Column Self-Inflicted Wounds and Near Misses haunt Everton in the FA Cup Anjishnu Roy 8 February 2025 42comments (last) Individual errors cost Everton as they went down 2-0 to Bournemouth in their final cup match at Goodison Park. James Tarkowski was at fault for both Antoine Semenyo and Dan Jebbison’s first-half goals. The Toffees were a much-improved side in the second 45 and even hit the woodwork thrice. In the end, it proved to be too little too late for David Moyes’s side as Everton’s FA Cup journey came to an end in the fourth round for the second consecutive season. The match began on a promising note for the Toffees as fan-favourite Iliman Ndiaye created the first chance of the game with some wonderful footwork to get past his full-back on the left flank but the angle proved too acute to test Bournemouth keeper Kepa Arrizabalaga. Idrissa Gana Gueye, Abdoulaye Doucoure and James Garner went toe-to-toe with Bournemouth in the battle for midfield in the first 20 minutes. The hosts made a lot of third-man combinations and secured neat exchanges in the opposition half. Everton failed to capitalise on that positive momentum and instead, ended up conceding a goal against the run of play. There was a hint of offside on Milos Kerkez’s line-breaking pass to Antoine Semenyo but James Tarkowski didn’t cover himself in glory as he brought down the Ghanaian international inside the box. With no VAR available to determine an offside, Everton conceded in the 23rd minute despite Jordan Pickford guessing the right direction for Semenyo’s powerful strike from 12 yards. The Toffees struggled to find their footing after going down as James Tavernier, Ryan Christie and Tyler Adams dominated the midfield for the Cherries. Miscommunication and lackadaisical body language also plagued the hosts who made several unforced errors on the ball. Tarkowski made another howler just before half-time as his sloppy ball out from the back led to Dan Jebbison scoring only his second goal for Bournemouth. David Moyes’s half-time team talk must’ve been convincing given how the boys bounced back in the second half. Ndiaye had a glorious opportunity to draw one back but he failed to make contact with the ball after Doucoure’s cutback surprisingly made its way into the box. Moyes made two changes in the 65th minute and the addition of Carlos Alcaraz and Jack Harrison provided plenty of impetus. New loan signing Alcaraz showed flashes of brilliance as he won a free-kick with a strong run close to the box and then hit the post from the ensuing dead-ball situation. There were more ‘oohs’ and ‘aahs’ from the home fans as Semenyo had to head a ball off the goal-line from a corner while Jake O’Brien hit the left post following a delicious delivery into the box from Harrison. With Kerkez continually pushing forward on the right flank, Harrison found himself with space to run into. He launched another great ball into the box at the 80th minute which missed everyone and went on to hit the woodwork again! Third-time lucky? Not quite. Pickford was called into action again late in the second half with Semenyo testing him after a rapid counter-attack while Justin Kluivert had the opportunity to score the third in the dying minutes of added time but ended up floating his shot over the crossbar. The referee's whistle after five minutes of added time brought another fourth-round exit in the FA Cup. While it was a bitter pill to swallow following the highs in the league in recent weeks, there were plenty of positives for Everton from this encounter. With Tarkowski having a bad day at the office, Jarrad Branthwaite led an excellent defensive shift as he made up for a lot of his partner’s errors and stood tall on several instances in the first half. Iliman Ndiaye had his moments of magic sprinkled across the halves and debutant Carlos Alcaraz showed so much promise with his deft touches and dead-ball prowess. Jack Harrison’s introduction also helped Jake O’Brien dominate the right flank in the second half. However, by far the biggest takeaway from this evening was how the Toffees clawed their way back in the second half. They went into the second half with a winning mindset and fans can take comfort in the fact that with a hint of luck, Everton could’ve not only drawn level here but could’ve even marched into the next round! Chin up, boys, there’s a derby that needs winning next week! Reader Comments (42) Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer () Phil Smith 1 Posted 08/02/2025 at 18:02:28 That was the most frustrating second half of football Ive seen for a long time. How we didnt score, I dont know…Once again Bournemouth beat us, undeservedly, without really doing enough to justify so. Older players crying out to be rested. Some minds on Wednesday, methinks. That one on the boss, in my opinion. Jeff Armstrong 2 Posted 08/02/2025 at 18:03:56 Good first report that, also quite accurate and as I saw it too, thought Moyes should have started the second half with Alcaraz, Tim did well and Harrison to be fair was far more productive than Lindstrom, good second half performance and food for thought for the last Derby next week, I think Moyes will select Harrison over Lindstrom and keep Charly on the bench. Mal van Schaick 3 Posted 08/02/2025 at 18:07:23 Sorry to say Tarks has served his purpose, for all the decent games hes had in the past, its time to move him on in the summer. Try Brantwaite with OBrien and if that doesnt work use the summer transfer market to recruit at centre back. The same goes for Young and may be Gana and Keane.If Everton want to be in a better place and make improvements for next season at BM, then its time to start looking at the rebuild now, PSR aside. Napoleoin 4 Posted 08/02/2025 at 18:07:35 What's going on with this site. Has it been bought? Christy Ring 5 Posted 08/02/2025 at 18:17:02 Should play Alcaraz instead of Doucoure on Wednesday, we only started playing, when he came on, and he looked very promising. Frank Sheppard 6 Posted 08/02/2025 at 18:17:43 Last cup game at Goodison- unfortunately a good commentary as to where we are as a football club-beaten again- by a tiny football club, with a small percentage of our previous spending power, that is just far better run than we have been for 10 years…….. John Keating 7 Posted 08/02/2025 at 18:19:20 Hoped wed win obviously but to be honest not the end of the world for me.Just grateful we appear to have no injuries and can concentrate on league fixturesTarks had a nightmare and hopefully thats a one offIt was never going to be our day as shown by the chances we didnt take in the second. The post needs a new paint job!Could have been worse. Fancy us losing by a goal that United scored last night! Tony Abrahams 8 Posted 08/02/2025 at 18:19:33 Has David Moyes lost more cup ties at Goodison than any other Everton manager? Andy Crooks 9 Posted 08/02/2025 at 18:41:52 Good report, Anjishnu, on a very disappointing performance. For what turned out to be the last ever cup game at Goodison Park it was devoid of passion and utterly uninspired.I hope the players are watching Birmingham and seeing what really giving a shit means. Neil Cremin 10 Posted 08/02/2025 at 18:57:43 Give it a break Tony Derek Knox 11 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:02:28 Spot on Andy, too many players having an off-day again, how many times does that happen - too many ? Doucoure and Beto proved that last week against Leicester was a flash in the proverbial pan. Add Young Tarks and Gana to them, and it is obvious why we lost.The only bright spell was when Alcaraz came on, I believe we have a player there, a pity the others are so lacklustre. Lady Luck wasn't with us either, the amount of times the post was struck, in the second half !Winning breeds confidence, - which will be at an all time low for Wednesday, doesn't even bear thinking about. Moyes can't be blamed for today's result, with so many letting the side and fans down.Paul F, agree Harrison did make things a bit better but again played on the right ? He isn't the answer going forward either. Paul Ferry 12 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:02:54 Why Neil? Tony asked a reasonable and relevant question. Then again you probably would not like the answer. Paul Ferry 13 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:03:41 Derek, all three subs made a big difference, Harrison more than Charly mate. Jeff Armstrong 14 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:04:16 Tbh John 7 it isnt a one off is it? Tarkowski has been both terrible and decent this season, 50/50 for me, whereas previous two seasons games like today were indeed one offs, I think once were safe, OBrien and Branthwaite should be blooded together, dont care who plays RWB but again if were safe give Dixon a run of games, pace is so important in that position and Roman has plenty of it. Neil Cremin 15 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:06:42 PaulI don't think it is relevant or necessary. But obviously you do. Jeff Armstrong 16 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:07:21 Yes Tony #8, he even lost one for Everton v Wigan when he was Man Utds manager! Paul Ferry 17 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:10:35 Yes Neil, I do. In the same way that it would be reasonable and relevant to ask how many has he won at home if we had won. Any manager's record is relevant at any time. It is what he is ultimately judged on. Paul Smith 18 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:14:36 Went to Goodison today for the last cup game and Tarks gave by far the worst display of any Everton player I can remember. Yes he was terrible and Captain. Colin Malone 19 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:17:32 Yet another game were they don't announce who is on the bench. Any reason why? Neil Cremin 20 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:17:41 Including Dyche and every manager we have had since Moyes or do you want to go back to Howard Kendall Looks like to me that todays result is only feeding what I said previously a justification for your bias. Sad. Raymond Fox 21 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:24:05 Moyes picked a first team, you cant ask more than that.In his shoes I don't think I would have done.As far as players making mistakes, who the hell doesn't. Dave Abrahams 22 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:25:00 Andy (9), I ‘llmiss Lyndon and Michael but I agree that wasnt a bad start by Anjushnu and was a fair summary of the game.I think Moyes will learn that silly and stupid mistakes will cost Everton games just as they cost Dyche some matches.The second half was a big improvement on the first and we could have scored two or three although Bournemouth also missed chances to increase their lead with two or three clear cut chances again created by poor defending and silly mistakes. Garner and Branthwaite had good first halves but the rest gave mostly poor performances with the nonsense of trying to play the ball out of defence, for a start the goalkeeper has got to have a football brain——ours hasnt got a football brain and it was noticeable that Pickford played mostly long balls in the second half. The new lad looks like he will add improvement to the team but I think the wins we need will come from the poorer teams in the division although the Derby game on Wednesday needs the team to start much better and show some belief in themselves that they can win this game as they did last year. Ian Bennett 23 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:25:14 Two terrible goals gifted away, gave Bournemouth a victory without breaking sweat.Second half it was better, with Iroegbunam and Alcaraz looking more promising. Add that into Ndiaye and Garner, and you sone footballing ability.Doucoure, Tarkowski, Young, and Lindstrom were poor today. We go again. Paul Hewitt 24 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:29:41 Well Moyes has probably played more games as manager at Goodison than anyone else. So he probably has lost more games. James Hughes 25 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:35:39 Neil @ various..Tony A. asked a question and it is relevant. If you disagree, then fair enough. But I wouldn't tell you to give it a rest nor should you Jim Bennings 26 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:36:29 Tarky had an absolute shit show, I doubt he's had a worse game in his entire career than that first half.We improved after the break but the reality is we couldn't live with Bournemouth's press and energy which worries me for Wednesday night because Red Bullpool have that as their trademark.If we play like that first half on Wednesday night it could be a cricket score.The nagging thing still troubles me and that's the striker situation.What the hell has Thelwell been doing since the summer window closed that he couldn't identify a reasonable option for January, knowing full well that we have the ongoing DCL situation and Chermiti and Broja that were two long term absentee players evening in the autumn.We are left with Beto who for most of that last 30 minutes was blowing out of his arse knackered. Jon Atkinson 27 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:38:17 well we didnt know it was going to be the last. We had no tempo in first half, gifted Bomo the tie. Garner was doing bits but his dead ball delivery today was woeful.Alcaraz always looking forward, that free kick bulges the net and youd fancy us, the crowd woulda got engaged then. No one gives us a prayer on Weds but itll be a different Goodison, cup games have a total dynamic these days as its a different crowd to the league game crowd. Redshite will want an early goal to knock the stuffing out the place, its imperative we stay level for as long as possible UTFT,s Mark Murphy 28 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:41:40 Came up from the sarf coast full of optimism.What a disappointment Not only the worst seat Ive ever had at goodison but also the most toothless display from the best eleven avaialable.Gutted!If I dont go to Goodison again good bye.But good riddance. Some views are just fcuking nonsense.UTFT Dickie Langley 29 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:42:08 Possibly my final trip to Goodison today, and the last 5 goals I've seen there have been scored by bloody Bournemouth!But there are signs of a team slowly coming together. Charly instead of Doucoure, and Mykolenko instead of Young, and we would do alright. There must have been a plan first half for Pickford to keep giving it to Tarkowski, but it clearly wasn't working and we paid the price.As for Lindstrom/Harrison, well one of them runs towards goal and is going to improve, the other one hits it into the middle and hopes for the best. The choice probably depends on the set-up of the team, but I like the look of Lindstrom (one of our rare players who looks comfortable with the ball). Jack Convery 30 Posted 08/02/2025 at 19:56:16 Miley should have been sent off for Barcodes tonight. Horrible tackle on the Birmingham lad, who was stretchered off. Not a mention so far from Shearer and Co. I wonder why ?As for EFC, this was another Home Cup tie, with the Moyesiah in charge and just like the Wigan game, the Captain was the worst player on the pitch. Brian Wilkinson 31 Posted 08/02/2025 at 20:06:29 Very very poor first half, Bournemouth pressed us really well and kept us on the backfoot the first half, fully deserved the lead Bournemouth, but shocking mistakes for both goals.Come half time I thought Moyes would have made a double switch, Harrison replacing Young and either Iroegbunam or Alcaraz for Doucoure and pushing Ndiaye down the middle to support Beto.When the subs finally came on I thought we pressed better and created chances and on another Day we get lucky with the three that hit the woodwork.I just thought we looked disjointed in the first half, struggled to Mount any attacks, again good pressing by Bournemouth.Hopefully Moyes will have learned from that first half and player selections.Come Weds, I think I would put Doucoure on the bench, and go with Guaye, Garner and Alcaraz in midfield.If Mykolenko has recovered from his knock then revert to him and Lindstrom as the wingbacks, Young just does not offer as much going down the wing, normally saves his best for the Derby Mykolenko.Given the players available, was probably the strongest 11 we could go with, until both Iroegbunam and Alcaraz can get up to speed after just coming into the team.Looking at them both today, both look like they are ready to start games.I think with a favourable draw, Bournemouth could be the dark horses for a very good cup run.What could go wrong went wrong today, need to step it up for Weds, cannot afford a first half like that again.But looks like Alcaraz could be a decent addition.We go again Weds. Paul Ferry 32 Posted 08/02/2025 at 20:08:08 Wow! Verbruggen! That will be on the top keeper howlers for a long time to come. He threw it into the net. Tony Abrahams 33 Posted 08/02/2025 at 20:08:30 Neil@/0, I support Everton, and have done all my life mate. And guess what, I have always wanted Everton to win, except that game against city a few years ago Oliver Molloy 34 Posted 08/02/2025 at 20:16:51 In the absence of any explanation from ToffeeWebCould someone in the know tell is what is going on with the site.Is this Evertonia a new venture - sorry but I can't work it out Jay Evans 35 Posted 08/02/2025 at 20:18:43 Thats a couple of references on this thread about Moyes, the Wigan game in the cup a good few years back and our captain(s) …. …. Im just thawing out after a particularly cold day at the old lady, and Ive had quite a few king of beers so please dont think me thick but, am I missing something ? What has that game got to do with todays ?Im not being funny or anything its a serious question. Asking for a friend as they say …. Derek Knox 36 Posted 08/02/2025 at 20:25:51 Oliver, the site is no longer run by Lyndon and Michael, two Indian guys have taken it over. If you go back on the pre-match thread there is more explanation there. Most have migrated over to Evertonia.com and I agree T W is now a lonely place with just a few of us left, but I expect that number to dwindle down too.Incidentally I have taken dual membership as the Live Forum is only on the other site, but up to now, no Match reports or comments. Hope that helps mate ! John Raftery 37 Posted 08/02/2025 at 20:31:05 Today we witnessed a reality check. It is one thing playing attractive passing football against weak opposition in the lower reaches of the league. It is an entirely different proposition trying to do that against a top seven team. There is a reason the Cherries are seventh in the table just as there is a reason we are fifth from bottom. They have better players. We have now lost four consecutive matches against Bournemouth in the last year. That they looked more comfortable in the first half than in any of the previous matches was disappointing. Our players could not get going with Betos limitations exposed when he is the target man while Kerkez had too much pace for Lindstrøm to do much more than pass back into the midfield.Our players at least made a decent effort to get back into the game in the last half hour and on another day, with a touch more luck, might have done so. Alcaraz showed promise in his half hour on the pitch. He looks like the creative, ball carrying attacking midfielder we have badly needed in the last eighteen months. Hopefully he can now build on the initial favourable impression. The challenge now is to prevent one defeat becoming two or three. Rob Halligan 38 Posted 08/02/2025 at 20:36:44 FFS, losing once to Bournemouth is embarrassing, but three times in one season is downright disgraceful, even when you consider they didnt really deserve to win one of those three games. 😡😡 Paul Hewitt 39 Posted 08/02/2025 at 20:38:12 Well Alcaraz has to start on Wednesday. Simply no reason for him not to. Oliver Molloy 40 Posted 08/02/2025 at 20:46:00 Thanks Derek, Still don't understand Taken it over - bought it or what is going on - are these guys Evertonians for instance ? Derek Knox 41 Posted 08/02/2025 at 20:50:59 Rob, Just what is it with Everton - it is possible for any player to have an off-day, but with us, it seems to affect half the team ? Doucoure and Beto were a disgrace- again, Tarks was woeful in defence. I feel for all those like Danny who made the trip to be let down en masse ! Derek Knox 42 Posted 08/02/2025 at 20:53:03 Oliver, I don't think they know much at all to be honest, and likely have never visited The Old Lady. Apparently a full explanation by Lyndon is in the pipeline, or so I am led to believe. Add Your Comments In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site. » Log in now Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site. How to get rid of these ads and support TW © ToffeeWeb