Having negotiated a comfortable margin of safety by steering Everton away from the danger zone, David Moyes has quickly earned the trust of the fans as well as the owners. While there’s still a long way to go until the end of the season, both the manager and The Friedkin Group are already on the same page regarding the plan for the near future - to usher in a strategic rebuild and make Everton consistently competitive again.

The final Merseyside Derby at Goodison reached a fever pitch with James Tarkowski’s indignant half-volley deep in added time. While the tall wave of emotions from that night may have soared until the weekend, the manager was already in discussion with the club’s owners, including executive chair Marc Watts, the following day.

The major takeaway from the conversation was that Everton are expected to have the necessary funds to pour into the squad this summer given that the profitability and sustainability concerns are expected to ease. The goal, however, is to do it in a strategic manner that bears a strong return on investment. 

“They want to build the club back up,” said Moyes. “There are lots of things that we have to try and change and I don’t know how quickly we will be able to change everything. But I sense they want to move on and get rid of this past as quickly as they can.

“It was good to hear what they had to say. My gut feeling of them is they want us to spend. When I say that I mean they want us to buy the correct players. There will be a lot of change here because there are a lot of players out of contract in the summer. How quick can we build that up? I don’t think you expect it to be done in one transfer window. This will be the first summer transfer window for TFG and maybe from there we will start to judge it more.”

The idea of squad rebuilding also plays to Moyes’ strengths as a manager. His first stint at the club suggests a strong eye for spotting talent. Although his record is not completely spotless, the Scot prides himself on his ability to elevate football clubs to a higher level.

For Everton, however, prudence should be key. The Toffees are well aware that simply throwing money at problems doesn’t make them go away, it creates new ones. Panic moves, nostalgic experiments, and rush signings should remain consigned to the past. 

“When Everton had the last owners they probably had more money than they’ve ever had. This might not be a club that can get built that way. This might need to be a club that gets built with progress year-on-year,” Moyes chimed in.

The winter transfer window, where the club signed only Charly Alcaraz on Deadline Day, was a strong example that maybe the callous ways of spending are behind Everton now. Despite needing strong reinforcements and battling a thin squad, the management didn’t make needless transfers because of a lack of availability of players who could come in at the right price and make a strong impact.

For Moyes, who signed a two-and-a-half year contract, ensuring the club’s survival in the top flight remains key. Although they are currently 13th in the table following a five-game unbeaten run, the experienced manager is well aware of his depleted squad and the shortcomings they might face going ahead.

“It’s too early at the moment to use the word ‘safe’ because we are not safe,” he added cautiously.


Reader Comments (49)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()


Andy Crooks
1 Posted 16/02/2025 at 14:33:54
Anjishnu, throwing money was our downfall. We nearly bought our way out of the premier league. I didn't want Moyes back but it was not to do with his signings. He is good at it; he spends money like it was his own. Any mistakes he made, Koldrup for example, were admitted and dealt with.
Paul Conway
2 Posted 16/02/2025 at 14:37:30
Let Branthwaite be the Bedrock!
Anjishnu Roy
Editorial Team
3 Posted 16/02/2025 at 15:09:36
#1 Andy, that's precisely what the second half of the article talks about where Moyes also acknowledged the mistakes made by the previous management and how throwing money at problems didn't work.

Moyes has a lot more prudence when it comes to signings.

Andrew Merrick
4 Posted 16/02/2025 at 16:35:09
That narrative sits well with me, the cyclic waste and damage done kept compounding until we were truly broken.

The frustration with Sean Dyche overshadows the fact that he grasped a poisoned chalice, and did a good job steadying things with no money and point deductions, quite an achievement in truth.

Thank you and goodbye to Sean, welcome back to the evolved Moyes 2, I can't quite believe we have a dizzy 30 points already.

The chatter now shifted to the summer window rebuild shows new direction, and Moyes isn't stoking any fires yet, saying it how it us but with optimism, no more dour Dyche.

Good report, keep us in the loop please

Mike Gaynes
5 Posted 16/02/2025 at 16:46:11
That's the first time I've ever seen the adjective "indignant" applied to a volley, but the point of the article is a good one. When you have an owner who knows how to hire smart people and is willing to listen to them about the proper approach to building a club, you've got a far greater chance of success long-term. I have never doubted that Friedkin would be such an owner, and Moyes has decades of experience in this area.

The open question remains who will be in charge of the process of finding and signing these players. Thelwell has further burnished his record with Alcaraz, and his interview last week seems to indicate that he expects to continue as DoF, but you never know.

Andy Crooks
6 Posted 16/02/2025 at 17:28:31
Mike, I've seen a few articles today suggesting that David Weir will be the new DOF. I hope they are wrong.
Ian Bennett
7 Posted 16/02/2025 at 18:06:13
Why hope they're wrong?
Mike Gaynes
8 Posted 16/02/2025 at 18:08:21
Andy, I've seen speculation since December about Weir, and also about Dan Ashworth, who left Manchester United after just five months on the job.

Ian, Weir has done a great job at Brighton, but personally I'd rather see Thelwell stay.

Mihir Ambardekar
9 Posted 16/02/2025 at 18:30:53
Thelwell should stay. I think he has done a good job looking at circumstances. This summer will prove as a new challenge as many players are out of contract. Buying right players and strengthening various positions will be a challenge. We have to ensure that we have to be more competitive in all fronts.
Dave Abrahams
10 Posted 16/02/2025 at 18:55:51
I’ve said before now that Davie Weir was offered the job not too long ago, he told Brighton about the offer to be on the level with them, came down and had a look around then declined the offer. I think he is settled in Brighton, his son is on the books there ——but if he has been offered the job to work with Moyes that might appeal to him and Moyes.

My preference is for Thelwell to carry on what he has been doing since he came here, balancing the books by selling players who he could, getting high prices where he could and also some£4M to £10M for others, loan deals, some good, some bad, some not wanted by managers buying players Dnaiye and Charlie could be prime assets, if Beto keeps scoring he could be another.

All in all I think Thelwell has done well if Weir does come in his place then I think Moyes has had a word and Moyes will be here for the full 2-5years of his contract providing the team keeps on improving but there is no guarantee of that.

Si Cooper
11 Posted 16/02/2025 at 20:30:13
“When Everton had the last owners they probably had more money than they’ve ever had. This might not be a club that can get built that way. This might need to be a club that gets built with progress year-on-year,” Moyes chimed in.

Hindsight is 20/20, as they say.

Let’s not forget why the huge amount of money was spent by Moshiri on bringing in players and wages.

Very specifically it was an attempt to catapult us over the chasm that exists between roughly the top six teams in the league and those, like we had been for roughly a decade, who were basically competing for 7th to 14th.

The (very) simple idea was to essentially buy improved competitiveness with the rewards that could accrue from some relative success then paying off the money (over)spent in advance.

It ended up being a bad gamble but it was an ambitious plan and had some potential for success.

That chasm still exists - despite some teams rising whilst others are falling at the moment, the longer term picture looks pretty much the same - and spending significantly more money (wisely) is likely to be required at some stage.

That final assault to reach the summit is a number of years away. For a while, moderate investment in ‘steadfast yeoman’ types will be good enough, but at some point the sights will need to be set on a bunch of (likely to be temperamental) superstars if the full stature of the club is to be restored.

John Pickles
12 Posted 16/02/2025 at 20:53:54
Our scouting has been woeful, for every Branthwaite there has been half a dozen Niasses, that's the first thing that should be overhauled. Brentford, Brighton and Bournemouth seem to find have a production line of cheap young talent, I'd start by seeing if any of their scouts fancy a pay rise.
Derek Thomas
13 Posted 16/02/2025 at 21:33:00
Mike Gaynes @ 5; upon reflection 'Indignant' given the amount of shit we have to put up with from kopite fans and media, it was quite apt, you could Imagine Tarkowski's inner monologue as he puts his laces through it - Have that you Bastards!
Brendan McLaughlin
14 Posted 16/02/2025 at 21:40:16
Naw Derek #13

I don't think James ever felt "indignant" about anything in his life. As for that strike... incandescent!

Frank Wolfe
15 Posted 16/02/2025 at 00:08:01
Fully agree with this philosophy. The previous owners have wasted so much money with panic buys, huge wage bills etc which ends up in a downward spiral. However, we the fans also need to take some responsibility. The push for instant success and lack of patience can push weak owners into these decisions. In his previous spell, Moyes was berated on here for lack of ambition despite, in retrospect, having us in a far better position than we are now. So, going forward we need to understand that this will be a gradual rebuild process and we, the fans, need to be patient.
Lenny Fisher
16 Posted 17/02/2025 at 07:10:15
I am looking forward to a few seasons of NOT worrying about relegation.
Steve Shave
17 Posted 17/02/2025 at 07:10:24
Moyes is bang on with this quote about how Everton should be rebuilt. It was obvious the ill-considered, overspending, scattergun approach was not going to work.

We need to fill holes this summer with a number of first team ready players who can slot straight in. Then every window after that seek to improve one or two positions. Initially we may need a free signing or two, clever use of the loan market and target quality permanent signings, some ready and some for the future.

I can see us buying a striker (Igamane, Igor Jesus maybe?) and a really good RB. We also need a right winger and maybe another 10 with Doucoure leaving. A back up left back with potential to push Myko as well. It’s a big rebuild and Moyes will have his work cut out getting that to gel.

TFG like loans and use the system fully to their advantage, that’s fine but you build a solid team through permanent signings. I’d like to see them send a player from Roma on the sly too, there is some real quality in that team.

I have been a staunch defender of Thelwell having his contract extended. However, if they go the other way then I would not turn my nose up at Weir or Ashworth.

It’s going to be an exciting summer window and next season for sure and it’s wonderful to feel some justified optimism for a change. COYB!

Jerome Shields
18 Posted 17/02/2025 at 07:33:30
Whilst signing players and plotting the squads way forward are important the other issues that Moyes mentions are more important. Important to the Friedkin Group who will want more cost effective performance. It is improvements in structure and performance throughout the Club that will insure the Clubs future.Whilst Moshiri may shoulder the blame he did provide the money
It was wasted by others.This includes Thewell and his recruitment drive. Equally guilty was those involved in other areas of the Club. Moyes admits that change is necessary though he can't put a time frame on it.Most of which will be beyond his remit.The Friedkin Group will be driving these changes and will have a time frame.

.

Ian Bennett
19 Posted 17/02/2025 at 08:14:48
Definitely will be looking at young hungry players. Plenty on the list by the summer.

Esteve - Burnley
Fellows - wba
Harrison Duncan - Rotherham

Nigel Scowen
20 Posted 17/02/2025 at 08:23:53
Jerome@18

Good thing this time though Jerome, Kenwright won’t be involved in any capacity whatsoever!

Good times ahead.

Jerome Shields
21 Posted 17/02/2025 at 09:07:34
Nigel#20

Some of the issues will be remnants of Kenwright &Co, but as you say Kenwright and his patrons will not be in charge to stemy any progress.

Moyes seems to be looking at Moyes 2 as a second chance.There is a quiet determination about him with no excuses and no attempt at sop for Evertonians.One of his first sentences on joining Everton again was it 'around here they think I hit a glass ceiling'.

We don't know his opinion on what happened after he left.He has never said a word, but I am sure he would have knowingly looked on and taken note.

Moyes is a committed Christian. He will see his job as a vocation and will want to improve on what he has done before.Everton he will see as his destiny.Working for the TFG will very much suit him.Old Moyes has learnt alot on his loan period away from Everton.

The fundamental definition point of a Premier League Manager is still being one.

Nigel Scowen
22 Posted 17/02/2025 at 09:36:10
Exactly right Jerome and long may it continue. I think he is bringing experience to the job now rather than trying to win fans over with phony rhetoric.
Ernie Baywood
23 Posted 17/02/2025 at 09:49:42
Andy #6, there's a bit more to Weir than just being an old boy.

He's got a graduate degree, a Masters in sports directorship, his coaching licence. He's also worked in player development and in football management, in addition to now being Brighton's DoF.

He seems to be pretty well regarded too.

Brian Harrison
24 Posted 17/02/2025 at 10:28:39
I am sure Moyes knows who he wants as his DOF and it should be his choice alone, to often our DOFs have been at odds with the managers they have served. Moyes has said regarding having a DOF, that its his head on the line and so he should have the final say on player acquisitions and sales.

This summer will be especially challenging, with a number of players coming to the end of their contracts and players whose loan deals finish. I think Moyes will offer Gana Gueye a new contract and why wouldn't he as he has been our best player in many games under Moyes. I think Harrison will be let go and unless he starts to add goals to his improved workrate I think he will let Lindstrom go. I think it will be interesting to see if he tries to make Mangala a permanent signing, although with Alcarez coming in he might not.

So for the first time in a few years we will have a manager who will be able to spend a bit of money on players.

Dave Abrahams
25 Posted 17/02/2025 at 10:47:26
Steve (17), Steve we didn’t need Moyes to tell us that the way the club had been run was the opposite of the way it should have been run ——plenty of us knew that and have been saying it for years.

Moyes is not soft nor deaf he’d put up with listening to Kenwright’s bullshit for eleven and a half years and was the highest earner at the club until Arteta had his wages increased to keep him here.

John Chambers
26 Posted 17/02/2025 at 11:02:30
Just reading a few of the comments about Thelwell and I'm not sure people realise when he joined the club. He joined in February 22, so he has had 5 transfer windows. During that time the only total dud signing, in my opinion is Maupay. You can question some of the loans, e.g. Danjuma but I would argue that was as much to do with Dyche not fancying him. Signings include Ndiaye, O'Brien and Iregbounam this summer and previously Gueye, Garner, McNeil, Tarkowski and Onana. All in a period when we have made a profit on our transfer dealings in order to keep the club solvent
Nigel Scowen
27 Posted 17/02/2025 at 11:05:07
Agreed John, I don’t see him as one of the problems, I guess some people want him out because he is linked to the old establishment.
Dave Abrahams
28 Posted 17/02/2025 at 11:11:38
John (26), I couldn’t remember when Thelwell joined the club so that’s not a bad record and being honest whether you liked Maupay or not, not a hard choice for most, you might agree he was played out of position all the time he was at Everton and did very well for Brentford playing off the striker instead of being one.
Raymond Fox
29 Posted 17/02/2025 at 12:19:31
Say what you want about Moshiri, but one way or another he got us a very shiny new stadium.
The ones that scouted the players let him down big time, him and you know who threw plenty of money at recruitment.
The problem was the new players weren't an improvment on players already here.
We still have the problem of top players preferring to sign with teams that are in the Euro comps. thats not going to change in the short term.

If I'm a Everton player now I don't think I'd be too overjoyed about the manager talking about 'improving the team'.
I suppose on the otherhand it should encourage them to try extra hard to impress him if they want to stay.

We are all smiles at the moment but it wont take very long for the mood to change if we go into a slump.

Nigel Scowen
30 Posted 17/02/2025 at 12:22:48
Raymond@29

I always said Raymond that Moshiri’s biggest failing was to leave Bill in situ.

Mal van Schaick
31 Posted 17/02/2025 at 12:41:24
I feel renewed confidence in Everton with great recent results and a manager who appears to be chilled and diligent in his outlook for the future of Everton at Bramley Moore in consultation with TFG.

We have a number of players out of contract and some players who are of an age where the manager will have to make decisions on retaining or releasing them.

Given PSR rules does anybody know what range of finance the club will be in to recruit in terms of total finance available for the rebuild of the squad for 2025/26?

Steve Shave
32 Posted 17/02/2025 at 13:54:45
Ian @19, id be delighted with all three of those signings! Add a striker and that lad Wesley for right back, done.
Jay Harris
33 Posted 17/02/2025 at 15:01:29
We need some ruthless decision making this summer.
If Patterson is not going to work out we need to sell him before his contract runs down and we definitely need better quality RB and LB in addition to a couple of goalscoring forwards/ wingers. Let DCL and Broja go and have a tilt at Delap and Hutchison if Ipswich go down.
Brian Williams
34 Posted 17/02/2025 at 15:10:46
Mal#31

I've been thinking that myself.

If we're clear of PSR I think we could have plenty to spend in the summer if my understanding of how transfer fees are spread over the length of the contract, for accounting purposes, is correct.

With the naming rights deal hopefully sorted by the summer and the new Castore deal money counting from then (I think) and also extra income from the stadium there's no reason we can't buy half a dozen or more new players.

As I say, that opinion depends on my understanding of the fees etc being correct.

Nigel Scowen
35 Posted 17/02/2025 at 15:16:44
Brian@34

I asked the question a while back Brian about the stadium naming rights and was told the end of June, by someone more up to speed. I’m also hoping for some wriggle room for 6 or 7 new players, so we can push on.

Brian Williams
36 Posted 17/02/2025 at 15:19:45
Nigel, does it work where the transfer fee is divided over the course of the contact?

As in, we buy a player for £30m on a 4 year contract so that's £7.5m that counts as spending for that year?

If that IS the case we could easily spend £100m or more even.

Nigel Scowen
37 Posted 17/02/2025 at 15:21:58
That is my understanding now Brian, thanks to another poster.
Brian Williams
38 Posted 17/02/2025 at 15:22:58
Then I see no problem in buying half a dozen good first team players, maybe more!
Mal van Schaick
39 Posted 17/02/2025 at 15:35:47
Brian and Nigel, thank you for that information.

Is it also the case that club spending may be based upon generating club income and being able to spend a percentage or portion of that income?

Nigel Scowen
40 Posted 17/02/2025 at 15:38:41
Hopefully Brian 🤞we will need them with players leaving at the end of their contracts. Jay Harris referenced Delap above, I would love to see him at EFC.
Brian Williams
41 Posted 17/02/2025 at 16:42:16
Going off air now. On my way to BMD. 😁😁😁💙💙💙
Nigel Scowen
42 Posted 17/02/2025 at 16:53:28
Lucky man, enjoy Brian

UTFT

Robert Tressell
43 Posted 17/02/2025 at 17:15:00
It's going to be a challenge to find more sub £20m players like Alcaraz to play in the first team.

When Moyes was last here - he was generally buying players who would now be in the £20m to £40m price bracket.

This is the same price bracket that the likes of Forest, Brentford, Bournemouth etc do a fair bit of shopping. It's not big money anymore.

Moyes also had a few (Johnson, Yakubu and Beattie) who would now be in the £40m to £65m bracket.

With contracts ending for DCL, Young, Harrison, Lindstrom, Broja, Mangala, Doucoure, Gueye, Keane and Virginia that's a lot of squad to replace.

We can pad things out with loans and frees - and Thelwell has proved astute at that since he's been here.

Hopefully, TFG release a net spend of about £100m - which again isn't a lot these days - to get some genuine quality into the squad.

Dave Abrahams
44 Posted 17/02/2025 at 17:43:27
Brian (41) Enjoy the night and the match Brian, oh and get yourself a couple of bottles of desperado’s and put it on our Tony’s tab!
Nigel Scowen
45 Posted 17/02/2025 at 17:49:44
Robert@43

So are Brian and myself correct in how new signings are judged for PSR as in 36, 37 Robert? or are we wide of the mark there.

Robert Tressell
46 Posted 17/02/2025 at 18:00:05
I don't know Nigel. If you are then you can see how a £100m net spend might be possible.
Derek Taylor
47 Posted 17/02/2025 at 18:56:43
TFG have the most experienced manager in the Premier to guide them through their entry into English football. And, as has been pointed out, he is not hamstrung by the 'Greatest Evertonian '!

If Moyesey wants Weir as DoE, then so be it, but just like Dyche, Thelwell deserves credit for buying cheap and selling well at a time when the League's focus has been on screwing their less successful clubs.

Mike Gaynes
48 Posted 17/02/2025 at 00:14:52
Robert #43, of that list I would consider buying both Mangala and Lindstrom if reasonable prices could be worked out.

Mangala is 27 and provides a cool head and superior squad depth at a very vulnerable spot. I've read conflicting reports on whether his loan deal includes a buy option, but I couldn't imagine a money-desperate Lille not being willing to dicker.

Lindstrom is 25 and having a season like McNeil had the year before we bought him -- no goals, no assists, yet showing value in both attack and defense. His buy option is £19 million, about what we are likely to pay for Tom Fellows this summer, but again everything is negotiable.

Exercise the option on Alcaraz, get McNeil and Ndiaye healthy and make sure Garner does his back stretches, and that's a pretty good young midfield core to start with right there.

Robert Tressell
49 Posted 18/02/2025 at 07:56:58
Mike # 48, pretty widely reported that the Mangala deal includes a £33m option to buy. Hes been good but that's way too much for someone about to turn 27 with a bad injury to recover from. We can probably haggle with Lyon but it might be time to find someone else. He has been good but we can't afford to spend big chunks of a modest kitty on deteriorating assets.

I would have thought that Moyes and Thelwell will need Lindstrom to show a lot more in the remaining games if we're to turn his loan into a permanent deal.

As things stand I'm not convinced any of our loan players will be at the club next season - apart from Alcaraz.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


How to get rid of these ads and support TW


© ToffeeWeb