City beat Europe-bound Blues in Goodison thriller

, 3 May, 44comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 2 - 3 Manchester City

Ross Barkley opened the scoring with a brilliant goal after 11 minutes
Clinical finishing combined with staunch defending by title-chasing Manchester City ensured that they edged Everton in a pulsating contest that was ignited by a sumptuous goal from Ross Barkley.

With defeats for Manchester United and Tottenham earlier in the day, Roberto Martinez's team knew that they were effectively guaranteed European football next season with a fifth-place finish but any fears that neighbours Liverpool might have had about a lack of drive from the Blues was dispelled by Barkley after 10 minutes.

The 20-year-old swept a stunning shot over Joe Hart from beyond the corner of the penalty area from Steven Naismith's lay-off to open the scoring and temporarily throw the Premier League title race open again.

The visitors responded with rapier-like precision, though, scoring three unanswered goals over the ensuing 37 minutes.

First, Sergio Aguero latched into Yaya Toure's pass and beat Tim Howard all too easily at the American's near post.

Then, a couple of minutes before half time, James Milner was allowed to clip a cross into the heart of the Everton area where Edin Dzeko rose unchallenged to head home and make it 2-1 at the break.

City threatened to break the game wide open three minutes after half time when they carved the Blues' three-man defence open at will again to make it 3-1. Samir Nasri collected a neat ball over the top and then engineered space for a low centre that Dzeko side-footed home from close range.

Things might have been very different had Joe Hart not pulled off a superb finger-tip save a couple of minutes earlier to deny Steven Naismith. The Scot had nipped past his marker to meet Barkley's through-ball but then saw his shot pushed inches past the far post by the England 'keeper.

Pellegrini seemed happy for his charges to retreat a little but then had his nerves and those of his players and fans alike set on edge when Leighton Baines whipped in a dangerous ball behind their defence and Romelu Lukaku threw himself at it, crashing a header in off the post to make it 3-2 with 25 minutes to go.

Everton couldn't find another way through, however, until Gerard Deulofeu's shot was deflected dramatically into the side-netting by Hart as the Blues pressed while Howard saved well from Pablo Zabaleta and Osman blocked a goal-bound shot by DiMichaelis.

City held out to grab the points to remain on course for the Premier League title while Everton saw their last hopes of a Champions League place ended.

Full coverage: ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (44)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Paul Kernot
2 Posted 03/05/2014 at 23:35:05
If we had to lose today then the other results (Tottenham and Utd) were a huge bonus. Congratulations once again to Roberto. He knew going into this that we had almost no chance of making 4th but that Europa League was safe so he shuffled his pack and we had a real go. It almost worked too.

Now it would be another nice little bonus to see Man City go on and nick the league from the RS with no harm done to us. Another interesting day in the Premier League.

Phil Sammon
3 Posted 04/05/2014 at 00:48:59
Was it a 'thriller' or was it a flat, dull affair?

I left Goodison thinking it had been a good game and thought that at least we gave it a go until the end.

I then got a text from my mate back in Leeds saying there was more atmosphere at the snooker that day.

I can't help but feel that the Sky coverage made the game flatter than it actually was.

Strange.

Steavey Buckley
4 Posted 04/05/2014 at 00:54:17
The moment I realised that Bob got the formation wrong with a 3-5-2 with Osman playing alongside McCarthy instead of Barry, who was ineligible – Stones would have been a far better choice, because of the way he brings the ball out of defense – I knew it was going to be one of those days.

Any experienced team would soon figure out that those who were playing such a system would soon fail to mark who they should have been And it was no surprise that all 3 of City's goals came about because of the Everton formation.

James Martin
5 Posted 04/05/2014 at 01:14:16
Martinez was well within his rights to experiment. We weren't changing position, we had injuries, plus that formation had worked against Man City before. We didn't owe anyone anything.

Had Distin been playing, I think we would have been more solid. Baines, Alcaraz and an unfit Jags was always a disaster waiting to happen.

Paul Kernot
6 Posted 04/05/2014 at 01:24:41
I absolutely agree James. Just like a pre-season game. Nothing much to lose or gain and given the injuries, I thought we did fairly well.

Alcaraz looks like he would have been a bloody good buy 6 or 7 years ago. He knows the game and makes some important contributions but is too old and slow for an upwardly mobile Premier League team.

Andy Crooks
7 Posted 04/05/2014 at 01:33:26
Not a bad day at all.
Steavey Buckley
8 Posted 04/05/2014 at 01:53:05
If Everton had won today, we would have been just 1 point behind Arsenal with them playing today against Vic's West Brom....
Tim Greeley
9 Posted 04/05/2014 at 01:42:24
It all actually worked out quite well for ze Blues... and even better for the fans. Didn't think such a thing was possible.

Personally, I'll feel better about 5th with a strong win at Hull. Take it either way though.

Europa League is a deserved reward for a genuinely good season, no matter what some say. Excited for what's to come......;)

Mike Gaynes
10 Posted 04/05/2014 at 03:58:42
Not sure if everybody caught it, but there was a quintessential Martinez moment today that exemplified the transition of this team. From 17:30, when Alcaraz took a free kick after Naismith was fouled, until 20:00, when Coleman mis-hit a cross over the bar, Everton controlled the ball nonstop for two and a half minutes. 54 consecutive completed passes.

I've never seen anything like it from our team before.

Kevin Rowlands
11 Posted 04/05/2014 at 04:57:37
Barkley was outstanding today, I would say he's booked his flight on the plane to Brazil for sure. I hope to god he signs a new improved contract or it's going to be a very worrying off season.

As for the RS, fuck them, if they want to point fingers and insinuate, maybe they should start in house with Captain fucking Marvel.

Darryl Ritchie
13 Posted 04/05/2014 at 05:46:58
Finally got to watch the match. The blues played hard, no doubt in my mind what they wanted the outcome to be. Barkley's goal is going to be a BPL goal of the year candidate. Perfection! I think that goal, and his play in this game, got him a ticket to Brazil.

We were a little bit dodgy at the back. We miss Distin's steadying influence more than we care to admit. Have to work more on " the three across the back " defence. A way to many gaps, and players not sure what they're supposed to do.

Glad that one's history. A way too much drama for me! The Hull match is going to be pleasurable to watch. The pressure is off, for players and fans. 72 points( possible) and fifth place ( certain ), not bad for a " transitional season ".

Phil Hendren
14 Posted 04/05/2014 at 06:15:01
Weirdest game I’ve ever watched. Totally conflicted feelings throughout. Wanted us to win but at the same time when we were losing I was still quite upbeat. Barkley goal was absolutely sublime that’s for sure.
Jermaine Jennings
15 Posted 04/05/2014 at 07:22:26
Despite the strange circumstances and the null atmosphere at goodison except for when we scored the players were first class!!! I thought City were not that good and if it were any other game without such circumstances.re RS then we would have battered them!!!

Look forward to next season when they come back to goodison because they will get what they deserve a proper spanking!!!

Jim Bennings
16 Posted 04/05/2014 at 08:29:14
Very very good first season for Martinez.

Area's we do really need to improve next season?

We need to get much better with corners, I get sick of seeing every corner kick we take cleared, has one of our centre halves won a header from a corner all season? This might just be the first time I can say that we haven't had a single goal from a centre back all season.
That must improve.

Elsewhere, we need to also get better defending crosses setpieces/corners.
We have had Distin/Jagielka, Stones/Distin and various other partnerships but we always look weak with any crosses coming at us.

I think we need an eventual replacement for Distin and even Jags who's best days in my opinion are behind him.
Stones is the future, Alcaraz is a stop gap but nothing special and always injured whilst Duffy is clearly not fancied either not good enough or whatever.

We also need to find another 20 goal striker.
We got lucky to sign Lukaku for nothing but he now leaves for nothing as our top scorer.
It's not very often an Everton striker scores 15 goals so we desperately need to replace Lukaku's goals with like for like.

Naismith is a trier but can't put the ball away on a consistent basis needed to score the required goals.

All in all a satisfactory season with the target of Europe reached.

The Champions League will still remain out of bounds though until we find extra finances to sign the top class players to win us so many of those tight games we struggle in.

Jim Bennings
17 Posted 04/05/2014 at 09:42:01
Just for the record.

Lets not hear anymore on here about the Redshite.

This is our website and should be about EFC and only EFC.

If those bitter deluded glory seekers across the park think we cost them the title then let them, who gives a shit.

They fucked it up themselves and the first thing they should do is take creasehead to a good shoe shop so he can get some grips.

Assholes

Tony Dove
19 Posted 04/05/2014 at 10:24:27
Hi Jim
Had any further thoughts on Ross?
Alan Newton
20 Posted 04/05/2014 at 10:26:55
I'm not sure I could call the game a "thriller" or "pulsating" but it had the odd moment of interest in between our drab defending and the on-going bafflement of Tim Howard's goalkeeping. Another two goals - the first for definite - that he should be stopping.

It's been a very disappointing last three weeks with three defeats in four during that period, after such a long unbeaten run and a season with only five defeats previously. I understand we don't have the squad and resources that others have, so injuries have an impact but Palace and Southampton were both avoidable, which would have made the City game yesterday a while different affair.

The silver lining is that it means the RS probably won't win the title, but I'm not counting on that yet! It wouldn't surprise me if Villa went and did a job on City on Wednesday night.

Jim Bennings
21 Posted 04/05/2014 at 10:40:02
Hi Tony

Ross was truly out of this world yesterday and if Hodgson had doubts about taking him to Brazil then that performance surely means Ross needs to start checking up the necessary travel requirements for South America.

That is the type of display that I would love to see on a more consistent basis from Barkley.
The slightly frustrating thing is we all know how good he is, he dictates games against the best sides but let's his levels slip against the lesser teams but hopefully that will come in time.

He was head and shoulders above everybody else yesterday though and that goes for those playing for City also

Eugene Ruane
22 Posted 04/05/2014 at 10:39:55
I (like Phil Sammon) was a little confused about the lack of atmosphere thing.

I went to the match, thought the atmosphere was, if not pulsating for the entire 96 mins, erm..'animated' enough, then I headed out for a pint.

This morning I'm catching up with all this Martin Tyler/Gary Neville stuff and thinking what the fuck was broadcast yesterday?

I'd actually like to see it just to see what was going on.

Believe me, I've seen Goodison quieter on hundreds of occasions

Jim Bennings
23 Posted 04/05/2014 at 10:48:51
Dare we say that the atmosphere wad a little like that at Anfield in May 1995 when Liverpool beat Blackburn (against their fans muted cheers, especially Redknapps winning free-kick).

Kopites thought they had gifted the Premier League crown to Man Utd thus the cursed ccelebration and then st the final whistle the fucking King Kenny love in.

Of course it's all ok when they do it but when it goes against Liverpool it's a conspiracy.

Absolute whoppers that lot they really are.

David Graves
25 Posted 04/05/2014 at 11:25:44
The amosphere wasn't as it was for Arsenal or United recently but it was still good. There was the odd shout of "come on citeh" but who didnt boo the shameful antics of Dzeko and if Del boy had levelled it the roof would have come off.
Raymond Fox
26 Posted 04/05/2014 at 10:59:10
Ridiculous for anyone to suggest we were not trying to win that game.

As for our defending, Alcaraz has been slated for going in to stop Toure, no one else was going to tackle him what's he supposed to do? We all know how dangerous Toure is when he's allowed space.
It depends how good the attackers are from a defenders perspective, they have special players which can make any defenders look average.

I had a look at the live forum yesterday, what a crock of shite that was!

We are going to finish 5th and qualify for the Europa thingy, if we do our best to win the thing I think it will definitely affect our league form.
We will finish lower than 5th next year for my money, I would have preferred us
to be able to concentrated on the PL and the cup competitions only.

Jim Bennings
27 Posted 04/05/2014 at 11:35:15
If you watch that full match again from yesterday then we probably had more clear chances than City so any deluded halfwit who tells you we threw the game really is just that...a serious deluded halfwit.

We keep the ball well, created chances and had the last chance of the match with Deulofeu, this against moneybags Man City with Christ knows how many players missing..Mirallas, Distin, Pienaar, Barry.

The only thing we didn't do well yesterday was defend.

Jim Knightley
28 Posted 04/05/2014 at 11:39:05
We got fifth before the match..we were never going to play at 100%, because the game was essentially meaningless. We did as well as we could of in the circumstances, and could of come away with a draw.

I'm very excited for next season. We are not going to get top four without spending, so why not go for the Europa League? Getting into the group stages is pretty much a formality, and then we'd have four 2 legged ties, and a final, in the way of a Champions League place. I think it's a competition we could at least reasonably expect to get to the last 16 in, and then, who knows?

The major issue for me, is both the squad size, and the aging cbs. Martinez has done a fantastic job in terms of bringing youngsters through, but the CB situation scares the hell out me long term. I simply think that Alcaraz is not good enough...I've thought it all season, as illustrated through my posts, and nothing has changed that opinion. I think Jags and Distin are superb, and still good enough, but they are on the wane. So Martinez needs to do what he has rarely done in his career, and sign a top effective cb. We are losing three effective loan players, and although I expect another three will come, they will not be as effective. I expect we will spend 20million in the summer, maybe even slightly more. If we sign Barry on a short term deal, and bring in a couple of young attacking loans to pad out our squad (Deulofeu could well come back I think, depending on how the issues with Pedro and Fabregas develop), I think it will leave 20mil for another centre back, a top striker, and perhaps another creative midfielder to play from the left, or the centre. The money will not go far. Personally, I'd be looking at Hernandez from United in a big way. Alderweireld also has not settled, and might be a tempting option. And if we cant get Barry, I think getting Tiago in on a one year deal would not be bad work. Whatever happens, with 4 loan deals ending, I think we need to add 8 to the squad to keep numbers up. I do not see Lukaku coming back, although I would love that to happen. I think Deulofeu might, and Traore could stay, and become useful in terms of Europa cup football in particular. I expect Barry will sign a short deal. But much of our season will depend on who the other five are.

Tony Dove
29 Posted 04/05/2014 at 12:13:33
Jim. Good stuff. He will hopefully get more consistent as time goes on. His potential is a bit frightening.
Matthew Roberts
30 Posted 04/05/2014 at 12:26:37
Good game, we looked good in spells, the defensive mistakes I can forgive because of our injuries and players unfit. Also, Ross showing how good for us he will be or how much he will cost somebody else.

Reflecting on the season, I think 5th is pretty impressive... but it's not the position that is so impressive: it's out record points tally. I've got a better and more hopeful feeling of things to come than I would have with Moyes.

Roger Helm
31 Posted 04/05/2014 at 12:33:44
Was the atmosphere muted? I went to the game and it seemed normal to me, the usual volume of sound or perhaps even a little more.

I am a little concerned about RM's defensive abilities. We have defended reasonably well this season, but with the defence that Moyes made. If Alcaraz is RM's idea of a good CB we should all be worried. Distin is good but too old now, Jags and Stones are not big enough. I'd favour Stones to partner McCarthy in CM and get someone bigger to partner Jags, or even re-sign Lescott; City's CBs DiMichalis and Kompany looked far more impressive.

We did well to score twice but were let down by our defence. All their goals looked pretty easy. Perhaps it wasn't the best time to experiment with three at the back.

Oliver Molloy
32 Posted 04/05/2014 at 12:49:48
Well, I wanted us to win, always do – no matter what. The fact is we didn't and Man City now have it in their hands once again.

I also think Aston Villa could pull off a shock this coming Wednesday; if they do, it will be interesting to see the comments flooding in on ToffeeWeb!

Jim Bennings
33 Posted 04/05/2014 at 12:50:15
Jagielka and Distin have been great servants but even great servants eventually need replacing.

We need a commanding strong centre half who is good in the air, somebody a bit younger than Jags but still experienced enough to help along Stones.

McCarthy has had a magnificent season, I just really really would love to see him add a few goals to his game.

Did anybody else notice that there was no Player of the Season announced before kick off??

Or did I arrive too late to miss it?

Sean Kelly
34 Posted 04/05/2014 at 12:58:31
I would like to say my heartfelt thanks to Roberto and the squad for giving me an enjoyable season. My Player of the Season is Seamus by a country mile. To see the young lads develop is a huge bonus for us. It's been a transition year and to see how far we have come under Roberto just compare it to Man Utd's transition season.

The only regrets I have are the early season draws. The WBA game away, Sunderland and Palace at home. If only.... but that's football.

We might have three of the loanees here next year: Del Boy, Traore and Barry on a permanent deal. Lukaku will be playing elsewhere next season and, even though he chipped in with some goals, I questioned his attitude regularly throughout the season. He's nowhere near worth £25 million.

For next season, we need a centre back, a midfield playmaker, a centre forward or two. How we do that I don't know with the reported £20 million budget but I'm already looking forward to next season and European football. If we can get some investment by some sheik or any other oil baron, who knows what we might achieve.

Oh another bonus this season was crease-head's slip. It couldn't have been scripted better (even by Billy). The sight of that prick screaming no more slip-ups pissed me off no end but the image of him slipping up will last forever. This is justice for the Blues fans who have suffered by them cheating and influencing refs either directly on the pitch or by their media mates. I have that slip on a loop and haven't stopped laughing for a week.

Thanks Roberto for an enjoyable season.

Kevin Tully
35 Posted 04/05/2014 at 14:17:30
Some commentators, journo's and 'pundits' will be proven very wrong next season. This is James McCarthy's first season with us and I truly believe he will be even better next season. I also think Ross Barkley will become world class over the next couple of years, the first player to wear the royal blue since Rooney with that sort of talent.

If we can find a striker we won't miss Barry, Deulofeu or even Lukaku. Anyone questioning what will happen next season without these players is not aware of the stars we already have - Barkley, Coleman, Baines, Stones and McCarthy would all be a target for any of the monied clubs if for sale. That's half a side who would walk into a Utd or Chelsea team. Barkley & Stones will take a couple more seasons before they realise their full potential, but we definitely push on from here.

We have the perfect manager to bring the best out of these young players, that's half the battle.

Peter Askins
36 Posted 04/05/2014 at 14:41:14
A few points, after just getting back from yesterday's match.

What's all this rubbish about "muted atmosphere"? Please, don't buy into this "Martin Tyler" agenda. It was the same, if not better, than every match I've been to this season. Actually, I've never known the area around Goodison to be so busy two hours before kick-off.

Alcaraz seems to be the new fall guy, but how difficult is it to stop/block crosses coming into our box, and killing the danger at source? All our defenders have been culpable lately – Baines, Coleman, Stones, Distin, Jags, and yes, Alcaraz. Get tight to the attacker, and if the worst happens and he "does you", bring him down (outside the box, preferably !), and re-set for the free kick.

The loanees are irreplaceable? What nonsense. Fair enough, they've all done well relatively, but I trust Martinez 100% to find even better, if all go back to their parent clubs.

Finally, the biggest statement we can make in the transfer market this summer is to buy a goalkeeper worthy of a club with top four ambitions. I like him 'n' all, but if Tim Howard is the answer, you're not asking the right question.

Nev Renshaw
37 Posted 04/05/2014 at 15:40:07
Looking at the league table and in particular 'goals against' there's only Chelski & Man Shitty had less goals scored against them than us. Perhaps our defence is not as leaky as some would have us believe. We could so easily have finished 3rd if our strikers had tried just that bit harder. Remember at the start of the season we had all those draws that should have been wins. Looking forward to the next campaign. COYB.
Colin Williams
38 Posted 04/05/2014 at 16:36:58
Peter#38 Great comments, especially about Howard! One of a few weak links we have.

Tony Hanlon
39 Posted 04/05/2014 at 16:57:23
Let's hope for an Arsenal win in the FA Cup Final so as to avoid a play-off match to qualify for group stages of Europa league.
Jim Bennings
40 Posted 04/05/2014 at 17:10:56
Nev

That's a pretty good point you make.
We do have a relatively strong defence, I personally believe it's because we always seem to concede the same kind of sloppy goals that they are constantlyput under microscope.

A clear example is that we seem very fragile defending corners crosses and we have done for more than two years.

The problem when defending corners and setpieces etc is that we seem statuesque, there is no movement, no jostling or trying to go with your man. We seem to stand there and just watch as done big bustling defender from the opposition walks in unmarked and buries a header.

The same applies when we have a corner ourselves..No movement, no trying to drag the opposing defence out of position, we just stand static and try to win headers from a standing jump...This is in my opinion why we struggle to make any impact in either box on dead ball situations.

Kieran Fitzgerald
41 Posted 04/05/2014 at 19:14:20
Tony, I just looked at the qualification rules on the PL website. An Arsenal win would indeed see us straight through to the group stage.

Ray Said
42 Posted 04/05/2014 at 20:21:07
Jim Bennings: I agree with your point about defending corners. The players seem to be marking space rather than the opposition. Lee Dixon pointed this out on commentary yesterday when he said "Space doesn't score goals, players do, so mark them!")

Regarding attacking corners, I noticed that a few times when Stones and Jagielka went forward for a corner, they stood together then split in opposite directions when the corner was taken. I suggest the problem is A) the delivery is usually rubbish and B) we always go for the outswinger and the delivery is usually rubbish. Either way, they delivery is rubbish.

Brian Harrison
43 Posted 04/05/2014 at 20:29:33
Being at the game, I wasn't aware of the comments of Tyler or Neville about the muted atmosphere. We were guaranteed 5th place before the game started thanks to the Spurs and Man Utd results, and yes the atmosphere would have been better if we had needed to beat City to get 4th place.

I read this morning Andy Dunne (a self confessed red) saying the conspiracy theorists may have a point... Well, the Everton team gave it their best shot and just come up short. So the majority of the fans around me wanted City to win, and why as fans wouldn't we want the other lot to win nothing?

To think they call us bitter, we don't even come close compared to the other lot.

Danny Munro
44 Posted 04/05/2014 at 20:48:28
Kieran - do you have a link to that page for the Europa League qualification rules on the PL website. I can't find it. Cheers.
Frank Duffy
45 Posted 04/05/2014 at 21:19:01
I had mixed emotions but I thought the team wanted to win and, on any other day, I think we would have. Looking forward to next season and I hope we will be in with a shout for the first position.
Jim Bennings
46 Posted 04/05/2014 at 22:08:27
Ray

I agree with you on the corner subject.

Remember the Hinchcliffe days?
You almost expected an Everton goal every time we hot a corner because as great as Big Duncan was in the air it was also down to the delivery of the inswinging cannons that Hinchcliffe sent over.
All they needed was the deftest of touches which they usually got.

Trevor Whyte
47 Posted 04/05/2014 at 22:52:31
Eddie Dunn
48 Posted 05/05/2014 at 11:17:48
Lukaku, as many people have observed, has a poor first touch, but since he has been back in the team, we have scored goals. He is a big distraction for the defenders, and creates spaces for his team mates. He is not the finished article, but will improve.

Whenever Distin plays alongside any of the other centre-halves, we look a lot more secure. He is the best header of the ball at the club. Whenever he has been missing, we have had problems.

The roles of McCarthy and Barry, sheilding our central defence have resulted in our good stats, but without Barry, we looked vulnerable. Alcaraz looks low on confidence, has no pace, is not tall, and his distribution against Man City was poor. Surely he will be shipped out in the Summer.

A super season with lots of promise for the future.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb