Season › 2024-25 › News Pickford plays hero again as Everton earn another valuable point Lyndon Lloyd 27/12/2024 42comments | Jump to last Man City 1 - 1 Everton Everton made it a hat-trick of draws against three sides that came into December sitting in the top four with a hard-earned point at the Etihad Stadium. Iliman Ndiaye cancelled out Bernardo Silva’s opener with a lovely goal, Jordan Pickford saved an Erling Haaland penalty and the Blues spurned a couple of hugely promising chances on the counter-attack late on as the spoils were shared in this Boxing Day clash. City came into the game in the worst run of form of Pep Guardiola’s managerial career but they appeared to have re-found their groove in the early going this afternoon with some slick movement and an early chance for Joško Gvardiol who planted a third-minute header onto the post off a corner. The Croatian defender was involved again with 13 minutes gone when he fed the ball to Jeremy Doku and he played it inside to Silva who appeared to attempt to square it across the face of Pickford’s goal but his effort took a horrible deflection off Jarrad Branthwaite’s out-stretched leg and looped into the far corner to hand the hosts the lead. Article continues below video content Everton’s first sight of goal came seven minutes later when Ndiaye slipped a pass square to Orel Mangala but his shot bent high and wide of the target. At the other end, meanwhile, Haaland was an ever-present threat for balls played over the top for him to chase but in one such instance midway through the first period, Pickford was out smartly to snuff out the danger. After Idrissa Gueye had tested Stefan Ortega in the 27th minute, Bernardo Silva really should have doubled City’s lead when he arrived to meet a ball delivered into space near the penalty spot but he went for a more elaborate finish with the outside of his boot and missed the target. Three minutes after that, it was 1-1. Abdouaye Doucouré’s cross from the right grazed Manuel Akanji’s raised knee and fell to Ndiaye who took a quick touch to kill the ball and then caressed it back across Ortega into the far corner. Guardiola’s increasingly looked to Savinho down their right early in the second half and Pickford had to be alert to parry his crisp half-volley five minutes after the break before Mateo Kovacic lashed the rebound inches wide. Man City appeared to have been handed their lead back on a platter, however, when Savinho tempted Vitalii Mykolenko into a rash challenge in the box and referee Steve Hooper pointed to the spot. Seamus Coleman was booked for delaying Halaand’s preparations for the spot-kick and Pickford gave him the eyes and a few off-putting faces before guessing the right way and pushing the Norwegian’s penalty away from goal. The loose ball was crossed back in for Haaland to simply head into the empty net but he had clearly been in an offside position and the “goal” was ruled out. Instead it was Everton who almost stole the points. First, in the 67th minute, Doucouré’s far-post volley almost crept in before Rico Lewis diverted it behind. Then, in the 83rd, another speculative Mangala effort took a wicked deflection and bounced just wide of Ortega’s goal. Despite the introduction of Kevin de Bruyne, City struggled to make inroads into Everton’s defence and with any guile in the final third, Sean Dyche’s men might well have pitched the points. Unfortunately, two stoppage-time breakaways came to nothing, with Jack Harrison failing to even work the keeper with the second opportunity. Still, the Toffees were good value for a point which keeps them unbeaten since that horror show at Old Trafford at the start of the month. Matchday updates and reaction Reader Comments (42) Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer () Mike Gaynes 1 Posted 27/12/2024 at 07:12:09 As Carly Simon sang, nobody does it better. I remain convinced he is one of the best shot-stoppers on the planet. Mike Gaynes 2 Posted 27/12/2024 at 07:21:47 This is the 8th penalty Pickford has saved for Everton (7 in league play, one in a Europa League qualifier), breaking the club record he had jointly held with Big Nev and Tim Howard. Jeff Armstrong 3 Posted 27/12/2024 at 11:08:31 In probably less than half the games Neville played too, Mike.Obviously the true stat would be penalties faced. Stu Gre 4 Posted 27/12/2024 at 11:09:33 Mike, completely agree. Pickford is underrated by so many. Joe Hart on Match of The Day last night (not sure if you get that) pointed out that there is more than 1 way to be a great keeper. Jordan's stats are amazing in a team struggling at the bottom, year-in & year-out. I hope we tie him down to a long contract, he's kept us in the Premier League. Anthony Hawkins 5 Posted 27/12/2024 at 11:25:10 Pickford aside, Ndiaye is a brilliant player and, with a more potent striker, I think we'd see just how good he is. The team has a handful of quality players who could be the spine of a fantastic team if better quality players can be brought in. Harrison, whilst he's done a job for us, just is not good enough. His final effort was terrible when we overloaded City's defence. He had to do better. Mal van Schaick 6 Posted 27/12/2024 at 11:41:18 I would keep Pickford and rebuild over the next few seasons in order that we have a top team gracing our New Stadium and pitch. Trophies and a better league position would be a bonus, and I don't think that we are far off that ambition with new ownership. Jim Bennings 7 Posted 27/12/2024 at 11:49:53 Pickford has made himself a presence now in terms of opponents know that they have to beat the best English goalkeeper to score, coupled with facing people like Tarkowski and Branthwaite it's easy to see why teams don't enjoy coming up against it.Just a shame that we can't get more potent attacking talent to match Ndiaye. Dave Abrahams 8 Posted 27/12/2024 at 12:44:47 Lyndon Lloyd: “ Pickford plays hero again as Everton earn another point”Michael Kenrick: “Another top draw thanks to Pickford's penalty save” Didn't Ndiaye play and score that goal that also helped us to get that draw?Not to mention Malanga, Tarkowski, Gueye and Branthwaite. I don't begrudge Pickford being in line for MotM but he helped the team gain a point — he didn't do it on his own! Ben King 9 Posted 27/12/2024 at 13:10:19 Dave #8,Absolutely spot on but I think the sentiment is that, had the penalty gone in (I'm one of the few people that thought it was soft: Savinho was already on his way down), then it'd have been another hard luck storyThere's so much more about this team now and Dyche deserves huge credit. We do need to reinforce in attacking areas – particularly right wing where Harrison is next to useless. If we could give Dyche some proper reinforcements to help, I think we'd see a difference. Mike Connolly 10 Posted 27/12/2024 at 13:12:27 Im glad people on here are praising Pickford rightfully. the media doesnt think he exist Until last night on MOTD Christopher Timmins 11 Posted 27/12/2024 at 13:23:33 England's number 1! Tony Abrahams 12 Posted 27/12/2024 at 15:48:30 Such is the nature of modern football, I honestly don't know what is and isn't a penalty on a lot of occasions nowadays, Ben.It would be interesting to hear your view of why you don't think it was a penalty, mate? Dave Abrahams 13 Posted 27/12/2024 at 17:33:59 Ben (9)Fair enough, and you were honest enough to admit you were one of the few who thought it was a soft penalty. I've got to be honest myself, I don't rate Mylolenko so there is a bit, or more, of bias in my thinking that it was a very rash tackle considering where it took place and he kicks him right on the knee as he follows through. I don't think there was any need for VAR. Tony Abrahams 14 Posted 27/12/2024 at 17:48:13 Watch it again, Dave, and you might just have a different view of it. You might not but I'm certain that the City winger stretches when he sees the tackle coming, to make sure he gets there first and win the penalty.Nothing wrong with this, especially in the modern game, but I personally thought he slipped before he got tackled because he's overstretching, and this is why I'm not always sure what is and isn't a penalty nowadays because a lot of today's decisions, especially when they've been rerun a few times, can be so subjective.You couldn't argue with the decision but it's something that I feel that a different VAR might sometimes interpret differently. Dave Abrahams 15 Posted 27/12/2024 at 17:56:27 Tony (14), Not taking the piss mate but I think, after watching it three or four times, that the only thing getting stretched is your imagination! Dave Abrahams 16 Posted 27/12/2024 at 17:59:06 Tony (14),On second thoughts, I was taking the piss, sorry about that. Mike Gaynes 17 Posted 27/12/2024 at 18:00:29 Dave, I don't know what's happened to Mykolenko. Last season, he was a lockdown defender, pretty much unbeatable off the dribble. This season year he's been visibly slower, which shouldn't happen at 25, and much easier to beat. And he's been caught egregiously out of position on a couple of game-losing goals. Dave Abrahams 18 Posted 27/12/2024 at 18:14:45 Mike, he was better last season, not sure about unbeatable off the dribble but he is a weak spot in the team this season although even when he has been poor, in recent games he has put in a couple of well-timed tackles — my bias put them down to luck! Liam Mogan 20 Posted 27/12/2024 at 18:42:09 Jack 'hit the first man' Harrison is a bang average player but Broja took too long on the ball and should have played it left, where Gueye and Doucoure were free. Harrison was always going to look at his feet, control the ball and then check inside. Must be the easiest player to defend against in the top flight. Christine Foster 21 Posted 27/12/2024 at 18:46:53 Tony, I went back and looked at the incident a couple of times and he defo played for the penalty, looking for it I think is the term I'd use. But, as football is now a contactless sport, Hooper, who was as biased a ref I have seen all year, was always going to give it.There was always only one outcome, play acting winger, full back who was being laced all day, and a ref eager to please the home team. Yep, job done, Mr Hooper, go back to Seasame Street, you Muppet. Paul Ferry 23 Posted 27/12/2024 at 19:39:14 Mike G. Are you not going to pop on to the other match thread to defend your statement that DCL has never scored a 'great goal' for us? There's a few on there who might want a word. Martin Farrington 24 Posted 27/12/2024 at 19:42:55 Christine @21, you are spot on about Hooper. We have dreadful, inept and incompetent referees in the Premier League, led by one of the worst of all time. Hooper's blatant bias was clearly one of the most embarrassingly obvious I have seen for some time. Brandishing yellow cards each time a City player faked yet another tumble.As for the penalty, if you look, the player had lost his footing. His foot sinks into the turf causing him to slip, then when already halfway down, in comes a hapless Mykolenko waving a leg that doesn't connect by his movement, in fact it is clearly the other way around.Pause that. Reverse the situation to the City box and there is not a chance in the world we get a penalty.With the lies of Webb supporting the disgusting Calvert-Lewin hack-down which was not given, but absurdly presented as Calvert-Lewin's fault, still ringing untruly in my ears, there was never a doubt it would be given. Mark Murphy 25 Posted 27/12/2024 at 19:51:19 Paul,He said what????? Jeff Armstrong 26 Posted 27/12/2024 at 19:55:34 Liam 20, spot on, that is how I saw it too, Broja should have released the ball 20 yards earlier, to his left.Harrison was always going to control it, and then come onto his favoured left foot. I'm not sure what the other two would have done with it though. I think we've got a problem as our very few better players don't trust the likes of Mykolenko, Doucoure, Harrison and are reluctant to pass to them. Ndiaye especially doesn't trust Mykolenko or Doucoure, and sometimes tries to do too much on his own. Dave Abrahams 27 Posted 27/12/2024 at 19:59:58 Jeff (26), Yes, that “Twenty yards earlier” makes a big difference to what might have been! Paul Ferry 28 Posted 27/12/2024 at 20:32:46 He did indeed Mark; on the other match thread. And MG doesn't drink! Derek Thomas 29 Posted 27/12/2024 at 21:08:48 There's a vacancy at Stoke, tailor made for the best boiled egg we know Paul Ferry 30 Posted 27/12/2024 at 21:23:08 Dyche and Stoke would be a match made in Heaven just like Thora Hird and Arthur Mullard. One quick look at Dyche and you just know that he loves oatcakes. Michael Kenrick 31 Posted 27/12/2024 at 21:44:19 Really, Dave @8?You're gonna challenge the concept of 'The Headline'? You want to see a full match description instead of pinning it on what is arguably one of the more important moments of the match?And not an everyday occurrence either. Pickford has saved eight penalties in as many years. Don't you think that might warrant a mention perhaps, especially as it preserves the draw that had been hard won at that point?Yes, it was a fine goal by Ndiaye (get his name right, for fuck's sake!) but it would have meant next to nothing if Pickford had not saved that penalty.And at that point in the game, it was all down to Pickford. With a sly and sneaky contribution from Coleman that would have required a paragraph and a half to summarize. Show some blooming gratitude that we give you the headlines straight and not like that maddening clickbait shite that seems all the vogue on the NewsNow feed. Brian Williams 32 Posted 27/12/2024 at 21:50:12 Dave the Grinch!Dave, a penalty save is much less common than a goal being scored.The headline almost writes itself mate. Brendan McLaughlin 33 Posted 27/12/2024 at 21:57:17 Brian #32Bit unfair on the Grinch... Brian Williams 34 Posted 27/12/2024 at 21:58:33 🤣 Paul Ferry 35 Posted 27/12/2024 at 22:06:59 How about "Rare Penalty Save and Rare Goal Secure Priceless Draw for Valiant Blues'. Mike Gaynes 36 Posted 27/12/2024 at 22:22:15 Apparently everybody on the other thread was drinking too heavily to notice that I described Dom as "a striker who can't shoot" and lost their shit over my subsequent sentence that he never scored a great "goal" instead of "strike." Some people just look for reasons to melt down.However, I stand by the point, which is that nobody has ever seen DCL rip a really great shot like we've seen from even non-strikers like Keane and Dwight and Townsend. The top corner is alien territory to Dom. Even the kind of side-netting outside-of-the-foot drive like Ndiaye pulled off yesterday is totally beyond his abilities. Hell, Gana's swerving shot off the underside of the crossbar a few weeks ago is something Dom could never even dream of trying.As I said on the other thread, Dom can do lots of fine things on a football pitch. Taking a powerful shot is not one of them. Brian Williams 37 Posted 27/12/2024 at 22:26:59 Mike. I didn't lose my shit I just disagreed.You posted "but he has never in his career scored a great goal."I still disagree. Paul Ferry 38 Posted 27/12/2024 at 22:32:49 You don't wiggle out of it that easily MG. It is clear as daylight. You are actually misrepresenting yourself. This is what you wrote: 'he has never in his career scored a great goal'. Where the feck is strike in that?And you now reduce things to 'taking a powerful shot'! That's a wiggle. Powerful headers, apparently, are not 'great goals'. I find it very perplexing (and unlike you) that you actually have a pop at people for responding to tell you erm you're wrong. And you simply push to one side all the examples and links others have given you to show you how wrong you are. And remember what me and others have said about the 'occasion'?And why insult good people by claiming they are in a 'meltdown' or losing their shit. That, too, is bollocks Mike. Your original mistake hardly merits any definition of 'meltdown' that I am familiar with. Tony Abrahams 41 Posted 27/12/2024 at 22:55:03 Wheres Noddy Holder, when you need him? Dont call Dave, “ The Grinch” Brian, listen to Brendan, because I thought Dave, was very unfair to me earlier in this thread, and Im definitely known as the grinch, in our family!I wish it could Christmas everyday…. Seriously I couldnt think of anything fuckin worse!! Jeff Armstrong 42 Posted 27/12/2024 at 23:02:52 Michael 31, you seem to forget that Dave doesnt rate Pickford, hence his upset at the headline, you need to think of these things when writing the headline please.“Fantastic Ndiaye goal supplements penalty save by Evertons goalkeeper “ Mike Gaynes 43 Posted 27/12/2024 at 23:06:51 Brian #37, I didn't mean you. At post #38 you can see a fine example of "losing their shit"... over one word. "Goal" instead of "strike". Clearly and obviously my point was that Dom cannot shoot a football. He has scored great goals, all but one with his head. The Arsenal bike was the only great goal I've ever seen him score with his foot. If you've got another nominee, shoot me a link. I didn't see one in the 50. James Hughes 44 Posted 27/12/2024 at 23:08:36 Mike, I didn't see people losing their collective shit on the other thread. However you are still posting shit on this one and trying to back out what you posted. Lol and all best Paul Ferry 45 Posted 27/12/2024 at 23:10:38 Phew! It's lucky that we in 'meltdown' who lose our shit and drink 'too heavily' have you around to correct us MG.But clearly not 'too heavily' that we could not spot a wrong statement about DCL. But, in your words, we were and therefore could not understand the superior subtlety of your more erudite post.The problem might be that probably like me we have not had a drink today and yep the post is wrong. Mike Gaynes 46 Posted 27/12/2024 at 23:15:45 Not trying to back out at all, James. DCL is a striker who cannot shoot. I have stood by the statement on both threads, and nobody has presented one iota of evidence, either video or even anecdotal, to refute it. Can you? What's the best shot you've ever seen him hit? If anybody can show me even one example that remotely looks like Keane against Chelsea or McNeil against Palace or even Ndiaye yesterday, I'll happily eat my words. In the meantime I'll have lunch to ward off starvation. Add Your Comments In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site. » Log in now Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site. How to get rid of these ads and support TW © ToffeeWeb