challenging periods of Everton F.C. when certain members of the FA seemed to want and tried to achieve Everton getting relegated.And thank you for this letter that shows you understood the value of the worldwide Everton supporters., all the best in your future. Dan Doran 20 Posted 10/03/2025 at 17:51:55 @ Paul, Every club has bad signings just like every player has bad games. Were gonna get a good chunk of what we paid for Maupay back when his loan becomes permanent and he was not on big wages. As far as transfers go, weve had way more damaging deals. (Tosun, Walcott, Bolaise, Schneiderlin, Gbamin…) Im tired of people judging Thelwell off of one bad signing that didnt really have much effect on us in the long run. Especially when he had plenty of good transfers all while having the only net POSITIVE (Brighton aside) transfer spend over his 3 years.Let the Maupay signing go already people. Ian Wilkins 21 Posted 10/03/2025 at 17:56:29 His reminding us that we spent £140m over 6 transfer windows with receipts of £220m over the same period, alongside the issues we were dealing with ( PSR deductions, change of ownership etc) puts his period of tenure into perspective. A few dud recruits for me, and Id like to have seen the Academy progress further, but on reflection its hard to disagree with Kevin having done a very good job.Good luck to him. Dave Abrahams 22 Posted 10/03/2025 at 18:03:29 I think Thelwell did a very good job in absolutely terrible circumstances I think he deserved more than a thank off the club but I hope he has something lined up to move into, best of luck in the future Kevin. Mike Oates 23 Posted 10/03/2025 at 18:07:09 I just hope hes not replaced by a “ Friedkin Global Football Director “ who works for both Rome and Everton. It would be a recipe for disaster, as would Moyes trying to do all jobs again.Still not sure why Thelwell sacked Liam Mogan 24 Posted 10/03/2025 at 18:11:40 Respect to him for his efforts when we were in the middle of a existential crisis. Further respect to him for a heartfelt leaving message. Seems to get the club.In today's click bait world he's either 'shite' or 'brilliant'. He did a good job and I hope we don't regret letting him go. Good luck Kevin. Paul Ferry 25 Posted 10/03/2025 at 18:19:47 Classy. Good luck to him. Martin Farrington 26 Posted 10/03/2025 at 18:29:29 Mike @ 23He hasnt been sacked.He hasnt been offered a contract after his current one expires at the end of the season. Add Your Comments In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site. » Log in now Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site. How to get rid of these ads and support TW © ToffeeWeb