Season › 2025-26 › News David Moyes labels second half against Sunderland “abysmal”, calls for more consistency Anjishnu Roy 04/11/2025 35comments | Jump to last David Moyes has called for his side to show more consistency during matches after suffering an “abysmal” second half in their 1-1 draw with Sunderland at the Stadium of Light on Monday. The Blues got the better of the hosts for the opening 30 minutes of the contest and created a flurry of chances which was capped off by Iliman Ndiaye’s fantastic solo run and goal. However, missed chances cost them dearly as the Black Cats grew into the game with time and completely outplayed Everton in the second half. Granit Xhaka scored just 40 seconds after the restart to restore parity and in the words of Moyes, the only positive from the second half was that his side didn’t concede a second goal. Everton are winless in three matches as the draw with Regis Le Bris’ side was preceded by losses to Manchester City and Tottenham Hotspur and Moyes wants his players to show their quality for longer spells. "Yes, we want to keep it going. That's why I'm disappointed tonight, because I thought the second-half performance was way below the levels we've set generally, and I think we'd set the levels we think we're at in the first half for long periods. But it's not good enough if we're only doing it for 30 minutes. We need to be able to play well. We played quite well at Man City for 30 minutes, we played quite well against Tottenham for 30, 40 minutes, but it wasn't enough and it's not enough. We've got to find a way out – doing it for much longer periods than we're doing at the moment.” Despite the way the match ended, Everton’s start to the game couldn’t have been better. They dominated possession inside the Sunderland half, created several interesting rotational moves around the opposition box and made constant forays. The Blues also pressed extremely well to recover the ball quickly as the Black Cats struggled to get out of their own half and relieve the pressure. James Garner had the first stab at goal, shooting from distance inside the first minute and just missing the target. Ndiaye put the Toffees ahead after beating four defenders and slotting into the left corner. Jack Grealish’s shot from outside the box was thwarted by the woodwork while Grealish almost had an assist just minutes later as his delicious cross to Thierno Barry was met with a ridiculous attempt that flew over the crossbar despite being just two yards away from goal. "After a few minutes or so I was thinking, 'We've got this game, we're playing so well and if we keep this up then we'll be getting the goals'. We get one, hit the post twice, then Barry misses a big chance which would have made it 2-0. I thought that took the wind out of our sails a little bit. I think everybody sort of went, 'Oh my goodness, we didn't take the chance we got', because Sunderland are one of the best defensive teams in the league at the moment and not giving away too many opportunities. "So to have got 2-0 up would have been a big thing for us and we didn't get it. I thought they became the better team in the last 15 minutes of the first half and they were certainly the better team for the majority of the second half. I thought we were absymal in the second half. We were resilient enough to stick and get a point out of it, but I'm a bit disappointed. I'm more disappointed with the performance today than I am with the point." Reader Comments (35) Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer () Alan J Thompson 1 Posted 04/11/2025 at 13:51:43 Though not as consistent as the Manager who really needs to see that he is part of the problem. Mal van Schaick 2 Posted 04/11/2025 at 13:52:48 There wasnt a lot wrong with that first half performance, but as you would expect from a home team, they came out for the second half and upped the tempo and put us on the back foot. Moyes should have addressed that by strengthening the midfield.I find it hard to believe that he is laying the abysmal tag on the players, when he and Irvine saw what we all saw, that Sunderland pressed harder up the pitch and they did nothing to combat that. Derek Street 3 Posted 04/11/2025 at 13:54:04 So the manager was disappointed with the second half performance, well Davey there lies the problem - the inability of the management team to make changes in order to have a positive impact on the game, but as with Man City and Spurs we prefer to let the game drift and then moan about it afterwards.What is the point in bringing on Charlie and Timmy in the 83rd minute when the previous 60 have been appalling.Our one dimensional approach to every game expecting different results is what got Dyche the sack. The Beto and Barry debate has raged for weeks neither look anywhere premier league standard but both play in some part every week. The decision making in the transfer and loan market (apart from Jack) has quite frankly been appalling. Changes need to be made, try Jack down the middle where he was his most effective at the Villa.Odds on the team selection for the Fulham game anyone. Andy Crooks 4 Posted 04/11/2025 at 14:08:26 The second half performance was down to the utterly abysmal coach.I think that bringing McNeil on was up there with the cretinous Martinez against Southampton. Bringing Moyes back for a contract longer than six months was mad. He has stolen a living of Everton and is just as complicit as Kenwright Paul Hewitt 5 Posted 04/11/2025 at 14:24:02 Your management was abysmal. John Williams 6 Posted 04/11/2025 at 14:34:46 Sadly, Everton have some crap supporters and have done for a number of years,Moyes might not be the greatest manager around, but some of you guys would give Pep a hard time if he was Evertons manager and what is worrying, most of you don t have a clue about football management.You just like a moan, you probably moan about your next door neighbours, your doctor, the hospital and anything you don't agree with.Some of you need to grow up or shut up. Stu Gre 7 Posted 04/11/2025 at 14:50:02 Really weird John that on a fan site you are asking people with genuine concerns about Moyes ability to shut up. Some of these fans will have spent many years, a lot of money and tears supporting their team. Surely it's OK to point out the managers flaws and his constant "not my fault" comments. It's no different to people blindly supporting Moyes, but apparently that's OK?Just as Moyes got a tune out of the same players Dyche couldn't, I suspect a different manager could do the same with the players Moyes is criticising. No harm pointing that out.I'm just shocked, given how trigger happy TFG have been elsewhere, that he is still in this job. Paul Hewitt 8 Posted 04/11/2025 at 15:02:01 John. I praise Moyes when he does well, like last season. But unfortunately he deserves criticism at the moment. Bit like most people in there jobs Andy Crooks 9 Posted 04/11/2025 at 15:02:11 Glad you feel qualified to call out fellow Evertonians as crap supporters, John. Nasty, smug little post. Christy Ring 10 Posted 04/11/2025 at 15:03:56 John hes probably right in that if we had scored that 2nd goal, wed have probably have won comfortably, but Xhaka ran the show in the 2nd half, and Tim or Rohl should have been on before the hour mark, to shore up midfield, and when did McNeill ever play as a right winger? You dont need to know too much about‘ football management to see that. Telling ToffeeWeb members to shut up or grow up, is definitely out of context, and makes little sense? Steve Brown 11 Posted 04/11/2025 at 15:04:51 Slagging off your fellow Everton fans as they actually have expectations and standards. You cant sink much lower. Daniel A Johnson 12 Posted 04/11/2025 at 15:06:45 Moyes is risk averse that applies to the players he likes and purchases and the coaching staff he likes to work with.When he was manager of Sunderland instead of acquiring young fresh talent he opted to sign:Darren GibsonBryan OviedoJoleon LescottSteven PienaarVictor Anichebe Ex Everton players all well past it.That tells you all you need to know about him.Oh yeah they were relegated also. Frank Crewe 13 Posted 04/11/2025 at 15:12:28 We've been poor now for a few weeks. This makes me suspicious that something isn't right between the players and the management. The side we put out last night is the same as we played earlier in the season. Yet our goal came from the individual skill of Ndiaye rather than a team effort.All those signings in the summer but the only one we see on a regular basis is Grealish and KDH. Barry gets the odd appearance but Dibling and Anzou barely get a look in at all. Yet Dibling, Anzou and Barry cost the club £70 million + between them. So why aren't they on the pitch more regularly? Particularly Dibling since he was a regular in the Southampton side last season. So they can hardly say he has no PL experience. Dibling was on the bench last night but Moyes used McNeil instead. I just feel there is something going on and we're not being told about it. But until whatever it is gets sorted out we will continue to struggle. Brent Stephens 14 Posted 04/11/2025 at 15:18:01 John #6, I agree with you as far as “Sadly, Everton…” Liam Mogan 15 Posted 04/11/2025 at 15:23:30 John 6 - you should write an update on that book, 'How to Win Friends and Influence People" Jay Harris 16 Posted 04/11/2025 at 15:39:18 Let me start by saying we played a side, that would go second in the league with a win at their home ground with massive Jordie support, off the pitch for 30 minutes so lets give some credit and praise for that.As far as I can see it the players automatically go to default defence afte taking a lead and drop far too deep no doubt encouraged by Keane, Tarks and Picks.Barry was regularly found in his own half so we had no forward outlet and resorted to long boots up the pitch.To me this is a lack of confidence and coaching so although I am certainly not in the Moyes out camp he is part of the problem currently.I ask the same question as others when KDH tired notably because he was running around like a headless chicken why not bring Rohl on.Why bring McNeill, who is not match fit and as slow as hell on to replace Ndiaye when we have Alcaraz and Dibling raring to get an opportunity.Barry's head dropped visibly when he missed that golden chance why let him carry on. Make a change !!To the whole team when we take a lead go for the throat while we have the momentum and the home crowd is discontent. Rob Dolby 17 Posted 04/11/2025 at 15:39:30 Moyes is correct in his summary of he game. He does fail to say that he is the only person who could have changed the formation and strategy. It's all very well saying we were shite for 60 mins, do something about it!. The away fans were singing for Charlie Alcaraz with 30 mins to go but Moyes gives the lad 5 mins.It's so obvious in every game a prem team will dominate our midfield as soon as we stop passing it and resort to percentage play.Our whole system is built around kdh. Like the last couple of years it's been Doucoure. If kdh plays well we play well, if not we get overrun.Moyes has plenty of options across midfield, he should be changing things.Our best 2 players are wingers so get the ball to both of them asap and then get it back asap once we lose it.John 6.When you say Everton you do mean "we" don't you? It makes you sound like your not a fan.When I talk about other teams I refer to them by their name. When I talk about the blues its"Us" or "we" Ian Wilkins 18 Posted 04/11/2025 at 15:43:48 The problem with our back up players, McNeill aside, who is currently bereft of confidence, is that they are not Moyes ready. Dibling, Röhl, Iro all have some talent, but dont yet do the PL required hard yards covering and the defensive duties he expects. I doubt some of the Summer acquisitions were Moyes. Hes not yet convinced by some of them. Maybe never will be. Im not sure who scouted Barry, but Id like to know. Where we a club who could invest in players for a few years time when we needed players on the pitch now…? Kevin Molloy 19 Posted 04/11/2025 at 16:00:40 Ian yes, this is the critical point. The result will soon fade, but that sub will still continue to bug me. It means he can't risk Dibling in the least pressurising environment (20 minutes, away to a crap side). We've just lashed out £40M on him! And so this reveals these aren't his players. So then you wonder, which are his players? Dewsbury-Hall, Grealish. And so we've got £100M of players that the manager doesn't rate. What a total cock up. And I'm not putting all the blame on Moyes, I fear this transfer committee has left it's mark on us already. Les Callan 20 Posted 04/11/2025 at 16:17:14 Jay @ 16. Don't let a Sunderland supporter hear you call him a “Jordie”! Phil Roberts 21 Posted 04/11/2025 at 16:21:10 Jay -- remember...He's a Mackem he's a BlueHe's a Toffee through and throughHe hates the ToonHe hates the ShiteJordan Pickford is Dynamite. Jay Harris 22 Posted 04/11/2025 at 16:23:08 Well spotted, Les, haha, predictive text strikes again. Maybe I should have said Georgies. That would really get them going. Jim Bennings 23 Posted 04/11/2025 at 16:30:42 It once again shows how mentally fragile we are collectively that a game completely turns on its head almost full circle after that Barry miss.I've never seen a football team before collapse so quickly when controlling a game as we do; it's not a one-off thing either.It would be interesting to see what our points tally, goal return in the for and against column was at this time last season because it was around early November that it very quickly unravelled for Sean Dyche. George Cumiskey 24 Posted 04/11/2025 at 16:30:48 Well said, John @6. You must be the person who taught Pep, Ferguson, Klopp, Slot, Carlo and all the great managers all they know about management. Well done, mate! Sean Mitchell 25 Posted 04/11/2025 at 16:45:13 There's been far too many first- or second-half abysmal performances.How about dealing with it instead of winging? Change and adapt. Drop the shite strikers for a start. Pickford up front would do a better job. Other managers find a solution. Moyes is stuck in 2004. Andrew Ellams 26 Posted 04/11/2025 at 16:52:39 The substitutions last night were shocking and the Barry - Beto switcheroo has become embarrassing. I don't see him being here next season. Ditto Grealish, who's love affair with the club seems to be slipping. Kieran Kinsella 27 Posted 04/11/2025 at 17:01:53 All those criticizing Moyes now... Just wait until early January when we play Shrewsbury Town in the one cup he hasn't thrown already.And he decides, because we've a few players away in Africa, that it is a great time to play a C-team and throw that cup too. Mike Powell 28 Posted 04/11/2025 at 17:20:01 We were abysmal, so why didn't you change it at half-time? Why keep swapping Barry for Beto or Beto for Barry, when we can all see it's not working?Midfield was non-existent in the second-half, both full-backs were awful, along with Tarkowski, Gana and McNeil when he came on.Why not try Alcaraz up front, put Dibling and Röhl on? John, we have some of the best supporters in the country who have every right to moan about that performance. What do you want them to do? Clap them and say "Well done, boys" for that awful performance? Iain Johnston 29 Posted 04/11/2025 at 17:23:03 For me, I'd like to see 4-3-3 with a midfield of Dewsbury-Hall, Alcaraz and Garner with Grealish, Ndiaye and Dibling upfront.We have McNeil for left-midfield cover who can track back and defend and again for me Patterson would make a decent right-midfielder. We have Röhl to fill in when Alcaraz tires and either Gana or Tim if/when we want to be a bit more defensive. Beto scores most of his goals with his feet so stop hoofing it up to him.As for Barry...? Next... Bill Hawker 30 Posted 04/11/2025 at 17:29:45 I've said it once, I'll say it a thousand times more.Many forget that Moyes, when chasing a match down 1-0 or 2-1, would bring in Johnny Heitinga for Phil Neville at DM.That's the type of manager he is and why it was time for him to go the last time around. He hasn't really changed at all but Dycheball was so turgid and unimaginative that any change would have been an improvement.But going forward? Moyes won't get us into the top half. Jimmy Carr 31 Posted 04/11/2025 at 17:40:16 I agree with John Williams, though I wouldn't put it quite like that. The thing is, Toffee Web is not representative of the Everton fanbase, the views expressed here are way more negative. It can be utterly depressing reading the ranting and 'told you so' posts after a bad or average result. John Williams' comment is a response to that and I get where he's coming from. It's fine to have a moan about Everton, but many of the posts offer zero balance or context and come across like an opinion piece about asylum seekers in the Daily Mail. Last night is a good example. We're told Barry's miss was 'ludicrous' and cost us the game. That is patently not true. A poor overall performance by the manager and entire team cost us three points. Barry's miss didn't help however a number of other players didn't turn up. That said we came away with a point against a team currently in the top four. Not the end of the world really, but let's not let that get in the way of another moan fest lads. Jerome Shields 32 Posted 04/11/2025 at 17:42:27 A abysmal Coach called David was the problem.All the reasons as above, except John who got the wrong end of the stick. Mike Allison 33 Posted 04/11/2025 at 17:42:42 Were in a hole of Moyes making. Alcaraz, Dibling and McNeil are all way short of match fitness and so we dont have the depth that it looked like we had. We finish almost every game poorly as players tire and arent replaced.Id be on the lookout now for the next manager. Moyes contract is for this season and one more. Id be looking to change next summer, but if the owners have an idea of who they want and they are available before then, I think we should just do it. Moyes is definitely not going to go beyond his current contract, so as long as we think were not in danger of relegation, it makes sense to put the long term plan in place as soon as the opportunity arises.To be clear, this is not a “Moyes out”, ‘he has to go now type post, but we should be looking beyond him and identifying the right long-term person. Moyes is showing all of his known weaknesses at the moment and showing no signs of learning and developing. Not too surprising for a 62-year-old really. David Bromwell 34 Posted 04/11/2025 at 17:47:16 Well Mr Moyes I hope someone points out the perspective from the majority of the Fans who will acknowledge that our squad has limitations but surely they could be managed more effectively ! As others have said McNeil as a right winger makes no footballing sense and when your team is regularly struggling why leave your substitutions until the very end of the game ?Hopefully we will see a team that can play for the full 90 minutes on Saturday, as 30 minutes of nice football is clearly not winning us many matches. You have options, please don't be afraid to use them, and don't openly criticise your players as we believe you are as much at fault as some of them are. Michael Coville 35 Posted 04/11/2025 at 17:52:53 Don't often comment about Moyes, wanted him back and he did a good job last year. However he is has become so one dimensional it is scary. We all know the definition of insanity, and he is the master. Ndiaye showed how a good center-forward scores goals and yet we continue to use the B&B duo who have shown again and again that they are not up to the task. I really thought that we would try something different this time, if he doesn't change the tactics soon we will unfortunately be on the managerial merry-go-around again. Add Your Comments In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site. » Log in now Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site. How to get rid of these ads and support TW © ToffeeWeb