I didn't post this sooner as I didn't want to ruin the excitement of the signing of a young potentially good player for Everton. However, now some time has passed, things are panning out the way I feared they would. So here is what we didn't hear much of (in England) when we signed Adam Aznou.

In May, Bayern Sporting Director Freund said of Aznou:

“Adam Aznou has gained valuable experience at Real Valladolid and developed very well. His regular playing time proves that he’s held his own at this high level. We now want to reintegrate him into our first team at the Club World Cup so that he can take the next steps.”

What the next steps in Freund's mind might have been remains a mystery... but Aznou himself felt the next step was for him to be the starting left-back immediately. He made this aim public (which was apparently news to the club) bizarrely on an interview on the video gaming streaming service Twitch. When he told a Spanish reporter:

"My future is uncertain. I want to play. If I don’t get minutes at Bayern, we’ll have to look for a solution.”

Upon arriving in the USA, Aznou apparently learned he was not going to be the starting left-back for Bayern in their Club World Cup campaign and, according to Sky Sports Germany:

"We heard from several sources that he let himself down in training during the Club World Cup and no longer showed the attitude that is needed at FC Bayern. If there is one thing Kompany doesn't like, it's when players drag their feet in training -- and perhaps think a little too highly of themselves."

Aznou's camp inferred youngsters weren't given a chance at Bayern — to which the club's board member Maz Eberl publicly responded:

“With Josip Stanisic, Aleksandar Pavlovic, and Jamal Musiala, we have three regulars from our own academy. That’s not a common thing. We’ve developed numerous players at the campus and I consider that positive.

"We also have plenty more players with real prospects,” Eberl continued. “Paul Wanner has a great opportunity.“ Then, when asked specifically about Aznou, he said, "You can't force a dog to drink." Which is a German saying that means roughly the same as the horse to water saying in English... ie, You can give someone an opportunity but you can't make them grasp it (train hard, work, have a positive attitude, improve).

His public comments after Aznou left were a bit more measured but had the same theme:

"We regret that we couldn't continue our partnership with Adam. We aim to focus even more on our talented players in the future. This season, young players, such as those who participated in the Club World Cup, will train regularly with the first team." 

"In general, the door is open to anyone who gives their all every day to achieve our common goals to establish themselves permanently with the FC Bayern professionals.”

After the transfer, Freund added:

"He's a very talented player. But the player has to be convinced by the club's plans. It wasn't our desire to sell him but it was his big desire to make the transfer. At the end of the day, we decided together that it had to be best for everyone, including him. He has to be convinced, full of energy and passion behind what he's doing. That's why we agreed to the move."

And so now, here we are at Everton... with Moyes saying recently:

"This boy’s a young boy, maybe not quite ready yet, but we hope he will be shortly. We see a lot of good things in him, technically very good, athletic, might need just a little bit to get himself built up and ready for the Premier League, so we won’t be putting him under any pressure.”

So in other words, Moyes has reaffirmed exactly what Bayern said. The kid has potential but is not ready. But given he threw down his tools and wouldn't train at Bayern — German champions and a Champions League club — how might we expect Aznou to be feeling about not getting game time at a 14th-placed mediocre side? Not very happy, I should imagine.

Rather like Thierry Small must have felt after he stomped off to Southampton.

And to that point, rumours are surfacing on African sites that Aznou is indeed unhappy and agitating for a January move. These may or may not be from credible sources, but they seem likely to reflect the reality. A kid with a big ego, who isn't that good, wants to be the belle of the ball at a successful club and now finds himself as a spare part at a mediocre one = unhappy camper. 

My question then is: Why did we sign him? Any scout or club official worth his salt would have been able to read the comments about him from Munich, including the cause of his "woes", before we signed him. Presumably, discussions over the signing (short of guaranteeing a first-team spot) would surely have given some indication as to how he would fit into Moyes's plans?

And yet we signed a guy who thinks he is top class already and should be turning out in the Champions League every couple of weeks. Congrats to the recruitment team. 

Reader Comments (42)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()


Michael Kenrick
1 Posted 27/10/2025 at 22:04:51
Very disturbing stuff, Kieran, but thanks for pulling this together.

And indeed, if you could do it, surely it's information that is well within the grasp of our recruitment team.

And the lad seems to be exactly the wrong kind of character to benefit from the dubious Moyes method of player development which involves holding them back and clipping their wings.

Derek Thomas
2 Posted 27/10/2025 at 22:34:41
Its all 'rumours' about Aznou of course... just like the one about Dibling... and we don't seem to have a DoF figurehead (aka somebody to sack) but a 'recruitment group' hiding behind a Harry Potter-esque blanket of invisibility, due diligence doesn't seem high on the KPIs either given the alleged 'previous' of Dibling and Aznou.

As somebody said: Can we really afford £45M sat on the bench -- however well they're supposed to be doing in training? (Add Alcaraz to that for a rounded-up total of about £60M??)

There's another rumour that Harrison Armstrong is ripping up trees at Preston.

Here's another bit of a Rumour for Anzou...

"Now here you go again
You say you want your freedom
Well, who am I to keep you down?"

Paul Kossoff
3 Posted 27/10/2025 at 23:37:50
Derek 2. I would send him out to Fleetwood, Macclesfield maybe.

After all, he is a bit green, wouldn't want him to Peter out... I'll get me coat.😁

Mike Gaynes
4 Posted 28/10/2025 at 00:30:52
Kieran, we bought him because he has outsized talent. Appears he has an outsized head to go with it.

Some gifted players take quite a bit of time to understand what sacrifices are necessary to become a top professional player (Lookman, Kean), and some never get it (Van der Meyde and, tragically, Royston Drenthe), but Moyes and our recruiting team thought the kid was worth taking a chance on. Moyes is known to be pretty good at getting the message over to young players about putting the work in.

Some signings are a gamble. They work out or they don't. You may recall there was vehement disagreement here over the likes of Grealish, Garner and re-signing Keane. Worked out pretty well.

Maybe Davey will get this kid's head straight, or put a boot up his ass. He's under contract until 2029 at only £25k/week, so there's no hurry. He may be "eyeing the window" but he ain't climbing out unless we say so.

DT, yeah, Harrison is doing great. Here he'd be sitting on the bench, unless you think he'd beat out Gana or Garner to a starting job, or beat out Röhl for his role. Personally I'm delighted to see him putting in Championship minutes and growing into a potential star.

Andy Mead
5 Posted 28/10/2025 at 00:38:18
Must be bloody awful if he can't get any minutes ahead of our current left-back. But if true, just like a lot of people of this generation, they want it all now.

Maybe a loan to the Championship would do him some good. No point loaning out abroad, he needs to adjust to the British game.

Si Cooper
6 Posted 28/10/2025 at 02:53:11
Andy (5), I don't think he has to be awful for him not to be picked, just not anywhere near as disciplined as the manager prefers.

From what I've seen the lad has tons of ability but doesn't carefully choose his moments to try the adventurous.

As Mike G suggests; big talent, big(ger) ego.

I really hope he settles, listens to what is required from him, and focuses on delivering it. If he does I think he could become a real asset.

Jack Convery
7 Posted 28/10/2025 at 03:11:10
The gift of being a youth is wasted on the young. It would be wiser to give the gift of youth to the elderly, as they know what life is all about and have gained the wisdom to get the best out of it.

If the above is true, then this kid needs to grow up or he'll end up playing non-league in Bulgaria or some such country, and wondering where it all went wrong.

Alan J Thompson
8 Posted 28/10/2025 at 05:07:12
I do wonder if this move was just left to his agent or if, when the move was discussed, the player asked what his chances were of being the first-choice left-back.

The blame would lie with the player as long as he was not made any now broken promises, especially if his attitude mentioned above was known to the club's negotiators. Or perhaps there was some naivety on both sides.

Derek Knox
9 Posted 28/10/2025 at 06:37:29
Jack C @7,

I think you have hit the nail on the head once again. Moyes, being as conservative as he is, will choose experience if fit over upcoming (possibly) talent. He is probably on very decent wages for a 19-year-old, but wants to run before he has learned to walk in the Premier League.

Hope it's got an element of misguided gossip to it, but Kieran (when not bear-baiting) is generally spot on with his comments and observations!

Paul Hewitt
10 Posted 28/10/2025 at 06:56:08
Let this be a warning to young players.

You ain't playing with Moyes in charge. Stay away.

Robert Tressell
11 Posted 28/10/2025 at 07:01:59
Young player, tiny fee, only just arrived in the country. Carrying an injury initially too.

He's had one short loan and maybe needs another to help him acclimatise. Bit early to accuse him of being a bad apple or a bad signing.

Mykolenko is out of contract in the summer. I would have thought the plan was to see if we could introduce Aznou over the course of the season to see if he can step up.

If so, great, we have a player who can be our left-back for years to come for absolute peanuts. That would make him brilliant business.

If not, one of those things which all clubs experience who develop young players. Each of Brighton and Bournemouth recently bought teenage left-backs from Argentina in Barco and Soler. Neither has worked out. Barco left the club fairly soon and Soler remains behind Truffert whom Bournemouth bought to replace Kerkez.

Not every player who turns up as a youth development project will be a success. It's not bad management or bad recruitment necessarily.

Alan McGuffog
12 Posted 28/10/2025 at 07:11:32
Mike,

I too am delighted with the reports coming out of Preston about Armstrong. Soon he'll be deserving a move to a "big" club.

Daniel A Johnson
13 Posted 28/10/2025 at 07:38:56
Moyes would rather play a player out of position or an ageing Coleman.

Not surprised the lad wants out. Not a Moyes player, too slight and too young.

I say again, we have the worst scouting and recruitment team in the Premier League.

Tony Abrahams
14 Posted 28/10/2025 at 07:55:58
It's easy to blame the manager but, until people have actually seen the kid play, then I think it's unfair to beat up David Moyes over this.

He needs a loan because, if he's really going to develop, then he has simply got to play, especially if he's not quite ready for the brutally, physically demanding nature of the Premier League.

We don't know the ins and outs but it does give the feeling that people aren't totally aligned behind the scenes in our recruitment team...

Sam Hoare
15 Posted 28/10/2025 at 08:45:20
I understand not throwing him in the deep end but I think its borderline ludicrous that he doesn't have a single minute in the Premier League yet.

This is not some totally untested kid. He performed reasonably well in La Liga last season, which is a top league, and he has shone in high-pressure European youth matches, even playing for his country at senior level.

He's not some run-of-the mill academy player; he's a top talent that needs to be given time to progress.

On Sunday, Moyes had Mykolenko playing more advanced than usual and getting quite a lot of time and space on the ball in their final third. He doesn't have the technical skills to shine there; Aznou does and yet was not given a single minute -- even when Mykolenko was playing poorly and we were 3-0 down.

It's a terrible message to send to young players and I really don't understand it. Surely you at least use those last 5 minutes to get him on the pitch and give him a taste?

Perhaps Aznou is not doing enough in training but then maybe he needs a little more encouragement and a sign that he might actually get on the pitch at some point. God knows we could use an overlapping full-back who is comfortable in the final third.

Robert Tressell
16 Posted 28/10/2025 at 08:54:41
I think Martinez would be trying to play Aznou and Dibling -- at least as subs. I get the impression that's the main gripe with Moyes.

Interesting how the more daring managers in recent years: Martinez, Silva and Lampard -- ended up completely losing it with us.

Whereas the less daring / more experienced? In Moyes, Ancelotti, Allardyce and Dyche -- all soon revert to a boring defensive shape.

Still we just don't know with Aznou. He may just be getting fit.

David Bromwell
17 Posted 28/10/2025 at 08:59:13
It must be difficult for talented young players who move into a big city like Liverpool, particularly if they are not playing regularly.

Where do they live? A smart hotel? What do they do after training? Remember, they will not have any mates and may not always be fluent in English. And on top of that you suddenly find that you are not as good as you thought.

It seems we have suddenly got three young men who must all feel that they should be playing more than an odd appearance as substitute, and with money in their pocket and time on their hands, they will need careful management and support.

Paul Hewitt
18 Posted 28/10/2025 at 09:18:58
That's 3 players bought for a combined fee of £80 million.

None are Premier League ready (Moyes's words)... Unbelievable.

Ajay Gopal
19 Posted 28/10/2025 at 09:33:53
I think Aznou has to get his head down in training and really give Moyes something to think about. His chance may not come in the next few games but, if he shows good attitude in training, I believe Moyes will give him an opportunity -- nothing spectacular, but a few minutes at the end when leading 2-0 at home (ha!).

Or when Mykolenko gets injured?

Perhaps one other factor in Aznou not getting game time is Branthwaite's absence? Jarrad's replacement, Keane, does not have the pace to cover for any mistakes made by Aznou, and Moyes does not want to take any chances on that account.

John Williams
20 Posted 28/10/2025 at 10:59:44
I think its clear, Moyes did not sign this guy, it was the group.
If Bayern thought they had a future star on their hands, they would have kept him.

I have only seen him on the pitch once, on TV when they where in the States, and he came on as a sub.

Am I correct in saying he was not in the squad on Sunday against Spurs?

Dave Abrahams
21 Posted 28/10/2025 at 11:10:13
Good post, Kieran, thanks for that, a lot to chew over.

All players have different personalities and nobody is perfect. One player I remember, very young, played for Spurs, wasn't happy not getting played. He was ambitious, went to Middlesborough to get regular football in the first team and was transferred to Liverpool for big money. He was a dirty so and so but a terrific player and captain, Graham Souness.

Lookman, remember him, didn't get a good run with us; some said he didn't deserve it; others thought differently. Lookman was one of them, he was also ambitious and look where he is now.

There were/ are plenty of other players who had big ideas about themselves who are long forgotten, I haven't seen Aznou so I don't know how good he is or can be but I would really like to see him to make my mind up.

I know nothing about his personality either but liked David's post @17 as well as Kieran's.

Mark Taylor
22 Posted 28/10/2025 at 13:48:25
The only reason Aznou is an issue is we know our quality and depth for both full-back roles is lamentable. So it beggars belief we bought no one capable of playing in those roles while being so overstocked on midfielders, we've sent one seriously promising one out on loan.

In an ideal world, we'd have this ample choice of midfielders as well as two quality ready-to-go full-backs but, since we were never going to be in a position where that was possible this season, I think we've put resources in the wrong places.

I agree with Sam that it has been apparent, and not just in the last game, that Mykolenko has been urged to get forward but all that has done is highlight his severe offensive limitations.

Of course striker is our other massive headache but at least we signed someone for that role... just that at this early stage, we may have ended up with yet another dud (though I detected the occasional glimpse of an actual player on Sunday).

Kieran Kinsella
23 Posted 28/10/2025 at 14:27:05
Dave,

I just question if Moyes is the "whisperer" to handle Aznou. He is young and egotistic.

If you look at Moyes's track records with youngsters, Barkley struggled under him, Rooney fell out and they ended up suing each other in court.

John-Paul Kissock seemed to think he was destined for greatness and rightly but probably wrongly blames Moyes for his demise, though falling all the way to non-league was a surprise.

Sheedy stated Moyes never took an interest in youngsters.

Then on the other side of the coin we have the "ego" issue. Again, Moyes doesn't have a great track record with "big personalities": Gazza, Drenthe, Jo, Shandy, Big Dunc (they made amends but he was banished for a time), Beattie floundered (Shearer said of him "If he was half as good as he thought he was, he'd be twice as good as he is").

Obviously some of these were nutters but there are nutter whisperers out there who somehow keep these types in check and get more out of them than most. But Moyes seems to be of the Roy Hodgson mould of preferring to have "good lads" in the team than egotists. Which is all well and good but begs the question: why sign Aznou?

The other thing is that he "may" become good -- in which case, people will say it was a good investment if we sell him. But we won't sell him for much if he never plays. More likely he will be someone who runs down his contract and leaves on the cheap before showing what he can do elsewhere.

Ian Bennett
24 Posted 28/10/2025 at 15:53:20
Think Coleman, Hibbert, Osman, Anichebe, Vaughan, and Rodwell did okay under Moyes. For £60k, total, that's good business in terms of game and transfer return...

He also had Barkley and Stones in reserve.

Not a bad list compared to what has come after, with a state-of-the-art Finch Farm fully operational.

Dale Self
25 Posted 28/10/2025 at 19:58:52
What Sam said @15.

I understand Moyes is reluctant to experiment since we have few players in the back line and midfield who are threats or have vision for the forward pass. Moyes is limited in what he can do with the initial setup.

However, when Plan A fails and there is 30 minutes left to suffer, why not give them a chance? Maybe a player like Aznou would be a risk to take off his development routine but there is a chance he could spark something.

On the left with Jack, it is a good chance to take.

Kieran Kinsella
26 Posted 28/10/2025 at 20:16:09
Dale

As far as a taking a risk goes, maybe Moyes should watch some old tapes and see what happened when Cadamarteri -- a last-minute addition to the subs who already played earlier in the day -- was subbed on v Chelsea. Or when Amokachi subbed himself on v Spurs.

Derek Thomas
27 Posted 28/10/2025 at 21:46:19
If you 'had you own opinions' and/or openly disagreed with Harry Catterick - you were quickly gone.

If you 'had you own opinions' and/or openly disagreed with Harry Catterick - but you were doing the business on the field, you were 'OK' - until you weren't- then you were quickly gone.

If you were quiet as a mouse and you were doing the business on the field, you were 'OK' - until you weren't- then you were quickly gone.

I think Moyes, while not that 'harsh' is possibly in that end of the spectrum - how far is a matter for speculation.

Anyway, with apparent rise in peoples 'entitlement', player power, contracts - not forgetting agents. It seems too much nowadays to have an old style 'I'm the Boss - and what I say goes!' workplace.

You can also add in that there are sometimes two types of signings;

1) Manager signings

2) 'Club' signings (DoF and/or recruitment group) who sign players for Investment..."and anyway if he's not ready, you're the highly paid Coach - coach him so he is fit for purpose"

But there always was and there always will be some people whose mouth also serves as a shovel and they just won't/can't stop digging...and sometimes that Shearer comment is spot on.

Steve Brown
28 Posted 28/10/2025 at 22:23:38
Lots of good points here.

We have never had sufficient control in games this season for the manager to sub on a young player like Aznou. We all know how cautious Moyes is and he will never do anything to jeopardise a game (in his opinion).

Given how average Mykolenko is as a player, I would have liked to see him at left-back but he has zero chance this season.

Aznou won't develop if he doesn't play, therefore a loan in January would be the best outcome for him.

Steve Brown
29 Posted 28/10/2025 at 22:37:25
Dave @ 21, Lookman is a good example of how you need longer development paths and patience with certain youngsters. Also, the player might have a different view of things than the club.

I thought Lookman had huge talent. He was technically excellent, had great control and was rapid. Physically, he wasn't strong enough but that comes with time. When Allardyce wanted to send him on loan to Derby, he insisted in RB Leipzig.

He is 28 now, and thriving at Atalanta with 40 goals in 98 appearances. Would we have had the patience and structure to nurture his ability over several years?

Everton had never had the stability over the last 10 years to manage the development path of young players. That is why it is an interesting decision to invest for the future in Rohl, Dibling, Aznou and Armstrong.

If it works, then brilliant. I am a bit concerned that the club still does not have the right structures in place to nurture their career paths.

Pat Kelly
30 Posted 29/10/2025 at 10:50:13
We can't afford to buy players to go out on loan. It's a Premier League club, not an apprenticeship scheme.

We need Premier League ready players at the moment. Beto, Barry, Aznou may never be up to the Premier League level, yet they're in the side or on the bench.

And Dibling looks a long way short as well. Is it any wonder we're struggling?

Steve Brown
31 Posted 29/10/2025 at 23:41:56
It is the only way the young will develop, Pat, unless you think getting splinters in their arse on the bench will help. Other Premier League clubs buy young players with potential and guiding them to the first team.

Better than signing ‘ready-now' dross like Walcott, Schneiderlin, Williams, Tosun, Klaassen, Maupay, Harrison, Rondon, Coady, Delph, Alli, Sigurdsson, Martina, Sidibe, Gomes, Bernard, McGeady, Niasse, Funes Mori, Alcaraz, Besic, Kone,

How much did that pile of under-performing shite cost in fees and wages?

Mike Gaynes
32 Posted 30/10/2025 at 06:00:58
Dave #21,

I mentioned Lookman in my post #4 as one who took quite a while to "get it". I would always call for him to be subbed in, but when he was, he would never quite get the job done.

After we gave up on him, Leipzig, Fulham and Leicester did the same. At 25, he seemed destined to be a journeyman. Then Atalanta signed him for chump change and he finally began to show real professional maturity to go with his talent.

But, as Steve says, could we have waited out that maturation process in a club desperate for survival, on the hope he would come good? The answer is obviously not.

The difference now is we can afford to wait for Aznou to grow up. (Pat, we're not poor anymore!)

Tony Abrahams
33 Posted 30/10/2025 at 07:29:00
If it's true that Aznou has got a problem with not playing, then I'm not totally sure that we can afford to wait for him to grow up.

And if it's true that the backroom staff are saying that Dibling is very unlucky not to have had a lot more minutes, then it appears that David Moyes hasn't lost enough of that natural caution that has always been his hallmark.

I remember Lookman coming on at Anfield in an FA Cup tie and changing us into a team that could suddenly attack. Rooney was hooked, Sigurdsson was taken off the wing and moved inside, and Lookman helped Everton to finally start asking Liverpool some questions.

We gave as good as we got, losing to a last-minute Van Dijk goal, with our keeper making another bad mistake, and the very next week at Wembley against Spurs, Sigurdsson was back on the wing and Lookman wasn't even on the bench; the game was already out of our sight well before half-time.

We have had to endure some shite over the years and if our Moyes doesn't break his management style and start trying to implement and integrate a few more of our players, ie, start using more of the players in his squad on the pitch, then I'm beginning to worry that things are going to get bad again.

Mark Murphy
34 Posted 30/10/2025 at 08:09:42
With all due respect to the natives on here, it must be hard for a young lad to swap Barcelona for Merseyside, in October especially.

I can understand his frustration at not getting a sniff and I don't mind a bit of cockiness and irritation if he believes in his own ability.

What I don't understand is why our recruitment people bring in players like him, and possibly Dibling, for a manager who isn't going to use them.

I'm hoping that we're building a younger squad for a new, more dynamic coach in the near future but it's a big ask expecting Aznou to swap 30-odd degrees and the Mediterranean lifestyle for winter in the North-West in the slow lane.

Early days yet -- maybe he will get a game but, in the meantime, I have a lot of sympathy for him.

John Williams
35 Posted 30/10/2025 at 08:49:49
Lookman has been mentioned about not settling in at Everton. I can remember taking my young grandsons to the back of the Park End at Goodison after the game. The players would come out to get in their cars; most would sign autographs and have photos taken with the kids waiting around.

Not Lookman: he would come out with three very tall and burly minders, the main man usually had a long black coat with a fur collar. They would head straight to the black Rolls Royce and disappear.

I remember someone saying that he headed back to London after the games.

Dave Abrahams
36 Posted 30/10/2025 at 09:33:26
Mike (32),

I'm not sure Fulham gave up on him, didn't they want to sign him again after he had left them? And at Leicester, he was doing well there at times including scoring the only goal of the game v Liverpool.

One of Everton's managers said he was one of the best natural goalscorers in training, might have been Koeman or Allardyce.The talent was always there, maybe being a very young lad, he was pining for London with Fulham being a good place for him to be — mind you, it's no use crying over spilt milk now.

Mark Taylor
37 Posted 30/10/2025 at 11:01:42
Mike @32

With due respect, we simply cannot afford to wait very long for Aznou to grow up because the incumbent left-back is bang average and not really up to being first choice.

If we were no longer relatively poor, I suggest we would have signed a couple of proper full-backs, including on the right where we have none.

Andrew Ellams
38 Posted 30/10/2025 at 12:39:07
We replaced solid pros with kids who aren't ready yet and whoever sanctioned those incomings (not too bothered by the outgoings) has questions to answer.

I'm still confident Dibling will come through but I'm equally confident both Aznou and Barry will disappear as nothing more than footnotes in the club's history.

Edward Rogers
39 Posted 30/10/2025 at 13:32:39
How many posters on here have criticised the club for buying 'older' players on high wages?

When we buy younger players (who will hopefully fulfil their potential, although not a given) on lower wages, we still moan.

Brighton & Bournemouth are cited as the "way to go", but we never hear about their signings that don't work out. As for our current on-field performances, not brilliant, but miles better than what we've delivered over the last 5 or 6 years, if not longer.

We will win on Monday.

Nicholas Ryan
40 Posted 30/10/2025 at 14:27:34
David Moyes has spent a lifetime managing professional footballers. He has seen the Good, the Bad and the Ugly! He also played Wayne Rooney when he was 16.

I am surprised that this lad hasn't been given a quick 5 minutes when the result wasn't in doubt. But the fact is, he hasn't.

There has to be a reason why not. Something must be wrong on the training ground; could be laziness, bad timekeeping; not getting on with the other players; lacking physicality etc.

If he were currently good enough, I have no doubt he would be in the team, or at least the squad.

For him not to be in the matchday squad, we must assume that something has gone badly awry at Finch Farm.

Tony Abrahams
41 Posted 30/10/2025 at 19:22:46
I have the same feeling about Dwight McNeil, Nicholas. He's not the quickest, although he's still a proven Premier League player who probably has the best shot in our squad.

He has also scored more than a few decent goals in his time at Everton but for some reason he he just can't get any minutes out on the pitch.

Liam Mogan
42 Posted 31/10/2025 at 08:51:02
The lad obviously has talent.

Rob @11 hits the nail on the head. Small fee, low risk, high reward. If it works out, brilliant, if not it was worth a punt.

The expectation from him that he'd be starting is unrealistic though. The examples of Brighton, Bournemouth etc show that developing and integrating these players is not an overnight process. It takes time.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


How to get rid of these ads and support TW


© ToffeeWeb