09/04/2026 34comments  |  Jump to last

It has somewhat gone under the radar. There aren’t many — if any — questions being asked of David Moyes about it, and there has been no talk from the player’s side. Nothing while away on international duty, for example.

But, as it stands, Vitaliy Mykolenko has less than three months to run on his Everton contract. Mykolenko penned a 4½-year deal in January 2022. Those 4½ years are very nearly up.

Now, there have been reports, albeit unconfirmed ones, that the Ukrainian’s deal includes a club option to extend by 1 year. Yet so far, there has been no suggestion or announcement that such a clause, if indeed it does exist, has been activated.

When you contrast the situation to say, that of James Garner, who David Moyes confirmed was previously on a contract which included an extension option, but was offered a bumper new deal midway through the season, then the difference is stark.

Now, Garner is a much-improved player who has been one of the Premier League’s top performing midfielders this term. He is crucial for Everton and, at 25, has plenty of years in the tank.

Mykolenko, on the other hand, cannot — and should not — be sure of his place in Everton’s team heading into next season, if of course he is still at the club.

At 26, Mykolenko is probably entering his prime, and while he has improved steadily since he was signed in 2022, he is still lacking in key attributes for a modern-day, top-level full-back.

Nobody can really doubt Mykolenko’s defensive ability. He has proved now to be a capable defender, and regularly turns in solid displays against some of the Premier League’s best wingers.

But Everton need to be moving forward, and for that, they need at least a couple of new full-backs, each capable of pushing on in attack and providing another facet to the Toffees’ play.

“A full-back’s first job is to defend” no longer washes — and really, it hasn’t in years. At least a decade. The irony is, Moyes had the best pair of attacking full-backs around in the latter seasons of his first stint at Everton, in the form of Seamus Coleman and Leighton Baines, yet in his second spell, he arguably has some of the poorest.

Adam Aznou has not had a look-in this season, while Nathan Patterson performed well when he was needed but then has not played a minute since the end of January. Jake O’Brien is no full-back, even if he has performed admirably there in the circumstances, and Everton’s best right-back is probably Garner, who also happens to be one of their best midfielders.

A lack of attacking punch from either full-back position has hurt Everton, particularly at home, and if they are to go ahead and re-sign Jack Grealish, then supplying him with a player capable of offering a threat from behind him will be crucial.

There is no doubt Everton need a new left-back, but that does not solve the Mykolenko issue.

They could let him go for free this summer, but that would not seem a sensible business decision. They could, in theory, offer him a new, longer-term deal to protect the asset and ensure there is an experienced option on hand for next season, allowing the new man time to bed in and also allowing Aznou to be loaned out and get some much-needed game time.

If there is a clause to activate, then Everton should do so, but that would then still mean Mykolenko heads straight into the last 12 months of his deal, so it would only be kicking the can down a very short road in that regard.

It will be intriguing to see which option Everton go with, and if reporters do start to press Moyes on the situation over the remainder of the season.

Or perhaps Everton have already made their mind up, one way or the other, and it’s just a case of an official announcement. At the end of the day, Mykolenko is not the level of the left-back the team needs, but as it stands, he is the only realistic option they have.

 
//

Reader Comments (34)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()


Paul Hewitt
1 Posted 09/04/2026 at 11:03:43
I'm sure we have an option of another 12 months.

Probably why the club haven't said anything.

John Collins
2 Posted 09/04/2026 at 11:10:47
Hopefully it's being ripped up and thrown in the bin.
Neil Lawson
3 Posted 09/04/2026 at 12:21:42
All the current talk is of the possibility of Europe for which a decent squad is required.

Mykolenko may have his limitations but he is a solid, dependable and committed defender and should be an invaluable and relatively inexpensive member of that squad.

In 2 years, neither he nor Seamus have been replaced by one better option; so, if he goes, where are we going to find and afford two?

Neil Lawson
4 Posted 09/04/2026 at 12:23:15
P.S.. The world's greatest ever footballer, Moaning Salah, was never able to get the better of him.
Nick West
5 Posted 09/04/2026 at 12:45:24
No one would be sorry to see him leave, he's just not developed at all despite being a regular and having Baines (and at one point Ashley Cole) to coach him.

That said, we need a right-back, a right winger and two strikers worthy of the name so left-back is a little bit back in the list of priority positions. Getting one in who regularly produces 7 and 8 out of 10 rather than Myko's 5 and 6 would see a huge improvement in results.

Eric Myles
6 Posted 09/04/2026 at 14:17:27
If he didn't have an extension clause in his contract, surely our ace recruitment team woukld have done something about it 12 months ago? Either sold him which seemed unlikely, or have extended.

So it seems likely that he has an extension clause but we are now in the same position. Extend so he doesn't leave for free, or sell.

Martin Reppion
7 Posted 09/04/2026 at 15:09:26
I've never understood the criticism Mykolenko gets on this site. He is a solid defender. Seldom gets beaten and makes countless blocks and chance-saving tackles. He also gets forward when the system allows him to, but this is not his strength.

Whilst I understand that modern full-backs tend to be wingers who can track back and tackle, he has been part of a defence that has consistently been amongst the most frugal in the Premier League. And this despite our struggles of recent years.

If, and it is a big if, there is an available Cucurella, Baines or whoever, that wants to play for Everton, and we can afford him, obviously we would have to upgrade. But as Neil wrote (@3), we may need a larger squad next season, and he does a good job, within his limitations.

The priorities, if we have a limited budget, are clearly elsewhere. Right Back, Striker, pace in the middle and on the wing. So I hope he continues to be the dependable defender we know for a while yet.

James Marshall
8 Posted 09/04/2026 at 15:09:56
Does anyone know how to find fan articles, and specifically ones about tickets for games on here nowadays? TW is close to unusable for me now.

You can't find anything, the 'recent posts' thing has completely gone and navigating the site is just awful.

I live about 10 minutes from Brentford so hoping to snag a ticket for the game on Saturday. Anyone any leads or ideas?

John Collins
9 Posted 09/04/2026 at 16:01:38
Try for one in home sections, James.

Your postcode will be enough.

Steve Brown
10 Posted 09/04/2026 at 16:08:18
He is very consistent in all aspects of his game -- he is crap at everything.
Mike Gaynes
11 Posted 09/04/2026 at 16:16:50
Yahoo Sports reported in January that Mykolenko had a 1-year club option on his contract to extend through June 2027, and that Everton was about to activate the option to keep Galatasaray away from the player. But with no club announcement or news coverage concerning that activation, there's space for speculation like this.

Personally, I think it's unfounded. Martin and Neil are right: he's a fine, committed defender who has great value in our backline. Certainly we need an attacking fullback, and hopefully Aznou turns out to be the guy, but I don't believe Mykolenko is going anywhere. The owners aren't going to let him get this close to walking away for nothing.

John Collins
12 Posted 09/04/2026 at 16:19:23
Steve 😁

To be fair to him he's done okay when given a marking job. Not as well as people think against Salah.

He offers nothing in an attacking sense. That's no good in today's game.

Mike Gaynes
13 Posted 09/04/2026 at 16:20:16
Steve #10, haha, I knew you'd weigh in quickly on this one. You're like Colin Glassar used to be on Iwobi. Never a good word to say. 100% negative.

And wrong, of course, but always entertaining.

Ian Horan
14 Posted 09/04/2026 at 17:03:49
The disrespect of Mykolenco is crazy, he is an out-and-out defender, he is quality. Saka, Salah and even Chelsea's wingers are yet to get the better of him.

Measuring him against Baines or Digne etc is wrong -- they are more wing-backs, not defenders. People forget how often Baines and Digne got beat in the air or turned their backs on crosses.

Lee Courtliff
15 Posted 09/04/2026 at 17:37:49
I've always liked Mykolenko ever since his debut against Norwich. Even though he didn't play particularly well, I just had a feeling he'd be one of those players we could depend on.

And he has been dependable, despite his well-known limitations, with his solid performances despite some real distractions in his personal life. He's just a real 'tryer', a very likeable player.

If next season we're in a position to call him a squad player, then we're definitely moving in the right direction.

James Marshall
16 Posted 09/04/2026 at 17:55:52
Cheers John.

I'd rather be in the away end so I'll probably just go to the ground and see if there's any blues selling a spare

John Collins
17 Posted 09/04/2026 at 18:06:28
Good luck, James.

Heads up though, mate --they go for big money. A lad I know paid £200 v Leeds away. Fanatical support sees loads travel without a ticket.

Christy Ring
19 Posted 09/04/2026 at 18:22:03
I'd definitely give him a new contract, for two simple reasons: he's the only left back we have, Aznou hasn't got a look in, and Jarrad is a centre-back.

We should definitely buy a left back in the summer, but keep Mykolenko, at worst for back-up, considering we've played Garner at right- and left-back this season.

Paul Hewitt
20 Posted 09/04/2026 at 19:25:06
I agree with Ian @14.

Mykolenko is a defender first, I don't understand the criticism that he's not good at getting forward. That's irrelevant, he's good at the job he's paid to do.

Derek Thomas
21 Posted 09/04/2026 at 23:11:03
For contract renewals, The 3 Amigos, Moyes, a variable on the day permutation -- any 2 from 4? Whoever the actual fuck really does our buying and selling is obviously waiting to see where we finish and in what competition(s) we're in next season.

Wherever we finish and in what circumstances, I can see Molyenko, Keane & McNeil being offered extensions. How long for and will they take them? Who knows?

Also, somebody had to sign off on Barry, George, Anzou, Dibling and Rohl (and Cuthbert, Dibble and Grubb for all I know). I hope they get themselves sorted a bit better come June or July

And while I'm at it, spunking big money for 4 years on an aging superstar to push our real best player, Ndiaye, out of position seems to be short-termism of the worst kind with the added insult of a mega long term price tag.

Or will Ndiaye (and/or Branthwaite) be sold and Grealish is the replacement? I'm not sure I like that any better... even worse short-termism.

As always with our Regents Road Ramblers (nee County Road Casuals)... more questions than answers.

Dale Self
22 Posted 09/04/2026 at 23:54:56
I would not think of letting him go without a proven replacement. A European qualification and he stays, end of.

As we develop some creative forward play, he may be able to position more often for some recycled possession and perhaps make it to the by-line to set up Dewsbury-Hall as he has before. It isn't beyond him, it is lack of cover when he goes given his lack of pace.

On overall acquisitions and lack of playing time and development, some patience is a fair ask. The loss of Grealish left us with questions we could not address with any kind of designed plan. We had to take what we could with finances tight and our transfer reputation in question.

I think the transfer team deserves some time. It isn't 'Plan A' but the core of our squad is getting it done so no need to assail them, some of these may work out or we may move them on nicely without losing anything but time.

Eric Myles
23 Posted 10/04/2026 at 03:49:28
Martin #7, sounds like you're describing a left-sided Hibbert, who I always liked, a great defender who not much got past.

So what we need is a left winger to go forward, especially if we keep Grealish.

Alan J Thompson
24 Posted 10/04/2026 at 06:22:41
I think some of you give Mykolenko an undeserved hard time.

He's a good defender and, if he has Grealish in front of him and gets down the byline, then he is in danger of getting in the way of Dewsbury-Hall's or Garner's move either outside or alternatively inside of Grealish. So Mykolenko takes up a position on the line slightly behind Grealish with Gana also further inside.

Mykolenko does however have the habit before crossing of looking up to see where our usual one striker in the box is as we rarely have more -- and never as centre forwards used to coming in off a back post position. Just crossing and hoping might work if we had 5 or 6 players in the box but we rarely do -- and if it was that simple, surely Grealish would cross it.

For me, a definite keep with Aznou getting minutes to see where he is up to and, all being well, that could be left-back sewn up for years to come.

Jimmy Salt
25 Posted 10/04/2026 at 08:31:10
Squad player. We need better to progress.

James Garner is like a modern-day Alan Harper, a very good footballer who can play almost anywhere. The difference is Harper played in a brilliant team, so he didn't stand out.

Dave Abrahams
26 Posted 10/04/2026 at 09:13:34
Jimmy (25),

I think Alan Harper was noticed and appreciated when he played. Most of us knew he could be relied on when he did come into the side as a replacement in whatever position he was taking.

James Garner has played every game this season but I think you would miss him if he wasn't playing, like most of us would.

John Collins
27 Posted 10/04/2026 at 09:15:43
3 goal assists in over 130 Premier League games…
Brian Harrison
28 Posted 10/04/2026 at 09:31:30
Jimmy @25,

Both Harper and Richardson played an integral part in us winning the league.

But it’s difficult these days to expect players of that quality to sit on the bench for the majority of the season.

Eric Haworth
29 Posted 10/04/2026 at 11:04:54
If making comparisons, although not an entirely like for like, in my opinion, Jimmy Garner is more akin to Kevin than Alan Harper.

Kevin was a lovely lad from the North East, who emerged with a good few others from our youth ranks and who also went on to successful careers. That was thanks in no small measure to the tutelage of a good friend of mine, Richie Wade, who sadly passed away recently.

There were many a blue legend in attendance at his funeral at St Michael's, such as Joe Royle and Jimmy Husband, among others. Richie saw the potential in Kevin from a young age and was key in him realising that potential.

He went on to enjoy an extremely successful career, winning both cup & league medals, both with us and Arsenal, and there aren't many pros who can match that.

If Jimmy Garner goes on to do half as much, he'll have done well.

Alan McGuffog
30 Posted 10/04/2026 at 12:09:48
Dave, hope I'm not mixing my games up but Kevin Brocks back pass is often mentioned as the beginning of our revival in 1984?

I'd say it was Harper's equaliser against that lot just after.

Dave Abrahams
31 Posted 10/04/2026 at 15:31:41
Alan (30) Alan I think that Oxford game is often mentioned as the start of the Everton revival, I thought it was the game in the earlier round v Coventry when we won in extra time—- but I’m on to what you are talking about and yes that goal from Harper in the 1-1. draw at Goodison v Liverpool was the real starter, we, for the first in a long time, let them know we were as good as them, never gave them an inch and for the next four years gave as good as we got, if not more in every game.

Grahame Sharp missed a penalty in that 1-1 game which would have been the winner.

Tony Abrahams
32 Posted 10/04/2026 at 16:04:53
I still think the game that made people aware of how good Everton, had suddenly become was the nil-nil at Wembley, when Hanson’s arm, stopped us going in front.
Ian Horan
33 Posted 10/04/2026 at 17:16:04
For the Mykolenko detractors, should we go all in for Robertson!!!

On a free, and local... just a thought?

Ian Bennett
34 Posted 10/04/2026 at 17:33:50
I think we missed out on Robinson at Dundee United and Hull.

Old adage of the players are out there, you just need to find them. Maguire another.

Alan McGuffog
35 Posted 10/04/2026 at 17:51:03
Dave, I don't remember that at all, the penalty miss.

But Harper's goal was a peach and, as you say, rightly that was when, for a few years at least, we lost our inferiority complex


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


How to get rid of these ads and support TW

© ToffeeWeb