Martinez hails Blues after 3-0 win at Stoke

Without doubt, Robles has had a part to play. His mere presence seems to have had a cathartic effect on the men in front of him and though some may disagree, which I respect, Funes Mori and Jags perform well together with more maturity than we show when Stones is playing.

John Stones may become a great star one day but at present, we have a job to do in salvaging what we can from our season and he really is a luxury we currently can't afford with his clever but very risky approach to defending.

Yet again, Funes Mori showed his scoring potential yesterday though this time he missed his chance. Lennon is a revelation and I have to wonder why Martinez hasn't utilised him before now this season, similarly with Cleverley.

Did Roberto pick what he thought was a lesser team for Carlisle, only to find that it just happens to be the best and most balanced eleven he's put out all season? I can only hope he doesn't tinker too much with this particular line-up, which really does look as it can do what we've all been wanting all season, and that is to WIN games, without the attendant worry and nail-biting at the end we've become so used to.

We – or should I say Roberto – is building a great side and also has the underpinning of young players to come through so or future growth is sustainable.

I don't think it's a coincidence that we have had clean sheets since Jags has come back, and hopefully Roberto will realise that we still need an old head alongside Stones and Funes Mori at this stage in their careers. Well done... it's an exciting time to be Blue.

On the other hand Baines has been one of our best players for years, has been cracked this year, and may need a little support to get back to his undoubted greatness.....

Good to see us get another win, but it doesn't change anything on Martinez – he needs to go at the end of the season as there's no real point doing it now the window's shut.

Three wins doesn't change his underperformance or his awful tactics and philosophy that's totally hamstrung a top six squad for the last two seasons. We could have been Leicester this season with a half-decent manager, would any of their players get into our team?

As for Martinez, he picked a team of in-form players, something we, the fans, have been demanding for months.

And guess what? We won.

Maybe he is learning a lesson here, and, if so, that is good.

";.......Glasshopper - know, and rearn..."

Defending has never been his strong point and, if you take the other attributes away, he is a very very average left back.

I may've been hasty in suggesting Oviedo or Garbutt should step in, but I do think there are other options out there that would suit us better.

Love the fact that we are able to use the squad - have competition for places and keep everyone on their toes and sharp for the run in.

Hopefully with a Wembley trip at the end!

We are overloaded at left back with Baines, Oviedo, Galloway, and Garbutt (next season?) but we don't have a left footed midfielder who can play wide. I sincerely hope that Roberto can give one of these lads the opportunity at some point next season.

Still, this happened last season with RM; we were way down the league with too many draws, only to pick up at the end to finish well and miss out on Europe. Again this is exactly the same even though we have a fantastic squad and no European commitments.

Martinez will not change, I'm afraid, and will continue to under perform. Sorry to say but we have some excellent talent in our squad and it should be better; don't be dragged into thinking different after a few wins.

But that stinks given what he's had at his disposal for this and last season. He has consistently and deliberately used tactics that have failed, consistently provided loads of angst to the fans, and squandered two season's worth of the short careers of our players. For that, he deserves the sack – even if they all stay on for next season, which I doubt.

Anthony (12)--
A friend of mine is a STH at Fulham and gave me a report a few weeks ago. Said that Garbutt is clearly talented, but that his talents are mostly being wasted at Craven Cottage because the squad isn't good enough to allow him to do what he is good at. In short, he described him as a carbon-copy of Baines: "adequate" defender with superb attacking instincts. Because Fulham is so poor, though, he doesn't get to attack much, and his defending isn't his main positive, so his contributions are somewhat limited.

Anyway - I was a craven Cottage on Saturday with a bit of a work hospitality gig and it was nice to have some partisan interest in the game with Luke involved. The standard of football was hardly the cutting edge of the noble art but I was able to spend much of the game watching Garbutt, his play, positioning etc.

All in all he did ok - provided the cross from which Derby scored an own goal, picked up a yellow for his tenacity, nearly got on the end of a cross only to be denied by a bit of excellent Derby defending and generally was always looking to get in to the game.

I am not sure besides getting actual game time what he's is gaining by being at Fulham though. He is being asked to play a markedly different role from that which he has with Everton but you can see he is constantly looking to penetrate down the left Baines-like.

It seems most of Fulham's attacking play seems to arrive down the right were they have a couple of reasonable lads. He did defend ok against Derby I thought, but I would have to agree with Scott's mate (albeit on the basis of just one game) that his talents are certainly not being exploited as you might expect.

Good that he's staying fit though, and we should look forward to getting him back and continuing to develop with Everton

And as for selling Baines...Christ on a bike, some people are just unbelievable...How can he bomb forward if he has no one dropping back to cover him? No one to link with (Pienaar)...get a grip of yourselves...You'll be after cashing in on Seamus next, or haven't you noticed he's not had the same impact as previous seasons? Again, no one to drop back (Lennon aside) and cover his runs. It's the tactics that dictate the effectiveness of our full backs...

Ah, shite, I'm gonna have to write another opinion piece now...

You seem to be in the same hyperbolic boat as Martinez. 'Atrocious' describes Villa's season or maybe Sunderland's but not ours.

Underachieving, frustrating as hell but hardly atrocious. Scoring goals at a really good rate, best away record for years and a run in the Capital Cup.

I agree it's too early to think we have neccesarily turned the corner after three games in six days but a least it's a start. Like many after Swansea and City I felt we may be at the point of no return, but that's being a supporter for you. The team and the manager deserve some credit for not folding after the City game. Let's hope it continues.

But you seem to be missing the major point of my post, Graham, which is that Martinez has a habit of putting decent runs together, doing enough to put the gloss on the end of the season. He's like a kid who has all week to study for a test and leaves it til the morning of the test and crams on the bus to school...ends up with a pass. That'll keep the parents quiet, you know? This is his approach to defending! Last minute, if it looks like we have to to save the season, then we'll do a bit of defending, but not before!!!

I do hope the good run continues, but I really do not want to be here again next season saying I told you so. Lessons learned, corner turned? I really want it to be true.

You described the season as atrocious, I would say that is over the top given we are 8th, reached the semi final of one cup and still in the other.

It's been maddeningly frustrating at times given that we all know we should be 10 points better than we are given the quality of football we have played at times. And some of it has been quality, certainly a huge improvement on last year's turgid fare.

I've been pissed of at times at what has appeared to be tactical naivety at times but I also think having calmed down a bit in the last week he deserves more time.

I would say lets see what the next three months bring, maybe we are on the verge of a good run. We certainly have the players to do it.

Taken in context, our last 2 seasons with the players we have at our disposal...no where near good enough. If Arsenal performed at this level and finished 11th last season, what would you describe their season as? What do you think Chelsea have been like until Guus Hiddink arrived? Below par?

I think player for player we're not far off their level, and Rom is way better than Giroud, so it's not a bad comparison. For gods sake, accept we have been far from good enough at the back and meet me half way?

And you have hit the nail on the head when you said things have calmed down in the last week...look at his record...happens every season(with the notable exception of his first with us, when the muscle memory for defending was ingrained) shit results, poor league standing , then a surge up the table after stringing a run together when he suddenly has no choice but to defend. Did it with Wigan, eventually got them relegated.

All I'm saying is if he's finally admitted to himself that clean sheets are an important part of a winning ethos, then great, if not, don't be surprised to find us in the same position next season, but with most of the talent having fucked off to greener pastures. That Graham, would be atrocious, and I will be sitting here wondering why people like you think that it's good enough.

Well of course my whole point is that describing this season as 'atrocious' was not in my opinion a reflection of this season. Putting semantics aside I would not even describe the whole season as poor. It certainly has been poor at times but overall much better than last season. We have actually only lost 6 out of 33 games in all competitions.Our defensive record at home has been 'atrocious' but away from home we have largely been ok.

I would certainly agree we should have done better, that's why most fans have been so frustrated. We know we have walked away from at least four games where we should have taken all three points and at the same time losing home games specifically to Stoke and Swansea when we should be dispatching both those sides.

But the season unlike last year is still in the balance. We are still in the FA Cup and only potentially two points off European qualification. So it's still a little early for doom and gloom.

As I said the side and the manager deserve some credit for the last three games given the whole place was at a very low ebb after Swansea and City. It's definitely too early to be carried away but let's see where we are in May.

We have been more solid since Christmas on the whole which again is about our formation, three midfield players and Ross in a front three is the main reason for this for me. Whether that is by chance or by planning I don't know.