Skip to Main Content
Members:   Log In  |  Sign Up
NewsRumoursReportsVideoTalking PointsArticles
Text Size:  A  A  A

Let's Talk About Jake Bidwell

By Dick   Anderson  ::  16/02/2012   20 Comments (ğLast) Being an Everton fan in Essex I only really get to see David Moyes men when they travel south. To make up for the lack of live football I regularly attend matches at my local side Colchester.

This week, I attended Colchester vs Brentford which had a particular interest for me because of The Bees young left back, Jake Bidwell.

Jake Bidwell was born in Southport in 1993. The left sided defender join Everton aged 11 and has steadily progressed through the youth ranks.

In 2009 aged 16 Bidwell signed scholarship forms at Everton and had already played for both the U18 side and the reserves.

Later that year David Moyes handed Bidwell his Everton first team debut by starting him in the Europa League clash against BATE Borisov.

The BATE game was notable for many Everton youngsters making an appearance (Duffy, Mustafi, Craig, Forshaw, Akpan, Agard, Baxter, Rodwell) but Bidwell was the youngest. And aged just 16 years and 271 days Bidwell became the youngest player ever to represent Everton in Europe.

Everton eventually lost to BATE 0-1 but the result was unimportant compared to the glimpse of the future the fans enjoyed. Rodwell looked good for 8 minutes before leaving the pitch injured (sadly a common theme to his career). Duffy looked decent next to Tony Hibbert in the centre of defence while the rest of them were pretty forgettable except for Jake Bidwell. He may have been the youngest player on the pitch but he played a full 90 minutes and look very at home.

So far that has been the only first team action Jake Bidwell has experienced at Everton. The main problem for Bidwell is Leighton Baines. Baines is an England international player, arguably the best left back in the country and pretty much an ever-present in the team. In fact I cannot remember a single game Baines has missed over the last couple of years.

Bidwell though has continued to develop behind the scenes. He has represented England at U16, U17, U18 and most recently U19 level. And last year Bidwell Captained the Everton U18 side to national title success. He was also named Academy Player of the year for 2011.

In November David Moyes decided the time had come to advance the development of Bidwell and sent the now 18-year-old player out on loan to Division 1 outfit Brentford.

On the 6th December Bidwell made his debut for Uwe Rosler's team in a 0-0 draw with Barnet. Bidwell played a full 90 minutes and received the Man-Of-The-Match award at the end of the game.

4 days later Bidwell played his second game for Brentford, a home win against Hartlepool. Once again Bidwell played a full 90 minutes and once again at the end of the match Bidwell received the Man-Of-The-Match award.

Bidwell continued to play well for Brentford over the Christmas period and in early January a very impressed Uwe Rosler contacted David Moyes and agreed to extend Bidwell's loan deal until February 14th.

Speaking of his loan extension Bidwell said "It?s been great here. I have had the odd game in front of big crowds but playing week in, week out in front of fans is what it?s all about."

Before last night Bidwell had played 8 times for Brentford and only lost once. Each appearance has been for the full 90 minutes. And in the 5-2 victory over Wycombe Bidwell assisted two of the goals. Both manager Rosler and the Bees fans seem to like the player and last week Bidwell got a call to join another Everton Loan player Luke Garbutt in the England U19 squad.

Which brings me to last night's game. The starting line ups were announced before the game and maybe it was my imagination but Number 24 Jake Bidwell seemed to get a louder cheer from the Brentford fans. Could this be because his loan spell was due to end yesterday and he was making his final appearance for Brentford? Or did this extra loud cheer occur just because he's a fans favourite?

Anyway the game began and I kept a watchful eye on Brentford's young left back. My first impression was how involved in the game he was mentally. Bidwell watches every pass and continually shouts instructions to his fellow teammates. He may be only 18 but the lad has a leadership quality on the pitch and it?s clear to see why he was Captain of that U18 side which won the title.

To be fair the first half was pretty uneventful. Colchester started the game without a recognised striker and so the Brentford defence and Bidwell remained largely comfortable. A couple of times Bidwell tried to get forward but nothing of any real note. He did look very tidy on the ball giving nothing away.

The second half started much the same way until the 55th minute when Bidwell in an advanced position received the ball outside the penalty area. At first I thought he would look to cross but instead the youngster surprised myself and Colchester midfielder Karl Duguid with a burst of pace.

Poor old Karl Duguid was making his 400th appearance for Colchester but Bidwell showed no respect and easily glided past him into the penalty area. Bidwell found himself with a clear sight of goal and Duguid hit the panic button with a sliding tackle that had no chance of winning the ball. Bidwell was fouled inside the area in a clear cut penalty. Duiguid got a yellow card. Brentford missed the penalty but scored from the resulting rebound.

Colchester manager John Ward then made 3 very attacking substitutions and Brentford's untroubled defence were suddenly faced with strikers with fresh legs.

The last 20 minutes of the game was all Colchester attacking. Bidwell did very well and Colchester had very little joy down his left side. 19-year-old winger Gavin Massey has plenty of pace and trickery but at no time did he find a way past Bidwell.

In the last 10 minutes Colchester did find a way to breach Brentford's defence and striker Steven Gillespie (a former Liverpool youth player) scored 2 goals to give Colchester a 2-1 victory. Neither of the goals were directly the fault of Bidwell and at the final whistle the young man look a bit annoyed that his team had thrown away the 0-1 lead.

Overall I felt Bidwell looked pretty useful. He was very vocal, very focused and very tidy on the ball. He looked to get forward and attack at times but also clearly understood his defensive duties.

Bidwell is quicker than I thought. His speed was crucial when winning the penalty and for every Brentford corner it was Bidwell who remained the last man at the back. Clearly Rosler feels Bidwell has the pace to stop an opposing team?s break after a corner.

Bidwell looked one of the better Brentford players and I would give his performance a 7/10 maybe 8/10 for winning the penalty.

So what does the future hold for Bidwell. Does he have an Everton future? Well the immediately answer is no. Leighton Baines is Everton's best player. Leighton Baines is only 27 and he does not strike me as the kind of player who will ever demand a move away from Everton.

So you could reasonably expect Baines to remain Everton's first choice left back for at least the next 5 or even 6 years. And given Baines excellent injury record you do not expect many first team chances to come the way of young Bidwell.

How long does Bidwell wait for his chance? Will his development suffer waiting for a Baines injury to give him his chance? Is there a chance Moyes might recognise Bidwell?s potential and decide to cash in on Baines?

As with all young players the future is unknown. I always expected big futures for John Paul Kissock and Peter Clark. And I never expected Leon Osman and Tony Hibbert to play over 200 games each for Everton.

But I do feel Jake Bidwell could be an important part of Everton?s future if he could find a way past Leighton Baines.

UPDATE: News released today confirms that Brentford have extended Jake Bidwell's loan for another month. Brentford manager Uwe Rosler told the club website: "I can only take my hat off to him for the level of performance he has delivered."

back See other Fan Articles  :  Add your Comments back

Reader Comments

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Andy Morden
468   Posted 16/02/2012 at 22:44:39

Report abuse

Sounds promising Dick. As you say, Baines is number one (3?) at the mo.

As you've pointed out, it will most likely take injury to oust him. Or a drastic loss of form. Or a sale in the summer (sorry, the cynic in me couldn't resist!)
Lee Courtliff
469   Posted 16/02/2012 at 22:36:56

Report abuse

A good read. I know it's all hypothetical but I just can't see Moyes cashing in on one of his favourites. No matter how much he rates Bidwelli don't think he will ever sell Baines. I'm not saying he should either. Who knows what might happen, we all thought Michael Ball was a left back but some of his best performances were at centre back. Maybe Baines and Bidwell will play together or maybe Jake will just fade away like so many do?
Michael Winstanley
488   Posted 17/02/2012 at 00:41:24

Report abuse

Thanks Dick, an enjoyable read. Let's hope he's better than Baines.
Peter Bourke
491   Posted 17/02/2012 at 00:47:04

Report abuse

Excellent article Dick, both informative and good questions raised.
I'm pretty sure at some stage he will get an opportunity as I don't know a player that can play for 4 or 5 seasons without injury or temporary loss of form. (hope i haven't put the mock on Bainsey).
Mick Davies
503   Posted 17/02/2012 at 04:52:57

Report abuse

I can't understand Moyes not doing what other managers such as Ferguson do, and that is play the promising youngsters in League cup ties. Let's face it, we don't have a large squad compared to Utd and Arsenal yet DM insists on putting out the same players who work non stop in the league all year round, in the League cup. They are usually worked so hard in the PL games that they treat it as a break, and possibly don't find the motivation against the likes of Brentford that they do playing City, Chelsea, Utd or the kopites. So for the sake of our club's future, it would be better to play the likes of Bidwell, Green, Velios, Barkley etc. and give the Cahill's and Bainsies a rest
Derek Thomas
506   Posted 17/02/2012 at 06:06:24

Report abuse

Mick 503; teams that do this don't care about the League or FA Cup.It's top 4 places and CL millions that count.On the other hand it's the only thing we have a chance of winning... for that very reason... e.g. The Semi final.Wouldn't have missed for worlds though, you keep on under-rating us Sir Alex.
Martin Mason
510   Posted 17/02/2012 at 07:50:37

Report abuse

Good article and great to see Everton developing yet another good young player from its own ranks. He can't displace Baines yet but I'm sure that Moyes will start to bring him on for cameo appearances and then possibly rest Baines for some games. He can't be guaranteed a game and competition for places is what makes teams great.
Ajay Gopal
514   Posted 17/02/2012 at 08:46:24

Report abuse

Maybe he will turn into a Gareth Bale and be played forward as a winger..:-)
Steve Guy
541   Posted 17/02/2012 at 11:52:30

Report abuse

Om the basis that Baines is a prime candidate to be sold in the summer ( especially if he has a good Euros) Bidwell may get his chance.
Stephen Kenny
545   Posted 17/02/2012 at 12:02:39

Report abuse

Excellent read Dick.

Good to see one of our younger players getting game time at a competitive level. Lots of lessons to be learnt at this point in their careers.

Hopefully next season will see him move up a level to the championship and Garbutt will foloow him by moving up a level too.
James Cadwaladr
550   Posted 17/02/2012 at 12:29:36

Report abuse

I have a good relationship with the Brentford General Manager and met with him last week and we discussed Jake and Everton, and QPR ? the side he supports.

Jake is very, very highly regarded there by all, has had a couple of indifferent games that you would expect from a lad of that age but is apparently improving game on game and they are very impressed.

He did also say that Everton have high hopes for him but forging a career at Everton may be a step above him and may find his level in the Championship. That said he didn't rule it out based on his current improvement
David Chait
585   Posted 17/02/2012 at 14:00:01

Report abuse

Loved reading that...I would like to see us keep ownership and have him play for likes of Wigan etc in the EPL.... but Championship experience in the next year. From 21 maybe become a more consistent understudy to Baines.. Baines by then will be 30 ...

Even though we have had hope before I will keep optimistic... He did play centrally with Garbutt at LB.. so maybe another option... Man I hope he comes good...
Trevor Lynes
613   Posted 17/02/2012 at 17:16:41

Report abuse

If you look at every top side with ambition?? Every position on the field has good cover... Baines has been shown ever since Lescott left as virtually without cover. Many times I have written about this on Toffeeweb and it's been good fortune rather than good management that Bainesy has not been suspended or badly injured.

If Bidwell has developed as well as the article writer mentions, then he certainly does have a future at EFC... The kid is still a lot younger than Baines and WILL get a chance to show his worth if he is persevered with by us. We have had a charmed life as far as Baines is concerned and decent cover is a priority for his position.
Sam Hoare
618   Posted 17/02/2012 at 18:22:44

Report abuse

Slightly frustrating that two of our best young players who are performing well out on loan Bidwell and Garbutt are both LBs. The same position as arguably our best and most consistent performer for the last 3 years or so! Maybe if they are two footed they could play at RB?

Great article to read Dick, always love hearing in depth reports on our youngsters.

I'm very optimistic that 2 or 3 out of Bidwell, Duffy, Barkley, Garbutt, Baxter, Hope, Mcaleny and Lundstram will be in the first team in the next 3-4 years.
Phil Houghton
642   Posted 17/02/2012 at 21:33:46

Report abuse

Given where the club is financially I am sure that I am not alone in believing that our best chance of competing in the coming years (unless investments comes along) is with the young players making the grade. For this reason I take a keen interest in how the young players are doing. Good player Bidwell, has potential. The thing we all need to keep in mind is that we are over-reliant on Baines - injury could strike.

Dick - if interested, I live 10 minutes from Colchester. Get in touch if you want to watch Everton games on TV or even better I'm happy to drive up to GP if sharing petrol costs helps? If so, email me on Regards
Roberto Birquet
658   Posted 18/02/2012 at 00:40:25

Report abuse

Why have we had so many good LBs for the past 15 years or more? But RBs??
Stephen Kenny
690   Posted 18/02/2012 at 10:11:57

Report abuse

If anybody is interested there's a fella on GOT who post an in depth match report of all our U18's games. I think he's either one of the coaches or his son plays.

His user name is alanball and there easily found. He will also answer any questions you have on the players and how they are getting on etc.

A good insight for those who want to know.
Wayne Smyth
695   Posted 18/02/2012 at 10:25:02

Report abuse

Given that we have no cover for baines at left back then its great to hear that we've got someone who could at least do a decent job.

Also considering that baines isn't the greatest defender but is very good going forward, and given Moyes preference for wingers who can help out in defence, it seems natural for Baines to move to the left wing spot over the next few years and Bidwell to be given some time at left back.

This also solves our problem of what to do when peanuts loan ends.

Moyes really needs to start looking towards the Youth system and giving these kids some time in the first team and using them the best he can. Giving Bidwell a loan spell is great for this season, but given our lack of cash it makes sense to use him in the first team and start saving 50/60k per week on journeymen loans.
Tony Cheek
696   Posted 18/02/2012 at 10:23:07

Report abuse

Great article Dick, nice to get a in-depth report on our young players out on loan. Sounds like we have a good prospect in the making there.
But, if he was back at Everton and Bainesy got injured, I am in no doubt Neville would get the nod at left back. Would be great if some of these young guns got a chance towards the end of the season, if we had our 40 points in the bag and there was nothing to play for. But, Moyes doesnt do things like that.
Vivek Bhalla
816   Posted 18/02/2012 at 20:31:29

Report abuse

As others have said, there's another promising Everton LB in Luke Garbutt who is currently on loan at League Two title-chasing Cheltenham.

Thos suggesting playing these guys at RB are forgetting we have Coleman who should develop into our long term solution for that role (I believe DM will revert him to this position once Prem teams figure out him out as a winger and/or one of Hibbet/Pip retire).

Most of our youth players that are being sent on loan are at League One and Two sides this season. Ideally, some of these will then be found Championship sides to continue their apprenticeship next season and then start breaking through to the first squad in two-three seasons time.

Either that, or be sold for a nice fee to boost DM's transfer budget.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to Fan Articles, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.

© ToffeeWeb

About these ads

Latest News

Bet on Everton and get a deposit bonus with bet365 at

Recent Articles

Talking Points & General Forum

Pinned Links


We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.