Season › 2024-25 › News Everton vs Southampton Lyndon Lloyd 17/09/2024 60comments | Jump to last Carabao Cup Preview Jake O' Brien is in line for his second start having made his full debut in the previous round against Doncaster Everton turn once again to the Carabao Cup for a potential lift in their fortunes and a platform on which to build a revival in the Premier League after four straight defeats as they welcome Southampton to Goodison Park this evening. This third round tie brings together the two teams yet to pick up a point in the league so far this season and where the Blues and manager Sean Dyche are concerned, it has to be viewed as an opportunity to inject some confidence into the veins after two psychologically brutal 3-2 defeats. Dyche has intimated that, just as he did in the last round against Doncaster, he will make changes to his team and field some players who are in need of minutes to either boost or maintain their fitness. That is likely to mean only a second start for Jake O’Brien and Jesper Lindstrøm, while Abdoulaye Doucouré could also be in the starting XI for the first time since the 4-0 hammering at Tottenham on 24th August with Beto leading the line. Article continues below video content Seamus Coleman is expected to miss out with the knock he sustained on international duty, Vitalii Mykolenko will be assessed after coming off in the first half at Villa Park Saturday complaining of illness, and neither Nathan Patterson nor Jarrad Branthwaite are ready having only just resumed full training. There could be an opportunity, therefore, for Roman Dixon to get more experience, either from the start or as a substitute, while deadline-day signing Orel Mangala is expected to make his full debut in midfield, possibly alongside James Garner. Saints boss Russell Martin is also likely to make changes of his own, with Taylor Harwood-Bellis a possible starter while he has confirmed that forward Ross Stewart will be introduced off the bench at some stage as he continues to work his way back to full fitness after injury. The south coast side demonstrated in the last round that they can score goals when they put five past Cardiff in a 5-3 win in Wales, a game in which Cameron Archer, a player with “previous” against Everton, scored a brace. Dyche will remind his players of what was, eventually, a handsome win over Doncaster as evidence of what they can do as he seeks to lift them ahead of a hugely important fixture against Leicester City this coming weekend. Kick-off: 7:45 pm, Tuesday 17 September 2024Last Time: Everton 1 - 1 Southampton (3-4 on pens) — October 2018 Predicted Line-up: Pickford, Dixon, Keane, O’Brien, Young, Mangala, Garner, Lindstrom, Ndiaye, Doucouré, Beto Live Forum Reader Comments (60) Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer () Nigel Scowen 1 Posted 17/09/2024 at 06:37:54 Beto with Doucoure playing off him.Gulp!!! Danny O'Neill 2 Posted 17/09/2024 at 07:03:52 Right Everton, go out to win this and heal the wound of the past two fixtures. No playing a weakened team. Start strong then rest, not the other way around and end up chasing the game.I can no longer travel. I've got to take my dog to the vets as he has suffered rapid weight loss, so I need to get him checked out.I have a ticket stored in my Google wallet, but I can share it. I can do it by email, which should give the option to print out. Let me know if anyone wants it. Lower Gwladys Street Stand.Probably best it is someone local.dannyefc26@gmail.com. 0796 600 7546. Ian Linn 3 Posted 17/09/2024 at 07:10:17 Let's make sure Keane, Coleman and Young get a run out so they'll be ready for the match at the weekend. Nigel Scowen 4 Posted 17/09/2024 at 07:27:18 Danny, I hope your dog is okay, mate.After losing my wife 2½ years ago at the age of 51, I fully get how important our 4 legged friends are. Neil Lawson 5 Posted 17/09/2024 at 07:28:19 Danny (2) — "no playing a weakened team"Given current performances, I'm not sure it is possible to make it any weaker. Danny O'Neill 6 Posted 17/09/2024 at 07:29:43 Ian, is there a sense of sarcasm there?!!!I don't like team predictions, but if Branthwaite is fit and training well, get him on the pitch. And give Dixon a run out. Malanga too.This competition has evaded me all of my life. Lift the gloom Everton. Paul Ferry 7 Posted 17/09/2024 at 07:44:21 Shit Nigel, so sorry, no age for either of you. I hope that smiling is a big part of your memories now.Danny, I remember you giving Neil your Luton ticket, says everything we need to know about you. Fingers crossed for your man's best friend. I kind of like Lyndon's team and think that he is probably right, alas, about Doucoure. I think that DCL will start and he will score for two games on the run, making the fella who said on here the other day that DCL only scores one in three chances and is therefore shite even more silly.3-1 us, DCL one or two.BELATED HAPPY BIRTHDAY DANNY Nigel Scowen 8 Posted 17/09/2024 at 07:51:56 Thanks PaulI also didnt get the whole DCL comment, hes not the problem for Gods sake. Danny O'Neill 9 Posted 17/09/2024 at 07:54:39 Nigel,My wife went recently at 55.You are right about our dogs. I always say, they know loyalty like we can only talk about.Apart from Everton! Nigel Scowen 10 Posted 17/09/2024 at 07:59:10 Danny Im sorry for your loss, gone but never forgotten mate.Its always with you but you do learn to live with it. Frank Sheppard 11 Posted 17/09/2024 at 08:12:12 I wonder if a 3 goal start might be enough? Bill Fairfield 12 Posted 17/09/2024 at 08:15:10 Only Man City have better possession stats than Southampton. And with our ability to constantly give the ball away it could be a frustrating evening. Hopefully not.COYB. Tony Abrahams 13 Posted 17/09/2024 at 08:18:56 I hope your dog is gonna be okay Danny, after everything you have gone through recently, mate. Christine Foster 14 Posted 17/09/2024 at 08:23:22 Danny, hope your coping ok, such an awful time, must be both depressing and upsetting and on top of it all, losing your loved one too.Sorry Danny, thought a bit of black humor might raise a smile.. at least I bloody hope it did!Let's hope the blue boys can give us all some light relief! God bless Danny! Jack Convery 15 Posted 17/09/2024 at 08:31:07 Seeing as Leicester have no midweek game, it's time to give others a chance.Virginia,Dixon,Keane,O'Brien,Young,Lindstrom,Garner,Mangala, (swap for Harrison after 60 mins ),Harrison ( swap for McNeill 2nd half ),Doucoure,Beto.Give Tarks a rest to help him get over the knock he's obviously carrying.Mykolenko too.We need DCL and Ndiaye as fresh as possible for Leicester.We played most of the 1st team against Doncaster and half them were running on empty, after 75 minutes against Bournemouth. We cannot afford to have that happen on Saturday.I don't like playing, such a weakened team but given the thinness of the squad and the need, to make sure that whatever happens. we are still in the EPL come May, it's what we need to do. Dave Williams 16 Posted 17/09/2024 at 08:39:14 Danny- what a crap time youre having. With two dogs of my own I understand how precious they are and in most cases I prefer them to people. Fingers crossed the vet sorts your boy out quickly.Your luck will change- ride out the crap times and the better ones return. Nigel Scowen 17 Posted 17/09/2024 at 08:41:00 Probably agree with pretty much all of that Jack. Ted Roberts 19 Posted 17/09/2024 at 09:01:59 Danny,being a dog owner myself all my life,I send good luck wishes for your loyalest friend and trust that all will be ok,also hoping that we can do the business tonight and get a good result from a good performance,and similar for the Leicester game.Couldnt make tonight but got my ticket for Palace so hope we have started the climb by then.COYB Danny O'Neill 20 Posted 17/09/2024 at 09:27:11 Thanks Tony and Nigel.I'll watch the blues tonight and keep an eye on Villa, as well as AC Milan. Although the last time I done that was when AC were 3-0 up at half time and I was busy texting red relatives. That came back to bite me in the arse!!Weill, let's get into the next round tonight so we break our duck in the competition. Danny O'Neill 21 Posted 17/09/2024 at 09:39:51 Thank you Ted.Yes, let's get to the next round and then onto Leicester.As grim as the start to this season has been, dependent on results, we could be 15th at the weekend. Derek Knox 22 Posted 17/09/2024 at 09:48:30 Danny, sorry to hear about one of the dogs, I know how close you are to them, hope also it is something than can be fixed easily. Any chance of taking that lazy useless hound in Doucoure along too ? If the vet asks for his breed it's a French Tripe Hound !Hoping for a win as per usual but a lot depends on who stubborn arse Dyche selects, perfectly winnable with the ' right combination ' we know who they are. How come he doesn't as manager ? Maybe he wants sacking as he is out of his depth ! Sam Hoare 23 Posted 17/09/2024 at 09:51:10 A shame that neither Branthwaite or Patterson will be fit to start, I'm hoping they might at least make the bench and see some minutes.Otherwise the only question for me is whether Tarkowski is carrying some sort of knock. Certainly his poor form this season might suggest it. If so then he should be rested.I'd also play Iroegbunam because this is the sort of match that suits him far, far more than the Villa match. It worried me that Dyche started him in that match as I think it looks quite obvious that he is not taking good positions defensively and makes us easy to play through. I don't think he should be starting yet in matches where we expect to be defending for large periods. Mangala is a less dynamic and more defensive player.VirginiaDixon O'brien Tarkowski YoungGarner IroegbunamLindstrom Doucoure NdiayeBeto Eddie Dunn 24 Posted 17/09/2024 at 09:52:47 Danny and Nigel. So sorry to hear of your tragic news.Sometimes all of the footy pain pales into insignificance.I too have two dogs, and as the kids have left the roost, they are my kids now.I hope your pooch gets better soon Danny.I lost my brother at 53, last year and my Dad a year before.It's been weird going back to the family home and sifting through the memories with everyone else gone.I did find my old Everton centenary mug from 1978.Also found a couple of tickets from around that time when I had dragged my Dad to the match, they were in one of his diaries in his shed.Everything changes but some things are forever. Brian Harrison 25 Posted 17/09/2024 at 10:09:16 The club are saying there are a few seats left for tonight's game, just highlights how amazing our fans are. I will be there hoping for a win to lighten the mood. Maybe our manager would be better thanking our fans for turning up in such numbers home and away instead of slagging some fans for leaving the game against Brighton early. I think its widely accepted that our fans have been fundamental in making sure our club stayed in the Premier league Dave Abrahams 26 Posted 17/09/2024 at 10:16:45 Brian (2Yes Brian I thought it was amazing how the crowd welcomed the players onto the pitch v Doncaster in the last round after the two very poor performances in the first two league games, we are certainly the biggest asset the club has got but I dont think we have really been appreciated by the club except for the late John Moores. Nigel Scowen 27 Posted 17/09/2024 at 10:29:34 Eddie@24Thanks mate, couldnt have put it better myself, my dog was my saviour.UTFT Paul Traill 28 Posted 17/09/2024 at 10:38:36 Hi guys. I've two tickets together for the Gwladys Street available tonight. usually season ticket seats so a good view. £40 for the pair (face value would be £50). Let me know if interested, either message on here or email paultraill2000@yahoo.co.uk Thank you. Danny O'Neill 29 Posted 17/09/2024 at 10:40:51 Derek, be sure to do some sort of tribal dance to the gods. And not a Navy two-step!!Eddie, I used to collect programmes and occasionally read the ones from the 80s. As much as they make me smile, it also fills me with what could have been. I've still got the one from the League {Milk} Cup final in 1984.Let's get through this tonight Everton. At some point, we are going to win this competition. Bobby Mallon 30 Posted 17/09/2024 at 11:03:20 That's the worse predicted front line ever 🤣 Mark Murphy 31 Posted 17/09/2024 at 11:15:23 Paul and Nigel - I just hope to God that DCL is at least 2 yards on side or Ill be disappointed to see it stand, FFS!🤦🏻♂️ My mates a palace fan and hes also livid their equaliser wasnt ruled out.I hear Newcastle fans have asked the league to declare Harvey Barnes strike an own goal due to the deflection and Villa fans are claiming Jhon Durans goal wasnt all that as it was nearer to the “D” than it looked and he spells his name wrong.UTFT Bobby Mallon 32 Posted 17/09/2024 at 11:31:26 Paul ferry @7 he scores 1 in 6 actually Neil Copeland 33 Posted 17/09/2024 at 11:47:47 Danny, I hope your dog is ok mate. My youngest one (dog) who is 15months recently had to have his left eye removed which is very traumatic but so rewarding afterwards to see him so happy again. What I am trying to say is, I am sure yours will be okay and back to normal soon.Nigel, thats terrible news. Dogs give so much, when I got divorced I missed the dog who stayed with my ex more than her! Since then I now have 2 Springers who keep me sane and help massively with just about everything.Hopefully the blues will lift everyones spirits tonight.UTFT Tommy Hughes 34 Posted 17/09/2024 at 12:08:22 My line up pickford, Dixon, O'brien, tarky,mcneil,Harrison, Tim, Jim garner, linstrom,ndiaye,DCL. I'd like to see MAngala,second half. Dyche start thinking chap the likes of kean Doucoure gueye Coleman young far to old every football fan can see it why can't you. Tommy Hughes 35 Posted 17/09/2024 at 12:08:22 My line up pickford, Dixon, O'brien, tarky,mcneil,Harrison, Tim, Jim garner, linstrom,ndiaye,DCL. I'd like to see MAngala,second half. Dyche start thinking chap the likes of kean Doucoure gueye Coleman young far to old every football fan can see it why can't you. Tommy Hughes 36 Posted 17/09/2024 at 12:08:22 My line up pickford, Dixon, O'brien, tarky,mcneil,Harrison, Tim, Jim garner, linstrom,ndiaye,DCL. I'd like to see MAngala,second half. Dyche start thinking chap the likes of kean Doucoure gueye Coleman young far to old every football fan can see it why can't you. Tom Bowers 37 Posted 17/09/2024 at 12:18:30 Winning tonight would be nice as long as it acts as a springboard to win the next league game.No game is a pushover for the Blues these days even when getting a two goal lead.It's getting to that make or break time for Dyche if not already. Getting his defensive tactics correct seems to be a problem for him and his staff. Ian Bennett 38 Posted 17/09/2024 at 12:23:24 In season review vs pre season optimism. What have we learnt??Medical department at fault for not getting Branthwaite injury cleared in off season.Dyche is a complete muppet for playing Michael Keane, when he knows he's not good enough dropping him for Mina & Branthwaite previously - and costing about 10 managers their jobs previously. But yeah starts him over O'brien for fear of conceding 13 goals in 4 matches, only to conceded 13 goals in 4 matches.The full back situations are a joke, such that Ashley Young is a guaranteed starter at 53 years of age.Keeping Beto is proving to be a waste of time. When he eventually comes on, he offers bugger all.Ditto keeping Doucoure is proving an expensive mistake. Top earner, but offers increasingly less.The possession and pattern of play is terrible, and the players are getting flogged.Dyche will get sacked after Leicester. And Moyes will be back. Derek Knox 39 Posted 17/09/2024 at 12:52:39 Ian @ 38, exactly who will sack him? We have no Board as such, Colin Chong acting as CEO, Kevin Thelwell DoF, who seems to be very 'in' with Dyche, and an absentee owner who can see no further than what's in it for him, and seemingly doesn't care what happens to us in matches! Nigel Scowen 40 Posted 17/09/2024 at 13:34:46 Danny @29,Milk Cup final, my first trip to Wembley, just remember being amazed how steep the terracing was at the old Wembley. The semi-final away at Villa will feature as one of my fave ever away games. Lost 1-nil but it was enough to get us through on aggregate. Mark Wynne 41 Posted 17/09/2024 at 13:38:30 I know the game is on the box tonight, but I don't see me tuning in. Even if we were to win tonight (which I seriously doubt), Dycheball with its 20% possession stats and one-dimensional style means it's an ugly watch, even on the best of days. If I could, I'd hit fast forward to a post-Moshiri, post-Dyche world, because frankly it can't come quick enough. Christy Ring 42 Posted 17/09/2024 at 13:39:51 Dyche has been saying since the start of the season, our new signings aren't match fit. Start Virginia, Dixon, O'Brien, Garner, Mangala, and Lindstrom, and hopefully they'll be ready for Leicester on Saturday, because playing a midfielder Garner at fullback didn't work. Keane has cost us goals as well, and forget about Harrison and play 3 in midfield tonight and Saturday, because you're stubbornness with your formation and tactics are the reason we're at the bottom of the table. Nigel Scowen 43 Posted 17/09/2024 at 13:44:26 Neil @33,Cheers mate, never a truer word said. Craig Walker 44 Posted 17/09/2024 at 13:48:22 We're bound to draw this 0-0 or 1-1 and go out on penalties. Doesn't that always happen to us in this competition? Howard Don 45 Posted 17/09/2024 at 13:54:01 Hope your dog is okay, Danny. They do help to get us through the bad times, don't they? Nigel Scowen 46 Posted 17/09/2024 at 13:58:51 Mark@31🤣 Couldnt make it up could you Sean Kearns 47 Posted 17/09/2024 at 14:10:47 This is actually a perfect test for us right now! Just the right level of opposition… a League One team or crap Championship might be an easy win. Saints will be up for it and a good win would settle more than a few nerves. Not to mention we need a trophy… play O'Brien with the intention of him replacing Keane as 3rd choice centre-back (or first-choice in a back 3). Jay Harris 48 Posted 17/09/2024 at 14:45:13 Hope your dog is OK Danny and he is just pining for an Everton win like the rest of us.I would try a reinforcement in MF and give Keane a well deserved long rest (hopefully rest of the season).My team would be VirginiaDixon Tarks Obrien McNeillGarner Mangala Ironman Harrison DCL Ndiaye Colin Callaghan 49 Posted 17/09/2024 at 15:04:16 Anyone who watched OBrien vs England should realize why he isn't a shoe in starter yet. He should start today.Would love to be able to rest Tarkowski for this also. He's not 100%. Nigel Scowen 50 Posted 17/09/2024 at 15:08:45 Jay@48Can McNeill play left back or is that you just trying something different, cant be any worse any rate mate.Personally I would swap Ndiaye for Lindstrom, I really wouldnt want that guy getting crocked in the 3rd round of the league cup nor would I play DCL for the same reason, Beto for me. I just want our best available for the weekend, all fresh and rested. I would also swap out Tarks, he needs a rest, I think hes injured ( just too hard to admit it). Nigel Scowen 51 Posted 17/09/2024 at 15:13:45 Colin@49Very hard coming on as a sub at centre half mate, no time to acclimatise into the game, every mistake magnified, against a good International team. Dale Self 52 Posted 17/09/2024 at 15:17:03 The Dyche defence setup is not settled due to two new players who offer something going forward but don't defend as well as the others yet. Stop acting like Dyche forgot something. Jay Harris 53 Posted 17/09/2024 at 15:19:45 NigelThat is me trying anyone but Young at LB or LWB as hopefully the case may be because we need to be on the front foot against these and not allowing them to pass around us. Nigel Scowen 54 Posted 17/09/2024 at 15:31:43 Jay@53 Understood and get it Derek Knox 55 Posted 17/09/2024 at 15:52:27 Jay @ 48, I do like your proposed team, but the chances are fairly slim on seeing it materialise without the inclusion of the serial Jodrell Bankers ! Robert Williams 56 Posted 17/09/2024 at 16:39:29 Lifes a bitch. Its a dogs life. I wonder how the underdogs will do tonight. Neil Lawson 57 Posted 17/09/2024 at 16:58:27 Haven't read the full thread but have read elsewhere that Pickford will be given a rest. Fair enough. He won't be missed at the moment. However, it is being suggested that Begovic will start. Newspaper bollocks probably, but if Pickford doesn't play, and Dino Dyche chooses Begovic over Virginia then I will be even more disgusted with him and will want him gone. Virginia has been pretty much faultless when he has played, can catch a cross and must not be overlooked despite his lack of premiership experience ( a la Dickhead Dyche ).Just saying. 🤔 Tony McNulty 58 Posted 17/09/2024 at 17:00:19 Looks like it's live on Sky Plus.Another evening of stress-free unadulterated pleasure for me, with light relief provided by the live forum on TW. Colin Callaghan 59 Posted 17/09/2024 at 17:30:14 Nigel, you have a lot of confidence in someone who we have barely seen play. Let's throw him to the wolves vs Brighton Spurs and Villa. I could argue it's an easier situation being subbed in and down already. There's no pressure.Start him today and give Tarkowski a break. We can talk again after the match. Billy Shears 60 Posted 17/09/2024 at 18:04:44 We need to change our style of play...get our passing going, play quicker & get the ball forward faster, play N'Diaye & McNeil upfront,as they can finish chances, play Harrison the left side of a Midfield three.No excuses,no bullshit... just fucking win this in 90+ minutes eh Blues!Also best wishes to Danny & his Hound too. Robert Tressell 61 Posted 17/09/2024 at 18:19:31 I would almost always say we must go all out in the cups to give us a lift, a sense of purpose and - above all - a trophy. Sadly the injury situation means that's not realistic. Surely can't risk Tarks or Mykolenko so sadly it'll have to be experimental (McNeil or Harrison or even Gueye or Doucoure?) at LB or Young.Shame we had to sell Samuels-Smith to Chelsea. He'd be a first team player with us by now.We need energy and commitment from the midfield. Let's get stuck in and Ndiaye and Beto to work their defence. Maybe a set piece goal for a CBs too. COYB Add Your Comments In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site. » Log in now Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site. How to get rid of these ads and support TW © ToffeeWeb