Report Dreadful deficiencies destroy Dyche's dogged defenders Everton surrendered four goals after a promising start at Old Trafford where Beto failed to take his chances. Michael Kenrick 01/12/2024 180comments (last) Manchester United 4 - 0 Everton Everton surrendered four goals after a promising start at Old Trafford where Beto failed to take his chances, the Blues gifting a flattering result with defensive errors that continued Ruben Amorim's unbeaten start to life as the new Red Devils' manager. Everton's increasingly beleaguered manager Sean Dyche, has finally dumped the seemingly uninterested Calvert-Lewin, with Beto starting as the lone and lonely striker up front. Armando Broja failed to make the bench after his run-out for the Under-21s against Nottingham Forest, but Seamus Coleman returns after his recent injury problems. The Red Devils started by somehow avoiding the obligatory ball back to their keeper, instead working it around for 89 seconds before they ventured into Everton's half. The first good cross from Dalot was cleared by Branthwaite. McNeil gave the ball to Mianoo who tested Pickford with the first shot. Going the other way. McNeil just ran in trouble and gave up the ball. But a good ball from Young was helped on by McNeil after Beto had advanced offside. An easy ball over the top found Dalot and Branthwaite was the only defender determined to stop him shooting. From the corner, Amad's volley was blocked but Everton broke through Ndiaye down the wing, Lindstrøm shot on target but from too far out, straight at Onana, no artistry or guile involved. Article continues below video content Doucoure did well to carry the ball down the wing and feed Beto, whose first shot was absolutely abysmal. At the other end, Amad had a great chance but screwed his shot across goal for what should have been a corner. Instead, Lindstrom won a corner that was easily repelled. Pickford came way out wide and was lucky that Amad's cutback was wayward. Everton had some ball possession that ended with a poor Gana pass and Rashford got behind, beating Pickford but not the brilliantly covering Branthwaite. McNeil gave Beto a ball to savour, getting round Onana, but his difficult shot was the wrong side of the post. Everton were having a nice spell of control. Branthwaite was fouled and Lindstrøm got in a decent cross but Beto was on the wrong side of the 6-yard area. Man Utd had a brief foray but overplayed it and then Ndiaye had a great chance to release Beto but botched his pass. Ndiaye then tried and failed to dribble through four defenders. A great run from Young ended when he passed straight to a defender. Rashford needed close attention at the expense of a corner, from which Rashford scored, hanging back unmarked, thanks to a big interception by Branthwaite! Oh dear... Pickford had it covered. Everton's defending became scrappy as the Reds benefited from a jolt of newfound confidence. Mykolenko took out Amad for an obvious yellow card, Pickford doing very well to clear the ball with his feet albeit Man Utd had gone offside. But playing out from the back, Branthwaite was shockingly ambushed by Amad and a second goal became inevitable for Zirkzee. Young was then bamboozled by Fernandes but recovered well enough to just avoid giving away a penalty with his late challenge on the Man Utd captain. Seems silly to say Everton had dominated much of the half when they collapsed so easily to give up two horrible goals — largely thanks to Jarrad Branthwaite. With no more than 20 seconds of the second half gone, Rashford scored easily — this time Branthwaite not at fault, although well out of position! Maino pulled back McNeil after losing the ball to him in a dangerous position. Chance for Lindstrøm to show his skill... off the wall! Beto sent Casmiro flying. He was then caught cynically by Martinez. The free-kick almost saw a chance but it was blocked. Everton kept playing on the front foot now the game was lost, Ndiaye winning a corner that was cleared for Rashford to attack, Mykolenko blocking his shot. Gana saw yellow for his battle with Amad. Pickford had to come out quickly to stall Fernandes. Beto was fouled by Casemiro, Lindstrøm showing his dubious prowess by putting it artlessly into the wall again. And Man Utd went up the other end after Amad stole the ball very easily off Tarkowski for Zirkzee to score a soft 4th. Mass substitutions accompanied a mass exit by Everton fans with 20 minutes left. Mangala did well to stop Garnacho running amok. And incredibly, even Dyche finally gave Nathan Patterson a runout. Docuoure failed to find Ndiaye with a key pass. Garnacho tried but failed to make it five. Patterson crossed far too close to Onana as O'Brien came on… Dyche using all five subs for only the second time this season. A great cross from Patterson saw a rare diving header of old by Calvert-Lewin, but it was too close for Onana not to save it. And the teams played out the final minutes, Rashford denied a late penalty claim to end a disastrous showing for the Blues. Manchester United: Onana; Mazraoui (56' Shaw), De Ligt (56' Maguire), Martinez [Y:50']; Diallo, Casemiro (66' Ugarte), Mainoo [Y:48'] (80' Mount), Dalot; Fernandes (66' Garnacho), Rashford, Zirkzee. Subs not Used: Bayindir, Malacia, Hojlund, Antony. Everton: Pickford, Young [Y:68'] (73' Patterson), Branthwaite, Tarkowski (82' O'Brien), Mykolenko [Y:39']; Ndiaye, Gueye [Y:57'] (67' Mangala), Doucoure, Lindstrøm (67' Harrison); McNeil, Beto (67' Calvert-Lewin). Subs no Used: Virginia, Begovic, Coleman, Armstrong. Reader Comments (180) Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer () Jeff Peters 1 Posted 01/12/2024 at 12:25:41 Pleased for the people who have a good feeling about today but difficult to see from the last 8 games why that would be. We shouldn't be going to bang average sides like the Mancs sitting in for a nil-nil but that's what we're likley to do and come away with a 2-nil defeat making them look good in the process. Very sad… but most likley true. Michael Boardman 2 Posted 01/12/2024 at 12:44:11 Dyche has history for this, usually whenever we play a Top 6 side away, he changes things so he gets to say "I told you they weren't ready and I know best!"It's an old Allardyce trick of keeping the "best" players for the winnable games. Colin Malone 3 Posted 01/12/2024 at 12:50:30 Doucoure. It's like Boris Johnson and Nadine Dorries. Dennis Stevens 4 Posted 01/12/2024 at 12:50:59 I hope Beto gets a goal or two. That'd shake things up a bit! Derek Knox 5 Posted 01/12/2024 at 12:56:10 Colin @ 2, Snap! At least she had a pair of tits! :-) Alan J Thompson 6 Posted 01/12/2024 at 12:56:13 Good to see the kids Bates and Dixon didn't make the bench so there's room for a second keeper…After all, what would we do with three right-backs on the bench? John Graham 7 Posted 01/12/2024 at 12:57:47 Two goalies on the bench again!Why? Jerome Shields 8 Posted 01/12/2024 at 13:00:04 Beto against Man Utd no less. Doucoure I wonder about. Jim Wilson was right midweek. Maybe they will get more space to run into. No gungho, Sean, please. Jim Wilson 9 Posted 01/12/2024 at 13:04:24 Can't understand why Mangala is not back in place of Doucoure after last week JeromeI would never start Beto and Doucoure together. Two players now in the team who struggle to control or hold a ball. Cause of the Bournemourh collapse! Jerome Shields 10 Posted 01/12/2024 at 13:06:49 Jim #8Bournemouth and Chelsea the gungho games. George Cumiskey 11 Posted 01/12/2024 at 13:10:21 Man Utd are fucked now we've got two goalies on the bench. A tactical genius! 👍 Jim Wilson 12 Posted 01/12/2024 at 13:11:08 Yes, my optimism for today has taken a very seious knock but here's hoping. COYB! Keith Gleave 13 Posted 01/12/2024 at 13:12:56 Doesn't matter whose up front with the way we play. We couldn't beat an egg. Ernie Baywood 14 Posted 01/12/2024 at 13:15:14 Let's be honest, we could predict a poor performance in this fixture without looking at the team selection. And very rarely will we be made to look silly by a sudden burst of hitherto unseen ability or ambition.So I won't go in on today's selection specifically. Except to say that I don't agree with Dyche's approach to football generally.Regardless of outcome, there has to be a setup that doesn't include Doucoure and Mykolenko. I don't fault their character or effort, but they're both levels below the Premier League. Neil Lawson 15 Posted 01/12/2024 at 13:19:55 Doucoure? Doomed. Dyche? Disaster. Jerome Shields 16 Posted 01/12/2024 at 13:28:10 Jim#8Dyche was always going to select Doucoure. But Dyche taking the game to the opposition away is a danger, because he does not provide for cover in midfield. Manalga provides cover.Attack for Dyche is Beto in front of goal and Doucoure running into the penalty area to shoot. Neil Lawson 17 Posted 01/12/2024 at 13:31:39 Being a little more constructive in my comments... swapping Beto for Calvert-Lewin. No argument but the poor bloke will be left isolated and made to look useless. (That is not an open goal for you miseries who will say he is useless anyway!) Doucoure. He has not made a meaningful contribution since returning from injury ages and ages ago. Can anyone explain just why he is selected? (Other than the obvious suggestion that Mr Dyche and Mrs Doucoure are very very close friends…) Sean O'Hanlon 18 Posted 01/12/2024 at 13:57:48 What can Ashley do for us today? Another penalty conceded, or perhaps and own goal? Derek Knox 19 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:04:45 Sean @ 18, He's never been a favourite player of mine, but in all fairness he has been okay overall. However, at 39 ,there is no way he should be our regular right back! Merle Urquart 20 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:05:38 We just can't do a simple pass when it's on for fuck's sake... It doesn't matter who it is or how much space we have, we just can't punish teams when it's on.Oh and Man Utd score... that's that then. Colin Malone 21 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:11:30 Same old Huff and Puff, Huff and Puff. Andy Mead 22 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:21:16 We were doing okay until they scored. After that, we have fallen to pieces. We have got to go 4-4-2 second half. Can't see it though… Ernie Baywood 23 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:21:30 Credit where it's due – that was a spirited effort for 25 minutes or so. Commentator claimed we had been more likely to score. I wouldn't go that far. Poor errors in defence but Man Utd have also sliced us open. A bit of quality making the difference. Kieran Kinsella 24 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:23:15 Its going well then. Colin Malone 25 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:23:28 Yes, the spirit is there… but the quality ain't. Tom Bowers 26 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:26:43 Can we fight back? Miracles accepted. Alan J Thompson 27 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:30:56 We started off well with the high press and McNeil was through but what the hell was he doing not getting a shot off? How many times are we going to miss these chances? Do we practice nothing at Finch Farm, especially putting away our easier chances?I was just thinking that Ndiaye was giving their right flank what for and then we seemed to stop feeding him and either team could be 2 or 3 up or even 3-3. McNeil had the ball out near the touchline and I thought "Play it to our man just in front and move for the return!" But, thanks to Optus's usual poor service, they were picking the ball out at our end and, from the corner replay, I wondered how many men we had between the near post and the edge of the 6-yard box when Branthwaite diverted it into the net. Then shortly after he pissed any chance of going to Man Utd with an atrocious delay to give them a second goal.Our trouble is that we don't seem to know how to use the space when attacking either outnumbering or having as many as defenders. A few times it just needed the ball pushed into the space in front of one of our players and he was through but none of them seemed to see it.I was thinking we don't deserve to be 2 down but both goals have been because of our poor play not because of anything they did. Andy Meighan 28 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:31:39 Probably the better side in that 1st half but, as soon as they scored, it all had an air of inevitability about it.Be honest: we're not getting back in this and it looks like we are in for another goalless afternoon.How hard is it supporting this club? They suck the life out of us. Joe McMahon 29 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:35:22 As some of you may know, my wife is from Burnley and is a Claret. She said to me just now "Sean Dyche hasn't evolved with the game has he, now it's Everton who just can't score" Brian Wilkinson 30 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:42:55 At 2-nil, any half-decent manager would have put Harrison and Mangala on for Lindstrøm and Doucoure at half-time. Now 3-nil down and still no reaction from our bench. Kevin Molloy 31 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:47:02 We need this takeover to go through, we are just listing now. Derek Knox 32 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:47:32 Butch Dingle (Dyche lookalike) would manage us better! Andy Meighan 33 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:54:03 I'm 65 years of age now. I've gone all my life; never thought I'd say this but I really am on the verge of leaving it now.This manager and his coaches and Thelwell suck the fucking life out of me.This was all inevitable once we went 1 down to, let's face it, a very average Man Utd side.Calling for his head is futile, he's not getting sacked even if we lose the next two — and we probably will.Sad sad times indeed for us. Bill Fairfield 34 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:54:23 Just awfully embarrassing. Andy Mead 35 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:54:48 Amateur hour. We can't take free kicks and both centre-backs have been dispossessed for 2 goals and there is the totally predictable one-for-one forward swap. Groundhog Day again and again… Ernie Baywood 36 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:56:26 Triple change from the coach.But can we get a triple change from the Board? Lee Whitehead 37 Posted 01/12/2024 at 14:56:48 Please fuck off, Dyche!!!! Andrew Bentley 38 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:00:49 The commentators comment for the first goal was “straight off the training ground”. When was the last time that phrase was ever used for an Everton goal?!? Watched and listened to most of the other Premier League games this weekend and Newcastle, Arsenal, Brentford all scored goals “straight off the training ground”. What does that useless prat and his coaching team do all day at Finch Farm? Absolutely clueless.Roll on the takeover and the removal of Dyche. How anyone can stick up for him is beyond me. 2 wins in 12 games this season, 1 in every 6 games, and we had the easiest run of fixtures on paper than anyone else did to start the season. Dave Abrahams 39 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:02:37 My stream has gone. I hope it stays missing like Everton's defence, they've been responsible for most of those goals. Really poor and unnecessary mistakes by supposedly professional footballers. Shaun Parker 40 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:04:01 Change the manager now. Get Potter in for the Wolves game.New manager bounce and grab 3 points. Simply, I've had enough of the Dyche drivel. Neil Lawson 41 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:07:10 He has to be gone before Wednesday. This idiot who shall not be named can not be allowed to lead us into guaranteed relegation. Guaranteed it is. Today is the first time that I really believe it will happen as opposed to 'may'.The man must now be dead in the water (and I was advocating removing him a long time ago when we couldn't even scrape a miserly point). Please, will someone set him adrift. The Toffeelady? Anyone??? Brian Williams 42 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:08:12 Missing like Everton's defence, they've been responsible for most of those goals, really poor and unnecessary mistakes by supposedly professional footballers.And yet some just blame the manager? How are unenforced errors and personal fuck-ups the manager's fault? Shaun Parker 43 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:09:52 Spot on from the BBC.Everton are literally unwatchable. School of Science is dead, the teams battling relegation in the '90s had bad players but managed to win with grit and determination. This lot are mediocre players with no plan or direction and don't seem to care either way. The new owners have a huge job to turn it around.How have we become so bad 🙈 Andrew Merrick 44 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:12:51 Unlucky Dom. Simon Dalzell 45 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:13:50 I'm with Shaun (40). Potter in now. Surely this is Dyche's final nail. Knowing this club, I'm not holding my breath. Sean O'Hanlon 46 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:17:23 Brian #42 - I agree. Players and their continual inept performances must also share the blame for these weekly shit-shows Simon Harrison 47 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:21:09 Joe [29],I know a Burnley season ticket holder who used to teach my daughter horse riding, and she was delighted when Dyche left Burnley; although she was appreciative of the European moments.She reckoned he was kept on too long after the takeover at Burnley.As for Everton, it just seems an exercise in futility supporting the team at the moment, if it's not Dyche picking favourites over form, it's the players letting him down by not converting chances or not being able to make a pass, or losing concentration when out of possession; or a lack of tactical substitutes or a general lack of application from the dugout or the players...The injuries at the start of the season didn't help, the sickness around Week 5 didn't help, the seemingly continual re-injury of players hasn't helped, and the lack of tactical acumen and the seemingly lack of player improvement on the training pitch certainly hasn't helped.I think Dyche is the common denominator, but the players have to take responsibility for some of their performances too. Dyche can't be held accountable for some of the piss-poor play we see from them.However, there just seems to be a general malaise on the playing field, which is surely coming from the inability to get the takeover resolved! Everything just seems to be in Limbo again! Dyche doesn't know if he'll be here or not, the players don't know if Dyche will be here or not and it shows on the field.Thelwell too, is apparently in the dark about his future, so maybe the footballing side and management are playing a 'holding pattern' till, or if, TFG's attempted takeover takes place before the end of December? Which if you read around, it seems that A-Cap and Kenneth King along with Leadenhall are trying to move the goalposts about the deal to resolve the formerly 777 Partnera debt (Circa £200M).Which until that is resolved, then the Premier League have their hands tied regards agreeing to their part of assessing the Owners and Directors Test.As I said above, it just seems an exercise in futility in supporting Everton, as it causes more blood pressure issues than resolving anything...Today isn't helping either:4-0 with a decent 20-25 minutes and then the usual capitulation once the first went in.Live in hope! COYB Ian McAvoy 48 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:25:13 Dyche has to go Now! I can't watch this type of shite, week-in & week-out. The players either aren't good enough or are being told to play in this way. Moshiri has destroyed this club! Michael Lynch 49 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:25:48 Dyche or no Dyche, this is a squad lacking in any quality whatsoever. Surely our only hope of avoiding relegation is the takeover going through and a very clever buying spree in January?Anyway, whatever, I can't see Dyche being here when Friedkin takes the reigns. We're going to be in the relegation zone by Christmas, probably a good few points off safety, it's shit or bust time. Lee Whitehead 50 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:27:36 Brian 42 & Sean 46,The manager and players are all a bunch of losers not fit to be anywhere near the club. How has it got this bad? Andy Meighan 51 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:29:44 I can't see where the next goal is coming from, let alone the next win.Yet, he's got the safest job in the game, not a prayer he's not getting sacked… I'll be massively shocked if it happens – as well as delighted.Thelwell has got a lot to answer for as well, he's bought some absolute shite: Beto and Lindstrøm to name two, yet he seems to get an easy ride.Disgraceful performance… but another in a long line. Andy Mead 52 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:31:07 McNeil laughing with Rashford with 15 minutes to go! What's so funny?Even the commentators here in Oz said that's awful. Ernie Baywood 53 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:31:47 It's not just about blaming the manager. And it's not really just about today. We know the playing staff are a level below Man Utd's.But we just had a generous run of fixtures and took nowhere near what was required. And I blame a lack of ambition for that and put it at the manager's door.What today did show us is how fragile confidence is in the team. One goal and we were finished. That's been a feature under Dyche. It's part of his job isn't it? He's supposed to get the best out of players... we're not seeing anything close to their best. Ian Bennett 54 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:32:40 Dyche Out! Frederick Parchment 55 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:33:36 Déjà vu time.This time last season, we went on a winless streak til April. Colin Glassar 56 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:34:56 Dyche Out!!! Ged Simpson 57 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:39:08 "The Club have revealed details of an exclusive membership option for a new social space..."TW headline.Where do ya reckon? Jim Bennings 58 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:41:06 I expect he'll be gone before Wednesday night. I don't know who comes in. I don't know – I don't care.But the fact is, if Dyche is still here Wednesday night, the place will become horrible very very quickly — and in a game we absolutely definitely need to win; that's the last thing we can afford.It needs to be done.You know when a manager has reached his expiration date, and this is clear as crystal now with Sean Dyche.Shake his hand, wish him well, and move on. Alan J Thompson 59 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:42:50 What can you say after that?!? Branthwaite has his worst game in an Everton shirt and the rest fall to pieces rather than helping out. I know Tarkowski was on the pitch as his name was on the team sheet and he got subbed off but, other than that, he did nothing and it's time he made way. Doucoure was his usual not-too-good self and Lindstrøm just doesn't look up to it. I've got my doubts about McNeil and, on that display, I'd prefer Beto up front over Calvert-Lewin. How can we be so wasteful up front and so poor at the back? A new manager, that would just be a start, but we need somebody who tries to put the faults right on the training ground as we still seem to be making the same poor mistakes up front. Dave Lynch 60 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:44:26 Surely he can't survive till the end of the week. Tom Bowers 61 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:47:27 Have we ever had an offense as bad as this.??The defense finally capitulated after some clean sheets and quite honestly the squad is a shambles with Dyche the head shambler.We know what has to be done but how long do we have to wait.He as stood by his favorite selections and strategies but he has failed. This was a debacle that cannot be overlooked by the board.However, I cannot see who else can do anything with this poor bunch at the moment. Jimmy Carr 62 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:51:30 Pat Nevin, commentating on 5 Live, had us holding our own until their first goal went in. He was also complimentary of Dyche's set up in trying to exploit space in wide areas against Man Utd's 3-4-3. Not that it means much now but those ranting against his tactics might acknowledge he tried something different today. He gave Beto a start, which many here have been clamouring for, and McNeil was obviously under instructions to stay close to him so he wasn't isolated.Once they scored, we showed no real appetite to get back into the game and it was a foregone conclusion. It's not just Dyche, this team is going nowhere at the moment and we need new players everywhere. Gonna be a grim month following Everton and hoping the takeover is completed. Chris Leyland 63 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:52:08 Jim (58),He won't be gone before Wednesday but he might be gone come Saturday afternoon if we get embarrassed in the derby. Surely, surely whoever is in charge of the club can see that we've gone backwards and that he is incapable of changing anything? Jim Bennings 64 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:52:14 The clean sheets we've been keeping have never convinced me.We were indebted to Pickford against Brentford and West Ham and Gordon missed a penalty for Newcastle against us.We've been up against opposition that you shouldn't be surprised if playing defensively yields clean sheets.Today and this month is a different ball game. Playing defensively will not reap any rewards. Colin Glassar 65 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:53:19 Well, I hope after that, the calls for “Beto to start”, stop. He's like 9 ft tall and still couldn't out-jump a 3-ft midget. Not only can Beto not jump, he seems to lack brain-to-feet coordination and any spatial awareness. A bit like Jack Harrison. Jim Bennings 66 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:54:16 Chris, I think it's cruel and unfair to do the same as what we did to Marco Silva. Why sack him after a derby twatting?Why not try and get the club bouncing before next Saturday?It's obvious that he will be sacked within the next month so why wait, do it now. Andy Crooks 67 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:54:50 I have supported Dyche, believed he could grind out some tough points. He can't; he has the players playing with fear. Nice guy (laugh when you get humiliated).McNeil really summed it up. They didn't believe they could win today and that is down to Dyche. His team selection was negative, strange and cowardly.Our best chance of survival, in my view, lies in him and his mates being gone today. I honestly thought we would nick a win today; now, I think it was never an option. Ian Edwards 68 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:55:16 Change the noise. Back on the grass. Small margins. We haven't scored since October. Without the points deduction we were mid-table last season. Dyche spent money in the summer and had some loan signings. All have been let-downs. Even Ndiaye has disappeared after 2 decent games. We have gone well into reverse. The club has been a basketcase ever since Moshiri sacked Martinez after he had one bad season (still better than most since) when he got 72 points and 2 semis.I haven't posted for a while as the football and results were just predictable and depressing. Even typing this feels awful. Someone needs to ring Friedkin tonight and seek permission to sack Dychesaurus. If he stays, it's fate we get relegated in our last season at Goodison Park. Brian Wilkinson 69 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:55:52 Pay Dyche the £3M or so handshake, get Moyes in as interim for now, it is our only hope, and if we get a points deduction for going over, so be it.We are so lucky the teams below us are not picking points up; something has to change and we cannot sit on our hands waiting for the new owner approval.If Moshiri has said he will turn loans into shares, if there is a delay in the ownership, then he can sack the manager. Surely the Friedkin group could have a word with Moshiri to action the sacking, even if they cover the £3M payoff. We are in deep deep trouble with this manager in charge. Jeff Spiers 70 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:56:33 Tom @61. Your last sentence sums us up. What frightens me is who would want to manage us? Kunal Desai 71 Posted 01/12/2024 at 15:58:20 An average Man Utd side who didn't get out of second gear, having played Thursday night, beat us 4-0. Frightening.This is the start of six straight defeats if there isn't a change in management. Jim Bennings 72 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:00:56 Football in the modern era is all about scoring goals, it's about entertainment, it's about scoring more goals than the opposite side these days.Nobody plays defensively anymore, it's gone out of fashion, but Dyche still thinks you can win football matches playing that style.He's never committed to the style he had at Burnley with two strikers, so he hasn't even replicated his style, he's actually regressed himself as a manager if that's humanely possible.I wouldn't even call what we play alehouse football, that was Pulis at Stoke, but at least it was productive for him.We just are a nonentity, it's nondescript dross. Lewis Barclay 73 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:04:51 Would it make sense to bring in a new manager with the run of fixtures the team have in December? I think Carsley would be a positive gamble as a managerial appointment, but how would any new boss feel presented with:“Here are a set of personalities utterly lacking in confidence and largely the same team of injury-prone players who have only just avoided relegation for the last few seasons. Can you take hold of them and try and help compete with the top five teams, based on current form, in the country over the next few weeks?" Kieran Kinsella 74 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:05:34 It's sad that, on the basis he usually avoids relegation, Dyche is here to turn out tedious crap week after week… but it is the Kenwright legacy. Simon Harrison 75 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:05:42 Lee [50] I have to agree with you in the main;Pickford – Yes, Top 8 keeper.Young (Out of Contract next June) – 39, decent but shouldn't be first choice.Tarkowski – Seems to have gone backwards this season, maybe being an Ironman all last season, and carrying a back injury for the early part (and still maybe?) has made him a liability in truth.Branthwaite (Saleable Asset) – Maybe his head has been turned? Maybe the hernia and soft tissue injuries are causing him problems? Nowhere near the heady heights of last season (maybe a blessing in disguise for us?)Mykolenko – Never looked fit in the pre-season games, and has never looked comfortable or fit this season, maybe also playing with Keane early season affected his confidence.Gana Gueye (Out of Contract next June) – Still a decent back-up player for us, but shouldn't be starting.Doucouré (Out of Contract next June) – Sadly past his best and, other than hustle and bustle, contributes little to the team now. Ndiaye – Flatters to deceive as MK is fond to say, would blossom in a different system I feel, but this system and being stuck on the left doesn't help. Would be best at the tip of a midfield 3 I think?Lindstrøm (On Loan) – Everton just persisting with the failed experiment performed at Napoli last season. Little wonder that the results are the same. Maybe Ndiaye left wing, Lindstrøm aa No 8 or 10, and Harrison right wing might be a way forward till January, and it is vital we get a right wing forward with pace! We can stand pat till the end of the season elsewhere in my opinion. Well, right-back and left-back too...McNeil – He will play 2 games at 7.5-8/10 then 4 or 6 games completely anonymous or worse as a liability...Beto – Willing, hard worker, technically lacking, and totally unsuited to this system of play.Other than that;Patterson – Too untried to tell, especially after being 'withdrawn' for not playing narrow as instructed!Coleman (Out of contract next June) – take a bow as an excellent servant, but past it, and his hamstrings seem to have gone.Dixon (U21s) – Too untried to tell, hot and cold – see Spurs and Southampton in the League Cup.Keane (Out of contract next June) – Played well this season, let down by the others around him and made a scapegoat when he wasn't at fault.O'Brien – Too untried to tell, probably not bought for this season but next. Yet, why in the name of Hades hasn't he come in as a replacement for Branthwaite or Tarkowski with their injuries this season?Iroegbunam – He has played well, but requires more cardio-vascular training and more minutes. Shame he got injured when he was in fine form. [Noe the decline in the form of Everton since his injury.]Mangala (On Loan) – After a couple of dodgy performances, he has really blossomed with Gana Gueye. Why he is a pine-rider, well ask Dyche about that one?Garner – Had a very tempestuous season being asked to play three positions and carrying a back complaint which became a full blown injury. The back complaint was apparently picked up on the 'second!' Gaffer's day!? Been missed, I'm not sure what he'd add though?Chermiti and Broja (On Loan) - Both injured before the season started, who knows? Chermiti looked good pre-season; Broja… will we ever see the 'real' Armand Broja?Calvert-Lewin (Out of contract next June) – He's been a decent servant, and integral to Benitz, Lampard and Dyche's tactics. Wants off, and who can blame him, by being played as an ariel ball winner, after 18 months under the Ancelotti's and Big Dunc and ask to score goals, not field Pickford long balls.Harrison (Loan) - Mercurial, sometimes blows hard and delivers nothing, other times is everywhere, and makes one or two key moments, i.e. interceptions, blocks, an assist or sneaks a goal.Everyone else is an U21/23 hopeful.So in truth we probably have;Pickford, Branthwaite (Asset), Managla (Loan), DCL (OOC) and NDiaye as competent EPL players.Then on the cusp or unknown;Patterson, O'Brien, Keane (OOC), Tim O, James Garner. Chermiti, Broja (Loan) and Lindstrøm (Loan).Pitiful really isn't it, Moshiri has tried but didn't have a clue, but really, fack you very much Bill. A very much controlled decline and self-enrichment plan...Sorry if this is all crap, I'm seriously getting depressed about this now. Joe McMahon 76 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:12:59 Kieran, he relegated Burnley twice, got them promoted again. But we know the season this Neanderthal was sacked, they were gone, with just 4 wins in 8 months. Colin Malone 77 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:13:09 Potter? No. Why? Brighton still doing well without him.Anyway. The nucleus of a good team is creativity in midfield but that's not in Dyche's hoofball tactics. That's why James Garner was on the bench. What is this love with Dyche and Doucoure? He puts the hard yards in, no guile, his is shite. Has he gone yet? Joe McMahon 78 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:18:56 Lewis, Carsley wants the England U21s again, that's why Coventry didn't consider him. Barry Rathbone 79 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:20:04 Over the Moshiri era we have descended to the astounding position of having only 2 players who might be first-teamers at a top-half Premier League outfit (Pickford and Branthwaite). The rest are studies in inconsistency or just not Premier League standard.We exist on prayers now because it doesn't matter who manages this outfit – without better players, the much declared prophesy of having the best ground in the Championship is becoming a real possibility.Better players please… someone, anyone!! Terry Farrell 80 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:20:25 That was a capitulation. Our 2 centre-backs lost 50-50s –which doesn't normally happen – and after that, it was game over. We need to beat those around us or we are in massive trouble. Lindstrom put a brilliant ball in at 0-0 when, if Beto had attacked near post it was a goal. Beto reacts but doesn't anticipate. Kieran Kinsella 81 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:28:22 Dyche loves to highlight our stats for shots on goal implying we are unlucky or let down by finishing. It's true we have more shots than under his predecessors. But they're not high percentage shots. Every game Gueye tries a 40-yarder knowing he succeeds once every few years. McNeil likewise tries a few worldies that come off a few times a year. Lindstrøm loves the powerful waist-high volley at the goalie's midriff… then we have our strikers. Inevitably they get the ball on the edge of the box get closed down and immediately panic and miss the goal with a snap shot. None of these repeated events are likely to lead to a goal. Aside from corners, we don't create any clear-cut high-percentage shots at all. But we can bang on “We ‘ad 10 shots on goal so on anova day 9 go in and the narrative changed d'int it?” No, it doesn't with these low-quality efforts. Raymond Fox 82 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:28:29 We were in the game till they scored; they have players that can put the ball in the net, we cant. I thought we might possibly grind a draw at best but, let's face it, the result is hardly a surprise. It's no use to keep putting all the blame on the manager, it's pretty poor when players who are very very well paid, can't, well — play!We were crap when Dyche took over, the club have bought £90M worth of players since but they have also sold £165M worth of our best players because we are strapped for cash.The players (apart from 3 or 4) are just not very good, that's the bottom line. Stu Gre 83 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:30:29 Now would be a great time to bring a new manager in. Bunch of games you aren't expected to get anything from, so lose them and it's expected – win a couple and you're a hero.Plus you get time to work out what you can have in January transfer window. Kevin Molloy 84 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:31:00 To be honest, Dyche is no longer the issue. He's gone, as soon as the takeover is announced. But this should have been announced two weeks ago, the only delay on this deal is certifying the Friedkins as fit and proper. I can only think the Premier League are dicking us around on purpose after last year. Dave Abrahams 85 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:31:59 Man Utd were not very good either for those first 30 minutes but those mistakes by Everton players gave them the confidence to play better and better with each mistake we made.Then my stream failed and never came back, the best part of another miserable day. Dyche is not helping himself picking players who are having bad spells but there is definitely not much to choose from. O'Brien at left back couldn't possibly play worse than Mykolenko, Lindstrøm has shown no sign of improving, and his free kicks get worse each time he takes one.We know Beto isn't the answer but trying him instead of Calvert-Lewin didn't make the team any worse, the way Dominic has been playing. Tarkowski could have been rested, mind you we haven't played for two weeks.Sixteen players turned out today so there wasn't much left to be fit to play, have the players given up on Dyche? Are they good enough? Will they be better for another manager? Will the board give Dyche and his assistants the boot before Christmas? When will this bleedin misery end for us fans?— Surely the last 30 years has been enough. I bet you those bastards are winning today! Joe McMahon 86 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:35:43 Lovely stat from the BBC: Man Utd have now beaten Everton 42 times in the Premier League, the highest tally of any side against one opponent in the competition. Those getting moist over Moyes return, your boy had a big part in that. Frederick Parchment 87 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:37:45 Even their new manager knew they would beat us. He stated "No excuses if we don't beat Everton."When we go up in games, teams find a way to come back against us. When we go down a goal, it's emag revo. Game Over.Dyche's brand of football: Yuck. And Fuck.Forget Moyes, for those calling him out. He had a dream team to work with at Old Trafford until we beat him and them in his last game in charge.Our history says former players win us things. But those former players came from a winning mentality. Our past players who could manage us have won nothing to build from. We are a club whose fan base hold on to the past of the '80s and successful years prior with adoration. Another thing that bothers me a lot is the acquisition of young players, who for some reason never fulfill their potential here, but move on and find their success. Most of which never really played for us. Just sat on the bench.When we buy seasoned players, they are injured and of no use to us for many games or years. This is a different team than last season but Dyche still picks yesteryear's players.It feels like a home drumming by Liverpool is the answer to our misery for Dyche's removal. Dyche has surpassed all other failing managers before him and still has his job. How the fuck does that happen?My rambling is over. Group hug. Rob Dolby 88 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:42:06 I am struggling to understand why we went toe to toe for the first 30 minutes, yet, when we play at home to lesser teams, we sit behind the ball.Individual mistakes and a lack of cutting edge are not a good combination in this league. I'd rather us sit deep and pack the midfield, we are far too easy to play against.Today was a free hit; Wednesday is a different story, we can't get beat. Luke Welch 89 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:46:29 I still don't know what 'Dyche fit' means. John Keating 90 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:48:15 I think his departure will come after the Wolves game if we don't pick up 3 points. Problem is: Who is there that can make a decision like that???I can't argue that the manager is ultimately responsible but the players really need to look at themselves.I don't even want to think about next weekend, whether he's there or not. Mike Gaynes 91 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:49:21 We should have signed Oviedo. Julian Wait 92 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:49:55 Rooney will be available to replace Dyche soon enough… What could possibly go right? Frederick Parchment 93 Posted 01/12/2024 at 16:55:42 Rob,#89,We couldn't beat 10-man Brentford. We've not scored in three consecutive games. The only way we win Wednesday is that Wolves forfeit. I'll even stick my neck out, if Dyche is still with us when the FA Cup begins, we'll probably get a lower to non-league side, at home, set up as though we're playing Man City, and ultimately lose the game. That's how much confidence I have in that mother sucker. Dyche out. Should've happened before the season started. Mike Hayes 94 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:00:44 Dyche needs to go and quick – he hasn't got a clue.You knew it was going to be a loss having Doucoure in and 2 goalies on the bench.The man is a fucking dinosaur clown. Get Out Now, Dyche!!! Jim Bennings 95 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:07:06 Fred @94,Hate it break it to you, mate, but it's 4 games without a goal – not 3, lol. Minik Hansen 96 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:08:14 Jim #72,You saved my day; “He's actually regressed himself as a manager if that's humanely possible.”A little laugh, cheered me up. Bring on Wednesday, because it'll be closer to the supposed takeover. COYB Mark Tanton 97 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:09:03 Clearly we missed Calvert-Lewin's firepower. Jimmy Carr 98 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:11:45 If Dyche goes before the takeover, then the new manager has to be Friedkin's choice, right? So how that works exactly, I don't know, but it won't be any of the names being bandied about on here. I'd be expecting an Italian manager or someone who's been managing in Italy. That rules out Dithering Dave and Graham 'my beard is perfectly manicured and do you like my knitwear?' Potter. Dyche gets criticised for being unimaginative but people here want to go backwards to Moyes?!? Really? Or they recommend Potter because Brighton passed it around nicely, didn't they? For fuck's sake!I still expect Dyche to be here until the takeover is confirmed. Might be wrong, dunno, just hope Friedkin is not as clueless at picking managers as our current owner. Or some on ToffeeWeb. And we'll still need a shedload of new players, whoever the next patsy is in the dugout. Frederick Parchment 99 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:13:00 Jim,Things are worse than I thought. Dyche thinks wearing a tracksuit will automatically win us games. Especially when we can't score a goal, in 4 games in a row now.Thanks for the correction, Jim. Jim Bennings 100 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:16:19 Jimmy,Most on ToffeeWeb could probably run the club better than the absolute circus it is.I don't want Moyes but he's a million times the manager that Cro-Magnon Dyche is.Going back to Moyes is not what I want, and we won't, I don't think, but keeping Dyche and then proceeding to question going backwards to Moyes, who actually made most of his players better, or questioning Graham Potter, instantly tells me you are arse talking.Dyche is one of the most pragmatic boring managers the Premier League has ever witnessed, he's up with Tony Pulis.He's a myth because the media love him, a bit like Big Sam, they are scared to question him properly. Ashley Roberts 101 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:17:51 Dyche is going to be in the dugout until the takeover. That is a given because The Friedkin Group will want to have their own choice of manager in charge. I agree, it is a big No to Potter and Moyes for me. The game against Wolves is a huge 6-point game. I just hope playing under the lights in the Old Lady works in our favour. Danny Baily 102 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:19:54 That wasn't a good day at the office, to say the least. Wolves is a must-win, as was Brentford. Only this time, fail to win and I think Dyche will get the boot. It's a results business, and there's little prospect of us staying out of the relegation zone over Christmas if we fail to beat Wolves.Looking at the relegation wall chart, we're already toast (that is, we don't have enough winnable home games to get to 10 wins). Fail to win midweek and we'll need some pleasant surprises in terms of results to avoid the drop. Soren Moyer 103 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:19:58 We can blame players as much as we want but they are not as bad as we think. It's all Dyche and his tactics! Someone please send him on gardening leave at least! He'll take us down. Brian Williams 104 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:25:22 Is it though, Soren? Were two of today's goals not down to individual errors?Surely that's down to the player and the player alone. No amount of tactics can account for errors. Jimmy Carr 105 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:31:44 Jim (102), so just remind me where I said we should keep Dyche? You're confusing your dislike of Dyche with a rational idea of what is needed to take the club forward. It's convenient to blame everything on the manager but the fact is we've been shit for a number of years, unless you've not noticed, and during that time we've had a number of different managers. Thinking a Moyes or a Potter would somehow solve the shit-fest that is Everton FC is wishful thinking at best. The club needs new players and an executive management team serious about implementing a different ethos from top-to-bottom at the club to have any chance of us recovering our former status. Potter succeeded at Brighton partly because he had a functioning structure around him, do you think we have that at Everton? Moyes merely represents the past, he also served up some unwatchable crap while he was manager. Neither are the answer in my view. My point about Dyche is that, while the ownership of the club is up for grabs, he may continue to escape the sack temporarily. As you seem extremely confident that you'd be able to run the club better than the current owner, I'm surprised you haven't clocked that basic principle. Soren Moyer 106 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:33:48 Brian,When you have a clueless man in charge of the team, anything is possible. Players have no confidence and really look confused at times! Look how Iwobi turned out after leaving us!!! Mick O'Malley 107 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:36:03 Dyche trotting his go-to excuse of "It was like this 4 years ago."Well you were brought in to improve things and you haven't. You've brought players here who you wanted, bu you never change fuck-all. I honestly can't believe any Everton fan wants this prick in charge a second longer. I absolutely despise him with a passion and can't wait til he is chased —him and his shit coaching team who have us playing shithouse football. Our fans deserve so much better. I don't mind losing but, for fuck's sake, 7 wins a year… just resign, you odious prick. Derek Taylor 108 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:37:10 News circulating yesterday seemed to indicate that 11th January is the expected date for the ordaining of TFG so little prospect of things improving much before then.If this delay is attributable to the Premier League comics it's truly a scandal! Michael Lynch 109 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:41:11 Seriously, Derek? Where did you hear that?We need to takeover to happen in the next 2 weeks so the new ownership can hit the ground running in the transfer window, and make whatever changes necessary to keep us in the Premier League. If that's even possible at this stage. Kim Vivian 110 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:53:30 Has anyone actually answered the question: "If Dyche is to be sacked before the takeover is closed, who will be pulling the trigger?" Presumably, the answer is Moshiri, and that, from my perspective, means it ain't happening. The takeover has to be completed with utmost haste. I've no idea exactly what the hold-up is (does anyone beside the actual protagonists?) but I am very fearful that there may be somebody getting cold feet. With the evident 'clout' that TFG supposedly have, surely they have the means and motive to expedite the deal. I just worry, with the way the dice has rolled over the past few years, that this might just go tits up. We would not recover from that. Besides the stadium, the entire Everton package appears to offer a very unappealing proposition just now. The team has somehow got to change that and offer a faint glimmer of hope sometime very soon.Changing the subject – I am tired of hearing this comment..."Pat Nevin, commentating on 5 Live, had us holding our own until their first goal went in..." or variations of that theme.Christ's sake, Wayne Rooney's Plymouth were "holding their own" before conceding 6 the other night. I know what people are trying to say but talk about stating the fucking obvious. I'm bloody livid tonight. Something has to happen. Pete Neilson 111 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:55:04 For 25 minutes or so, we were playing pretty well but never really threatened a goal. No serious intent. Then mistakes and collapse. We've a poor team but Lindstrøm is a big disappointment for me, he seems far too lightweight for the Premier League. I thought Beto did as well as Calvert-Lewin would have. I'm weondering if lack of runners and players making themselves available is down to the defensive positioning the team is coached in and terrified of varying from (even though it isn't working)? Bagging a free parking space was invariably the highlight of the afternoon. On we go against Wolves which does seem like a must-win even though there are other shockingly poor teams around. Colin Glassar 112 Posted 01/12/2024 at 17:57:45 Can we put Pep out of his misery and offer him a short-term, results related, contract? James Hughes 113 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:06:23 I have only seen the brief highlights on the official site but it seems clear that the team are not fighting. They are not playing for each other and it is all awful. I'm normally the optimist but now I am more than a tad worried. I think Dyche has lost the fans and the fans are not backing the team in the same way. So the team are just not there in any way, shape or form. It really is time for a change… but I suspect it won't happen. Bill Gall 114 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:07:43 Derek #110, In another article, I wrote that I believed that someone in the FA had an agenda against Everton, and the delay for new ownership is a legal move to slow down the new ownership. Dyche has lost the players and is losing the fans, as his reluctance to change his system and tactics is beyond him as he only knows one way to play, and it is becoming easier for opposition managers to set their teams up.If a change in manager is going to happen, it has to be done as soon as possible to avoid what is starting to become a relegation possibility.It is no longer dwelling on what Dyche achieved last season; we have to look at the future and presently the future looks bleak. I will hold my hand up and admit that I thought that Dyche would be the manager to do better this season but, even with signing some new players, the standard and intensity of play has diminished drastically and something has to change quickly. Jeff Armstrong 115 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:08:19 Kim @112, You're quite correct, we were holding our own at 0-0, until the inevitable first goal goes in. From then on, we just don't seem to be able to change the game.We hardly ever equalise, or turn it around to a winning situation. 0-0 to 1-0 usually ends up at 4-0 against Top 10 sides, the first goal is crucial. David West 116 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:08:22 TFG need to get hold of Moshiri and tell him to get rid of Dyche, tell him who to replace him with, or they may be buying a Championship club!!! I'm not having this "he can't be sacked" bollocks!! He can't be kept is the real truth! We could be in serious trouble come January… then what? What players are you going to attract? If any? It's going to be a long month. Frederick Parchment 117 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:09:27 Liverpool gets a new manager and looks likely to win the Premier League at his first attempt. Former player, no. We get what? And for how many years?Since the introduction of the Premier League, we have regressed to what? I don't know. A whole generation of fans only know the shit Everton. I don't know the answer to our mess. But I sense that our future lies with our home supporters. Oust this man out by making noise. Like we did to Sam, Benitez and others before, when the standards had truly disintegrated.Get out, Sean. Pack your bags and leave. Derek Taylor 120 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:23:07 Michael @111; The Guardian ran a story which referred to this date and some discussion took place on here following Moshiri's announcement that he would convert debt to equity if the deal was not completed by the cut-off date of 11 January.All seems a bit worrying to me because, by that date, it may be too late to hope for anything but a miracle! Danny Baily 121 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:23:57 Lose to Wolves, then maybe we could hit the eject button on Dyche. But he's earned that game. Just like Lampard earned his home fixture against Wolves a few years back.Failure to sack Lampard after that game nearly cost us dearly. We should be prepared to act swiftly on Wednesday night.The finest of margins separate wins from draws. A couple of wins from the preceding fixtures and we'd be in a comfortable position. But we didn't get the wins, we are where we are, and results dictate that Dyche must go if he fails to get the win midweek. Alan McGuffog 124 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:34:40 I've defended Dyche to some extent over the months, directing my ire at the useless bunch of second-raters who wear the shirt on the pitch.Enough is enough and he needs to be jettisoned, and soon. But please, as others have asked, who is there at the club who is in the position to do the deed? David West 127 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:45:24 Alan 126. Don't you think TFG could be on the phone with Moshiri tonight.? Saying "Listen... get him to fuck!! We are not interested in buying a Championship club." Why is he still there? Surely they have to be consulting with the club on any major issues and decisions being taken during the takeover process? So why can't they say... "Him out... him in... we know it will have a price financially but that price is worth paying to stay in the Premier League, stay above the main relegation scrap, and we will be able to attract some players in January"? If TFG are confident of Moshiri and this club making the right decisions,then we may not be getting the owners we think. Act now!!! Charles Ward 129 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:48:31 Wolves is a must-win. They have a dreadful defensive record – the worst in the League – but have scored twice as many goals as us.Make of that what you will but, if they score first, it will be truly draining. Fred Quick 130 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:52:42 I didn't bother with any domestic footy on the telly today, and unfortunately my decision has been well and truly justified. I wasn't expecting a heavy defeat at Old Trafford, as Man Utd have hardly been pulling up trees in recent months, but neither was I expecting Everton to come away with all the points.Starting Beto at Old Trafford instead of Dominic Calvert-Lewin is a worrying decision by Dyche; if he wanted to give Dominic a kick up the ass, he should have done it weeks ago, prior to the so-called easier fixture list, not now when we're facing a tough run of games. When a manager starts tinkering with his team, it means he doesn't have a clue how to fix the issues his team have, particularly when he only gives opportunities to players such as Patterson when the game has already been lost. Dyche may survive until Christmas, he may even survive until the end of the season, but the more important thing is: Will Everton survive? If nobody is in place to make a change or if nobody at the club wants to make a change, then they'd better start planning for the Championship and how to escape from that division. As it stands, I can't see how we could even give those teams in the Championship a game, so it would be best for the club if we at least tried to stay in the top-flight.Most of us know we aren't good enough, but we can't allow the players to show a lack of pride in the shirt they wear, and I just get the feeling that is what's happening before our very eyes. Wolves on Wednesday is the biggest fixture we've faced so far this season, and its importance to the club is far greater than any upcoming derby game. We have to win on Wednesday, by hook or by crook, because if we don't, that would be 2 wins from 14 and that's definitely relegation form. Jay Evans 131 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:55:53 Lots of anger and ire on here — understandably.Serious questions though:1) Who sacks him? Thelwell? Never. My guess is that he will be on his way as well as Dyche once the Spitfire lands. Chong? I can't see it myself. An interim CEO who may be holding the reins ‘officially' but whose only actual remit is delivering the new stadium on schedule.2) Who replaces him? No decent coach in their right mind would fancy this shit show and who could blame them? Also, who negotiates with our incoming saviour? Thelwell? Chong? I refer you back to Question 1.One final point: If you ever needed something to sum up this current team, just have a look at our Captain's ‘challenge' which led to the fourth goal today… Now there's a man for a battle. Julian Exshaw 133 Posted 01/12/2024 at 18:59:12 What frustrated me was the fact that we were beaten by probably the worst Man Utd side I've ever seen. We actually outplayed them for the first 30 minutes. Generally, we start most games pretty well ('pretty well' is relative to what we've had to witness in the last 3 years!). Mark Murphy 136 Posted 01/12/2024 at 19:02:54 I've finally admitted to my (southern born) wife that I'm actually fucking relieved I don't live up north now. I can fend off the gloating telly Kopites and plastic Mancs by asking what the fuck it has to do with them anyway but, if I had to walk amongst them, I'd either get arrested for GBH or hospitalised, more likely, for attempted.I'm embarrassed at what we've become. We are a laughing stock in the North and an irrelevance in the South. I wish I didn't care, but I'm hurting. I'm supposed to be on a six-day dry run. That ended at full-time. Sam Hoare 149 Posted 01/12/2024 at 19:54:06 The owners, current and probably future, will have been desperate for Dyche to build upon last season and finish his contract with a solid 10-14th league position. But we have regressed. And look as bad currently as we did under Lampard.I think it's unlikely that Dyche would be fired till the new owners are in place but a loss against Wolves might force the situation.If the rumours of a Concecaio, Terzic, Sarri and Potter is true that's encouraging. I'd be excited to see what Concecaio could do if we were able to persuade him. Rob Dolby 152 Posted 01/12/2024 at 20:00:18 I am not exonerating Dyche from all blame – after all, he is the manager… but 3 gifted goals, 2 from our £70M rated centre-back. Many Man Utd fans will be glad they never bought him on that display. Our Captain's Cryuff turn shit-bag attempt for their fourth surely can't be blamed on Dyche.If Keane had played like Branthwaite today, every other post would be slaughtering him, though as it is, he has been barely mentioned.Big game on Wednesday; I think the only change I would make is Mangala in for Lindstrøm. Pack the midfield and make the opposition work for it. Mike Connolly 155 Posted 01/12/2024 at 20:11:09 Rob, "make them work for it"? We're at home to Wolves – the opposition should be making us work for it. That is how far we have sunk. Ernie Baywood 159 Posted 01/12/2024 at 20:20:32 We are trying to break this pattern of work for a breakthrough, drop down, breakthrough, drop down.I haven't watched the video of Dyche's interview so does anyone know what this means? Was he rapping? Rob Dolby 160 Posted 01/12/2024 at 20:23:23 Mike 157, I agree but that's where we are as a club. Back to basics if that's even possible and cut out the individual mistakes, play a % game and see what gives. Tony Hughes 162 Posted 01/12/2024 at 20:24:52 Crapping I think Ernie Kieran Kinsella 163 Posted 01/12/2024 at 20:25:13 Brian Williams and Rob Dolby,True we can't blame Dyche for Branthwaite's errors. But we can blame him for setting out his stall to get 0-0 against mediocre or rubbish teams we've already played. Anthony Dove 164 Posted 01/12/2024 at 20:36:51 Man Utd were abysmal until they scored but we still couldn't find the net. Luckily, they played out the final 20 minutes as a training exercise. Humiliating. Peter Mills 165 Posted 01/12/2024 at 20:38:21 I drove past the Liver Building at 5:00 pm and it was bathed in red lights. Rob Dolby 166 Posted 01/12/2024 at 20:38:55 Kieran, I didn't exonerate Dyche, the football is turgid stuff.Mistakes happen in football, the team that makes the least mistakes tends to win.We need to cut out the mistakes and start being hard to beat. I couldn't understand why we were so open in the game compared to our previous matches, especially at home to lesser teams. Frederick Parchment 167 Posted 01/12/2024 at 20:48:40 Under Dyche's gleaming head, we can't even beat bottom-of-the-table sides. Southampton home and away ring a bell? Okay. I was encouraged by our first 25 minutes or so. But then everything fell into place.1 lone striker. 65 minutes gone, 4-0 down. Now we substitute. Do we play with 2 strikers? No. It's like he saying to the fans indirectly "I'm playing your players but the result is the same."I'm tired of watching an excellent club being the joke of the Premier League. Last week, we opened up the same way, encouraging performance to start, but only flattered to deceive.I once watched us play, with the notion if we played well enough, we could get a positive result. Under this idiot, that passion has all but gone. To be happy with a defeat so as to remove our manager is sacrilegious, but how much are we to endure before we cut him loose? John Dean 168 Posted 01/12/2024 at 20:48:57 There is an informative comparison to be made between Dominic Calvert-Lewin's diving header (which was saved easily) from a cross wide on the right wing and an almost identical cross from wide on the right wing which Braiden Graham also met with a full-length diving header that flew into the top right-hand corner, leaving the goalkeeper with no chance of making a save. It was Everton U18s' fourth goal in the dying minutes of the game to secure a point having come from 4 - 0 down against West Ham. Braiden knows how to score and Dom does not. Gerry Quinn 169 Posted 01/12/2024 at 21:01:59 Peter 165 - were you serious or just joking about the colour of the lights on the Liver Building? I thought that it was owned by us... Fred Quick 170 Posted 01/12/2024 at 21:03:03 Whether we like it or not, whether the decision to sack comes or doesn't come in the near future, Dyche is now in dismissal territory having amassed just 11 points from 13 games. Mike Walker is the only manager to have Everton on less points at this stage in a Premier League season, with 7 points. It wouldn't be so bad if we had seen some green shoots of recovery during this season, and we all had something to cling onto. A side lacking in goals and beginning to show the deficiencies in the back-line, which in truth have been there all season, isn't going to be solved easily, either by Dyche or by somebody else. I believe we're at the point where Sean Dyche is less likely to turn things around than a new face and new voices out on the training pitch might be able to. Andy Meighan 171 Posted 01/12/2024 at 21:04:41 Wolves have been leaking goals for fun this season. They must be rubbing their hands at the thought of playing goal-shy Everton nil on Wednesday.On another note, those calling for his head – and I'm one of them – are pissing in the wind; not a prayer he's getting sacked.We're stuck with the clown, and I could be wrong here – didn't TGF say they'll keep him til the end of the season?All well and good but expect to be playing our first season at the new stadium in the Championship. Brendan McLaughlin 172 Posted 01/12/2024 at 21:08:10 Peter #165 and Gerry #169"World Aids Day" and red is the colour.We have offices there but not sure we own the Liver Building though, Gerry. Ian Bennett 173 Posted 01/12/2024 at 21:20:44 11 points, and we've played the weaker teams.Come the New Year, you can see this squad being rock bottom on 11 points. It lacks quality, and now lacks fight. It's hard to see who is going to lift the performances. Raymond Fox 174 Posted 01/12/2024 at 21:22:50 There's very few mentions of our players in the thread, you know – the ones that actually play the game.We have had more managers than hot dinners with feck all change in our status. Another patsy will not miraculously make our players more skilled – which the lack of, is the real problem.Luckily, there are 5 more teams in the Premier League that are just as crap as us. Brian Wilkinson 175 Posted 01/12/2024 at 21:23:56 Be careful out there this time of year.Only left my door open for a few minutes and someone took my Take That Greatest Hits CD – where my season ticket was hid.A day later, someone pushed my season ticket back through the letterbox…The Take That CD, however, is still missing. :-) Ernie Baywood 176 Posted 01/12/2024 at 21:29:06 I've watched his interviews now, though I can't find the one where he starts rapping.Changing the narrativeI've talked about this endlessly That's the hardest thing for a managerI've been in this league a long timeIt's been a problem since before I arrivedSame old story.It's horrifying to think that he probably won't be sacked. It should have happened last season when we were also appalling for a long stretch. Obviously there are some poor teams in this league, hence we are 15th... but that really could change in the next month. If we really want to change 'the story', then we need to move on the guy who is telling it. His exit can't come soon enough. Brendan McLaughlin 177 Posted 01/12/2024 at 21:34:45 Patience, Brian #175 Andy Meighan 178 Posted 01/12/2024 at 21:35:16 Raymond @174.At the moment, we are the worst side in the Premier League.At least the sides below manage to score goals; I think there's only 1 other side in the Premier League that's scored the same amount as us.A disgraceful stat and all down to one man – Dyche. I honestly think he'd be delighted with drawing every game 0-0.I don't know how we get out of this with this manager in charge because we don't look like weve got a goal in us – let alone a win. Tom Bowers 179 Posted 01/12/2024 at 21:40:31 Dyche may have his faults and his first-team choices have been limited to sadly mostly second-rate players and of course by the usual injuries that most clubs have.It's hard to believe he will be around much longer and he will probably do well back in the Championship.Everton have had a lot of managers, it's true, but so have Chelsea who have done so much better over the last 10 years.The difference is money. When you can splash it out, you can attract the best players but Everton's financial problems leave them for the most part getting the dregs left available.I also think Everton's scouting is sub-par.Hopefully, the New Year will see the kind of improvement all around that we all want. Mal van Schaick 180 Posted 01/12/2024 at 21:58:26 A typical pragmatic interview from Dyche where he picks out his own highlights, and then blames the players for their mistakes. No chance of him going down with a sinking ship.How Dyche can emerge with any credit from that shit show is beyond me. Peter Mills 181 Posted 01/12/2024 at 22:05:46 Brendan#172, thank you for that information. The lighting puzzled me, Im glad to see it was for a worthy purpose. Brian Wilkinson 182 Posted 01/12/2024 at 22:06:20 There is no other manager, even in none league football that would not make a couple of substitutes at ht at 2 nil down. To still dither on the touchline at 4 nil and wait until 67 minutes before finally making changes is beyond madness.For all Martinez faults towards the later end of his management, he never once threw a player under the bus and it was always we or us when he talked about Everton.Dyche has blamed everyone bar himself, the players, been like this before I came, well you have been here 2 years and fixed nothing.When we win it is all down to him, lose and its everyone elses fault.Next Saturday is our last ever league merseyside derby, the fans will do everything they can, the players will be up for it, and if we pull another result out of the bag, will all be down to the Manager, in his own words.He put Patterson and O,Brien on, does anyone think either of those two will get a start on Wednesday, Tarkowski has been poor all season, yet Keane who to be fair had been playing well gets dropped.A must win game weds, a few simple tweaks, bring Keane back in for Tarkowski, give Patterson a run out at right back, drop Doucoure for Mangola, I would even consider dropping Mykolenko and switching Young to left back, sure we could tweak a couple more but my gut feeling is he will start with the same 11 again, or just change Beto for Dom with the other 11 unchanged. Derek Knox 183 Posted 01/12/2024 at 22:06:24 Brian W @ 175, little sympathy from me. What did you expect when the Instructions were on the CD and Season Ticket ?Take That ! :-)It's a pity Dyche doesn't have a UB40 CD ! Brian Wilkinson 184 Posted 01/12/2024 at 22:10:22 He put it in an envelope Derek, it said sorry I was weak, I was desperate, but not that desperate, left me a fiver donation and said you poor barsteward, have a drink on me. Derek Knox 185 Posted 01/12/2024 at 22:12:19 Brian, the War's over, what did he expect you would get for a fiver ? :-) Michael Kenrick 186 Posted 01/12/2024 at 22:15:58 Derek Taylor @108 and @120, and others responding about the 11 January date that has appeared in some news stories — this is not the projected date of TFG's takeover. Most sources tracking the takeover still predict it being approved by the middle of December, although there are no guarantees that this is what the Premier League are or will work to…But put that aside — the 11 January date relates to shareholder loans, not TFG's takeover: Any Shareholder loan that was entered into before 22 November 2024 and which is replaced with other forms of financing (e.g. by way of conversion to equity or repayment) within 50 days (i.e. by 11 January 2025) will not be required to be submitted as an APT or assessed for FMV.Any Shareholder loan that was entered into after 14 December 2021 but before 22 November 2024 and remaining in effect on 11 January 2025 must be submitted as an APT. Mike Price 187 Posted 01/12/2024 at 22:33:14 Ive been banging on for years about how unbelievably bad Mykolenko is. Hes one of the worst footballers Ive ever seen; so how a defensive manager cant see how bad he is, is beyond comprehension. Ian Pilkington 188 Posted 01/12/2024 at 22:35:42 Michael@186Thank goodness for that.The deal was announced publicly on 23rd September, 10 weeks ago tomorrow.Ratcliffes deal to purchase 25% of Manure took 9 weeks.Surely we shouldnt have to wait much longer. Jim Wilson 189 Posted 01/12/2024 at 22:48:10 Rob @ 152 - I think Mangala in for Lindstrom Wednesday night and pack the midfield is an excellent suggestion. Brendan McLaughlin 190 Posted 01/12/2024 at 22:54:38 Ian #188Moshiri issued a statement as to how Everton would respond to the new Premier League rules under his watch if the takeover hasn't been completed by 11 January.Why?I think we're going to have to wait a bit longer Fred Quick 191 Posted 01/12/2024 at 23:05:22 According to Dave Powell of the Liverpool Echo, in response to the Guardian's 'exclusive' reported:But in committing to convert his loans to the club into shares before the deadline, even if the TFG deal hasnt come to a successful conclusion by January 11, the club would be shielded from incurring such a cost burden.The expectation from sources close to the deal is that it may well be a moot point, with Moshiri having committed to make that move some time ago, and confidence remaining high that regulatory approval will arrive within the initial timeframe that the potential new US owners had been working towards.The 'some time ago' line in the final paragraph is possibly open to interpretation, was it days before the Guardian's report or possibly weeks or months? Don Alexander 192 Posted 01/12/2024 at 23:22:53 Just watched MotD and was pleasured by seeing goal of the month, in which we didn't feature at all for a change (ha-ha), but then got to wondering whether those at Finch Farm think it's called "Can We Score A Goal This Month"?Just asking. Brendan McLaughlin 193 Posted 01/12/2024 at 23:25:25 Interesting Fred #191I certainly had been taken in by the Guardian article.All spin perhaps... Brendan McLaughlin 194 Posted 01/12/2024 at 23:30:45 Don #192Doesn't happen often at our age... just enjoy being "pleasured". Ernie Baywood 195 Posted 01/12/2024 at 23:51:00 Mike 187 - Myko is pretty game, but he's been dreadful since the minute he arrived. He's so far away from the level required that I just can't understand him being picked.I've advocated for all sorts of formation changes purely to find a way to get him off the pitch.His part in the third goal also seems to be being overlooked. He put Tarkowski in a terrible position when there were forward passes that only required a reasonable level of football ability. Just turn and play the pass... instead he plays a hospital pass back. It's standard Mykolenko kind of stuff. Don Alexander 196 Posted 01/12/2024 at 23:54:29 Brendan, I always have, as have more than a few other sheep farmers. Matt Smith 197 Posted 02/12/2024 at 00:52:24 Ernie #195> instead he plays a hospital pass backWas about to say the same thing. He is so scared of losing the ball it's his first instinct. There was actually no one on him.With the 2nd goal - Young/Branwaite should be able to handle 1 ManU player - simple training ground stuff - but instead he puts a tiny bit of pressure on them and wins the ball, both trying to pass it backwards. Pickford shouldn't have passed it to Young in the first place. The ManU player probably knew this and hedged his bets.And if Tarkovski hasn't got the energy or speed to stop Rashford getting that ball for the 3rd - everyone knew Rashford was going to get a pass - or at the very least get in Rashford's face and make him work for it. But instead Tarkovski just gave up and looked exhausted.BTW - who is the gentleman with the spectacles that Mr. Dyche keeps speaking to under his hand? I find it funny when this chap doesn't speak under his hand to respond. Alan J Thompson 198 Posted 02/12/2024 at 02:56:51 Matt(#197); I find this covering of the mouth by Dyche to speak to the man next to him as very strange as every manager in the Premier League know how he plays and what his options are and the only thing that might surprise them is if he used one of the two keepers on the bench as an outfield player possibly striker as we don't seem to have one of them.Oh, and I notice this covering of the mouth has now spread to some of the players who must be talking a better game than they are playing. Christine Foster 199 Posted 02/12/2024 at 04:14:48 I was stuck in the Wup Wups this weekend, no internet, no phone. Just as well… first game I have missed in years.I wrote an article a month back re the forthcoming fixtures, replacing Dyche with an interim manager till next season.Since then all we got was the backing of the board and a single point. Worse still, if it's possible to play worse then we have done so.We are running out of time, if we get beat by Wolves and the other lot, it won't be cushions raining down from the stands, it will be the bloody seats!Someone has to make a decision… the longer it's left, the less chance of surviving a relegation fight.. Steve Brown 200 Posted 02/12/2024 at 04:51:52 Brendan, re the Liver Buildings.Corestate Capital currently owns 35% of the building while Mr Moshiri owns 49.9%. It is understood that the other 15.1% is owned by a group of international investors. Mike Gaynes 201 Posted 02/12/2024 at 06:21:24 Okay, so here's the latest from Rumor (sorry, Rumour) Central:The New York Times reported a few weeks ago (I can't remember if I posted about it or not) that TFG hired Nolan Partners, one of the top sports executive headhunters in football, to find a new CEO for Everton. They have in the recent past found various executives for Chelsea, Newcastle, Southampton, Inter, Monaco, US Soccer and the MLS clubs in Vancouver and Houston.One name reportedly popping up on Nolan's target list is Dane Murphy, former CEO at Forest when they won promotion to the Premier League. He's now working as a consultant to the American company that owns AC Milan. The Friedkins know him well. And I actually saw him on TV once, on the Men in Blazers show (Yank Evertonians will know). He looks about 17 but came off as a very bright guy. Just food for speculation.PS... I found the interview clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=29z_R6Uk3Bc Mark Murphy 202 Posted 02/12/2024 at 07:40:17 Yay! The world needs more Murphys!UTFMT Colin Glassar 203 Posted 02/12/2024 at 07:45:15 Are you sure it's not Danny Murphy, Mike? That would be typical Everton. David Stranack 204 Posted 02/12/2024 at 08:22:15 Sorry that's a no from me (for Dane Murphy). He clearly knows what he's talking about, very articulate, hungry and driven.(regardless I saw him in my 15 year old lads after school table tennis team last week).I digress... So he's obviously not a fit for our beloved blues. Next? 😶 Paul Hewitt 205 Posted 02/12/2024 at 08:36:59 Well, if he's not sacked today, then serious questions need asking of this board and even TFG. Why the Friedkins are spending hundreds of millions on a business but just watching it crumble, is baffling. The only reason I can see why TFG haven't sacked Dyche is because the deal isn't going smoothly. Alan McGuffog 206 Posted 02/12/2024 at 08:49:45 When will our final game at Goodison be played if we get to Wembley on 17th May?I'm here all week, folks!!! Kim Vivian 207 Posted 02/12/2024 at 08:49:47 Paul, 205, whisper it quietly but I am really worried about that as well, as I've said elsewhere. Hoping its just the general malaise causing this uncharacteristic pessimism. Rob Halligan 208 Posted 02/12/2024 at 09:09:24 Im not defending Mykolenko for his overall performance, but I will defend him in his part for the fourth goal. The lad was hemmed in right on the touchline, with Diallo right behind him, and not a chance in turning to play the ball down the line. Rashford comes across to attempt to win the ball but misses it, leaving Myko with an easy pass to Tarkowski, who totally shit out, letting Diallo take it off him and a clear run on goal.Theres a golden rule in football…….always play the ball the way you are facing. Granted, not always, but in this instance Myko played the right pass. If Tarkowski had put his foot through the ball and cleared it down the line, the fourth goal does not happen. Sean Kelly 209 Posted 02/12/2024 at 09:35:04 The day after that disaster doesnt feel any better. As a club and a fan base we are like rabbits stuck in the head lights just waiting to be scraped up as road kill. Derek Knox 210 Posted 02/12/2024 at 09:35:37 Alan @ 206, more chance getting to Weston Supermare, where Dyche (Donkey in Chief) could introduce most of our donkeys to their's. Might even be able to do a few swaps ! :-)I know we have a limited squad (not entirely Dyche's fault) and a couple of injuries, but to keep picking, more or less, the same under-performing ones leaves little excuse. Young at 39 should not be first choice RB, but in fairness has been okay-ish. Myko has been pretty awful for a while so why not try O'Brien there ?Doucoure, enough said, offers nothing while Mangala sits on the bench for the most part. Beto has the heart of a lion but is just not cut out for the Premiership. All the mention of Broja having played a large part in 2 U21 matches. Where was he ?Maybe, clutching at straws but trying something different keeps players on their toes, and may just provide a different result. At least it would have been tried, as opposed to same old, same old ! Add Your Comments In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site. » Log in now Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site. How to get rid of these ads and support TW © ToffeeWeb