Brentford 1 - 1 Everton

Beto's goalscoring prowess deserted him tonight and it came down to Jake O'Brien to rescue a point at Brentford with a very fine diving header.

David Moyes makes a change with Charly Alcaraz starting for Everton, Abdoulaye Doucoure is not on the bench because his wife is having a baby but both Nathan Patterson and Youssef Chermiti make a welcome return from their respective injury absences.

The home side got the game underway, getting forward and winning an early throw-in. A long-range striker from Lewis-Potter flew past Pickford's post. Going the other way, Garner's first effort was bizarrely spooned high and wide. Mykolenko then tried to release Beto without success.

There was some decent Everton play until Gueye decided he too should try a silly shot at goal from way too far out. Gueye was fouled but the turnover was waved on by the referee. Tarkowski needlessly played the ball into touch and Schade drove in on goal, forcing a corner. Tarkowski redeemed himself, heading the ball clear. 

Lewis-Potter caused more trouble and Schade forced another corner that required some considerable defending, Everton penned back.  Branthwaite tried to release Mykolenko but he completely mis-hit the ball and The Bees surged forward, Branthwaite saving a corner at the expense of a throw-in.

Brentford eventually worked the ball well to the far post but Wissa could only head into Pickford's grateful hands.  The Blues finally got forward but Mykolenko was denied possession. 

A great turnover and Alcaraz drove forward, Lindstrom crossing, but it flew over Beto and Alcaraz could do nothing with it at the far post. Schade almost stole the ball off O'Brien. But Everton were getting a lot more of the forward play although Beto had no real chance to convert a difficult volley. 

Ajer did well to stop Harrison overlapping, but Alcaraz did not control the ball well. A nice move into the Brentford area saw an interesting backheel from O'Brien that was unfortunately wayward. 

Brentford worked another foray forward; more firm defensive work was required, with Mbeumo putting in a tempting cross toward the far post.

A Harrison cross to O'Brien seemed to be a good set-up for Beto coming in but he was rather easily put off by the defender. End-to-end and Brentford couldn't quite shape the shit before Beto gets away from Pinnock but one-on-one, he makes it far too easy for Flekken to snatch the ball.  

Brentford attacked again but the Blues cleared the ball and Collins wellied high and wide. Beto again got free one-on-one again after a very smart header forward by Alcaraz but this time his shot hit Flekken's arm and got just enough of a deflection to touch it past the post. 

From the corner, there was a nasty clash of heads between Mbeumo and Alcaraz, with the Everton man flat out — but eventually both were able to run off for the enforced (ridiculous!) 30-second sin-bin on the sideline. 

Wissa was given space to shoot but Pickford palmed it away. But from the long throw-in bounced before Mbeumo was allowed to head it onto the bar and Wissa easily nodded the falling ball over the line.

Really a shocking goal for the Blues to give up on the verge of half-time as Alcaraz shows he too can shoot stupidly from a ridiculous distance away from goal. 

O'Brien won an early corner after the restart, the brilliant delivery from Harrison almost going straight in before it hit O'Brien on the line — who seemed to have no idea what just happened!

Everton had some possession but just allowed themselves to be pushed all the way back to Pickford. Lindstrom crossed in, then the ball fell at Alcaraz's feet but he could not react and the ball came out to Garner who decided he too should show everyone how badly he could shoot.

O'Brien was very strong competing with Schade and incorrectly winning a corner. Harrison's corner this time was pitiful as the referee saw an infringement by the attacking side.   

The hour-mark approached as Everton tried but failed to work an opening, Moyes with very little on the bench to affect the outcome. Harrison's cross was deflected into Flekken's hands. Another Harrison cross was delivered too close to Flekken. 

Lindstrøm was bundled over by Lewis-Potter, but Pickford's free-kick soon came right back to him. Gueye Lindstrom and Beto tried an intricate move through the middle that broke down. Mykolenko was next to cross straight to Flekken. 

Lewis-Potter got a good cross past O'Brien to the far post but Pickford was there for the following header.  Garner and Harrison did well to let Alcaraz work a dangerous shot that flew just wide. 

Alcaraz drove forward with intent but rather generously played it to Harrison, whose low shot was well blocked. by Ajer. Alcaraz tried another shot from way out that bobbled wide. 

Brentford seemed to just walk through the Everton defence for Wissa to score his second but thankfully it was flagged offside. A Brentford free-kick was headed wide. Then Tarkowski almost got into trouble. Brentford built again but were repelled, with Everton failing to really threaten as Moyes finally made his belated changes on 75 minutes. 

But with very little seemingly happening, Mykolenko picked out the giant Jake O'Brien who stooped to conquer with a fine header that flew past Flekken. That goal certainly enlivened the pace of what had been a flat game at times, both sides now determined to find a winner.

Everton had a good spell with the ball, Brentford on the back foot. It was then Everton's turn to defend until they forced a break, Alcaraz stretching as he fired the ball at Flekken. 

Brentford looked to have fashioned a dangerous chance but again Everton turned it over and Beto was again put through one-on-one but again Flekken got a hand to his attempted lob. 

It led to a couple of corners and again a wayward shot from Alcaraz ended the move. Beto was body-checked by Collins, winning a late free-kick but Harrison's ball in evaded Tarkowski at the far post.

Iroegbunam wins a throw-in by the corner flag but Wissa heads it clear. Everton tried to get the ball up to Beto again in the last minutes but it would not fall for him.  

Brentford had a late throw-in of their own that saw O'Brien edge his man aside, screams for a home penalty waived away, and that's how it ended. 

Brentford: Flekken, Ajer (81' Kayode), Collins [Y:90+1'], Pinnock, Lewis-Potter, Janelt, Yarmoliuk [Y:80'], Damsgaard, Schade (76' Maghoma), Mbeumo, Wissa.

Subs not Used: Valdimarsson, Carvalho, Mee, Konak, Ji-Soo, Morgan, Arthur

Everton: Pickford, Mykolenko, Branthwaite, Tarkowski, O'Brien, Harrison, Garner, Gueye (75' Iroegbunam), Alcaraz [Y:89'], Lindstrom (75' Young), Beto.

Subs not Used: Virginia, Begovic, Patterson, Keane, Chermiti, Sherif, Heath.


Reader Comments (208)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()


David West
1 Posted 26/02/2025 at 18:32:18
Must be a forced change, be nice to have a nice lead and bring on chermiti & Patterson.

Chance for Charly to force himself in to the side permanently.

1-0 Alcaraz!!!

Jay Harris
2 Posted 26/02/2025 at 18:34:19
Is Doucoure injured? Pity cos he was just coming back to form and scoring goals.

Let's hope Charly is my darling and lasts the 90-plus minutes.

Brian Wilkinson
3 Posted 26/02/2025 at 18:35:24
Doucoure not even on bench. Deffo forced change, must have the shits from Lindstrom last week.

Good line-up.

Joe McMahon
4 Posted 26/02/2025 at 18:37:15
Bryan Ferry and Howard Kendall were in same school football team. I didn't know that.

https://x.com/AlanRobert44297/status/1894644772502905341

Paul Kossoff
5 Posted 26/02/2025 at 18:38:33
Charly Alcaraz to break us out of the prison that Warden Dyche locked us in.
Mike Hayes
6 Posted 26/02/2025 at 18:41:14
Doucoure and partner expecting birth of a baby – best wishes to them – fingers crossed Beto and Charly can get their game on and score a few. COYB UTFT 💙
Paul Kossoff
7 Posted 26/02/2025 at 18:44:46
Joe 4 Apparently they used to work together, they would dance away, and do the strand, more than this I don't know.👮👮👮
Gerry Quinn
8 Posted 26/02/2025 at 18:46:52
Evening guys and gals, looking forwards to the game (which certainly makes a change from the last season or two)!
Christy Ring
9 Posted 26/02/2025 at 18:49:50
Hopefully Chermiti is over his injury problems, he was impressive in Sligo on preseason.
Geoff Trenner
10 Posted 26/02/2025 at 19:08:33
Does anyone know whether the young lad Heath is related to Inchy?
Derek Knox
11 Posted 26/02/2025 at 19:10:58
Don't let Wissa take the Pissa !

COYB 💙

Brian Wilkinson
12 Posted 26/02/2025 at 19:15:50
Aye Doucoure Mrs expecting baby, so Doucoure at hospital with her.
Michael Kenrick
13 Posted 26/02/2025 at 20:25:03
A real shame after they had defended every other attack very well. Beto at fault for misjudging the long throw and letting it drop behind him. That plus his missed chances. Should be 0-3 but it's 1-0.

But what is it with these ridiculous shots not on goal?

Alan J Thompson
14 Posted 26/02/2025 at 20:27:19
Everton looked a bit lethargic, almost just sitting back as there seemed to be little movement in midfield or out wide for that matter and it all seemed too slow but then Beto was put through and just as I thought, "He doesn't miss these", he did… and then did it again a few minutes later.

Then we give away a soft goal from a long throw-in for which nobody seemed to want to challenge. Brentford just seem to be quicker, better organized and not without a bit of skill and Moyes will earn his money sorting this out at halftime.

John Wignall
15 Posted 26/02/2025 at 20:34:55
Beto could've had 3; poor finishing – that's being kind.

Full backs and wingers giving us nothing going forward.

Nicolas Piñon
16 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:23:50
COYB!

A good point on the road. Alcaraz has to become a permanent addition, what an agressivenes and understanding of the game he has.

If Beto should’ve passed that we would have won it.

Great point and still moving forward.

Paul Conway
17 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:31:36
Haven’t felt so comfortable trailing 0-1, in a long while.
Just a pity about some poor crosses.
O’ Brien and Beto are an absolute revelation !
Alan J Thompson
18 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:34:36
Brentford seemed to catch Everton's lethargy in the second half as their play was a lot slower than they showed in the first half.

From the corner it looked like Lindstrom stopped it going into the net. And who said Mykolenko can't cross a ball as O'Brien gets his first. Beto spoils his reputation by missing a third one on one chance with their keeper.

A game which could have gone either way and without either team looking like they wanted it a draw seems a fair result as Mr Moyes effect continues.

Oh, and a final word, the Ref had a good game but what is the point of Linesmen if they won't flag offside until VAR tells them to.

Craig Walker
19 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:34:41
Good point away from home. Thought we were the better side. Beto was wasteful but at least we are getting men forward and showing some attacking intent.
Michael Kenrick
20 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:34:47
A draw on the road, another point toward the 40. Now unbeaten in seven league games (don't mention the FA Cup!) but it still feels like a win that wasn't with those chances Beto had.

No doubt we'll be told that they weren't really chances, that no-one could have scored them.

Well, there is one player I know who certainly couldn't!

Roger Helm
21 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:35:21
Good performance and a handy result away against a useful side. Beto didn't score but the keeper made some good saves. The three CBs, Charly and Gana all had very good games. I thought.

We will get better with a bit of a rest and troops coming back, on this form we will be soon in the top half.

Scott Hamilton
22 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:37:30
We looked out of sorts first half but were much more on it in the second.

You could argue that Beto should've scored all three of his chances but the keeper did well each time and the effort that caught Flekken under the arm could easily have gone in.

O'Brien and Tarks were immense and we looked the most likely to score a winner. And I'm gonna say it: we're now safe. 15 points and massively superior GD.

UTFT!!!

Kieran Kinsella
23 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:38:20
We failed to score in 8 out of Dyche's last 10 league games. We've scored in 7 out of 8 of Moyes league games.

Obviously, Beto finding form prior to this game helped but getting goals from set pieces and people following up on loose balls have also helped. This was basic stuff we'd stopped doing for whatever reason under Dyche.

As to the performance tonight, it was a bit below par but games are coming thick and fast for our threadbare squad so it is not surprising to see a bit of lethargy creeping in.

Kevin Molloy
24 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:42:14
When you think of what a run-of-the-mill squad we have, and that we've had to cope with 10 injuries, the level of performance after what has gone on is quite remarkable.

The team that is third from bottom needs now to make up 16 points on us, so we're up basically.

Dave Abrahams
25 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:44:16
Well it was another game where the result stops any real criticism with the squad we have at the moment, poor defending by the full back for their goal but he redeemed himself with a well-taken equaliser.

I don't think we deserved to win but we had some good chances and Brentford didn't deserve to win either so I'd say
I'm happy with another point which makes it almost certain we can relax for another season.

James Garner was the MotM for me.

Brendan McLaughlin
26 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:45:15
Good point on the road against a decent Brentford side and, given Beto's opportunities, we were unfortunate not to score more than one.

IMWT2

Mike Gaynes
27 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:47:07
You could see within 15 minutes that there wasn't much sharpness, not much snap in the legs. Too many games in too short a time with too few healthy players. This was a point from raw grit. Congratulations to Jake on popping his Everton cherry.

Strongly dispute the criticism of Beto... their keeper did very well, that last chip was bound for the top corner if not for a great save, the pass to Alcaraz was NOT on, and Charly's tantrum was less than seemly.

Oliver Molloy
28 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:50:13
Well, my expectations have certainly changed since the arrival of Moyes.

I thought we threw away 2 points against Man Utd and I am really disappointed we didn't win tonight. Beto had four chances, two of which he really should have scored.

Two points from two games with a depleted squad is better than zero points – but it should have been six.

Christy Ring
29 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:50:19
Michael #20,

Definitely over the top, would it not be great to get Calvert-Lewin back from injury?

Ian Linn
30 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:54:01
Harsh headline and some comments harsh on Beto. The third chance was a great save by their keeper.

Good overall performance by us, I wish we had more options off the bench.

Nigel Scowen
31 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:55:30
In my opinion, with the number of injuries we have coupled with the amount of games played this month, that was a fine performance by the lads.

Well done Moyes and the team, a never-say-die attitude.

Denver Daniels
32 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:55:59
Beto made it easy for the keeper with the last 2 chances. For the first one, who knows what he was trying? To go around the the keeper if I was to guess.

At that level, he has to score at least one.

Brendan McLaughlin
33 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:56:48
Moyes saying if it wasn't Everton he wouldn't have taken on a club at this end of the table at this stage in his career.

"Fairytale of Bramley Moore Dock" perhaps?

Colin Glassar
34 Posted 26/02/2025 at 21:56:57
I agree Nigel. They are all playing for each other despite their limitations. I can’t wait until next season.
Robert Tressell
35 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:00:10
Another very good result.

Very, very impressive start from Moyes.

Tony Abrahams
36 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:05:36
The only time Mykolenko produced a little bit of quality and our other fullback popped up with a fantastic header, but otherwise there was very little on offer coming from either flank.

A gritty performance, you can see Beto's shortcomings but, he also gave us an outlet and is becoming a real handful to play against, and I'm sure the goals will continue if he keeps getting in areas that will always give him chances and he gets back to keeping the ball on the floor!

The best thing about tonight was that I'm no longer exasperated when I watch us and you can slowly begin to see the players gaining confidence. The rest should do us good and hopefully a few players are fit for the Wolves game in ten days time

Colin Malone
37 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:09:12
The two wingers, Harrison and Lindstrom, going forward, they were fucking shit.
Christy Ring
38 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:14:59
We definitely deserved to win tonight, but equalising 13 minutes from the end, I'm delighted with the point.

Beto's first two chances one one-on-one, he should have scored, the last chance wasn't easy, but I can't fault his effort.

The 10-day break is badly needed, and hopefully we'll have more players back before Wolves.

Paul Hewitt
39 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:15:05
How can anyone moan tonight FFS. It's a good point, should have been 3, but we've come on miles since Moyes arrived.

Clearly safe now, and I expect us to put up more points that's remaining.

Ian Burns
40 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:16:52
Given the circumstances along with a bit of a frightening bench, this was a good point and well deserved. I pray Beto takes confidence from his movement to get into position to take those chances and gives their keeper the praise he thoroughly deserved.

If Leicester don't win tomorrow, it will be the final confirmation we will be in BMD as a Premier League club next season, even if it is all but certain now anyway.

Thank you, Mr Moyes – take a bow.

Neil Tyrrell
41 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:17:49
Good second half anyway, we looked the more likely to win it by the end.

Oh for a game changer on the bench. Shame about Beto not converting, but he's already scored more one one-on-ones in the past month than Calvert-Lewin probably ever will, so I'm willing to cut him some slack.

Overall, a good away point, especially coming from behind.

Andy Meighan
42 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:22:13
Well said, Paul @39.

Never in my wildest dreams did I think we'd be more or less safe when not even out of February.

What a job the manager has done and I never doubted for one minute tonight that we wouldn't score.

I would never have said that under the other clown because, as soon as Wissa scored, that would have been game over under him.

Yes, Beto missed great chances tonight but let's credit him for the ones he's stuck away lately.

On another night, at least one goes in but the keeper made 2 good saves so let's not be too harsh.

As I said when he come back, I can't remember having too many sleepless nights when he was here last time. I couldn't say that under The Waiter, Frank, and Him who I can't mention.

Thanks, David and his threadbare squad, for giving us back our pride... at least for this season.

Kevin Molloy
43 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:22:16
I just watched the 'misses'. Very few strikers have the pace and power to even get themselves into position. Hard lines with all of them, not like Calvert-Lewin, who finishes like a centre-half.

We've got an excellent striker here. and their centre-half should have been sent off for the first one, took Beto out.

Mike Hayes
44 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:23:42
Great header from O’Brien for his first Everton goal - No one more disappointed than Beto with those three misses one on one - 1-1 not bad unbeaten in 7 league matches - so confidence may be dented but things have been going better since Moyes return - long may it continue and those chances if given again Beto and Alcaraz will put those away 💙
Oliver Molloy
45 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:29:04
Paul @ 39
"How can anyone moan tonight FFS. It's a good point, should have been 3". moan or what !!
Derek Thomas
46 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:30:38
We didn't play that bad, or that well either, Beto could've won it for us.
Yet we fail to defend the basic agricultural long throw.

O'Brien took his goal well and Moyes continues to confound his critics, of which I am one...but so far on a game by game basis he's doing OK, so fairplay to him.

10 (?) days off now to rest a day regroup.

When draws go from being 1pt gained to feeling like 2pts lost we must be doing something right.

Raymond Fox
47 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:30:40
Another good point, we are best priced at 100/1 to be relegated now but I think that should be 10,000/1.

The little fat southern bbc match commentator whos name escapes me always says - he should scored - every time a player has not even a half chance which always causes me to utter an expletive.
They are all easy from the side-lines.

Paul Conway
48 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:31:26
From all the chances that Beto Had, I thought the best option, was after he got tripped, when he got up, he could have taken a couple of touches, composed himself and chipped the Keeper, who had well advanced off his line.
But, it’s great to see him getting into these positions.
His XG has gone trough the roof, since our ex manager headed off, with his Bag of Swag.
Wasn’t he once a big fan of the XG factor?
Brendan McLaughlin
49 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:32:11
i'm just waiting for... "If only Moyes had made earlier substitutions"
Jay Harris
50 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:33:31
Ian we might prefer that Leicester get at least a point tomorrow to keep West Ham below us too.

Thought Beto did well to get onto those chances with pace and strength but was generally not getting much service and very little support.

The first one he tried to go around the keeper but being young and agile the keeper thwarted him, 1-0 to the keeper, the second one he tried to put away early on the ground and again the keeper got a touch to get it just around the post, the 3rd one he tried to loop over the keeper who managed the faintest of touches to again get it over the woodwork.

Thought our MF was tremendous today with special mention for Charly, Garner and Gana Gueye.

The flanks not so good with poor crosses and weak defending at times particularly our left flank which needs a boost in the summer.

Paul Johnson
51 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:33:49
Thought we more than deserved a point, just on chances created.
As an ex goalie though guys surely Pickford has to come and claim the ball after the ball has bounced in th six yard box. He does not command his area enough.
Peter Mills
52 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:37:44
This was an excellent performance.

We gave as good as we got, at the very least. Beto could have scored, of course. But their goalie understood that he prefers to hit the ball to the keeper’s left, anticipated and saved. Or, in the first instance, made him go the wrong way. Excellent goalkeeping.

We fully deserved O’Brien’s well taken equaliser.

And, of course, cautious Moyes settled for the point. Or, rather, he didn’t - he absolutely went for the win, despite his very limited options from the bench.

Ernie Baywood
53 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:38:11
We're disappointed not to win away to Brentford. The team that we played out a bore draw against just a couple of months ago (against 10 men at home).

If you compare those two matches it's night and day. We showed precisely zero bravery in that first match and they were booed off the pitch. Tonight we had chances and the equaliser came from both full backs in the final third.

I'm not even too disappointed in Beto. He didn't do too much wrong for the second two chances. For the first one I don't think he ever quite regained his composure after the initial challenge.

The Charly/Beto combination looks like it's got legs. Charly can be a bit hungry (and he wasn't happy with Beto taking a shot) but I like his attitude. He looks nailed on right now to be a permanent deal.

By the way, a little bit of fortune for our equaliser as I thought there was a late challenge before the ball turned over. Referee looked like he put the whistle to his mouth and then changed his mind.

Mind you I also thought Gueye was fouled in the build up to their offside goal.

No complaints at all from me. We're playing out mid table fixtures now, the team is running on fumes, the matches have been coming twice a week, and yet we keep seeing the same drive and commitment right to the end of matches. They've earned their warm weather break.

Finally witnessing my Everton. Thank God we made that change. It was sucking the life out of me.

Si Cooper
54 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:42:24
Better we are creating chances and missing them than not creating them at all.
Things have improved so much you feel like we are always in games like this. When we scored it felt like we could go on to get another and there was no sign of simply going defensive and just trying to preserve the point, though that is obviously easier psychologically having reached a position of relative safety.
Shame we aren’t still ahead of United and Spuds, nipping at the heels of Brentford and Palace, but there is still time for a winning streak to power a surge up the table.
Will need no more injuries and players to become available again but it’s definitely a case of looking up with ambition rather than nervously ‘checking over our shoulder.
Lester Yip
55 Posted 26/02/2025 at 22:49:28
Another point on the road. Not bad.

For a one on one situation, it's 3 phase:
1) Win the leg race and first to the ball;
2) Steady yourself and shoot on target;
3) See if GK can block it.

I'd say Beto did well on all occasions for (1) and did ok for (2). But the Keeper did come out calmly and position well enough.

Brian Williams
56 Posted 26/02/2025 at 23:21:02
Proof, if ever any was needed, that one on ones aren't as easy as some would have you believe.
Rob Dolby
57 Posted 26/02/2025 at 23:34:59
We played well again tonight, subtle changes in position and making the opposition worry about us rather than the other way around has changed our fortunes.

Obrien ran 80 yards to get on the end of the cross, something unheard of under Dyche.

James Garner is looking like a midfielder that can stamp his authority on games. Gana Gueye looks like a footballer and not just a destroyer.

Massive credit to Moyes and the coaches for turning this around. I honestly didn't think he had it in him.

It's still obvious we lack quality down the flanks but even the lads playing there are putting a shift in.

I thought the ref had a decent game, I haven't said that for a while.

Beto on another night could have scored a hat trick. I think their goalie pulled off 3 good saves and one just hit him. He was their best player on the night which shows how many chances we had.

Garner was very good tonight though O'Brien did well again and got his goal for my motm. The lad needs to celebrate a bit more.

Ian Wilkins
58 Posted 26/02/2025 at 23:35:51
Beto’s one on one successes recently have come from passing the ball on the floor past the keeper, keepers unable to get down quick enough.
Keeper had done his homework and didn’t stand up, except for the final one when Beto tried to beat him high.
I’m pleased he got into those positions, especially the third, outstripping the defender.
The nature of his game means he will get lots more one on ones. Needs to keep working on his composure.
This was a hardworking gutsy performance against a decent team.
We understandably lacked some zip and energy, but we were always in the game and might easily have won it.
The fact we end up disappointed in dropping points, especially away from home, is real progress in itself.
Mark Murphy
59 Posted 26/02/2025 at 23:39:03
Sort of sat in the neutral seats as my second half seat was basically in our end apart from a gantry so I got a calmish view of the game. They looked sharper in the first half without really troubling us. Their goal was out of nowhere and I couldn’t really see what we could’ve done to defend it. Beto “shouldve” scored the first one on one but if he scored 100% of those he’d be the new Ronaldo (mark 1). I’ll let him off that one. Second half we controlled the game and nullified their threat. We look a very good composed and strong side these days. Danny and I couldn’t settle on a motm. I edged for O’Brien but Danny went for Harrison. Tbf Branthwaite, Tarks, Myko or Alcatraz could also be in the running. No-one had a bad game.
Didn’t feel like a win but a good game and a satisfactory result.
The match experience in the home end is VERY different. Got served quickly at half time - very little queuing - a choice of 4 beers, several tasty meal options and loads of room to eat and drink. I could hear the mayhem on the other side of the divide and wished I was there.
UTFT
Colin Glassar
60 Posted 27/02/2025 at 00:12:44
I can’t wait to see Alcaraz play alongside Ndiaye. I just hope it happens this season.

Harrison looks like he’s improving. Lindstrom on the other hand, not so much.

John Raftery
61 Posted 27/02/2025 at 00:30:58
Dave (25) I agree James Garner was man of the match tonight. His return to the team has been as impressive as it has been timely.
Mark Andersson
62 Posted 27/02/2025 at 01:02:50
Great to read mostly positive comments. Another away point is still going in the right direction.

Moyes doing well, the team fighting till the end. A well deserved warm weather break.

Hippy dayz...

Craig Scott
63 Posted 27/02/2025 at 01:03:04
While always willing Everton to win each game I also try and watch from a neutral's perspective to assess which team looks the better. Unfortunately, there have been few games this season or last where I feel, from this perspective, that we have deserved to win over the whole contest. We've had spells in games where we show intent and promise but we've rarely dominated any team.

Credit to Moyes he has managed to get the team to typically battle and scratch out results that they might not have previously gained. That's a hallmark of Moyes' teams really. But its glaringly obvious that he just doesn't have the quality in the squad. We probably have three decent players, Branthwaite, Pickford and Ndiaye. Our midfield are bereft of creative talent and contribute very little in the way of goals (perhaps McNeil excepted). Every team needs to have midfielders chipping in with goals and most teams we play seem to have much more space to create chances from midfield than we do. Still too much lateral and backwards passing from our lads in my opinion.

Recruitment of creative midfielders and two strikers who can finish are definitely the priorities for our summer transfer dealings.

Mike Gaynes
64 Posted 27/02/2025 at 01:19:19
Colin #60, an attacking midfield of McNeil, Alacaraz and Ndiaye is going to scare the hell out of the rest of the PL.
Lester Yip
65 Posted 27/02/2025 at 03:18:24
Re-watch again. Beto's 1st attempt trying to square to feint a shot to his right then push to the left to round the keeper. But the keeper did not fell for that. An attempt only when you're confident but unlucky it doesn't work out this time around.

Alcaraz looks good. Right into the team and making impact.

Jonathan Oppenheimer
66 Posted 27/02/2025 at 03:49:49
The difference in the goals Beto was scoring and the ones he missed today is that he’s been putting it away when he doesn’t have to think about it too much. It’s a small thing, but it’s significant and something a lot of players struggle with. Not to say Flekken didn’t come up big, but it’s often easier to finish one-touch than one-on-one. He still deserves all the credit for getting in position to score, but because he’s not fleet of foot and has almost no moves, he’ll always be better when he’s not dribbling.

As for Moyes, there’s so much credit to go around, but at the top of the list is his decision to bring big Jake into the fold. To think we were playing Ashley Young over him earlier in the season. I know, I know, old man Ashley did his part, but what a revelation O’Brien is and what a reflection of Dyche’s stubbornness that he was keeping him on the bench all season long.

Well earned point given how tired our legs were, another gritty performance.

Laurie Hartley
67 Posted 27/02/2025 at 04:19:42
I think that was a fair result. Having said that, there is plenty to be encouraged about by our performance.

I think the headline is very harsh on Beto Michael. Yes he had three one on ones with the keeper so should have scored at least one of them. But I also look at how he got himself into position for those three opportunities.

The other thing to keep in mind in my opinion is that his last effort was stopped by an absolutely top class save. That ball was heading for the top right hand corner but Flekken did really well to get a hand to it.

If you did a poll of premier league centre half’s on which of Everton’s centre forwards they would prefer NOT to play against it would be Beto by a landslide majority. He gives us a threat up front that we have’nt had for I don’t know how long. He will do me.

I have said it before but I am very impressed with O’Brien’s ability with the ball at his feet and the way he makes a pass. Terrific headed goal - it went exactly where he intended it to.

Another shout for Mykolenko. That was a terrific cross. He looked up and plonked it right on the spot where O’Brien needed it.

Alcaraz is a winner. Thelwell has done really well getting him in. Nailed on to be signed at the end of his lone spell. I’ll say it again - he has got “winner” stamped on his forehead.

I have gone from hiding behind the sofa for every game to fearing no one. What or who is responsible for this 180 degree change - answers on a postage stamp.

What’s our name!

Kieran Kinsella
68 Posted 27/02/2025 at 04:57:13
Jonathan Opp, agree mate in thinking versus instinct hope you’re family are doing well.

Dave A/Laurie

I agreed on a fair result until I read Thomas Frank said the same which is what managers always say of a draw when they know they deserved to lose. 3 points lost lol

Sam Hoare
69 Posted 27/02/2025 at 07:13:26
We’re not safe mathematically but we’re not getting relegated now and should be looking up not down. I hope Leicester get a result against West Ham.

On the night it was another encouraging performance and we should really have beaten Brentford despite having a stretched and presumably quite knackered squad.

Lots of decent individual performances though there is room for improvement on the wings especially, neither Harrison or Lindstrom has a goal or assist between them this season which is not ideal despite their work rate.

Beto had a less satisfying day at the office but was probably due some misses and still showed the crucial ability to find chances. Shame he couldn’t bag one but the keeper did well also.

Really looking forward to a more relaxing end of the season and especially seeing Ndiaye back in the team, hopefully with McNeil at some point. Also looking forward to seeing more of Alcaraz and where Chermitti is at in his development.

Derek Thomas
70 Posted 27/02/2025 at 07:16:04
You can bet that a supposed smart cookie like Frank will have noticed Beto's one-on-one form and had his keeper practicing coming out quick and staying large... a fingertip here the corner of a knee there – fine margins

Their keeper was MotM for them and they know they got 'lucky'.

But like the famous golfer said; "...some call me 'lucky', but the more I practice the luckier I seem to get."

Somedays they go in – somedays they'll stay out.

Dave Lynch
71 Posted 27/02/2025 at 07:17:09
Imo...Beto is a much better target man than Calvert-Lewin. He won a lot of headers last night and was actually finding his team mates with them, not just aimlessly heading them on.

On another night he'd've got a brace. 1 he cocked up and the other 2 were very good saves by a very good keeper.

I would rather have seen Patterson than Young come on though.

Andy Meighan
72 Posted 27/02/2025 at 07:22:17
If Ndiaye plays in them last 2 games, we'd have been 4 points better off now.
Ernie Baywood
73 Posted 27/02/2025 at 07:48:00
In DCL's defence, Dave, the striker actually has players around him now.

It's chalk and cheese compared to what we witnessed before. We're seeing the strengths of these players now rather constantly seeing their weaknesses.

Phil Roberts
74 Posted 27/02/2025 at 07:50:35
I wish people would get over this obsession with 40 points.

Last team to go down with that many was West Ham in 02/03 with 42. The average for the last 20 years has been 34 points. And we still have Southampton at home on the last day. We are safe.

Thank you Mr Moyes for taking away my stress in March to May - yet again.

Colin Crooks
75 Posted 27/02/2025 at 07:59:45
I am really enjoying the improvement.

Dyche must be kicking himself watching O'Brien acquit himself with such aplomb.

I also loved that we were still going in search of win the dying minutes.

I think those using Beto's weston to hammer DCL embarrass our fan base and demonstrate a rare degree of ignorance. Calvert- Lewin's abilty to take a long ball has been abused by every manager (including Carlo) since he came to the club. He's been used as an "out" rather than as a striker.

Beto (bless his heart) is a lovely man. He has deserved his recent run of goals through sheer hard graft. I love his goal celebration - although I cant figure it out.. But some on here really do need to pull themselves together..

The two strikers are roughly the same age and while one has spent most of his career in lesser leagues, the other has been playing top flight football since he was a kid. So how the fuck can the fella who has scored less goals despite playing in lower leagues and only ever being employed as a striker, be a better goal scorer than than somebody who (despite long injuries) has scored more than him playing all over the park at the very highest level ?

Calvert Lewin will be gone soon. He'll be free of the brainless tactics he has endured throughout his time here and he will be free of the grade A clowns who want to spend their whole time hating upon him.

Knowledgeable Evertonians ? Yeah right. These are the people who embraced Denis Stracqualursi's "huge heart" whilst Hounding Lukaku from the day he got here.

Breaking news...Calvert - Lewin hasnt played for a month. He may not play for us again. You are going to have to find somebody else to hate upon. you're also going to accept that the lovely Beto gave away a goal by misjudging the flight of the ball and missed three very easy opportunities to make amends. Nothing to do with DCL. He has this Weston all by himself

Christy Ring
76 Posted 27/02/2025 at 08:06:33
Dave#71 In all fairness Dave, when DCL was heading the ball under Dyche, he had no one near him to head it too, he had to run for the 2nd ball himself. Beto has been terrific, but if it was Dom who missed three one on one chances, would anyone be praising the keeper. I thought Garner played well last night, but Gueye has been brilliant since Moyes took over, no comments from Ian, and it’s quite funny that the usual whingers haven’t really posted since our superb run under Moyes?
Jerome Shields
77 Posted 27/02/2025 at 08:11:34
Everton seemed to be a team looking forward to a break.Long shot shortcuts a plenty.Therefore a good result against a difficult opponent. The keeper was well versed in dealing with Beto.A wake up call for him.


Nigel Scowen
78 Posted 27/02/2025 at 08:14:21
Phil@74

Totally Phil, we draw and end up pulling a further point ahead of the bottom 3. There is no way, in my opinion, the bottom 3 teams are getting to 32 points, I’ll be amazed if any of them get to 30 frankly. Throw in the goal difference and we are safe already.

The only reason Moyes is talking about 40 is because he doesn’t want the players to think about taking their foot off the gas.

Andrew Ellams
79 Posted 27/02/2025 at 08:21:17
I think last night vs the last month is Beto to a tee.

He'll always have you shouting his name but not always for the right reasons.

Colin Glassar
80 Posted 27/02/2025 at 08:37:03
I like Beto. Love his enthusiasm and passion but like Jelavic, Cadamateri, Jeffers, Andy Johnson etc… once defences cotton on to his attributes they, like happened with the others, will learn to neutralise him.

In other words, Beto is not the long term solution. He might be a decent impact sub in the future but we need something different.

I hate to say it but look at the rs forwards. They are not huge units but they are quick (in body and mind), skilful and lethal in front of goal.

Brian Williams
81 Posted 27/02/2025 at 08:37:31
Andrew#79

Fully agree Andrew.

He fully deserves the plaudits he's been getting lately but having watched his three one on ones several times over I think it's fair to say that two out of three were straight at the keeper and no great saves required for those two at all.

As I posted earlier it shows that one on ones aren't as easy as some make out. I'll bring Haaland up again and say that he fails to score lots of one on ones, and how good a finisher is he?

There are very fine margins between scoring them and not. I've seen plenty hit badly and more or less straight at the keeper but they bounce off a knee or an elbow and still go in, and plenty hit well but saved.

It shows it's not an exact science, but two out of the three chances he had last night were "poorly finished" if we're judging him as a certain other of our striker's would be judged and that same striker would have been crucified for missing three in one match.

Robert Tressell
82 Posted 27/02/2025 at 08:58:10
Colin # 80, each of the players within the RS forward line is not lethal in front of goal. Salah absolutely is from a wing forward position. Jota is also very reliable when fit. Gakpo and Diaz - also wing forwards - are very good but not lethal (ie in Salah's class) by any stretch. Nunez is a very good player with all the right attributes but a hopeless finisher.

Our issue is that we have only one goal threat - and no options from the bench.

The RS have 6 senior players for their front 3.

It's a squad game and to kick on into the top half and beyond we need to really stock up on wing forwards with goal contributions.

Danny O'Neill
83 Posted 27/02/2025 at 08:58:45
I don't think Beto is an out and out target man Dave @71. Yes, can be a handful for defenders, but he is much more effective when running onto balls.

His touch isn't always great, as seen last night, so doesn't really hold the ball up too often.

That's not being harsh on him, but it's better when we play to his strengths, which isn't as a target man in my opinion.

Colin Glassar
84 Posted 27/02/2025 at 09:06:17
I can’t really disagree with anything you write, Robert. Their mental sharpness combined with abundance of skill makes them lethal imo. Nuñez is useless in front of goal tbh.

I still consider a fully fit DCL to be a better option than Beto.

John Hood
85 Posted 27/02/2025 at 09:09:52
Certainly a much better match than the dire Goodison one.
Two solid well organised teams slugging it out..Bees' home form has dipped just when away has improved..Thought Everton were strong second half, certainly the biggest team I've seen this season.
For Brentford to be a comfortable mid table PL side is a miracle of over achievement, coming up to 5th season now.This is my 64 th season, mainly watching the club teeter on the edge of disaster, so not bothered by any one particular game.
Good luck for rest of this season and I look forward to visiting the amazing new stadium next year.
Alan Corken
86 Posted 27/02/2025 at 09:11:23
Colin@80. No no no, never give the devil's spawn any credit on here. They are not lethal, they are cockalorums, they are snollygosters and Stymphalists.
Turn around 3 times and throw salt over your right shoulder!
Colin Glassar
87 Posted 27/02/2025 at 09:18:03
Alan, you’ve made me feel grubby now. I’m off to repent for my sins.

They are a bunch of cheating bastards. But they do that well as well😉😀😀

Andy Mead
88 Posted 27/02/2025 at 09:20:02
Hi everyone.

I'm travelling home from Australia in April and hoping to attend the Arsenal game. Long shot, but would anybody know where I can get a pair of tickets please?

Seen loads of sites online claiming to be able to get you some, but Idon't trust them as I'm sure it's not that easy surely? Any help would be appreciated.

Rob Halligan
89 Posted 27/02/2025 at 09:21:17
Regarding Beto’s first one v one…….I’ve only seen the incident once, but it did appear to me like the defender who slipped, brought down Beto, which surely would have been a red card, with him being the last man. Fair play to Beto for getting up and carrying on, rather than staying down in an attempt get an opponent sent off. I can think of a few players who would have stayed down, looking for that sending off.

Was kind of frustrating to only come away with a draw. First half I thought was pretty even, but I think we were the better team in the second half, creating a fair few decent chances. Jake O’Brien must have been secretly seeing Dyche’s missus, for him not to be selected. Another solid display culminating in converting a fine header from a great cross by Mykolenko.

James Garner seemed to be everywhere, and probably my MOTM. On another day, Beto could easily have had a hat trick, but we said after his second and third one v ones you have to give their keeper credit. Had that been Pickford we’d all singing his praises. One v one isn’t as easy as some think.

So another point towards “Safety”, but I think we could lose every game from now on and still be safe, as the bottom three won’t be getting anywhere near 30 points. Moyes has done a great job since coming back, and with a ten day break, with a few days in Dubai to look forward too, we should come back raring to go and get wins at Wolves and at home to West Ham, before we cross the park and go to Tourist FC.

Sam Hoare
90 Posted 27/02/2025 at 09:23:50
Calvert-Lewin certainly does some things better than Beto. But one has 3 goals in 1600 minutes this season and the other has 8 goals in 900 minutes.

A goal every 112 minutes is top class. I doubt Beto will be able to sustain it but till he drops off talk of replacing him is premature.

Robert Tressell
91 Posted 27/02/2025 at 09:26:17
Beto and DCL would be fine as options from the bench behind a more talented striker.

Broja was an attempt to find that more talented striker with a tiny budget. It didn't pay off. It will be really, really hard to get hold of a striker who is currently better than DCL and Beto this summer.

It may be more fruitful to focus on the wing forward positions where, Ndiaye aside, we remain pretty terrible. Two more Ndiaye quality players would make a huge difference.

Andy Crooks
92 Posted 27/02/2025 at 09:28:10
Colin @73, I would love to see DCL in our current team with the current tactics, because I believe we would see just what a good player he is. I hope he stays because, much as I love how Beto is playing, I think DCL under Moyes would be different class.
Derek Knox
93 Posted 27/02/2025 at 09:34:56
Couldn't comment post game due to P C malfunction, but very much a game of two halves with Brentford enjoying the lion's share first half. Having said that, Pickford wasn't troubled too often until that Keystone Cop moment before half time.

The second half belonged to us, and had Beto even scored one of his 3 one on ones the result would have gone our way. I suppose a draw was fair under the circumstances. Ten days to get ready for another away visit to Wolves.

Hopefully work on a few things before then. Beto's one on ones, Alcaraz's positioning and long range shooting with Jimmy Garner joining him on the latter. Thought Harrison and Lindstrom both pretty anonymous for too long in the game.

Still unbeaten in seven, can't be bad !

Dave Abrahams
94 Posted 27/02/2025 at 09:43:38
Kieran (68) You sound like that referee on Saturday who should have stuck to his first decision!
Colin Crooks
95 Posted 27/02/2025 at 09:59:41
Try the bigger picture Sam. It reveals an awful lot more than simply quoting one players purple patch against another's barren spell. Who o the two has scored the most top flight career goals ?

Beto trying to play the DCL role under Dyche was appalling. DCL scored the best goal seen at GP or years as soon as Dyche was gone

Sam Hoare
96 Posted 27/02/2025 at 10:16:12
Colin, what does it reveal that we don't already know? I already said that DCL is better at things than Beto and its clear that he has the better career overall. These things are plain.

But right now one is scoring goals and one isn't. The stats show clearly that over the last year or two DCL has been one of the most wasteful strikers in Europe. He's not and has never been an excellent finisher but he has other useful qualities and is likely a better footballer overall than Beto.

I'm not hammering DCL, i'm sure he'll bounce back but it will likely be for another team as he does not seem to want to sign a new contract.

If you want bigger picture then DCL over his entire career has scored a goal every 275 minutes while Beto has managed one every 190 minutes. Obviously DCL has done it (mostly) at a higher level but nonetheless I think it's Beto who is the more natural goalscorer.

Ian Wilkins
97 Posted 27/02/2025 at 10:17:16
Beto and DCL bring different things, one good back to goal, one facing goal is his strength. It’s worth having both options in your squad, if we could.
As good as Beto has been recently, and he has, he had an off game last night. Couldn’t hold ball up, missed 3 one on ones, played prime role in their goal.

Dyche would have called him out. With ifs and buts, citing ‘they’ the players and ‘he’ Beto.
Moyes praised him for getting in those positions. Knowing he thrives off confidence. Moyes cites ‘us’ and ‘we’ Everton, the team.
What a difference a Manager, a man manager, makes.

John Keating
98 Posted 27/02/2025 at 10:35:11
I still feel that last night was similar to the United game, a loss.
Could have and should have won both games and be mid table.
Saying that a few weeks ago I would have been made up to get a point from each game. Just shows how expectations due to recent results have improved.

Glad the break is coming so I don't have to decide where to go this weekend. Edinburgh derby, and hopefully blasting out "Sunshine on Leith" at full time!

Brian Harrison
99 Posted 27/02/2025 at 10:35:45
So Moyes has now had the longest run without losing that stretches back to 2017, not bad for someone taking over a possible relegation team. I know some made the point before yesterdays game that Moyes has had the luxury of more home games than away games, but we have beat Brighton, Crystal Palace and drew with Brentford away all teams above us in the league. I thought we played well throughout and were unlucky mot to come away with all 3 points. While frustrated that Beto didnt take any of his 3 chances, but he kept working hard his head didnt drop so fair play to him and he looked just annoyed with himself as any of us did. Also on another day he scores at least 2 of them.

I also think its worth mentioning that this is without Ndaiye our most creative player and McNeil who probably has the best delivery at the club. Added to missing DCL, Broja and Chermetti and last night had to do without Doucoure.
I am sure the warm weather training in the UAE will give the group some much needed rest and recovery, they have had a few very intense games against Liverpool and Man Utd fairly close together and with a depleted squad that takes its toll.

Ian Jones
100 Posted 27/02/2025 at 10:35:52
Amazing and great how people on here have different views of certain players. Have left out names of the posters for no particular reason...have to say that I am guilty of this to a point. Imagine it's just life.

'The two wingers, Harrison and Lindstrom, going forward, they were fucking shit.'

'...and I couldn’t settle on a motm. I edged for O’Brien but. went for Harrison'

'Thought Harrison and Lindstrom both pretty anonymous for too long in the game.'

My particular favourite comment this thread..

'Knowledgeable Evertonians ? Yeah right. These are the people who embraced Denis Stracqualursi's "huge heart" whilst Hounding Lukaku from the day he got here.'

I was definitely guilty of saying something like that about Lukaku from time to time. All he seemed to do was score goals, wasn't a team player...bit like saying without Gary Lineker and his goals we would have won the league that year :)

Rob Halligan
101 Posted 27/02/2025 at 10:46:13
Was Beto having too much time to think, or having too many touches on those three one v ones last night? The two he scored against Leicester and the one v the RS were all scored with a defence splitting pass, all into the penalty area and finished without a touch of the ball. The one v Palace he received the pass just outside the area, he took one touch before lofting the ball over the keeper. Barely time to think in any of them.

However last night, all three were well outside the area when he broke away, he had to take several touches, and maybe his mind was whirling as to how he was going to finish? Something to work on in the warm sun of Dubai over the next few days.

Ian Jones
102 Posted 27/02/2025 at 10:55:57
Two further points from reading Sky Sports report of the game.

'Regardless, the fact that Everton were able to create so many clear opportunities for the striker is something they can be pleased with. It underpins the Toffees improved attacking output under their new boss, as they have already matched the number of goals they managed in Sean Dyche's 20 games prior.'

I appreciate it's sometimes difficult to compare 2 managers performances due to the teams played, the particular time of the season games are played, certain teams suffering from loss of form/ injuries etc, but at the moment, it's like chalk and cheese.

'Since the beginning of the 2022/23 season, Everton have won just one of their 23 Premier League matches without Abdoulaye Doucoure (D9 L13) posting a win percentage of just 4.3 per cent, compared to a win percentage of 33.8 per cent with him in the side.'

Looking solely at those stats, Doucoure would be in my Everton team. Sky suggesting we miss him when he's not playing.

However, to balance it, how many games have we won, drawn and lost when he has played...

Colin Crooks
103 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:02:46
You do love your stats Sam.

I prefer facts

DCL has played and scored more goals than Beto because he is a vastly superior player and has always been selected - At a higher level.

While Beto lost his confidence and played very poorly under Dyche for a year, missing virtually fleeting chance which came his way. DCL has endured year after year of that sort of service.

Your stats may be telling you that one of these players are scoring and the other isn't, but my facts are telling me that one of them cant score because he is out with a serious injury and the other is enjoying the most support given to an Everton striker for years.

Your stats tell you Beto is the better goalscorer, but my facts tell me DCL has scored more and his have all been in top flight football.

I don't agree that you are "not hammering DCL". You are and you are choosing carefully selected stats with which to do it.

I honestly believe that the constant bashing of our best player has played a very big part in his decision to run down his contract. Look no further than this thread ? Beto has a total total nightmare yet despite the fact that he is out injured, DCL is taking more stick. Why on earth would he want to stay ?

I love Beto and want him to continue scoring, but I have no doubt in my mind that a section of our fan base are driving out a player who is superior in just about every department. As the old saying goes; Form is temporary. class is permanent

Laurie Hartley
104 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:03:16
Colin # 75:-

“I think those using Beto's weston to hammer DCL embarrass our fan base and demonstrate a rare degree of ignorance”

“he will be free of the grade A clowns who want to spend their whole time hating upon him”

“Knowledgeable Evertonians ? Yeah right”

What’s it like up there?

Colin Crooks
105 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:06:24
It`s all good, Laurie... What about down there ?

BTW you cut out the bit where I said they ( The knowledgeable Evertonians) loved and embraced Stracqualursi and hounded Lukaku. Why was that ? Do you deny it ?

Feel very free to challenge my points

Liam Mogan
106 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:14:45
I thought Beto was unlucky not to get one last night and am confident if he plays all 11 games, he will pick up about 4/5 more goals at least.

It was notable that in the 2nd half Brentford played much deeper to nullify his threat in behind. That allowed us to gain territory and play in their half.

Under Moyes we actually try to move the ball, create space and trust the players. This led to numerous excellent crossing positions, which were wasted until the goal.

After we scored Brentford pushed up again and Beto got the final chance (which he did brilliant to latch onto). Against teams who play a high line and with players now attempting to create, he'll get chances.

It's fascinating watching Everton atm. After the tactical turpitude of recent years the change is fundamental. There's a coaching team who have a plan based on the players available, are willing to tweak and amend things and actual evidence (O'brien, Beto, Lindstrom) of proactive 1-2-1 coaching.

Coaching to try and improve things? Now there's a novel idea!

Sam Hoare
107 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:15:43
Colin@103, i'm not sure what the difference is that your drawing between facts and stats?

How am I hammering DCL? We are agreeing on the fact that that he is the better player overall. And has scored more goals.

You told me to look bigger picture so I did. I used the stats/facts that encompass their whole career which show that DCL has scored more goals but has also had more playing time (something you keep omitting). I said that the level of games should be taken into consideration of course though arguably Serie A is a harder league to score goals in?

I think you may be trying to pick a fight with the wrong person here as I am and have always been a big supporter of DCL. He's a good player and I'll be sad when he leaves. But if you think he has not been wasteful in front of goal for a sustained period then you have not been paying attention.

Him and Beto are different types of players and yes overall I believe DCL is the superior one but Beto is clearly in better form at the moment than DCL has been all season.

Liam Mogan
108 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:22:52
Colin - do you really think DCL is the best player we have?

Better than Pickford, Branthwaite, Ndiaye, Gueye, to name a few?

I think DCL has been unfairly treated at times, and the booing of him at Villa a disgrace. But our best player?

Colin Crooks
109 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:24:19
Not picking a fight with anybody, Sam.

I think it's very telling that the live forum (which I hardly ever use) was littered with disparaging remarks towards DCL. While excuse after excuse was being made for Beto's woeful performance. I thought this thread was going the same way.

It's up to others whether they think you were hammering DCL. I've said how it appears to me

BTW Sam I did not omit the fact that DCL has played more - Look at first para on post 103.

I repeat; DCL did not play last night.

Phil Roberts
110 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:29:58
First time we have gone 7 games unbeaten since Big Sam took over (Unsy and then 6 from Big Sam).

Somehow, I just feel the football is a lot better than the 7-2 aggregate for Big Sam's first six games.

Ian Jones
111 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:31:41
For those that like stats, from The Athletic.

Myko made his first Premier League assist last night in his 100th appearance and about 8000 minutes.

Brian Williams
112 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:33:38
Liam#106

I thought Beto was unlucky not to get one last night

Now I'm not trying to pick a fight either but if it had been DCL who had failed to convert one of the three one on ones last night he'd have been slaughtered on here, absolutely slaughtered.

I guarantee nobody would have posted "DCL was unlucky" etc.

Sam Hoare
113 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:34:49
Glad to hear that Colin. I’m a fan of DCL and have stuck up for him countless times. Though that does not mean I’m afraid to point out his shortcomings, as with any player.

As I said I think him and Beto offer different things. DCL is more likely to knit things together and Beto is more likely to find a chance. Crucially one looks like he will be here next season and one won’t.

It will be interesting to see who Moyes uses when/if DCL is fit again.

Ernie Baywood
114 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:35:49
The last time I saw DCL play under Moyes he scored a beauty and was probably MOTM.

There's really no need to debate it. Just enjoy that with one striker out injured we have another who can come in and score a few. Maybe we might even see a third striker introduced at some point and find out if he's any good.

I don't know whether we'll see DCL again. I think it's a shame if that's him done as he's given a lot to the club and could feel a bit aggrieved at some of the shitty assignments he was given and the treatment he received. I genuinely hope he does well in the future. Though I'm still holding out some hope that this new era can convince him that he's better off at BMD.

Laurie Hartley
115 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:44:39
Colin # 105 - I feel very comfortable where I am down here because I have come to realise that the higher you are the harder you fall. I’ve learnt that the hard way.

I am not challenging your points - I’m challenging your attitude.

I think the reason those Evertonians liked Denis Straq was because when he pulled the shirt on it was all about the team and the privilege of playing for the club. I, like quite a few others, went right off Lukaku when it became obvious that he wanted away and made no attempt to hide it from anyone. It was his attitude that got on my wick.

Finally, as far as hating is concerned - I don’t hate anyone. I don’t think I can afford to.


Colin Crooks
116 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:51:48
Oh I see, Laurie.

You were getting all shirty because when I pointed out the attitude towards Stracq and Lukaku. You didnt like it because the cap fitted you like a glove.

Wondered why you edited that bit out when quoting me.

Oh well. I dont see anywhere where you were accused of hating, but you`re as entitled to your opinion as the next man

Liam Mogan
117 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:58:22
Brian 112. Yes you have a point.

Beto was slaughtered on the live forum though. Also, DCLs chance missing history is much longer tbf. If Beto carries on missing like last night, I'm sure the comments will turn.

Atm, I'm just glad we are making chances and trying to play a form of progressive football rather than what we've had to endure.

Conor McCourt
118 Posted 27/02/2025 at 11:59:32
Brilliant point last night and delighted with the performance given the resources available to Moyes. I like how he is finding ways to hurt the opposition and play to the strengths of the players at his disposal. Still a question mark for me on his in-game management but that is for another day as he didn't have much to work with yesterday.

I do find that there is always an overreaction to some of the players on here. Andy Crooks nails it when he speaks about how Dominic would be performing in this set-up. I really think posters who use stats about his strike rate over the last 3 years must not understand what has happened to him in that time with regards to a serious injury and then how he has been used when back to peak fitness. His overall performance against Tottenham was absolutely fantastic and shows that he is still top class and the best we have got. I have argued all season that we have 3 really decent strikers at the club when all are fit with different traits and delighted that the less talented of the 3 is doing so well. We also have Chermiti to see as a 4th.

Again we see a lot of criticism for our wide players which I can't fathom. Harrison put so many teasing balls in last night where if DCL was fit I think he would have had a field day. I was delighted with Jack as he is slowly getting better and a little more confident every game. I would love to see him get a match winner as I think he was the player who suffered more than anyone under Dyche. Even Moyes mentioned this.

Lindstrom also getting a bit of stick yet he has played the last two games with a virus. Fair play to him for not shirking like a lot of players do. For me I think the United game changed when he went off and this boy has a great attitude and is developing nicely under Moyes. I liked a couple of times he and Charly interchanged and that is something I hope to see more of as this will really play to Jesoer's strengths.

Sorry Ernie just read your post where you made the same point.

Brian Williams
119 Posted 27/02/2025 at 12:08:35
Liam#117

Agreed mate.

Out of interest when do people think we'll actually be "safe"?

Personally I think mid April.

Useful tool here
Link

Christy Ring
120 Posted 27/02/2025 at 12:27:09
Sam#90/113 You can't use stats comparing DCL'S record to Beto. Dom under Carlo with two superb wingers scored goals, this season under Dyche he was totally isolated, his 2nd game under Moyes, he scored and MoM, a totally different player, Beto comes in and has been a revelation, because of a more offensive setup by Moyes, you can't compare Dom under Dyche and Beto now, I believe Moyes would have kept Dom upfront if fit, and he would have thrived in this setup.
Brian Williams
121 Posted 27/02/2025 at 12:28:18
Christy #120,

Fully agree!

Kevin Molloy
122 Posted 27/02/2025 at 12:39:33
we're safe now Brian.
Robert Tressell
123 Posted 27/02/2025 at 12:41:05
We've only had two strikers in the entire Premier League era who are Champions League standard - Rooney and Lukaku.

I guess you could make case for a few like Saha and Ferguson and Yakubu - but really they all fell short for one reason or another.

If you extend it to wing forwards its probably only Richarlison and Kanchelskis. Again you could make a case for one or two others but generally nearly but not quite types like Mirallas or talented but injured / has beens like Limpar or Rodriguez.

The numbers and quality of our attacking options needs great attention if we're to kick on as a club.

Moyes never addressed that in his first spell despite spending what would now be £40m to £65m on each of Yakubu, Beattie and Johnson. He didn't address it at West Ham either despite (I think it was him but may be corrected) big spending on Haller (€50m) and Scamacca (€38.5m).

He did however do a good job of developing Bowen.

That's how I think we need to approach it thus summer (and how I think we will approach it) - finding players of lower cost (sub £25m), workrate and some quality to develop into a player like Bowen (who is definitely top 6 standard - albeit not necessarily a starter for the richest clubs).

Alan Corken
124 Posted 27/02/2025 at 12:46:32
A number of you, starting with Andy Crooks, have made the point that DCL in the current team might have thrived. I think that is a fair point and one I look forward to seeing if it bears out. I would go as far as to say every one of our players has improved under the new management. In fact even the level of debate on here has improved since Moyes came along. So much so that I'm even in agreement with Andy! (No offence pal)
Mike Hayes
125 Posted 27/02/2025 at 12:46:34
Great to watch Alcaraz and his skills to feed Beto, who for some reason, couldn’t score three of the chances. We need to keep hold of him, Branthwaite O’Brien and build a team around them ready to make a decent challenge and start to BMD 💙
Danny O'Neill
126 Posted 27/02/2025 at 12:47:39
I thought that at the time, Rob, the defender's slip resulted in Beto stumbling, but he demonstrated honesty in regaining his feet to try and score. You don't see that from a lot of players in the game now. It disrupted him momentum, needed a touch too many, and the keeper was already out to meet him.

It would have been an interesting one had that gone to VAR, because it could have been a red card. I admit to not knowing if the outcome would have gone in their favour because it was accidental and there was no intent??

I don't see the need to bring Calvert-Lewin into this. He hasn't played for weeks and may not even play for Everton again.

All I would add, is that any Everton striker of the past couple of seasons has lead a lonely existence, feeding off scraps with little support.Beto has flourished recently because he has runners in support, either to play through the lines and put him through on goal, or to play off him.

Kevin Molloy
127 Posted 27/02/2025 at 12:51:49
Alan,

Who cares about DCL? I wouldn't give him a minute's exposure. He's taking his ball elsewhere.

Let's concentrate on the players who want to be here.

Brian Williams
128 Posted 27/02/2025 at 12:52:55
Kevin #122,

I meant mathematically, Kev. You know us Evertonians, we're not used to relaxing!

Dave Abrahams
129 Posted 27/02/2025 at 13:03:30
Robert (123),

Talking about wing forwards, there is no 'probable' about Kanchelskis — only here for one season but he stood out, I think, for everyone that season.

Ian Bennett
130 Posted 27/02/2025 at 13:17:40
Mbeuno was the £25m winger that could have taken it to a Champions League club. He'd easily command £60-70m now.

Wing forward, I'd put up Gary Speed as well. Came from Leeds on the right, and slowly moved into the middle. Arteta as well started out there, and was a high performing wide right/central type.

In terms of strikers, Robert is right. I'd throw in Peter Beardsley as being Champions League class with us. He was a brilliant player, but came to a team unable to match his ability and footballing brain. 2 seasons with us, and another 4 seasons at Newcastle where he scored nearly 60 goals.

Sam Hoare
131 Posted 27/02/2025 at 13:21:37
Christy@120, you're both right and wrong in my opinion.

Of course the setup, team, manager any player is playing with should be taken into account. And I've no doubt that DCL could do much better in this Moyes team. But that doesn't mean you can't compare them. Whoever is picking between them when DCL is fit will have to compare them in order to make the decision!

Naturally the stats only paint part of the picture but they talk of one player high on confidence and one player not. Of course that could change quite quickly.

Further diving into the stats will show what I've said earlier which is that (irrelevant of manager) Beto seems to both get and convert a higher proportion of chances whilst DCL will hold the ball and create better. That holds for when they were both playing under Dyche.

If DCL gets fit, there is a very good chance Moyes will prefer him, though possibly not while Beto keeps scoring a goal every 112 minutes!

Pete Clarke
132 Posted 27/02/2025 at 13:51:31
I'm amazed how good we have been since Moyes came back and I hated the thought of his return. We have good intent going forward and now create chances rather than just sitting back and hoping for a point.

Yeah, we should have won last night and Beto should have had a hat-trick but it's a lot better than moaning about a defender's slip that cost us a point. Moyes may have just realised that where we are headed requires a more positive way and his experience at West Ham is aligning with our future. I wrote him off but I hope he does a Kendall to prove me wrong.


Andy @88, I'm in Perth, Australia. My brother has tickets available now and then but not guaranteed. Give me a call: 0412473564.

Colin Malone
133 Posted 27/02/2025 at 13:53:57
Let's hope Charly gets a run in the side. He does his defensive work, without running around like a headless chicken. When he receives the ball, I can feel something going to happen.

Doucoure works his socks off, without success. It's great to see a proper Number 10 in the side.

Raymond Fox
134 Posted 27/02/2025 at 14:57:50
Colin you are forgetting the goals he scores and his assists.

Doucoure is and has been first choice in his position for several of our managers, he must be doing something right.

Alcaraz is a very good player I'm not disputing that, theres room for him elsewere in the team, I wouldn't drop Doucoure for him.

Raymond Fox
135 Posted 27/02/2025 at 15:06:56
Looking at the BBC webpage today, I can't find one word or picture about our game yesterday.

Loads about you know who, women's football and Scottish games, but try finding Everton!

I stand corrected after looking again there is a small piece about the game.

Robert Tressell
136 Posted 27/02/2025 at 15:10:48
Ian # 30, fair enough with Beardsley – but it says something that we have to go back to the inaugural season of the Premier League (over 30 years) to find another quality forward.

Speed and Arteta certainly played wide at times but neither were ever remotely modern style wing forwards - very definitely midfield players.

Across the major leagues, fast and skilful and versatile wing forwards are often the difference-makers for top clubs playing a 4-3-3 or 3-4-3.

If we ever want to get past 6th place, these are the sorts of players we need to find and invest in.

Mick O'Malley
137 Posted 27/02/2025 at 15:20:43
Calvert-Lewin looks like he's moving on, not before time for me, I've never really been a fan of his, but I agree with Colin Crooks that, if DCL had missed those chances last night, he would have been slaughtered on here.

The first chance Beto missed was absolutely woeful, he tried to go round the goalie but went the wrong way, running to where a defender was. I don't know why he didn't hit it as soon as he steadied himself. The second one he hit straight at Flekken.

Beto has been great lately. I'm not going to hammer him but I thought they were poor finishes,

Connor, I agree with you about Lindstrom, I like him, clever footballer, but he is no winge. I thought Alcaraz played well also, putting Beto through on goal on a couple of occasions.

We should have won that game after a much-improved second-half performance compared to the first half – it's like night and day compared to the shite Dyche served up.

Robert Tressell
138 Posted 27/02/2025 at 15:25:58
Raymond #134, Doucoure has been a regular under a few managers now – and a rare goalscorer too.

However, I think this is because we've been too poor to buy anyone of real quality – not because he's genuinely good.

His main quality is workrate and versatility, which has served us well fighting against relegation. But he doesn't offer a lot beyond that.

Ian Wilkins
139 Posted 27/02/2025 at 15:36:18
We can do better than Doucoure at Number 10, Alcaraz looks better. Harrison and Lindstrom have improved, but we have to look for better out wide. We need some pace.

Mykolenko is steady, O'Brien is doing a job at right-back for a centre-back. But we have to look for better full-back options.

There's plenty of room for improvement, through shrewd dealing and astute loans. It's going to be a fascinating Summer.

For once, I know we'll be active, and the excitement will be building for a new season at BMD.

Frank Thomas
140 Posted 27/02/2025 at 15:38:41
Dyche's fault during his tenure was that he kept selecting players that were not playing well. Moyes has started off well giving eager players a chance to shine.

However against Man Utd he changed that selection criteria and even though Alcaraz had scored and created an assist against Palace he was dropped and Doucouré played. The result, Doucouré missed a chance to make it 2 - 0 and then allowed a United player to enter the wall. That 'gap' was where their first goal was scored. This 'no matter how you play' as soon as a 'regular' is fit then they will be selected policy has to have an effect on players like Beto and Harrison.

Also Moyes stop talking internally about survival LOOK at your team.

Pickford England goalkeeper, Branthwaite, Centre half that Liverpool, Madrid and Man Utd are all raising funds to buy. A wing back, Gueye with currently the BEST tackling record in the whole of Europe. Another wing back Garner who since his return has delivered stunning passes that Even Thomas Frank acknowledge before the game were amazing. Upfront we have Alcaraz who I believe Messi said was a really good player.

Beto with a, before last nights game, conversation rate of 40% is very powerful fast and difficult to knock off the ball BUT he has one major fault he does not pass when he feels his position in the team is threatened or limited (2nd para above). He had a chance to pass to Alcaraz but tried a futile attempted himself when Alcaraz had a much better chance.

The team players above are good enough to qualify for Europe this season. We are lucky that Chermiti will be ready to play after the break. He has the ability to link up with Alcaraz or Beto in unpredictable ways that will produce many goals for us. But he needs to play even coming on as a sub or maybe Moyes could play him like Dyche did one full game against Brentford (April 24) which we won 1 - 0 but should have been 2 - 0 but Doucouré skied it over the bar from the penalty spot a reoccurring theme from Doucouré last season and this season.

If we qualify for Europe this year we stand a good chance of keeping all the players I mentioned above plus another £20+ in prize money

Raymond Fox
141 Posted 27/02/2025 at 15:47:13
Robert, I'm not saying he's worldbeater, but he gives 100% every game and strikes me that he's a great one to have in the dressing room.
Frank Thomas
142 Posted 27/02/2025 at 15:47:57
I would hope that the extra prize money was £20M not £20.
Brendan McLaughlin
143 Posted 27/02/2025 at 15:58:19
Frank #142

You did say £20+.

Thought you were just being cautiously conservative.

Phil Roberts
144 Posted 27/02/2025 at 15:58:50
Brian #119.

Here is another tool. How well did the teams they replaced do last season.

Luton last season - from the 12 fixtures that haven't happened this year = 5 points. So far Leicester 17 points from 26 games. Luton for those 26 fixtures got 21 points. You really feel Leicester are going to seriously outperform Luton and get 15 points from those games when they have done worse so far?

Burnley last season - From the 11 fixtures that haven't happened this year = 8 points. So far Ipswich 17 points from 27 games. Burnley for those 27 fixtures got 16 points. You really feel Ipswich are going to seriously outperform Burnley and get 15 points from those games when they are doing no better than Burnley so far?

Southampton - yeah. Relegated. 23 points from 11 games when they have 9 from 27.

Stop being so Everton and looking down not up.

When do I think we will be safe? When we drew with the ****** two weeks ago and got to 27 points.

Brian Williams
145 Posted 27/02/2025 at 16:09:22
Phil. I'll relax when we're mathematically safe. :-)
Chris Lawlor
146 Posted 27/02/2025 at 16:45:38
Solid performance last night, for a group of players to have come through the last month without a league defeat is a feat in itself.

Everton FC are a changed club in a very short time under David Moyes and it is there for all to see in terms of goals being scored and points accumulated as much as it is with the revitalisation of certain players who were deemed surplus to requirements.

The team depart now for warm weather training and a well deserved break from play.

We are essentially safe from relegation now and are a club looking up rather than down. Players due to come back for the run-in and a manager who has delivered a feel-good factor just in time for our goodbye to Goodison.

Given the torrid last number of years, this is finally a time for Evertonians everywhere to open the windows and breath fresh clean air for the first time in a long time. UTFT

Tony Abrahams
147 Posted 27/02/2025 at 17:02:06
I also think there is a player in Lindstrom, but I don't really see him developing on the wing. He looks frustrated to me but maybe it's because I'm frustrated that he's playing on the wing, because I believe he would offer the team a lot more if he was allowed to play inside.

His pass to Beto that continued the move for our second goa on Saturday gave me a glimpse of what I think he could offer if he moved inside. But I don't think he's offering much playing on the outside and I wouldn't be signing him if it was to play in the position he his currently occupying.

Mike Gaynes
148 Posted 27/02/2025 at 17:04:14
My summary of the debate that's been going on here while I was sleeping in this morning... Dom is the better player, Beto is the better finisher.

But Colin, I can think of a half-dozen better goals scored at Goodison in the past couple of years than Dom's last one. And he is not, and never has been, our best player. No sir.

Colin Malone
149 Posted 27/02/2025 at 17:29:16
Raymond @134.

Doucoure cannot trap a bag of cement, his retainment of the ball is useless, his passing is atrocious, he cannot tackle. His work rate is like a headless chicken, he just follows the ball. So, when we get a quick break to attack, Doucoure is not where he should be.

I feel excited when Alcaraz gets the ball. Definitely not when Doucoure receives it. It's nothing personal, just strictly business.

Brian Wilkinson
150 Posted 27/02/2025 at 17:29:31
If Ipswich do go down, I would look to nip in for Philogene again, who we missed out on in January. He looks pacey on the right wing and a fair shot and skill as well.

This 10-day rest will give the players a chance to recharge their energy levels and hopefully have a couple of the injured players back. Both Patterson and Chermiti were on the bench last night and a chance Ndiaye might be back as well, throw in Doucoure returning and our squad looks so much better.

They've done great the barebones of a team that have gone unbeaten in 7 games. This break has come at the right time for Everton.

I get some would prefer to have a cup game this weekend, wouldn't we all, but the break will do us good and hold us in good stead for a final push of the season.

Regroup in the summer, get players back, get players in through the transfer window, then start looking at one of the cups next season.

Frank Thomas
151 Posted 27/02/2025 at 18:10:19
DCL or Beto? They both seem to be missing something important.

The obsession to improve as a footballer not necessarily for monetary means but for professional reasons.

If they did, their accuracy would improve every week and so would their enjoyment of the game.

Brian Williams
152 Posted 27/02/2025 at 18:21:28
And you know that how, Frank?
Raymond Fox
153 Posted 27/02/2025 at 18:52:36
Colin @ 149, I don't agree.

It's strange he is always on the team sheet if he is available!

As I said before, I'm a fan of Alcaraz too, but have them both in the team.

Robert Tressell
154 Posted 27/02/2025 at 19:28:15
Frank @151, I disagree with that.

That DCL and Beto are Premier League players at all is largely down to their hard work and determination. Neither has a lot of natural talent. They have probably done much better in the game than was ever expected of them.

Anthony Dove
155 Posted 27/02/2025 at 19:46:22
That was a tremendous header by O’Brien. We could
have a real player there.
Phil Roberts
156 Posted 27/02/2025 at 19:46:57
Brian,

Philogene has turned us down twice now. No way. We do have our pride.

Much as I like Ipswich, for him to choose them over us and then get relegated – Sweet sunshine. You have made your bed, not lie in it.

Robert Tressell
157 Posted 27/02/2025 at 20:03:30
Phil # 156,

Philogene didn't prefer Ipswich. Villa preferred Ipswich's bid.

Ian Jones
158 Posted 27/02/2025 at 20:13:58
Colin @ 149.

One of your comments about Doucoure made me laugh:

"His work rate is like a headless chicken, he just follows the ball. So when we get a quick break to attack, Doucoure is not where ye should be."

I was watching the game at the weekend with a Man Utd supporter friend and I was saying something similar about Doucoure, just before he started a move, followed the ball during a quick attacking break and ended up where he did and put the ball in the net.

It's all in the timing...

Rob Halligan
159 Posted 27/02/2025 at 21:02:22
Colin……..No!
Colin Glassar
160 Posted 27/02/2025 at 21:13:04
He cuts a sad and lonely figure, Rob. He’s so placid, it’s unbelievable

Next 5 games for Leicester are against top 6 teams. They’re doomed

Laurie Hartley
161 Posted 27/02/2025 at 21:16:03
Colin # 105 - I was a big fan of Lukaku when he first came to Everton as a 19 year old. I certainly was not someone who did this.

“ whilst Hounding Lukaku from the day he got here.”

If you read my post again you will see that it was when he started his “come and get me” attitude that I went right off him. That may seem irrational to you but it is how I am when it comes to Everton.

I will admit to this though. When people wanted him back I did disgrace myself on here with a comment I made. Something I truly regret and for which I later apologised in a post because I was right out of order.

Paul Smith
162 Posted 27/02/2025 at 21:36:47
Beto is better than Dom you wait and see. That first touch last night for the one on one miss was pure quality.
Frank Thomas
163 Posted 27/02/2025 at 21:51:24
Brian (152) Obsession is an unbelievable driver.
My old neighbour wanted to be a millionaire after nearly 20 years he is worth a lot more than that. My close friend wanted to break into software and become a consultant in Network and Software Architecture. He succeeded by working at night after normal work and most weekends. He got a Masters in Computer Software and Networks and became a high level consultant.
Both were obsessed to spend their free time to succeed and both are experts in their fields.
That is how I know how obsession works and why I believe that neither DCL or Beto are showing signs of being obsessed by football improvement.
Tony Abrahams
164 Posted 27/02/2025 at 22:02:47
Some forwards work harder, some forwards score more goals. In a limited team it is essential that you have got a centre forward that works very hard for your team and Beto, is beginning to pass this test with flying colours.

Should he have scored last night? Obviously, but he kept running and trying, and this willingness to run helped him get another chance right at the death, and this type of effort becomes infectious.

Beto is not a natural footballer, well versed in playing with his back to goal, and this must be the reason he never did much, but look like a very cumbersome player under Dyche, but when you play it in behind and ask him to run, then he suddenly has defenders in trouble.

Early days but if a player is going to keep improving then he’s got to keep producing the effort, and when you produce the effort, then most people will get right behind you.

Not many would have been sad to see Beto leave, and yet just one month later, most of us will be very glad that he didn’t, even though he never scored last night!

Rob Halligan
165 Posted 27/02/2025 at 22:08:54
Colin # 160……..I said earlier on that we could lose every game between now and the end of the season and we’ll still stay up. Any mistake, error, loose pass or whatever by Leicester, and RVN just stands there on the line, showing no emotions at all. He knows Leicester are down, just won’t admit it. Probably another one who’s just waiting for his P45 to be dished out, so he can ride off into the sunset with a few million quid stuffed in his sky rocket.
Robert Tressell
166 Posted 27/02/2025 at 22:24:34
Frank, if that's the case then I think pretty much all of our players in the Premier League era have lacked that obsession because very few have been any good. Not sure why you'd single out DCL and Beto.
Brian Williams
167 Posted 27/02/2025 at 22:32:31
Frank. I think your example/s is/are a gross over simplification.

Be obsessed and you'll reach the pinnacle?

Doesn't always work, and not everybody has to be obsessed to reach the pinnacle.

Plus, I'm guessing that you're only guessing about DCL and Beto anyway, because I doubt you know either of them personally.

Mike Gaynes
168 Posted 27/02/2025 at 22:39:56
Frank #163, sorry but I think your comments are just ridiculous. The idea that having successful friends makes you an expert on obsession, and that you can tell from your stadium seat or your comfy TV chair that Beto and DCL lack that level of commitment, is simply farcical.

Almost nobody reaches the top .001% of their field of endeavor without being dedicated to maximum performance, and both Beto and DCL have achieved that. Tell me, are your software friends supremely conditioned to work their keyboards and overcome violent carpal tunnel injuries? And are others at their level of software design actively trying to prevent them from succeeding by kicking them around the ankles?

The comparison is ludicrous.

Brendan McLaughlin
169 Posted 27/02/2025 at 22:55:26
Frank #163

Your old neighbour should have obsessed about being a billionaire!

Frank Thomas
170 Posted 28/02/2025 at 00:46:59
Brian (167) spot on mate I don't know either and yes once again you do not need to be an obsessive but they are normally driven and will almost always achieve a greater degree of success than most people.

Mike (168) I hope you don't work in legal, maybe marketing because I did not say I was an expert I mentioned two people that achieved success primarily because of their obsession but if you want more examples please read the book 'Bounce' by Mathew Syed or read what Tiger King did growing up or the Williams sisters or what David Beckham did in his spare time. Also remember that Kings dad did not know the rules of golf likewise the Williams dad knew nothing about tennis. In bounce it also mentions 3 sisters they were the first three women grandmasters and many many other examples. However I did not know any of those people.

There is a downside to obsessive behaviour, it cost my software mate his marriage. You are right Mike nobody kicked his ankles but they did dispute his worth until my mate broke ground in new areas of software going beyond the three amigos if you know software you will know them.

Mike I was also alluding to the real prospect of both players working with other experience professionals they would get 'extra' expert drills if they request it. I did not see Beto's ankles being kicked for the three opportunities that he had against Brentford.

For improvement to quote Socrates " I know you won't believe me but the highest form of human excellence is to question one self and others".

Obsessiveness to an extreme is a very bad thing and hence the term OCD.

Brendon (169) It would not surprise me if he was on his way. He started by importing and selling cars (before the Euro) then moved into commercial transaction consultancy and then into buying and renting houses. His son told me he had 20 houses in 2010 so I feel safe in thinking he probably has 30+ now.

Laurie Hartley
171 Posted 28/02/2025 at 02:03:58
Frank # 170 - I remember reading this TW article when Beto first arrived:-

Link

It may well be that he has that personal trait that you are talking about. It brings a smile to my face because it could also mean that the best is yet to come from the lad.

Danny O'Neill
172 Posted 28/02/2025 at 07:05:36
I would call it desire, dedication and commitment with hard work thrown in. Obsession, ironically, can actually lead to a lack of focus and tunnel vision, becoming unaware of what is going on around you.

To Mike's point, these players don't get where they are without those attributes and a bit of luck along the way, like in any walk of life. Right place, right time as they say.

I always like to remind people that, whilst easy to point to wages and privileged lifestyles, we often forget the sacrifices young players and their families make on the journey, with no guarantees of success. From an early age, often losing many of the normal things in life that we take for granted. It's why I'm not a huge fan of the academy system in its current structure.

In football, forwards are an interesting beast. Stereotyping, they are generally selfish, and they should be. The first to sulk and get a strop on, always needing an arm around them.

Lineker wasn't a great football, but was quick and knew where the goal was. Everton played to those strengths.

Lukaku was strong, not a particularly good footballer, accused of being lazy, but used his strength and scored goals.

Andy Johnson and Marcus Bent worked had to make up for any shortfalls.

Beto has been a victim of how Everton were using him. Now that we are playing balls in front of him to run behind the defence, he is getting and taking more chances.

Robert Tressell
173 Posted 28/02/2025 at 07:18:04
Frank - you mention Beckham, but surely Beckham could have trained even harder because he wasn't as good as Seedorf or Ronaldinho. As George Best said Beckham had no left foot and couldn't head the ball. Surely with more dedication he could have ironed out these wrinkles?
Colin Crooks
174 Posted 28/02/2025 at 08:40:07
Mike. G

You recently came on this website making the staggering claim that DCL had never scored a great goal. Your reluctance to give him credit is well documented. but if you have seen "at least half a dozen" better goals scored at Goodison in recent years than the one where he turned three defenders inside out and slotted. I would loved to have seen them. I've missed one home game in the last five years... Perhaps they were all scored then.

For the life of me I don't understand the logic in the argument both you and Sam present about Beto being a better finisher. The simple fact remains that DCL has scored more in a higher league over their respective career`s

Sams claim that Beto has more chances and has a higher conversion rate just doesn't stack up. If he actually does get more chances then he must miss more to have scored less.. You cant have it both ways.

It was Beto who missed the chances on Wednesday (He has lots of previous too) and DCL should not even be part of this match thread - that was kinda my original point.

I find it impossible not to like Beto and I would love him to do a "Chris Wood", but I cant allow myself to be blinded by a month long Purple patch.

One player is liked and for some reason the other is despised by a considerable section of the fan base. That is obviously clouding judgement here, because the guy who is loved has spent the first ten years of his career operating several rungs down the ladder from the fella who isn't. There is a very good reason or that.

Sam Hoare
175 Posted 28/02/2025 at 09:02:57
Colin, I can’t speak for Mike but I’m talking about how many chances Beto gets and converts per game/90 minutes.

You we’re criticizing me yesterday for selective stats but one thing you keep ignoring is that DCL has played twice as many minutes over his career than Beto. So it’s hardly surprising that he has more goals!

Colin Crooks
176 Posted 28/02/2025 at 09:30:21
You are using selective stats, Sam and they are leading you up several garden paths.

The claim that Beto score's every 112 minutes is a very carefully selected stat. He is coming up to 200 league games and if his scoring rate was even half of what you claim. He would have have had the top clubs in Europe banging down his door.

You claim you are not criticising DCL, but you carefully avoid mentioning that, unlike Beto. He has been employed to do many different jobs, in various positions. You don't mention the many, many matches where the set up has been so negative. the team could barely muster an attack, let alone create a chance, nor do you mention the fact that several managers have played him knowing he was injured.

It would be very easy to praise Beto without trying to denigrate DCL with stats that don't even come close to telling the true story... Why cant people just do that ?

Dave Abrahams
177 Posted 28/02/2025 at 09:41:23
Robert (157), I thought that Philogene had a good mate at Ipswich when they played together at Hull City (?) which might have had a lot to do with him joining Ipswich.
Sam Hoare
178 Posted 28/02/2025 at 09:43:07
As are you Colin. To continuously say that DCL has scored more goals without mentioning that he's played twice as many games is to leave out the most necessary and pertinent context.

When I said that Beto was scoring a goal every 112 minutes I made it entirely clear I was talking about this season which was relevant because we were talking about current form.

It's totally fair to point out that DCL played a fair few games out wide or even at right back at the start of his career. Obviously there are thousands of factors that affect these players performances and output and unless you want a thesis we can't go into all of them. But how many games a player has played is a pretty major factor.

I'm not denigrating DCL but as with all players he has his faults. Him and Beto have different strengths. I'm surprised that should seem controversial to some people.

Danny O'Neill
179 Posted 28/02/2025 at 09:54:30
Robert @173. I never quite saw the hype in Beckham. Don't get me wrong, a very good player and his achievements speak for themselves, but I don't rate him as one of the game's greats. He was deadly from dead ball situations, but did have a few limitations in my opinion.

Probably the best comparison in recent years, along the lines of your point would be Rooney and Ronaldo.

I can't remember who made the comparison, probably a few, maybe even Sir Alex himself? But it was suggested that Rooney had better natural ability than Ronaldo, when they were younger.

Ronaldo worked harder than our Croxteth lad and ended up being the better player, over the course of a glittering career that endured and is still going at the age of 40 as far as I am aware?

Rooney arguably relied on his natural talent. He still had a glittering career, with many achievements, but a combination of not working as hard as Ronaldo coupled with his lifestyle. As we witnessed on his return, the legs were gone by his early 30s.

Caveats. I don't know or have any inside information, just from what saw and read or heard in discussion over the years.

Dave Abrahams
180 Posted 28/02/2025 at 10:04:13
Danny (179), Yes Danny I’d go along with that, Rooney could have definitely altered his lifestyle and improved his natural ability while putting a good few years on his career at the very top.

I think Ferguson lessened Wayne’s career by using him all over the field attacking and defending year after year, great for United and Ferguson not so much for Rooney.

As Bob Paisley said about Roger Hunt the amount of running on and off the ball Alf Ramsey had him doing for England shortened his career with Liverpool.

Colin Crooks
181 Posted 28/02/2025 at 10:12:53
That simply isn't true Sam.

Firstly I would never use "stats" when the official records are so readily available and secondly I did not ignore the fact that DCL has played more games I address that fact in post's 103 + 109.

The dangers of using often ill-informed stats are highlighted by your claim that DCL has played twice as many games. Check the facts - He is well over 100 games short of doing that.

Beto has not come close to scoring a goal every 112 minutes at Everton or anywhere else and you must realise that presenting figures based solely on the best scoring spell of his entire career (the past month) is bound to produce a distorted and misleading figure. DCL`s injury during this more adventurous period makes comparisons kind of redundant.

Anyway Sam. Although we are not far away on the way we see several of these issues. I don't think either one of us are going to change the others mind on the fundamental point. We will have to agree to disagree my friend.

Thank you for the debate

Sam Hoare
182 Posted 28/02/2025 at 10:47:41
Cheers Colin, I'm still not entirely sure of the distinction you're making between stats and facts but its not a big deal.

Also thank you for pointing out I got it wrong in post 178 but in 175 you'll see I meant DCL has played around twice as many minutes (16491) as Beto (8766). I got these figures off whoscored but if you have a better source then please do tell me. What are the official records you refer to out of interest?

I agree that stats can often be misused and misrepresentative which is why I try to be careful when using them. Once again I did not claim that Beto has scored a goal every 112 minutes at Everton, I said he had this season. 8 goals across 900 or so minutes (not just the past month) which i've said repeatedly is not a massive sample size but is nonetheless impressive.

I agree that we seem close in viewpoint and I'm not even sure what the fundamental point of difference you are referring to is? Perhaps that i'm a Calvert-Lewin basher? Ha! I'm really not. I think he's a great player and has done sterling, often unappreciated, work for us. I'm a big fan of his but still see flaws as with all players.

Thanks for the debate and have a good weekend.

Nigel Scowen
183 Posted 28/02/2025 at 10:47:59
Danny@179

I’m sure having film star looks, being married to a Spice girl and being part of a very good United team would have helped with the hype Danny.

Robert Tressell
184 Posted 28/02/2025 at 11:02:13
Dave # 177, yes Philogene probably knows Jacob Greaves from Hull.

But surely he is at Ipswich because Everton couldn't afford the £20m it would take to buy him - not because he only likes playing football with his friends?

That seems to be the reason Kudus, Gibbs-White, Elanga and lots of others don't play for us too...

These players haven't rejected Everton as a club. The clubs that sold them just got better (or actual) offers from other clubs.

In the same way that Beto would now be at, say, Spurs if they'd have offered Udinese money up front instead of our £0 in year one proposal.

Mark Murphy
185 Posted 28/02/2025 at 11:21:42
Dave, I get roundly abused when I voice my opinion to United fans, that Wayne Rooney’s genius was “selfishly” diminished by Ferguson.
Rooney was a genius that could’ve should’ve been regarded in the same bracket as Maradona, Best, Cruyff and Pele. And certainly above Ronaldo. (But not Messi - I think he’s from another solar system let alone planet).
But Ferguson turned him into a team player and dulled his edge. I know it worked for United but at the cost of Wayne’s natural genius.
I tell united fans he was a great at United but would have been a God at Everton.
And who knows where he might’ve taken us? I certainly think we would’ve won a couple of cups at least.
Worst bit of business since the sale of Alan Ball in my mind. I lost a little piece of my blue heart when Wayne left.
UTFT
Kevin Molloy
186 Posted 28/02/2025 at 11:33:49
I don't think I'll ever get over Rooney's departure. He treated the Everton fans with complete contempt. Not a backward glance, just a smirk, and an 'I'm big enough to deal with it'. Obv the Moyesiah I think was ready for him to leave, and kenwright was obv playing a double game, but Rooney himself was appalling. A nightmare to manage as well according to Moyes.
What a player though. That goal against Leeds away, first touch and his marker just fell over, and then bang, the winner. That was a mental few weeks.
Dave Abrahams
187 Posted 28/02/2025 at 11:33:51
Robert (84) Yes Robert the money obviously comes into it but going to a new team at a young age and having a mate there certainly helps and comes into consideration along with the fact that he would have been coming to a struggling club and Everton are no longer the big team we once were, still a big club but struggling to get back up there.
Robert Tressell
188 Posted 28/02/2025 at 11:45:13
Dave, if Everton had matched or beaten Ipswich's bid then Philogene would be playing for us. There are no two ways about it.
Mark Murphy
189 Posted 28/02/2025 at 11:48:38
Re Philogene - from what I've seen of him lately I don't think we missed much. This may come back to bite me on the arse but he looks ordinary to me.
I KNOW he scored two at United but look at them!
Both due to that shite keeper they have.
btw https://www.tiktok.com/@nayeemutd1/video/7475814759049366786
Dave Abrahams
190 Posted 28/02/2025 at 11:50:58
Mark (185), That’s the way I saw it as well Mark, he should have had a longer and greater career if he’d looked after himself better on and off the field.

He did the wiser thing in leaving Everton and doing what was best for himself, Everton would have kept him back the longer he stayed with us playing for a club that lost it’s hunger for success but content to be on the outside looking in at the real successful clubs as long as we were comfortable in the top half of the table.

His transfer fee, although nowhere near as big as it should have been, saved the club financially at the time and further on big sales kept us going while all around parts of the club were being sold to keep us going so Wayne got himself out of that mess and eventually the man who sold him bought back gave him a huge wage when his natural talent was long gone and that wage was another burden on the club.

I thank him for those two years and didn’t begrudge him his transfer one bit but certainly missed his presence at Goodison Park.

Dave Abrahams
191 Posted 28/02/2025 at 11:56:11
Robert (188), Well if you say there are no two ways about it it’s pointless me debating the subject any further!
Robert Tressell
192 Posted 28/02/2025 at 12:03:23
Very defeatist Dave. You're still very welcome to tell my why I'm wrong (I often am).

Anyway, if we're worried about 23 year old Philogene being able to settle in without a few friends, spare a thought for all the foreign players who come here. The new lad Gomez has gone from the Gambia to Nigeria to Everton to Lyon and back all before hitting 19.

Steve Brown
193 Posted 28/02/2025 at 12:06:13
Let’s have it right on Rooney’s departure.

Rooney returned for pre-season ready to play after Euro 2004, and found that the club had been touting him around for sale.

“Before Euro 2004, I knew that I was getting touted to other teams - because Everton needed the money. Certain individuals were going into other clubs saying ‘would you take Wayne Rooney for £30m?’

“I was heartbroken, I loved the club and wanted to play for Everton.

“To find that out, I was devastated. I would have left at some point, of course I would’ve, to try and better myself and go and win trophies. But I was devastated.

“I went to Barbados after Euro 2004, I’d broken my foot obviously. I came back to Bellefield and was ready to go out and start running, and step up my training from a broken foot. I remember getting told you can’t do that because if your foot breaks down we won’t be able to sell you.”

Kenwright had negotiated his transfer to Chelsea.

At which point, Rooney told the club that if they wanted to sell him then he would only move Man Utd. As Everton were losing out on a bigger fee from Chelsea, he was forced to hand him a transfer request so the club wouldn’t have to pay contractual loyalty bonuses.

Classic Kenwright. And, of course the transfer fee allowed Bill to retain control of the club as he would not have been able to source new financing to meet operating costs.

Steve Brown
194 Posted 28/02/2025 at 12:16:36
“I'm still not entirely sure of the distinction you're making between stats and facts.” Neither is he Sam.

Condemn stats, say you prefer facts, then offer opinions. I think that was it as far as I can make out.

I also like DCL as a player, but his current injury means he may have played his last game for Everton. So really I no longer care about him.

Beto is the player in form, scoring goals and contributing to our improving results.

Dave Abrahams
195 Posted 28/02/2025 at 12:19:44
Robert (192) I still think having a mate at the new club would have been a been a big help in the lad going there just as it would have been to any player coming in to the club, more special if they were coming from far away places.

By the way I didn’t know anything about Philogene ‘til I heard we were interested in him.

Dave Abrahams
196 Posted 28/02/2025 at 12:25:29
Steve (193), You’ve painted the picture as it was but doubt you’ll change the minds of those who still can’t forgive him for looking after himself, especially in those circumstances you describe!
John Keating
197 Posted 28/02/2025 at 12:44:59
Had The Worlds Greatest Evertonian not run our Club as his trainset and private treble GT palace, Rooney would have been here and winning things for years.

However when I look back and see other brilliant fantastic players lost to our Club for whatever reason my mind springs to Tony Kay and Billy Kenny.
Game changers for us

Raymond Fox
198 Posted 28/02/2025 at 12:58:59
On the subject of players, I'm suprised how mature mentally the great majority seem to be, given that most are under 30yrs and paid a great deal of money.

I've no doubt things happen that are brushed under the carpet, but all in all they seem to manage themselves very well.

Steve Brown
199 Posted 28/02/2025 at 13:40:54
Dave 195/ John 197, I don’t know how people still believe the stories the chairman planted in the press about Wayne. Especially given the way Kenwright behaved subsequently.

We lost Rooney after 2 years in the team and kept Kenwright for another 19 years.

Surely the most damaging transfer sage in the history of football?

Colin Crooks
200 Posted 28/02/2025 at 14:00:29
Distinction between Stats and facts.

Stats can be selective.

They can be manipulated.

They can be misleading.

They can be ill-informed.

They can be in the eye of the beholder.

They are often compiled by idiots

They can and are often used to distort the true picture.

They are often in stark contrast to the evidence of your own eyes (Doucourie`s passing stats)

I'm with Winston Churchil - "I would never trust stats I hadnt doctored myself"

IMO Facts are a far sounder base upon which to base an opinion....or an argument

Sam Hoare
201 Posted 28/02/2025 at 15:16:36
Thanks Colin. Though I'd say lots of those initial qualities could be applied to facts too. Certainly in recent times we've seen plenty of people parading high debateable 'facts' in both football and politics.

A quick google came up with this distinction: "Statistics is a science that involves analyzing facts. Facts are realities without arguments and false representations. When you collect several facts and then draw conclusions from them, you are creating statistics."

This supports what you're getting at I suppose though am not sure there is any clear arbiter of what is fact and what is stat!

Danny O'Neill
202 Posted 28/02/2025 at 15:19:22
Clubs decide whether to sell or buy players. Agents obviously play their self-benefitting role in proceedings.

I would wager that very few players get to dictate a move unless they have been influenced or, as in Rooney's case, they become aware that the club is touting them out. Then it becomes a case of them deciding on a place of their choosing.

That's why I don't like or pay too much attention to stats Colin. They can be manipulated and fixed to form an argument, support an opinion or shape a narrative. The goal posts can be shifted to do that.

It's not just football, but other walks of life, but I won't go there as we could get into a political debate!!

Colin Crooks
203 Posted 28/02/2025 at 16:12:22
Thank you Sam

Yes I see and fully take on board your point.

Fair play

Derek Thomas
204 Posted 28/02/2025 at 23:13:00
I've collected 4 quotes which is almost a statistics in its self, pick those that suit your argument best...

Most people use statistics like a drunk man uses a lamp post; more for support than illumination.

Facts are stubborn, but statistics are more pliable.

Statistics are like bikinis. What they reveal is suggestive, but what they conceal is vital.

There are Lies, Damned Lies - and Statistics.

I dislike these football free weekends, international breaks etc.

Mike Gaynes
205 Posted 28/02/2025 at 23:36:32
Derek, your post captures 67% of history's best quotes about statistics.

Two more:

"If you need statistics to prove it, it isn't true."

"If all the statisticians in the world were laid head to toe, they wouldn't be able to reach a conclusion."

But dammit, I still love those little numbers. Stats are fun!

Paul Conway
206 Posted 01/03/2025 at 09:13:04
DCL has been at this Club since 2016.
If he stays another year, that’s a decade!!
He’s entitled to score a Worldie, in fact so is every other member of the team, in a similar Timescale.
I know he’s had injuries, but, I hope we are never going to pay anyone else 100 k per week,for such a Paltry return.
Dave Abrahams
207 Posted 01/03/2025 at 09:27:36
Paul (206)Dominic is also entitled to a benefit game if he stays for another year! Do you think he will stay on for that?
How many will go to that game if arranged ?
How many of them will be deranged if they do go?
Paul Conway
208 Posted 01/03/2025 at 15:32:23
Dave 207
I hadn’t thought about that and that is even more resounding.
Back in the day, when I was growing up, it was called a Testimonial and to my mind was reserved for Club Legends.
My Boyhood Hero, When I was growing up, was Joe Royle, now there was a legend !
As, far as I know ( correct me if I’m wrong), he didn’t stay for Ten years.
He went off to play for Man City and Norwich.
Did he get a Testimonial, when he came Back?
Anyway, the Point I’m trying to make, Is, I don’t consider DCL a Legend!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


How to get rid of these ads and support TW

© ToffeeWeb