11/01/2025 173comments  |  Jump to last

Everton have confirmed the appointment of David Moyes to replace Sean Dyche, whose sacking was announced only hours before the FA Cup tie against Peterborough Utd on Thursday.

The 61-year-old has signed a 2½-year contract with new owners, The Friedkin Group, and hopefully provide the stability needed to preserve the club’s Premier League status before they move into the new stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock at the start of next season.

Upon his return: Moyes said: “It’s great to be back! I enjoyed 11 wonderful and successful years at Everton and didn’t hesitate when I was offered the opportunity to rejoin this great club. I’m excited to be working with The Friedkin Group and I am looking forward to helping them rebuild the club.

“Now we need Goodison and all Evertonians to play their part in getting behind the players in this important season so we can move into our fabulous new stadium as a Premier League team.”

Article continues below video content


Moyes, who has been out of work since his last contract expired at West Ham in May, spent a largely unproductive and disappointing 11-year spell at Goodison Park after initially coming on board to drag Everton away from relegation danger in 2002.

Everton executive chairman Marc Watts said of Moyes’s return: “We are pleased that David is joining us at this pivotal time in Everton’s history. With over a decade of experience at the club, he is the right leader to propel us through our final season at Goodison Park and into our new stadium. We look forward to working with David to build the foundation of a new era for Everton.”

The club became known as "plucky little Everton" under the dour Glaswegian before he departed under acrimonious circumstances for Manchester United in 2013, having been hand-picked by Sir Alex Ferguson to be his successor at Old Trafford.

His tenure in Manchester lasted less than a season, however, and included two memorable defeats to Marco Silva's Everton before he was sacked. After poor spells with Sunderland and Real Sociedad, he had two stints with the Hammers, pulling off two more escapes from the drop before landing the Europa Conference League for the London side in 2023.

Although Moyes represents a controversial choice for many Evertonians, some see him as a steady influence who can get the most out of a squad that is limited in talent and hit by injuries in key areas but which many believe has under-performed playing Dyche's brand of anti-football.

The Toffees won just one of the former Burnley boss’s last 10 games in charge, scored in only two of them, and failed to register a single shot on target at the Vitality Stadium last weekend.

 

Reader Comments (173)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()


James Hughes
1 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:02:48
No, No thrice NO!!!

It is now up on the official site.

Ernie Baywood
2 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:04:11
Yep. Officially announced.
Peter McHugh
3 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:05:29
Practical choice makes sense.

I was not a big fan of Moyes when here but he will be a better manager than the one who left us and I do think he is a decent manager and better than the majority linked with.

Also, thank goodness Dyche went – the team has been terrible this season.

Hopefully, Moyes does well. First job: stay up.

Mike Hayes
4 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:07:43
A shrewd move or a backward step?

Only time will tell…

Danny O'Neill
5 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:08:30
Confirmed then.

'Deflated' is definitely an apt emotion.

I think I'll skip the glorious homecoming on Wednesday and stay downstairs until just before kick-off to take my seat for the match.

No sports news for me between now and then. I'll find something on Netflix.

Trevor Bailey
6 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:08:46
Good!
Matthew Salem
7 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:11:25
I have nothing against Moyes, but I am really displeased with this.

I have nothing more to say, other than it's a step backwards. We might as well have kept Dyche.

Robert Tressell
8 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:11:53
I am glad they did it quickly.

I am okay it's Moyes.

Hopefully a few players now incoming too.

Back Moyes, back the club – stay up and next season promises much more.

Kevin Molloy
9 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:11:53
Finally!
Paul Hewitt
10 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:12:28
Qué the wailing.
Bob Parrington
11 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:13:54
Oh shit!

Big mistake IMO.

Sam Hoare
12 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:13:59
Hurrah. The Moyesiah is back to lead us to the promised land of… relegation survival?

A sensible if uninspiring move in my eyes and, whatever you make of the decision, it is one that seems to have been made quickly and efficiently by TFG which is a nice change to the ‘3-man shortlists' etc.

Mark Tanton
13 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:14:53
I was feeling quite pessimistic about this and have been moaning to myself a bit. But actually, this morning I have changed my tune. The man's a club legend and he found us in a dire situation and gave us some brilliant nights in Europe.

Who can forget the first-minute goal against Derby to kick it all off, the nights in Europe? Ironically he's probably Man Utd's best manager since Ferguson!

Anthony Hawkins
14 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:16:35
Let's welcome Moyes back and let's see what he can do.
Brendan McLaughlin
15 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:20:38
Welcome back, Davey Moyes!

Or, as I like to refer to it... The Return of the Magnificent Seventh!

Lewis Barclay
16 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:20:47
Hopefully, Moyes will be less averse to playing O'Brien and Armstrong than Dyche.

Now, we need a striker who can score at least 10 goals before the end of the season!

Mal van Schaick
17 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:21:04
Okay. Let's move on, get results on the board, and fight for our Premier League status.

On the pitch, the type of football has to improve.

Derek Knox
18 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:21:23
Matthew @7, sticking with Dyche would have been almost suicidal, a quick check on his results history across his tenure, would indicate that the chances of even drawing our way to safety, in the remaining fixtures, was more than slim.

Not saying I am right behind, or approve of Moyes's return, but it certainly is a far better option than Dyche. How Dyche managed to keep us up the last two seasons is as bewildering as it is somehow commendable, and we owe him for that.

To even chance that he could repeat that would be folly. I think even players were deciding against joining us if offered, whereas Moyes may succeed where Dyche failed in attracting some new faces, which is vitally needed to survive and progress.

Paul @ 10, wailing? Don't assume we all drink Carling! :-)

Eddie Dunn
19 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:22:50
This appointment is a reflection on what we have become. Relegation battles, a fanbase that is numb with years of anxiety, and players that have been ground down, playing to a rigid system that is soul-destroying for anyone who has a touch of creativity.

Moyes is hardly an inspired signing but, as we have recently had the likes of Big Sam and Benitez to stomach, then we all have got used to pragmatism.

The crumb of comfort in this appointment is that Moyes is not the manager that coached us for 11 years. He is more experienced, he is more able, knows more people and he has won something.I won't knock him for winning a European trophy of any kind.

Hopefully, he will calm the nerves in the dressing room and bring some good staff with new ideas. Imagine if Fonseca or Terzi rolled into town and our players couldn't adapt and we went down.

It's a sensible appointment which will hopefully get us enough points to climb the table. I am not expecting miracles. Just football that is a little bit better than before and a few wins.

Good luck, Moyesie.

Mike Brownlow
20 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:24:02
I'm okay with Moyes... I get it he's not an exciting appointment and I say never go back but, in the current situation, he is the best manager available and he can hit the ground running – definitely better than Dyche.

Dyche admitted himself that they only trained defence with no part of training focused on attack… it lead to all 11 players only being able to defend. That's okay if you're hoping for just 0-0 but, the moment they score, you're screwed.

At least Moyes will be more balanced. Is he the long-term solution? ideally not… but if he gets us regularly mid-table to 4th, I'll take that now.

Longer term, I'd love a more exciting, dynamic manager who could push on but, for now, I'd take a manager who can stabilise the balance of the team, keep us up, and is more than likely to get better bang for our buck in transfers.

I'm not upset about what happened when he left; it could have been better but life's too short… and so is the rest of this season.

Chris Langton
21 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:24:33
This was the best possible appointment with our precarious position in the league. Regardless of our differing opinions, all true Evertonians should now get behind the team and its manager to ensure we stay in the Premier League.

That's all that matters now. Debates about our long term future can start once our Premier League status has been secured.

Kevin Molloy
22 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:25:17
His contract is actually 10 years, with a break option at Year 5.

That's longer than I expected – I thought it was 2½ years?

Bill Fairfield
23 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:25:28
If he brings in the type of player he bought for West Ham, the likes of Paqueta, Bowen, Kudus, for example, it would be a huge improvement.
Andy Kay
24 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:26:35
Gutted.

I really think we could possibly do a Sunderland now. Hope not but this appointment doesn't instill me with confidence that we can stay up.

Dyche was taking us down. I think Moyes is too similar… God, I hope I'm wrong!

Robert Tressell
25 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:28:36
Bill #19.

€110M brought Kudus, Paqueta and Bowen to West Ham, not Moyes.

Andrew Merrick
26 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:29:56
He's got grey hair, of course we care.

Marc Watts saying this is a pivotal time for the club how many twists and turns make a pivot?

Roll on the summer, then we will have some certainty again at our club, everything crossed for this one.

Richard Duff
27 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:32:20
Happy to read this quote from Marc Watts

“We look forward to working with David to build the foundation of a new era for Everton.”

Foundations that allow a more glorious construction on top (by AN Other) once established.

Annika Herbert
28 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:32:41
David Moyes's previous achievements at Everton:

None whatsoever!

Benjamin Dyke
29 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:32:54
He's probably not the Moyesiah, he's probably not Satan's right-hand man, he's no doubt somewhere on the spectrum, but whatever…

Let's get behind him and pray he brings stability, Premier League safety, and then builds a new Everton that starts competing at the right end of the table. Now we have some money and a new stadium, he can start taking artillery guns and tanks to gunfights.

Martin Faulkner
30 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:33:11
Never wanted him back at our club, ever. He stayed too long the first time and left with more than a sour taste.

I could have stomached it slightly better had it been 18 months instead of 2½ years.

I hope they have some clauses in that contract and aren't paying him stupid money.

Robert Williams
31 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:34:21
I'se ah fackin dis-custard.
Ian Pilkington
32 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:34:42
The most depressing moment in my seven decades long support of the club since Rooney was sold to Manchester United.

Moyes will keep us up but my hope is that TFG plan to sack him at the end of the season (like Fat Sam 7 years ago) and appoint a manager for the long term.

Colin Crooks
33 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:34:58
TWELVE AND A HALF MILLION!!!!!.

By the time TFG have paid Dyche off. They would have spent 15 million to trade on a negative percentage merchant for another few months. Only the one we got is more likely to take us down. Those greeting this appointment with a fanfare should consider the facts.

This guy was sacked (and paid off) by Man Utd after fan pressure forced the board to terminate his 7-year deal while it was still in its infancy.

He was ran out of town by the Hammers who couldn't stomach his entertainment-killing approach.

Took the Mackems down, pissing off everyone at the Stadium of Light in the process.

Kicked out of Sociedad (and paid off again) after a year for stinking the place out.

Cheer and clap this appointment all you want, but I can't shake the feeling that we have just hired the richest failure in football management history.

Daniel A Johnson
34 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:37:35
Oh art thou, David!

We giveth £12 Million…

Take thee back to the glass ceiling, knife to a gunfight, dithering Dave transfer windows, getting rogered by the Top 6, derby defeats, the biannual colonoscopy from Man Utd, no wins down south, Keep It Tight And Nick One, the striker's graveyard, getting knocked out of cups by Arsenal's B team, no strikers up front, and being terrified of trips to Anfield.

Oh David Moyes, how I've missed thee.

Mark Tanton
35 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:38:43
We'll put you down as a 'maybe' then, Colin.
Anthony Flack
36 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:39:02
Oh well…

Hopefully safer as a result and if we stay up then a step forward as sadly I think Dyche ran out of ideas

I'm quite anti-Moyes both because of what he did and what he does.

I'll get behind him, welcome him at Villa, and hope we move forward – both up the league and even up the pitch…

John Keating
37 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:39:23
His words on returning to this “great Club” don't match the way he treated the Club and supporters when he left for Manchester United.

Personally, I am not happy, however, the only thing that matters is staying up.

Steve Brown
38 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:39:36
It won't last long, Colin, might as well give him the money now.
Paul Tran
39 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:41:08
I wanted a quick decision and quick action: they've delivered. If anyone thinks we'd get someone of note to sign a 6-month contract, don't get a job where you need to negotiate.

I'll take unexciting competence over brash, reckless gambles any day of the week.

Let's crack on!

Martin Farrington
40 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:41:18
It couldn't get worse. From the pan onto the fire.

So I checked all the registered historical facts and I was not shocked to discover that going back rarely works.

The spectre of the dead one lingers long.

Bill Fairfield
41 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:42:18
Moyes is the best appointment since Moyes.

It was disappointing he won nothing… but it has been an utter nightmare since.

Andrew Heffernan
42 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:42:33
Makes complete sense over an unknown aspirational manager - Task 1 = survival; Task 2 = complete turnover of squad to enable us to climb league and then attract higher quality of player, and potentially, manager.

This would not happen by appointing Moyes in a short term capacity. We are sick and need to take our medicine. He may not be the answer for a lot of fans, but he's definitely the solution we need at this time. COYB.

Ps. Davey, can you at least tell us where the Arteta money 💰💰💰 is!?

Paul Birmingham
43 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:43:12
And so it is.
History will judge and so let's look forward with hope.

Will he bring in Alan Irvine, Davey Weir etc who knows, but more than ever to stay up this season.

UTFTs!

Allan Board
44 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:43:26
Owners have panicked already and are protecting their investment. Hey ho- and it all starts again- somewhat underwhelming I'm afraid.
I wonder if the shite will be rehiring klopp in 12 years time?
There's your difference and the issue at Everton.
Rob Halligan
45 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:43:32
Wouldn’t have been my first choice, but now that he’s here, we, as fans, have to back him and more importantly back the team.

I don’t know if TFG had anyone else in mind, you’d like to think so, but that “anyone else” would no doubt have probably still been under contract elsewhere, and it would have cost the club to release him from his contract. That plus paying off Dyche and his gang would have raked up millions in compensation, something we can do without right now due to PSR.

Like him or loathe him, Moyes has the experience of being a premier league manager and knows how tough the premier league can be, and I’m sure he can lead us to safety.

We all wanted a Pep, or a Carlo, but unfortunately their likes weren’t available, but I’d like to think Moyes will be a better choice than Leicester getting Van Nistlerooy or west ham getting Potter. Vitor Pereira who ended up at Wolves, was not wanted by many on here when he was linked a couple of years ago, so we’ll never know how his appointment would have gone down.

So there’s bugger all left to do except welcome Moyes back and get behind him and the team.

Andy Mead
46 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:46:21
Not the most exciting appointment but come on, who else was available and willing? Somebody with no PL experience who could have been great or a total disaster?

Saying he achieved nothing is unfair also. How we would love to be the best of the rest and qualify for European football on a regular basis. Apart from BB shoes first season in charge, we have been awful and never finished so high in the league. Hell,even Fat Sam got us to an 8th place finish. Let's all get real here. Dyche was taking us down. Just watching the match was a chore. If Moyes still has the same eye for an unknown player(Arteta, Fellaini,Cahill,Pienarr) then he could pull a few rabbits out of his hat this month and improve the team tenfold. Or it could all turn to shit. But that could happen with any appointment.

Howard Don
47 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:48:01
Only sensible choice out there.

Time to forget any past grudges some may have and get behind David Moyes. A long hard road ahead for the rest of the season.

A couple of shrewd signings needed to freshen up a jaded looking squad.

Stan Grace
48 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:48:18
'It was disappointing he won nothing.'

No, it was predictable.

If you don't try to win key games, that's what happens.

Phil Bickerstaff
49 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:49:05
Welcome back, David Moyes. The best stable manager we had since Howard Kendall.

Look how he left us to go to Man Utd – no other manager would have refused to go to Utd at that time.

When Billy Brown Shoes came in, he inherited the best squad since the '80s and finished in the Top 6. Since then, we have become laughable.

Look at the players he brought in with zilch money: Cahill, Arteta, Fellaini… the list goes on.

I'd rather have him than Mourinho and the other managers who have been mentioned.

Tony Cunningham
50 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:51:21
Like him or not, it took less than 48 hours to get him in place... that would have taken 2 weeks under the old regime!

We now have plenty of time to hopefully get a few bodies in and sort ourselves out for the fight ahead… (gun or knife fight!)

Scott Hamilton
51 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:52:27
Right, it is what it is.

Now let's get behind him and do this.

UTFT!!!!

Colette Black
52 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:52:32
It's strike one for TFG.

Two more strikes and there will be spitfires with "TFG Out" banners above our new, soon to be named... Groundhog Day Stadium.

Different owners. Same lack of foresight.

For anyone who thinks it can't get any worse …. Imagine Moyes leading us out in the Championship.

Rick Johnson
53 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:53:18
Surely we need to look at this appointment objectively: I don't agree that his 11-year tenure was anything other than a job reasonably well done – Sir Alex is a shrewd judge, and Moyes was his favoured choice.

His job at West Ham was good – they won a European trophy, for a club that had been battling relegation.

Realistically, anyone looking at us would see a club in trouble, although with a bright light shining at the end of the tunnel, so they would be wary of a potential black mark against their CV.

All-in-all, I think this has to be the best appointment we could have realistically expected, and I hope we all get behind him and the team.

Kevin Molloy
54 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:53:44
I think we need to remember where we are. Philogene this week preferred the bright lights of Suffolk to a career with Everton.

We all want to move the club forward, but to do that we need a manager who can get us to Top 10, and (for a change) sign some good players. This is exactly what Davey does best.

He struggles once he gets there, as West Ham know to their cost, but there is no one better (not even Carlo) at working in the zone we will need Davey to work in over the next couple of years.

Alan J Thompson
55 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:54:29
I've never really been a fan of returns or second chances particularly in management, of anything, and I hope that somebody has seen the light and that his contract has several KPI's. To put it more crudely, reasons to sack him without compensation such as say a month in the bottom five in the League, a month of losses that is getting no points at all, or failing to win a game in 6 weeks or just a lack of any tangible improvement.

I'd also like to know if the DoF was consulted before the appointment and if there is/was a defining of responsibilities possibly including seniority.

Regardless, I hope it proves a successful appointment at least until the finances are sorted out and Mr Ancellotti asks if he can return, but there is a nagging feeling in the back of my mind that whispers, mediocrity.

Joe McMahon
56 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:55:11
Uninspiring, my choice would have been Michael Carrick, but yes Moyes is more experienced in management. Also looks like we will never land Thomas Frank.

For those thinking back to bargains like Cahill etc, that was 20 years ago. But anyone is better than Dyche.

Shaun Parker
57 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:56:53
I feel there needs to be a reality check here.

This is the least risky option on the table. Sure, like most I’d have preferred a younger, more dynamic manager. Someone to build us again, but we cannot afford that risk.

2.5 years is not that long and as we all know, if things don’t work out the manager will be sacked. He gets his pay off as any other manager would do.

Im not sure why it matters about the money side either. It’s not our own personal money, the FG have pots of money so complaints about the cost of this and that shouldn’t really concern any of us.

IMHO, Moyes comes back a better manager. Far more experience. He’s gone out there and challenged himself. Sure it’s not always worked out but he’s not just sat on his arse in a warm studio being a mouthpiece (and a shit one at that Carragher)!!

Him leaving for Utd, get over it. So long ago it’s hardly worth debate.

For now, and that is all we need to focus on, he’s our manager and we all simply have to get behind him and the players and keep us in this league !!!

John Raftery
58 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:57:41
The least risky option. That is not to say there are no risks. I doubt there will be a honeymoon period. A couple of early defeats will prompt a negative reaction from fans, more protests and pressure on the new owners.

We desperately need additions to the squad. One or two new players in attacking areas, the return of McNeil, Garner and Iroegbunam and the rapid progress of Harrison Armstrong could transform the look of the team.

We have two far from easy, but winnable, home games coming up. Four or six points from those games will ease the pressure on everyone and create some momentum.

Nigel Scowen
59 Posted 11/01/2025 at 09:59:14
It’s done, time for everyone to get behind him for the sake of the club.

Welcome back Davey Moyes and good luck

Ian Bennett
60 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:00:08
Moyes, who has been out of work since his last contract expired at West Ham in May, spent a largely unproductive and disappointing 11-year spell at Goodison Park after initially coming on board to drag Everton away from relegation danger in 2002.

Gees I wonder what MK really thinks of Martinez, Koeman,Alladyce, Silva, Anchelotti, lampard, and Dyche thereafte, if Moyes was unproductive and disappointing, after inheriting a dog shit team and backed by Esso tokens.

He did a decent job of getting Everton best of the rest. If hadn't, one of the biggest teams in the world wouldn't of come in for me.

Balance please. Is he who we wanted long term? No, but the immediate priority is Premier League survival and sorting a squad with 12 out of contract players come the summer. This is no time to gamble.

We need someone to take us to mid table add some emerging players and then hand it over. Based on that brief Moyes seems a fair choice. Could my choice Iraola keep us up this season? Honestly with these players, playing how he likes,possibly no.

It's clear Friedkins wanted to keep Dyche in place till the summer, but results and a meeting where he'd practically gave up has forced their hand.

Dale Rose
61 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:00:52
I would have preferred Bill Murray..
Peter Hopkins
62 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:02:21
I said on the other thread, this is not a manager to get us where we want to be, this is a manager that will get us back to where when he left. Let’s stabilise, then with the stadium at PSR in a better place, then kick on. We have been in a downward spiral for years, I still feel the future is bright but in order to get to get to th future we need to stay in the present and the present is safety
Tony Waring
63 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:03:31
Yes the right appointment at a difficult time. I think he'll do the joband keep us in the PL. He knows the club and can spot a bargain to improve the team. Can't understand all the vitriolic bile spewed by some supporters; not called for and in any case what superstar of a manager would want the job in the first place ?
Oliver Molloy
64 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:06:48
I think many of us would have wanted a different name, but the fact is - now is not the time.
Moyes knows the club, the league, and with THIS group of players is the best choice for us to stay up.

Who's to say TFG won't "relieve" him of first team duties before 2027 !
COYB - UTFT.

Andy Crooks
65 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:08:19
On this darkest of days could I ask Lyndon and Michael to move Eugene Ruane's post last night on to this thread. It deserves to be read by everyone. It made me laugh out loud which I didn't think possible.
Only Everton, would have appointed this second rater. New stadium, new dawn and Davy fucking Moyes. Our ambition died today.

Steve Brown
66 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:09:08
No Shaun Parker, we don’t need a “reality check”. But I would respectfully suggest that you do.

It is a regressive and divisive appointment which a large part of the fan base disagrees with. As evidenced by the posts over tthe last few days. Offering him a 2.5 year deal is just comical, as his career trajectory was occasional appearances on the “Rest is Football” or Sky.

Nevertheless, he will be supported in his early days by all of us because we want the club to succeed. It will become a serious problem when things do not go his way, as Moyes does not have a huge amount of goodwill in the bank.

Rob Halligan
67 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:09:23
Alan # 55……..what you say about KPI’s (Key Performance Indicators) is very much like what I’ve heard about Potter at West Ham. I heard that Potter was only given a six month contract with required certain KPI’s to be met to avoid the sack. What they are I don’t know, but I assume it’s something like avoiding relegation, but as you say, let’s hope the same applies for Moyes.
John Raftery
68 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:10:23
Rob (45) Your last sentence sums up the position perfectly.

I’m guessing there would still have been moans about Pep or Carlo from people who are never happy except when they are moaning.

Neil Cremin
69 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:11:13
As I read through the litany of comments ranging from reviled, unimpressed or resigned to this decision in other threads on TW, I started to reflect on my feelings. Initial reaction was on disappointment but on reflection possibly only decision open to TFG. My logic is based on the following scenario.
1 TFG had talks with Dyche
2. Dyche didn’t convince them he would keep us up
3. TFG started to sound out replacements incl Potter
4. Word got back to Dyche who demanded back or sack
5. TFG don’t bow to threats. Sacked Dyche
6. All the realistic alternatives (PL experience) saw us as high risk
7, All exciting foreign or up and coming managers were considered too risky
8. Moyes was only one available will to take on the challenge.
9. TFG reviewed EFC Managers over last 20 years
# Moyes era never fighting relegation (bar 1in 13) and finishing regularly in top half of table
# Every other manager got fired because we feared relegation with the exception of Carlo
# For the last 4 years we have been living in abject misery tethering in the drop zone only surviving because other teams usually the promoted teams were so much worse.
# TFG to my mind made the only realistic business decision available. Dyche had lost dressing room, manager with PL experience and willing to take on tha thankless task needed. Only one available was Moyes.
Decision made and we need to get over it for the good of EFC and forget the ridiculous and childish venom being trotted out here and other threads.
I’m not thrilled about this appointment but I want us to stay in the PL which I don't think would have happened under Dyche.
Our criticism of previous management of EFC was there was no strategy. This move, I believe this decision is only the first step to stability where, once in BMD with more revenue, we can start to build back our club to compete at the top half of the table and hopefully onwards and upwards thereafter.
Only superstitious fear is Burnley sacked Dyche and they went down afterwards. Hopefully not Deja Vu
Bill Fairfield
70 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:12:13
Hopefully it will bring stability,until we get our new funds from increased match day takings and naming rights for the new stadium
Martin Faulkner
71 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:13:04
Shaun @57

Have you not been paying attention the last 2 years?

"Im not sure why it matters about the money side either. It’s not our own personal money, the FG have pots of money so complaints about the cost of this and that shouldn’t really concern any of us."

Whatever he gets paid will be paid by Everton Football Club not The Friedkin Group, His wages and any associated payoff if he gets sacked will count in our profit and loss and affect our PSR

Mike Owen
72 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:13:37
Is EFC the first club to become a time machine? I feel as though we've just hurtled back 20 years.

It would be interesting to know who advised Dan Friedman and Marc Watts on this appointment.

Of course, I hope it ends well.

Chris Keher
73 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:13:38
Welcome back Davey. Hope you can assemble a team even half as good as the last one and can get us that elusive trophy this time round.
Shaun Parker
74 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:16:11
Your opinion Steve Brown.
But it’s very easy to jump on the bandwagon of negativity.
Nobody has a crystal ball and so we should all remain positive and get behind the whole team. Goodwill in the bank, get real. It’s modern day football. Ruined 100% by the greed of money. It is now a business. People have the freedom to choose where and who they work for, why should we knock ambition.
Andrew Heffernan
75 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:17:46
@Collete - if Moyes does lead us out in the Championship it certainly won't be down to his lack of trying; but more the lack of quality in the squad available to him due to mismanagement of the club for over a decade... some reality needed for the situation we are in. No short term appointment would be beneficial to the club either. This is real world, not 'championship manager'
Dan Nulty
76 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:19:30
Got to put any personal feelings aside. I hope that fans who don't want this appointment can still get behind the team instead of undermining him and what we need to do for probably this season and next which is battle against relegation. The worst thing we can do is become a self fulfilling prophecy and say because I am against it I will be glad if we go down.
Lee Courtliff
77 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:20:34
I wasn't overly thrilled at first but the more I think about it, the more it makes sense.

Moyes will have us well organised like Dyche did, but he'll offer more going forward and our full backs will be allowed to overlap and actually cross the ******* ball!!

This could be the perfect appointment to get us back on an even keel before more ambitious moves are made in the future. I have no doubts that we'll stay up quite comfortably this season.

Mihir Ambardekar
78 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:21:09
I don't get why people hate this appointment so much. We have been absolutely pathetic last 4-5 years with average at best players & dire football. This season we should have been in a better position but we find ourselves in relegation scrap with Wolves, Ipswich and Crystal Palace improving.
Moyes has been appointed to help us avoid relegation and subsequently stabilize us. This club needs a couple of seasons to get stable & develop a team and then we can look at a progressive manager who can take the baton forward. Moyes is nothing more than a transition manager who will improve certain aspects of the team from recruitment and performance point of view. Lets stick together and support the manager and the club. UTFT

Christopher Timmins
79 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:23:10
Neil

There was no other game in town given the set of circumstances that existed, you have it pretty much spot on I would think.

It’s not a given that he keeps us up so your fear is justified.

Daniel A Johnson
80 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:24:37
The irony of the club moving to a shiny new future in a shiny new stadium, whilst being managed by the Moyesiah is not lost on me.

The guy shat his nappy every time he went down south.

Not happy but will have to suck it up like a big boy.

On side note the fact that The Friedkin group have their two clubs manged by Dour Dave and the ageing Tinkerman shows where they are at in terms of the football knowledge they have.

I would just like to know who the fuck is advising them? Who advised them that David Moyes and Claudio Ranieri is the best they can get.

Did the appointment of David Moyes come with a free pen and a £50 M&S voucher?

Tony Cunningham
81 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:25:21
Lot's of fans here seem to be of the impression that just because we have new owners we can suddenly attract big name managers.

We are still a club in trouble both financially and on the pitch and it will take several years to stabilise the club before any chance of making giant strides forwards. Moyes seems to be the right man to offer that stability (all other names would have been a risk too) and then hopefully in 2 years if he has only taken us to mid table then we can look to find a better manager if need be and then we'll have some more money to spend.

John Graham
82 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:25:21
Great appointment, best person available at the moment who will get the best from the players we currently have, especially DCL and Beto. Hopefully we will also be able to bring a couple in during this window.
Difficult to see Thellwell surviving too long but time will tell.
COYB
Danny Baily
83 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:25:44
Agree with the sentiment on here. Get behind the manager. As few as 5 wins could be enough, and the seamlessness of the appointment is a massive plus. Let's hope there's some movement on the transfer front now.
Anthony Dove
84 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:26:19
Moyes to lead us in our last games at Goodison and the
first ones at BMD. Can’t describe how depressing that is.
Robert Tressell
85 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:27:40
Andy # 65, our ambition died at the end of the 2020/21 season when Moshiri pulled the plug and left us struggling to remain solvent with a very badly assembled squad.

Currently our ambition is on pause while we try to stay up while being outbid by Ipswich for reinforcements.

Unfortunately the damage was done 2016 to 2021 by a combination of idiots. It's left us poor during a period where other bottom half Premier League clubs can compete with the likes of AC Milan for transfers.

Moyes achieved nothing at the club. But neither has any manager in the last 37 years. The problem isn't with the managers - it's been with a succession of people running the club.

Next season should be a lot better than this season. The season after that should be better still.

Sean Byrne
86 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:27:47
He’s not the moyseiah, he’s a very naughty boy…retrograde step to employ another dinosaur…
Tony Cunningham
87 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:28:39
Anthony Dove (84) if we are clear of relegation before the last few games at Goodison then I don't think anyone will care who is manager.
George Cumiskey
88 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:28:54
A bit disappointed with Moyes appointment especially on a two and a half year contract, His first signing should be Davie Weir who's done a brilliant job at Brighton.
Steve Brown
89 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:28:59
Yes my opinion Shaun, thanks.

I don’t knock Moyes’s ambition, as he must be amazed that it has come his way. TFG’s ambition for the club in making this appointment? It demonstrates that it will be limited.

It is funny to see the first excuse making for Mr Moyes coming before he has even started “ if Moyes does lead us out in the Championship it certainly won't be down to his lack of trying; but more the lack of quality in the squad available to him due to mismanagement of the club for over a decade.”

He was announced less than 2 hours ago, and the excuse factory has already kicked in.

It is nice though to see some many posters who have written on here for over a decade popping back in.


Rob Halligan
90 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:31:16
Anthony # 84……..If Moyes leads us out at BMD, then it will mean he has succeeded in keeping us in the premier league, because I’m almost certain if we go down Moyes will be gone in the summer.
Dave Abrahams
91 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:31:20
When the new manager left Everton I wrote a letter to the Echo which was headlined on the football letters page “ Free at last, Free at last, Free at last “. This was a reflection on Martin Luther King’s terrific speech outside the White House with about a million supporters with him.

And now that dour,dull, depressing xxxx is back, well those who want him can fuckin’ have him, I’ll use the rest of my season ticket this season and then I’m done after watching this club for the last 77 seasons.

Obviously I desperately want my team to stay up but that’s the biggest kick in the balls I’ve ever had off Everton and I’ve had quite a few, plenty while that xxxx was last in charge, so stay up Blues but I won’t see you at the new ground.

Dave Williams
92 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:32:22
Sensible appointment. No good bringing in a foreigner who would take time to settle, wouldn’t know the players and a stranger to the league.
Moyes is sensible, pragmatic and vastly experienced. He did actually produce a very good side last time- a midfield of Arteta Pienaar Osman and Fellaini would do very nicely in todays team( even at their age)!!
Give him a chance!
Stu Gre
93 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:32:48
I guess that's Branthwaite to Man Utd sealed then.

After all he deserves to go to a Big club.

Welcome back to little old Everton old man.

Barry Cowling
94 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:35:26
I woke up this morning in a sombre mood, I remember the last couple of years of Moyes and I could not stand it, he had stayed too long and the football was dire. Dyche clearly must have forced their hand because its not the kind of signing you would expect from TFG. A sensible choice, yes but personally I would rather of kept Dyche, we were not going down with him, but we probably wont go down with Moyes either. 2 1/2 years is way too long but it probably says how desperate TFG were to get someone in, I was hoping a deal would have been sorted for Sarri in the summer. I just hope they have a pay off early option on him. But all that being said, we are where we are so I will of course back him and the team, but also I give best wishes to Dyche, he did what we needed despite all the shit he had to deal with, plus I hope his pay off included not being able to take over another premier club this season
Alan McMillan
95 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:36:02
Welcome back Mr. Moyes. Sort of.

Underlwhelming but unsurprising.

Any word on his assistant??

Kunal Desai
96 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:37:17
Something tells me, and it's just a hunch I have that he's here for six months and it's a golden handshake to see him off and walk away with around £10 million or TFG have negotiated a role for him elsewhere at the club.

Moyes may have negotiated a blinder to protect himself. £10 million will be a drop in the ocean for TFG once we're confirmed as a premier league club.

Daniel A Johnson
97 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:38:22
I guess that means we are we going to be Man Utds feeder club again?

Expect to see Harry Maguire and Anthony in Everton shirts pretty soon.

With Branthwaite going the other way.

Rob Halligan
98 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:39:16
Dave # 91……..your choice, obviously, but as I said on another thread, once you give up your season ticket, you won’t get it back, as there will be someone on the waiting list who will snap it up. Moyes won’t be here forever, so why give up your season ticket for the sake of a couple years?
Lord Hughes
99 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:40:56
Anyone heard any confirmations of who Moyes back room team will be?
Derek Thomas
100 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:43:30
2.5yrs doesn't mean he stays 2.5 yrs.

Anyway, we're stuck with him for now.

Two home games, 6pts and he was everybody's pick, always said he was good, etc.

He's got the best start he could get - 2 at home under the lights.

Get that bear pit going.

Terry McLavey
101 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:44:33
'I enjoyed 11 wonderful and SUCCESSFUL years at Everton' What?
This club just goes around in circles, it's focused on survival rather than success, but according to Moyes we've already had that?
I must have blinked?
Daniel A Johnson
102 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:49:43
"I enjoyed 11 wonderful and successful years at Everton and didn't hesitate when I was offered the opportunity to rejoin this great club."

Zero fucking trophies mate

Dean Johnson
103 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:50:38
Think of it this way

Comes back, keeps us up and takes us into BMD.
Then he can move upstairs and be part of the board.
With Moyes I remember he will only buy a player that is an improvement, rather than someone to do a job. Almost every player we bought since Moshiri has been to do a job rather than improve what we have.
He knows what makes a good player more than anyone at our club and that should be kept at all costs.

Give someone more progressive thereafter but Moyes can vet the player.

Getting way ahead of myself here but I am reasonably happy and never had a beef with him like some

Alex Fox
104 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:51:17
Is this an uninspiring appointment? Yes.

Does he have flaws? Absolutely (knife to a gunfight mentality, terrible cup record, inability to sign strikers).

Is he comfortably Everton’s best manager of the last 30 years? Without question.

Here’s our average league positions during the Premier League era:

Pre Moyes: 14.1
Moyes: 7.5
Post Moyes: 10.9

We were awful before he arrived, we’ve been awful since he left. At a time when we need stability and with our hands tied by PSR parameters and stadium debt, I can completely understand why TFG have made this move.

Martin Mason
105 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:52:02
So the incompetent failures continue to bleed the club dry of funds which should rightly be used to buy players. Moyes coming now like a 20th century Manager when what we wanted was a skilled head coach with management done by managers. Modern football clubs are far too complex for managers and people like Moyes have zero qualifications to do the job. Or to be Head Coach. He is a proven failure.
Ron Sear
106 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:52:38
If ever there was a battle between the idealogues and the pragmatists we are seeing it now, but give the man a chance and for heavens sake no booing by the grumpy side at his first match back.
Nigel Scowen
107 Posted 11/01/2025 at 10:58:54
Good article on Sky website about Managers returning to the same club and whether it was a success or not.

Didn’t realise there was so many actually.

About 50% were deemed successful returns.

David Israel
108 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:01:15
Sam Hoare to#12 ' sensible, if uninspiring' is the aptest synthesis of this rather swift choice, I agree. Ican understand those on here that would prefer Guardiola, but, unfortunately, the Sheiks haven't yet got round to giving him the boot. As for those who bemoan his picking, I know his football wasn't exactly made to enthrall a crowd, but some of the most bitter voices around here do sound as if the man, somehow, was meant to fight closely for the Premier League title, or even, if I may have a proper go at one of the European competitions. Time has passed, and his football has evolved(I can remember watching a couple of more than decent Hammers displays under him. Upmost in my mind is that I welcomed his appointment back in 2002, when we were in a very similar position to where we now are, and he was the proverbial ' up-and-coming manager for the future,having just brought good old Preston North End straight from the whar they now call League Two to the second tier,and, perhaps (I'm m not sure now) bringing them within an inch of the play-offs. His early days here still remind me of Joe Royle's, who had faced a similar flight, and equally discharged himself with applomb! To sum it up, I have to say,, "welcome back, sir!"
Geoff Hind
109 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:02:01
Dyche knew he was going so his leaving saga was about compensation and self interest. Everton were then in an impossible situation, rock and a hard place. Any manager that came in (with any experience) will have been sacked before and have good and bad on their CV. At lest the owners acted swiftly. Can Moyes deliver some goals? Time will tell.
Kevin Edward
110 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:05:01
What’s done is done, like many I’m not very pleased about it, but agree that for the next 9 games we should give him a chance to win us over and improve the team and results on the pitch.

Let’s see where this is going, I don’t wan’t to hear a load of excuses (no funds, injuries, poor culture). He’s marketed as an experienced manager so we should expect improvement by end of Feb.

Time to dig out the One2One shirt, and start praying. UTF Moyes Ts!

Stu Darlington
111 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:05:21
You’re right Dan,@76 the only important factor is that we avoid relegation.That is the bottom line.Non-negotiable.
To achieve this I don’t care if the new manager is Mork from Ork.Ming the Merciless or The Lady of Shalott.
To me our best bet to avoid relegation is a manager with Premier League experience who has a good knowledge of our opponents and their players,can get our squad playing to their maximum ability with pride and passion,and add perhaps one or two players in key positions.
He also needs to change the game plans to include trying to win games and playing players in their best positions.Oh,and he needs to do this with only half a season left.
The manager will also need the support of the Goodison crowd too.The atmosphere in Goodison as we all know can be very volatile,dissatisfaction with performance etc can make itself known very powerfully.we need to play the only hand we have and make Goodison a fortress again.hostile to the opposition and supportive of our team.
If any of you know any managers with a better chance of doing all this better than Moyes at the moment speak now or forever hold your peace
Shaun Parker
112 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:06:06
The new manager does not need success, he simply needs to keep us in the league and add stability. Then pass over to a more appropriate manger.

What will the noise be like when he brings in a few unglamorous players.

Could he bring in Rashford? Would that appease anybody?

All the opinions on here are great. We all have our opinions and are all respected.

The reality is what it is.

So let’s all get behind the cause and get our FABULOUS club up this table and stop having to look over our shoulders.

Noleen Daya
113 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:11:53
Heeehaaa!! I've been wanting this man back at our club since the dreaded S.m Al..d..e (I can't even type his name in full) infested our beloved Goodison. I hope he'll have some of degenerates shaking in their booties.
Anthony Jones
114 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:15:41
If Dyche said to the owners that he had taken us as far as he could then he is a bottler.

He must have known that it would lead to him leaving early.

I will be interested to see how he spins it in his memoir.

Moyes out.

Brian Harrison
115 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:17:48
I think we need a dose of reality, those bemoaning Moyes never won anything, well in the last 70 years yes 70 years we have had only 3 managers that have won trophies, so can we stop behaving as if we were perennial winners before Moyes arrived. Most of the time here he had to look down Kenwrights sofa for some loose change to buy players, and what gems he unearthed, which he sold for much gold that kept this club afloat financially.
While not winning Trophies he did get us into the Champions league which Catterick did and Howard would have done if it hadn't been for the Hysel ban. He also took us to an FA Cup final and an FA Cup semi final not bad on a shoestring.

Look I don't know if he will be successful here depending on what various people gauge as success, but I know we are in better hands than we have been under the last 3 managers, so I will take that.

Shaun Parker
116 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:18:37
Hi Martin #71

Of course, it’s hard not too.

All I'm trying to say is that should not bother us. We (the fans) cannot do anything about this, the money men will have their day.

We can only affect what happens in the pitch by giving our full support.

There is very little we can have an affect on.

Mike Price
117 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:22:34
Stu#112 Good post, couldn’t agree more.
Nigel Scowen
118 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:23:07
Ian@60

Agreed mate,

My God some of the posts on here, anyone would think that David Moyes had actually got us relegated at some point in the past. Far from it.

It really does reek of jilted bitterness because he went to United. Football is a ruthless business, accept that, and maybe we can use Managers like they use us, for specific circumstances.

In 6 months time we will be in the Premier League and Moyes won’t be our Manager in my opinion, job done.

Jay Evans
119 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:23:51
He’s got grey hair and we don’t care …

Except we do care.

This is an absolutely awful appointment.

It is also - unfortunately - the most sensible appointment we could have made in our current predicament.

David Moyes was not a successful manager during his previous tenure with us. He was though, a stable manager. The question for me is, which of these do we need now the most ?

If this is a short term gig, so be it but anything more is unacceptable. Someone mentions earlier on in this thread the magnificent seventh. I remember we brought out a DVD with this title at the end of this particular season. For me, that is embarrassing and flies in the face of our motto.

We needed Mr right but have ended up with Mr right now.

Anthony Dove
120 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:23:56
Rob@84. The only hope keeping me half sane is that he
will be gone at the end of the season whatever happens.
We’re landed him with now and we have to live with it
for the time being. But God help us if he gets off to a
bad start.
Neil Lawson
121 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:30:11
Stu 112. I believe that your comments fairly encapsulate the reality.
I have mixed feelings but ultimately can not take issue with the rationale behind the appointment.
Hopefully the immediate negativity can be bottled, at least until he has sufficient games for us to determine progress ( or otherwise ). Any progress is good. Small positive steps are acceptable given our current state.
Mark Frere
122 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:31:23
Absolutely gutted. Football has evolved and moved on from the dinosaurs like Moyes, Allardyce, Pulis etc.

I could just about stomach 6 months of "Dour Davey" until the end of the season... but 2 and a half years?!?! No thanks!

I would've hoped TFG had adopted a more modern approach of employing a DOF who had a vision of a style of play he wanted to play, then identify the suitable manager to implement that style. For example, a DOF that wants to play a high energy, high pressing style and only signs players under the age of 24 to develop into that style with a manager that shares that same vision.

I understand we need to survive relegation this season, and we could do worse than Moyes to achieve that goal. But, with so many players out of contract and going back to their parent clubs at the end of this campaign, next season is pivotal in developing a new squad and style for a future generation in a brand new stadium.

Moyes is not the future! He is uninspiring! It isn't at all surprising to me that TFG has gone down this route as things have played out similar at Roma. They don't seem to have a clear plan on the footballing side of things. They just seem to hire and fire managers with differing styles of football without having a clear vision in the first place.

TFG will no doubt improve the finances and commercial side of the club. They are shrewd business men... but I'm highly sceptical on their ability to take us to the 'promised land' on the pitch, which when all said a done, is all us supporters care about.

Colin Metcalfe
123 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:34:36
Feel as though I have been punched in the stomach, at the moment I am lost for words... Just so so disappointed
Rob Halligan
124 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:35:56
Shaun, he was taken off into the corner where an ambulance was waiting, and a mate of mine saw him put into the ambulance.
Christine Foster
125 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:36:59
Dave 91# I'd give my eye teeth for your season ticket, but I won't get it because there isn't one of us who isn't proud of the new stadium and the hope it brings. Moyes appointment was inevitable and if you want to blame anyone its Dyche. Why? because stating you have no more to offer an American business means you are gone, immediately. He could have shut up, told them what the wanted to hear even if he didn't believe it himself, and he would be still in the job. But no, lets be clear Dyche bottled it and wanted out without resigning.
I said early on that Moyes would be back in an interim role only and just because he has a 2.5 year contract doesn't mean he will actually be there at BMD. If he does ok, secures a mid table finish this season, we will get10m plus just in position. We stay in the PL, he gets paid off, new manager for BMD.
Costly but little choice at the moment.
Please don't think for a moment I am happy to see Moyes back, He burnt his bridges and some when he left, he doesn't deserve to be back. But I also get the problem TFG had, gamble on unknowns or known? Its all about the money Dave.
I am more than happy to see the back of Dyche, his attitude and negative set up I think would have surely done us this season and I think even he knew it in the end. He didn't have any answers.
I think I feel like I have been beaten up so much recently, I am punch drunk..
But I will say this, in days to come Moyes will be put on the spot repeatedly to answer for his comments and behaviour first time round. I don't expect an apology and he shouldn't expect an easy ride. He owes us big time and the debt needs paying off. Good luck with that Moyes.
I get all the reasons why TFG have appointed him, but I hope they understand in doing so they have alienated many fans, so don't you dare give that season ticket away Dave, a season is a long time in football.
Justin Doone
126 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:39:13
The owners will be judged over the next 5 to 10 years but at least they acted swiftly and brought in a good experienced manager quickly.

We all have differing opinions on Moyes but for those unable to see the positives we have got rid of Dyche and not replaced with Sam or Rafa.

Someone wrote on another thread about possible regrets after giving up their season tickets.

That's exactly what I did after witnessing Sam's first game in charge and I have had no such regrets. With Dyche now gone, new owners and BMD in the horizon I'll be looking to get a season ticket with renewed optimism.

Timing is important. I feel lucky to have skipped the anti-football recently serve up apart from witnessing the odd game.

Hopefully our recruitment can be even luckier with bringing in the right player's at the right time.

The youth set-up needs to step up and in a few season's we can really progress with a best in class manager, coach, DOF, academy etc.

So welcome back Moyes, your our space saver replacement wheel to ensure we get to our next destination safely.

Frank Knight
127 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:40:49
Wonder if they keep him as manager till season end and then replace Kevin Thelwell with him for next season? Think Moyes might be a good sporting director and would be minimal outlay, he can take charge of this windows incomings knowing he’ll be planning ahead in the summer upstairs?

Or maybe I’m overthinking how to save cash in a situation like this

Bjorn-Ivar Pedersen
128 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:42:46
"Upon his return: Moyes said: “It’s great to be back! I enjoyed 11 wonderful and successful years at Everton and didn’t hesitate when I was offered the opportunity to rejoin this great club."

Can anyone tell me how people at Everton define success??? Because it sure as hell is not about winning trophies.
And with this signing Friedkin shows us he is Kenshite 2.0

Neil Cremin
129 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:43:33
Thanks Christopher #79
I’m not thrilled about the appointment as it is divisive as can be seen in the various threads and leading articles, I was only trying to rationalise in my own mind how the decision was made and have to admit it is the only one that made business and strategic sense.
Those advocating Carsley, Fonseca or others at this stage of the season, who have no PL management experience, are gambling with the future of our club.
Thankfully I think TFG are making the unpopular decision for what they believe will be the best for the future of EFC.
We all need to get behind this decision now or it will end up like the Benitez era.
I’m disappointed with some of the responses of some of the stalwarts who will not welcome him. EFC is not about individuals. As they say “There is no I in TEAM.
Rob Halligan
130 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:43:33
Serious question………..If Moyes had kept quiet about him going to Man Utd and just seen his contract out that season, would people think anymore of him?
Rob Halligan
131 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:44:59
Frank # 130……I’m hearing that Davie Weir is coming in to replace Thelwell.
Martin Mason
132 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:46:11
I agree that avoiding relegation is the key target but for me a better target would be to stay up and play football. To have been fed Dyche's excuse for football for so long hasn't been good enough for the paying and travelling fans and did it keep us up or did we stay up despite him being a millstone around the neck of the team?
Ed Fitzgerald
133 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:46:46
It would appear that TFG are adopting the same template for decision making as Moshiri desperation, short sightedness and a lack of imagination.

Rob Jones
134 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:51:14
Damn. Here I was, waiting for some sexy manager to come in, play possession football with our set of brilliant players and usher up to the European places, before taking us to the title next season...

Oh wait, this isn't Football Manager, this is the real world, we have some good but mostly mediocre players, no wiggle room within PSR, and we're, yet again, forced to cut our cloth to our circumstances.

John Graham
135 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:57:22
Moyes is not another Pulis, Allardyce or Dyche.

Although it can be a bit dour at times, he is not a "kick the ball forwards and hope for the best" or "rough the other team up" type of manager.

Don't forget, we had the likes of Cahill, Arteta, Baines, Pienaar, Rooney, Coleman, Yobo, Kilbane, Jeffers, Johnson, Yakubu and more who were not just kick-and-rush players.

We can't expect open attacking football, especially in the position we are now, but surely it will be better and more positive than we have seen lately.

Mike Corcoran
136 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:59:08
We just need a couple of his sneaky Jelavic-type signings to see the season out.
Dennis Stevens
137 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:59:12
We're doomed!
Brian Williams
138 Posted 11/01/2025 at 11:59:29
Shaun @137,

We should deffo keep Bainesy if he can see into the future! :-)

Dave Abrahams
139 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:00:50
Rob (@134),

Yes, I heard that last night with Bill McKinlay as his assistant. I think McKinlay was with him at Preston in some capacity, possibly a player.

Hugh Jenkins
140 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:01:55
Rob (45) – succinctly put – as ever.

It is what it is. We are where we are.

Let's hope that – come May – we are where we want to be.

Rob Halligan
141 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:02:40
Shaun, I can’t get that link to work. What is it?
Liam Mogan
142 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:02:49
Dave @91.

I feel very similar to you about this appointment. I'll be renewing my season ticket, but only to keep it in the family really. I doubt I'll be going much at all though.

I've been increasingly disenchanted with football in general over the past decade. Everton's woes have deepened that. This is possibly the final straw.

Stan Grace
143 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:03:51
I'm going to have compile a list of Moyesisms:

#6 'not bad on a shoestring': He had the 7th best Premier League budget, was the 5th highest earning manager in Europe and yet his average finish was 8th.

'Not good use of a shoestring' would be more accurate.

Shaun Parker
144 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:07:08
Sorry, Rob. It's a YouTube clip.

If you go onto YouTube clip and search for 'Leighton Baines', you'll be able to see it. Not sure why the link will not work.

Rob Jones
145 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:07:37
Unmatched compared to any other manager we've had since Howard Kendall would also be accurate, Stan...
Mark Stone
146 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:07:50
Stan, where do you get that data from (7th best Premier League budget)?

I'm not necessarily questioning it, but a bit more detail would be nice. Was that the 7th best budget in each of his seasons, or averaged across them?

Alan Rooney
147 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:07:57
Maybe I've missed it… but no IMWT yet? 😁
Robert Thomason
148 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:09:22
How is a David going to cope going into a gunfight with a ballon on a stick?
Les Callan
149 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:11:08
So let’s fast forward a bit. It’s 2036. Dour Davey has managed to keep us in the PL. We’ve had the odd foray into Europe, a couple of semi finals and a final or two. We’ve still not won at Analfield or the other “ big” four, and that’s success is it ? Not for me it ain’t. The problem I have though is that at the moment I can’t see a practical alternative. Woe is me !
Someone earlier said “ an awful but sensible appointment “. Just about sums it up.
Nigel Scowen
150 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:11:21
Frank@130

I would be amazed if that idea hasn’t been considered Frank. If not Weir then I think he could be very good at that role.

Peter Jansson
151 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:15:30
Oh my f*n god. One anti-football guy out and another one in. What a fuckin joke. I have a feeling that we might get relegated this year.

How come we have leaders in our club without any fuckin idea if how to hire managers to play modern football? We are totally f*in clueless.

Derek Wadeson
152 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:18:41
My personal feeling is whether it was good judgement or just plain good luck. TFG waited until our relegation rivals all with the exception of Ipswich (who are not going to) replaced their coach. Which meant Sean Dyche would not be going to any of them. Imagine Everton being relegated at the expense of a club Dyche kept up.

Thanks Sean for what you did for us. But it was the correct time to parts ways.

David Moyes please have me watching Everton so I can enjoy it once again.

Rick Tarleton
153 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:18:44
There's a group of clones, Moyes, Allardyce, Dyche, Moyes and we love them, or at least we keep appointing them. The men who believe that your first (and only) option is to hold on to the point you have at the kick off.
There's no sense of adventure, no sense of "the glory game".
If we survive this relegation battle, we'll have dour Davie to lead us into our first season at the new stadium.
It is gruel of the thinnest texture.
Steve Brown
154 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:20:40
Dave Abrahams @ 91, keep your season ticket is my advice.

The outcome of this decision has the same air of inevitability about it as the appointment of Benitez.

Raymond Fox
155 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:20:49
I don't care if they had chosen Vlad the Impaler as manager as long as he was the best suited to keep us in the division this season.

As for the bleating ' he left us for Utd' he's a professional not a spectator he does the job for money, not because he 'loves the club'.

Its up to us to do what we can to help the club in any way possible now and get behind Moyes and the players.

We are clinging on just above the bottom three and theres a very great danger that with the squad we have we could be relegated.

With Moyes I think we will just about scrape enough points together to stay up, but its far from certain.

Ernie Baywood
156 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:22:04
All feels a bit unimaginative. And our club has been guilty of that in the past - our appointments seem to have generally come straight off the back pages.

But if you took away the fact that he's always linked due to previously being with us, his CV would probably still stand out as a safe choice to provide actual stability and recovery - ie not just park the bus and get out before the decline becomes terminal.

Honestly, I can't think of many others involved in our club over the last couple of decades that I would trust more to take us through this next 6 months plus. And it may just end up being 6 months - the contract is a commercial offering that gives Moyes the financial commitment that other clubs might have offered. It's not a guaranteed period in the role.

I doubt he's going to be leading us to glory, but he's capable of guiding us away from the brink of disaster and starting the recovery.

Stan Grace
157 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:22:59
Mark, the 7th average expenditure calculation is a combination of data from
The Deloitte Football Money League and Transfermarkt.
Steve Shave
158 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:23:52
It will be interesting to see what happens with the DOF role now, they either have to back Thelwell or replace immediately, if so we could do alot worse than Weir that's for sure. Though Ashworth should also be considered. Let's hope they've done their homework.

I am also curious about Moyes' team. Someone else echoed my thoughts earlier by suggested we go all out to get Carsley, a progressive coach alongside Moyes. I think Baines and Coleman too would give a lift to this uninspiring appointment.

If they are really progressively thinking then a transition plan with Carsley taking the reigns after Moyes.

Simon Harrison
159 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:25:24
Rob H, I'm wondering if there will be a DoF position while Moyes is here? As Moyes likes to do the leg work himself. Though he worked with a DoF at WHU.

Maybe the departmental heads, e.g. scouting, academy, sports science etc will be left to themselves, till either we know our future League status. and or Moyes is dismissed/retained? Or maybe Thelwell will be kept till summer and judged then?

As I've heard (hopefully a little more reliably) that Fabio Paratici, formerly of Spurs is being eyed, who is a huge fan on Fonseca. Maybe says a lot, maybe not.

I think that rumours of Dan Ashworth can be put to bed.

Tom Bowers
160 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:27:19
Any chance he will appoint Rooney as his Number 2?
Simon Harrison
161 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:28:32
Dave A [144] I just read an extract on a 'banned list' website, that quoted David Ornstein.

Apparently, ITKs have said that Moyes would like to reunite with Kevin Nolan, Billy MacKinlay and David Irvine...

Make of that as you will. Though Ornstein does usually have a good ear.

Also Moyes is not at Finch Farm today, he'll be in tomorrow tho.

Rob Jones
162 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:29:34
Moyes was never a Dyche, Allardyce type. We beat the teams we were meant to, rather than going for cowardly 0-0 draws away to the likes of Southampton.

I get that he's not the man people want, but the revisionist bollocks is just that, bollocks.

Mike Corcoran
163 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:32:28
Jack Convery
164 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:33:39
He's not the Moysiah, he's a cunt. It was bad enough when he came with opposition teams as manager but to have him back as manager… for fuck's sake!!!

He's already rewriting history by saying his 11 years here previously, were successful! My arse! I must have missed that or my memory is truly faulty.

And as for him claiming it as "our" new stadium, meaning he's included himself as part of "our" — what a bloody cheek.

I can only hope TFG are planning to shaft him come June, though how you shaft someone by paying them off with the best part of £12M, beats me. Hateful man.

Kunal Desai
165 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:39:20
I sincerely hope the big changes TFG make are for the summer. Still no annoucement of who will be on the board permanently or CEO.

Perhaps the likes of Marc Watts and David Moyes are just that, stop gaps and there will be a total revamp once the season is over.

Dave Abrahams
166 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:40:03
Christine (@128), I offered the ticket, for next season, to my older son but he said “No thanks, not with that chump in charge, I had more than enough of him last time he was here.”

Maybe someone will take it.

As for fans who think Moyes leaving the way he did makes them think some of us embittered I, for one, couldn't wait for him to do one.

In fact, coming out of Wembley when we won on penalties against Man Utd, one of their fans said to me “Sorry we'll be taking your manager off you soo.”

I replied “You can fuckin' have him, mate, the quicker the fuckin' better!”

Everton made him a multi-millionaire with fabulous wages, he got plenty out of Man Utd and other clubs… and he is now “Happy to be back at this fabulous club.” The club he couldn't get away from quick enough.

Good luck, Everton. I've always loved you, always will… but enough is enough. Stay up, please. Players, managers come and go but our fans are as good as any other and better than most. But after this season, I'm through, and I doubt I will be the only one.

Chris James
168 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:46:22
Great move. Given what reasonable options there were this is probably the best option. Now let’s give him a chance and see if People’s Club mark 2 can deliver.
If not the new owners won’t just sit back and tolerate.
Frank Sheppard
169 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:49:59
Don’t mind that news…. Not exciting news….. but sensible….. I hope
Simon Harrison
170 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:50:59
Dave A [166]

Please don't deny yourself the opportunity to retain your season ticket.

Yes, I admit that for long-term fans (I only supported EFC from 74/75) who have seen the real glory days, i.e. the 60's and the brief resurgence in the 80's.

However, I say to you Dave Abrahams, that is is just another fleeting moment in our club's history.

By the end of June, Moyes may well not be our manager, and he will have achieved TFG's goal of PL survival. I despise that word, but currently, from where we are and with the club and squad as it is, it is the bottom line target we need to achieve.

They say patience is a virtue, well never a truer word spoken for the current phase in time with your Club.

At this moment in time, with the team struggling, and the ownership having to deal with things it hadn't planned to address so soon, what is needed more than anything is the patience, understanding and support of the fans.

I'm not suggesting asking for the same level of support as during the last three relegation battles, and pi55 p00r seasons, but we as fans need to show that we've not given up on the team, and more importantly the club.

Remember Dave, "This too will pass!"

Good wishes mon ami, and hang on in there, the club needs you!

David West
171 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:55:37
It's done now ! I Didn't want him, I don't see him being here long term at all.

However, we have to give him a clean fresh start !
We can't afford to bitch and moan about the past now, what good is that going to do ? It doesn't matter, its history! What matters is what he does now !
He's here, hes got a job to do, we need him to do that job, so I'll be offering my support.
Harking back to 12 years ago and what he done is just negative, not going to help anyone!
Who's arsed now about losses 13- 14 years ago? I'm more interested in the next 10 years not the last 20 !

Forget his past it means nothing for our future!!!


Barry Rathbone
172 Posted 11/01/2025 at 12:57:12
Dave 166

Sums up what a lot of us feel.

A managerial change should at least start with a honeymoon period, a sense of hope of what might be. Unfortunately we know what Moyes brings and mid table mediocrity bereft of ambition isn't "hope" for many.

Excellent post.

Peter Brogan
173 Posted 11/01/2025 at 13:01:43
Welcome back Mpyes. I’m more than happy with this. He will move us forwards on and off the pitch. UTFT
Annika Herbert
174 Posted 11/01/2025 at 13:01:44
Brian @ 115, ask United, Sunderland and Sociedad fans if they felt they were in better hands when Misery Moyes took over

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


How to get rid of these ads and support TW

© ToffeeWeb