The Greatest?

Rick Tarleton 30/05/2020 45comments  |  Jump to last
I read and enjoyed Dave Williams's homage to Alan Ball. It was a well-written article about his favourite Everton player.

Funnily enough, I suspect I'm a little older than Dave. I loved Ball and enjoyed his combative style and his leadership and he was certainly the central figure in that wonderful trinity with Harvey and Kendall. I was born in the summer of 1946 and managed to see one game when Everton were in the Second Division, that game made me an Evertonian.

My family were reds, I smile sometimes when on this site fans insist that Evertonians are born not made, but my second ever football match — I'd been to Anfield to see Stanley Matthews after the famous Matthews FA Cup Final and Liverpool won 5-2 to the delight of my red father and uncles — made me an Evertonian.

Or, to be more precise, a blonde-quiffed centre-forward with a dashing style enthralled me and, because of Dave Hickson, I declared myself an Evertonian. My family assumed it was a passing phase... it wasn't. 67 years later, I'm still a devoted blue. Hickson was my early hero. To be honest, there wasn't a lot of choice in the Everton team of the 1950s — if you wanted dash and glamour, it was Hickson or no-one.

Anyhow, an Evertonian I became; and who'd be my greatest player? Without doubt — Alex Young. He's not the best Everton player I've ever seen but, to me, he was everything I want in my cult hero. He had style, skill, charisma and grace.

But people a generation or two older than me would probably pick William Ralph Dean and figures suggest he must be as great as anyone who ever played for Everton. I met him and he was a lovely man and very complimentary about Young and Vernon. That was in 1964, my dad knew him from the 1930s when my uncle, Nel Tarleton was a big mate of his.

A few years older than me and you'd possibly have Hickson or the great Bobby Collins as your greatest Everton player. Collins for me was the player who made the biggest impact when he signed for the club and, in my all-time Everton team, would be in the midfield alongside Trevor Steven, Tony Kay and Colin Harvey. I'd pick Collins before Ball, I'm afraid. And Colin Harvey is my vote as the best all-round player I've seen at Goodison Park.

A generation later and Bob Latchford becomes an icon; then a later generation picks, Peter Reid, Andy Gray, Kevin Sheedy. Then, after that, Duncan Ferguson becomes the hero... and so on.

Defenders come out badly. Ray Wilson was the best player I ever saw in his position for any club. Brian Labone and Kevin Ratcliffe were magnificent, but it's usually forwards and particularly characters who get our attention. I always feel Graeme Sharp, because of his quiet polite manner, is under-rated; his display against Liverpool at Wembley in the League Cup Final of 1984 was brilliant.

I think what I'm trying to say is that, our decision as to who is our greatest will probably above all else depend on our age. My son adored Duncan Ferguson, a signed Duncan Ferguson framed shirt cost us more than any of my first three cars which we gave him for his fortieth last year. Yet to me Ferguson was a smashing player, not the greatest finisher and not an icon to me.

I've chosen Alex Young. In some ways, I don't regard him as the best Everton player — I don't even think he was as good as Vernon – but, to me, he epitomises what I want Everton to be: cultured and graceful.

Young was at his peak in 1962-63. I was 16 and bliss was it in that season to be an Evertonian. But to be young (pun intended) was heaven, as I think someone said.

Share this article

Reader Comments (45)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Steve Barr
1 Posted 30/05/2020 at 18:10:11
Hi Rick, I agree with your assumption that age is a major factor in arriving at one's greatest/favourite player.

In my case I have to go with Joe Royle and Bob Latchford as far as centre forwards are concerned.

I started going to Everton games in the late 1960s through to the late 1970s before I moved down to London for work.

Joe Royle really grabbed my attention as far as centre forwards go; particularly the way he leapt and swept big centre-halves aside as he ran in to head home a Johnny Morrissey cross!

But big Bob Latchford, ably assisted by Dave Thomas, has to be my choice as greatest Everton player.

What a goalscorer. Not blessed with the best touch but couldn't he finish?

Isn't it a great privilege that we have all been able to watch these players perform, and many, many more great Evertonians, regardless of which generation.

May it continue for our younger generations!

Peter Neilson
2 Posted 30/05/2020 at 19:35:42
Likewise Bob Latchford for me. Lucky enough to meet him twice but too awestruck to say anything! Very humble guy and what a Number 9. Bust my hand against the bedroom wall when he equalised in the last minute against Villa. Can still hear the commentary.
John McFarlane Snr
3 Posted 30/05/2020 at 19:51:30
Hi Rick, I'm inclined to agree with you regarding your choice of Bobby Collins ahead of Alan Ball, I was serving in Cyprus with the army when Bobby Collins joined Everton, the season they lost the first six games scoring 4 goals and conceding 20. Bobby scored on his debut in a 3-1 victory over Manchester City at Maine Road, alongside Wally Fielding and Jimmy Harris.

I add that bit of information not for you, Rick, but for the younger fan base who may not be aware of the dire straits we were in. Worse was to follow when Tottenham Hotspur thrashed us 10-4 on 11 October 1958, a date etched in my mind.

You may recall that I mentioned that my uncle Phil was a friend of Nel's when they lived in the Phythian Street area, and my Auntie Nora claimed that she taught Nel to dance at Pepper's dance hall, on the corner of Aubrey Street and Everton Road.

I think that everyone down the ages has had one or two heroes, in the '40s and '50s, mine were Wally Fielding and Dave Hickson; in the '50s and '60s, Bobby Collins and Alex Young replaced them, and although Tommy Ring only played 26 times for Everton, he showed me skills I had never seen from an Everton winger.

In the '70s, Mick Lyons for me epitomised what a 'True Blue' feels for the club, by the bravery and commitment that I have expected from anyone wearing the Royal Blue Sshirt.

In more recent years, there have been players that I have admired: Andy Gray for much the same reason I warmed toward Mick Lyons; Peter Beardsley, because without him and Neville Southall I don't know where we may have been.

I'm afraid that my Hero Worship no longer exists, and I don't think that it's becoming of an Octogenarian to indulge in such practices, nor do I see anyone in the present personnel to tempt me in that direction.

Peter Neilson
4 Posted 30/05/2020 at 20:05:40
Tentatively linked to this. Albert Dunlop organised my uncle's wedding in Walton. Part way through the evening, he took my dad aside and asked him for money for the bar tab which he paid up. My uncle had already paid him in full.

Years later, my uncle told me the story when I'd bought him the James Corbett history and we were flicking through it. Told me he chased Dunlop down County Road to get the money back but couldn't keep up.

Dave Abrahams
5 Posted 30/05/2020 at 21:07:07
Bobby Collins for me Rick, a thorough professional in the way he looked after himself, didn't need the captain's badge, don't know if he ever was, but he demanded the commitment, fighting spirit and the will to win he gave himself in every game he played for Everton. He dragged a very, very poor squad from the depths of division one to a team ready to win consistent honours, aided by the astute signings of Harry Catterick, ironically transferred to Leeds United before he got the medals he richly deserved at Everton.

Other great players were Vernon, Tommy Ring, unfortunately injured early in his Everton career, Gabriel not mention to mention Brian Labone already at the club.

Peter (4) if your uncle had been joined by all the people owed money by Albert in his chase for his money it would have looked like the start of a marathon race, he was noted for his gambling habits and debts caused by them.

Rick, I think your uncle was related, possibly by marriage, to Ernie Roderick, another great fighter who lost in a great fight to “Homicide” Henry Armstrong over 15 rounds. Ernie was an ex pupil of the school I went to, Netherfield Road RC, better known as The Friary, and he came back to the school to show us his Lonsdale belt.

John Keating
6 Posted 30/05/2020 at 22:28:48

Agree with you about Alex Young and the reason you gave. John Snr makes a good point about Mick Lyons – still to this day a true Blue.

Dave is right about Bobby Collins leaving us just before we started getting well-deserved medals but, then again, Mick Lyons just missed out too.

Dave, some rough houses down the Friary not least "local lad makes good" Father John! One look, not only to the kids but to the Dad's too and you'd shut up.

Rick Tarleton
7 Posted 31/05/2020 at 06:30:25
Yes, Dave, Ernie was a great man, he lost his money overnight, the tax man caught him and had to start work at the power station, never moaned or groaned. Still in touch with his eldest daughter.
Dick Fearon
8 Posted 31/05/2020 at 09:47:22
John Mc @3, I was at Maine Road when Collins made his debut for us. Little was known about Scottish football. The tannoy reported his overnight signing and hoped Man City fans would join Everton's in giving a big welcome to Bobby who was a legend North of the border.

Upon seeing him for the first time, my thoughts were, "Gee, our mascot is a chunky little bloke!"

John McFarlane Snr
9 Posted 31/05/2020 at 15:09:00
Hi Dick, [8] as I stated in my post, I was actually stationed in Cyprus when Bobby Collins signed for Everton, my first glimpse of him was in December 1958 when he played against Portsmouth. Dave Abrahams [5] is right when he credits Bobby for dragging a poor squad from the brink of relegation, he did a similar job with Leeds United. I felt that Bobby was treated badly by Harry Catterick, but I guess the retort would be, "We won the League in 1963 didn't we?"

Another player I feel had a rough deal at Goodison was Alex Parker, but that was in the pre-Catterick days. Alex was also stationed in Cyprus with the Scottish Fusileers, but he arrived after me and returned to 'Blighty' before me.

Alex signed in July 1958 two months earlier than Bobby Collins but because of his military commitments, made his debut in November 1958, two months later than Bobby Collin. The reason I believe that Alex was treated badly is because he played his first 5 games at right back [his rightful position], but was switched to right half for the following 12 games before reverting to his natural berth for the final 12 games, this switch cost him his place in the Scotland side, Eric Caldow regaining that position and denying Alex the opportunity to increase his international total.

David Currie
10 Posted 31/05/2020 at 23:24:46
John Mc,

Always enjoy your posts and glad that you mentioned Mike Lyons. I started watching Everton in the '70s as a kid and loved Lyons. Every time he scored a goal, the joy and passion on his face was truly memorable. Really wish he could have lifted a trophy for us as captain. Just interested to know who your favourite players were in the 1980s?

John McFarlane Snr
11 Posted 01/06/2020 at 14:47:06
Hi David [10] in answer to your question regarding my favourite players during the 80s, it's not easy to select favourites, when for the best part of that decade there were few players who merited criticism. The early part of the 80s didn't fill us with confidence, finding us occupying 15th, 13th, and 12th, places after the first three League games of 80/81. The 83/84 campaign saw us struggle in League games, although we did rally toward the the end of the season, buoyed by the success of our FA Cup run and the ultimate prize against Watford.

I think that it will come as no surprise to read the usual names, of Neville Southall. Kevin Ratcliffe, Andy Gray, Graeme Sharp, et al but I would like to add to those, the names of Adrian Heath ['a small man with a gigantic heart'], and Paul Power, ['a stand -in left back'] who made 40 League appearances in the 1986/87 League Championship season, he was for me, the 'Footballer of the Year'

As I said at the start of this post David, after a poor entrance into the 80s it was 'almost' impossible to criticise any of the players who entertained us for the major part of that highly successful decade.

Jay Harris
12 Posted 01/06/2020 at 15:06:42
To select a favourite/Greatest player you have to think who made the greatest impression on you.

As a young kid in the 60's it was undoubtedly the "Welsh wizard" Roy Vernon. Roy could take a pass from the kickoff waltz around the opposition and then round the GK too and hit the net with regularity. But for the Golden vision and his penchant for drinking and smoking he would have been a crowd legend.

Then it was Howard Kendall (I used to play MF myself) a player whose talent for winning a sliding tackle, coming away with the ball and having the ability to pass long or short was incomparable and he could also score goals.

As sir John said the 80's was full of exceptional players but the absolute king of Goodison was the best Goalkeeper in the world Neville Southall. If he played CF he would have been in the Dixie Dean class. We never had anyone before or since who has even approached his ability between the sticks.

Lenny Jameson
13 Posted 01/06/2020 at 17:29:44
Mr. Currie (10) and others,

You're right about Mick Lyons. He was never the greatest player but if everyone put in the effort he did, we'd have had some team.

I met him through a friend of mine who used to go to De La Salle with him. We became friends and would often meet on a Saturday night after a game and have a few pints. Even after we both got married, we'd meet in the Empire in Hanover Street and always have a good night. Imagine that today. Meeting the captain of Everton in a pub in town!

He's a great lad. Never played the big deal. He'd always have time for people and is still the same whenever you see him now.

He'd never do anyone any wrong except for one night in the Babaloo.

I was out with my mates and Mick was in there with a few players. He spotted me and came over. " Lenny," he said," Have you met Bernie?" He introduced me to this wild man of Borneo and disappeared into the club. That's how I got stuck with Bernie Wright for the night. And what a night it turned out to be!!!!

David Currie
14 Posted 02/06/2020 at 04:04:08
John Mc Snr,

Thanks for your reply, my favourites were Big Nev and Paul Bracewell who I think was becoming better than Reidy.

Lenny, that was great to hear about Mike Lyons who now lives in Perth, Australia. I would love to meet him one day. Wonder if he ever goes back to Goodison?

Brian Harrison
15 Posted 02/06/2020 at 10:16:09
Well, as far as Everton's greatest player, there is only one: Dixie Dean. His record will never be beaten.

Years come and go and world records are broken and Olympic records are broken. But Dean's record will never be broken. I don't know but it must be close to the longest unbroken record in any sport.

Now if we are talking best player you have personally watched, sadly I didn't see Dixie. I think like many my age, Dave Hickson was one of my first heroes, and as time goes by, more are added to the list. Certainly Bobby Collins, Alex Young, Tony Kay, Brian Labone, and Ray Wilson were amongst my favourites. Then along comes Peter Reid, Sharpy, Bracewell, Southall.

Dave Williams
16 Posted 02/06/2020 at 10:34:00
Great article, Rick. I will be 65 next week so, as you say, a slightly different generation.

I can't recall anything of Alex Young at his peak but my dad was a huge Collins fan and always maintained that selling him, not Bally, was the biggest mistake we ever made as a club.

As you say, most generations throw up a new idol. Latchford was a huge hero of mine and I named my first car after him! I really liked Varadi, probably because of the exotic name. Watching our 2-1 win over RS in the cup around 1981 on YouTube the other day, he looked a smashing player and far better than most we have had since then, though I know he missed a lot more than he scored.

Adrian Heath was a big favourite of mine – I loved his enthusiasm and refusal to be intimidated by bigger players (virtually everyone was bigger than him). Duncan was up there by default as he was awesome when he wanted to be but couldn't be bothered other days... but who else was there? Today, Calvert-Lewin and Richarlison have potential to be greats but have a long way to go.

Add to the above Royle, Harvey (the best pure footballer I have seen though he lacked Ball's ability to drag the team with him) and my love of wingers which made me a huge fan of Alex Scott and Jimmy Husband.

Articles like this show us what great players we have had and what a dearth of great ones there is now.

Brian Harrison
17 Posted 02/06/2020 at 10:48:25
I just realized I skipped a whole generation in my list of favourite players, how could I have not mentioned Ball, Royle, Harvey and Kendall???
Lenny Jameson
18 Posted 02/06/2020 at 16:18:18
David (14),

Yes, he's still a great lad. When he comes home he always goes to Goodison. You can usually see him outside the main entrance on a match day, surrounded by people and signing autographs. However, his visits are understandably quite few these days and it's just pot luck whether you bump into him.

All the best.

Alan McGuffog
19 Posted 02/06/2020 at 17:24:31
John... I agree totally about Alex Parker. With regards to his limited number if caps... it's been said that there was always a bias against Anglos, English based Jocks.

That limited the caps that the likes of Young, Collins and Parker won. Did Jimmy Gabriel even get one?

John McFarlane Snr
20 Posted 02/06/2020 at 18:16:12
Hi Alan [19], I omitted from my post, the fact that I had the pleasure to chat with Alex Parker at one of the 'Hall of Fame' evenings at the Adelphi Hotel. When I praised him on his slide tackling ability his response was, "I was faster on my arse, than I was on my feet" – a truly modest gentleman.

Jimmy Gabriel played twice for Scotland, his first appearance was against Wales in a 2-0 loss at Ninian Park. Alex Young also played in that game. Jimmy's second and final appearance was apparently as a substitute to Jim Baxter in a 6-1 victory over Norway at Hampden Park. Alex Scott also played in that game.

Rick Tarleton
21 Posted 05/06/2020 at 14:11:44
I think a certain personality goes with our heroes. The quietly efficient John-Willie Parker was never considered as a hero in the same way that Dave Hickson was, Peter Reid was often mentioned, but like David Currie, I too rather liked Paul Bracewell, but he too was basically a quieter personality. Similarly with Graeme Sharp and Andy Gray, Gray was a great player and had charisma in spades, but I think Sharp was a true great, but a quieter type of player and person.

It's quite amazing how we all have our heroes and what the criteria we used in selecting them. Hickson made me an Evertonian, but for me bliss was 62-63 and Young and Vernon were strutting their stuff, I was sixteen, the perfect age for this aspect of support and we won the League in some style. I'm obviously biased about it, but four of that team would be in my all-time favourite eleven of the last almost seventy years that I have been supporting Everton. The four are: Alex Parker, Tony Kay, Alex Young and Roy Vernon.

John McFarlane Snr
22 Posted 06/06/2020 at 12:00:14
Hi Rick [21],

There were people who considered that John Willie was lazy and that he didn't contribute to the extent of Dave Hickson, and without Hickson's physical contribution he wouldn't have scored so many goals.

I'm by no means an expert on football, but I know enough to appreciate that, in any goalscoring partnership, it often appears that one player becomes a work-horse, but his partner still needs to be in the right place at the right time.

Danny ONeill
23 Posted 06/06/2020 at 12:04:13
I was fortunate to have watched the 80s team in my teens, so I'm blessed like others with this being a difficult one to call.

At the time, I'd have said Sharpe. Southall was the best keeper in Europe and I wish Paul Bracewell had not been beset by injuries as he was some player who was only going to get better.

I watched Howard's Way (again) last night with my son. The poor lad had to endure the same comments I make at the same point in that documentary every time we watch it; in fact, he preempts me now! But, "that" volleyed pass on the turn to set up Steven for the goal; wow.

There's another, Trevor Steven; graceful and skilful. But when I look back now, it has to be Kevin Sheedy. A magic wand of a left foot complemented by a football brain that was 2 steps ahead of everyone else on the pitch. Listen to him talk about the double free-kick take; "I'll just put it in the other corner" as if it's the easiest thing in the world to do.

And his patience waiting for Andy Gray to make the run against Bayern whilst 50,000 were screaming "man on", baying for him to get rid! Sheer natural brilliance, that he probably can't explain.

A combination of playing for unfashionable Everton and the fact that team had the platform upon which it was about to step onto ripped away from them, means he is rarely spoken about outside of Evertonian circles. Such a shame that team was never afforded the opportunity to play on the stage it deserved to.

I don't wish to open up old wounds and much poor decision making has gone on at our club which contributes to where we are now. Nor do I want to change the direction of this thread, but such a pivotal and defining moment in our history. Great team, great memories, I wish they could have given us more – and they could have.

John McFarlane Snr
24 Posted 06/06/2020 at 13:26:57
Hi Danny [23],

My season ticket at that time was in the Upper Bullens Road stand, and I had a great view of that pass, and goal. How Paul Bracewell picked out Trevor Steven was incredible. I think that to see the possibility at ground level and through a crowded mid-field, was a moment of pure genius.

I can recall a mate of mine saying "What a pass!" It was so unbelievable, my reaction was to say, "Yeah, if he meant it." I was doing him a disservice because he obviously did mean it, a once-in-a-lifetime pass, and I'm thankful that I was there to witness it.

Dave Abrahams
25 Posted 06/06/2020 at 13:49:58
Danny (23), that team you talk about in the '80s was an all-round team of many parts and characters. I don't think there was a weak link in the squad. Harper and Richardson played great parts in the success.

Speedy was a great favourite of mine but he was never two steps ahead of everyone else and definitely not Peter Reid, who might have been two yards slower than most in the team, but his football brain was up there and quicker than most in the league never mind Everton's team.

That pass by Bracewell, we'll never know if he meant it or not, it turned out to be a fantastic pass anyway. I'll never be convinced he meant it, now if Sheedy or Peter Reid had made that pass I could be swayed.

Peter Rigby
26 Posted 06/06/2020 at 14:08:33
The “Golden Vision” was and still is my all time hero, so much so my son is named after him. I met my idol at the BlueKipper initiation into Hall of Fame, at the Adelphi. The boys got me into the green room and when Alex came in, I stood and could hardly speak to him.

When I mustered the words “Thank you, Alex, for everything” he said, “No son, I have to thank you for taking me and my family into your hearts.”

Cue a grown 60-year-old man crying. He left too soon unfortunately, but we went to see him play one game for Stockport County after he came back from managing Glentoran in Ireland.

Thanks for a great piece.

Danny ONeill
27 Posted 06/06/2020 at 14:33:43
So many great memories that I too was thankful to witness, John.

I should have also mentioned Peter Reid, Dave. And you're spot on, let's not forget the contribution of Harper & Richardson. Like Harper, when all were fit, he wasn't good enough to get in Howard's first choice 11 most weeks. That says a lot for that team given Richardson went on to win league titles with Arsenal.

With you mentioning Reid, aside from the ability those players had, the documentary highlights the mentality. Reid's & Ratcliffe's accounts of being flies in each other's ear if they thought players (themselves included) weren't performing to the standard. Andy Gray about to bollock Reid for a "poor" free-kick from which Adrian Heath put us into the FA Cup Final. Winning mentality as well.

Whereas more recently, we had the likes of Jagielka playing down expectation in interviews and footage of him consoling Ross Barkley in the tunnel, assuring him that the fans "weren't booing him" personally.

Winning mentality to complement winning ability.

Dave Abrahams
28 Posted 06/06/2020 at 15:00:13
Danny (27), we all have our favourites, no harm in that, and Kevin Sheedy was an outstanding player. You are absolutely correct in focusing on the winning mentality all the players had in those magical four years under Kendall and Harvey, on and off the pitch.

I went to Bellefield one afternoon, we were playing Liverpool that week. I got talking to Kevin Ratcliffe and I said “I hope we get a draw at Anfield.“ Kevin was on to me right away, “A draw,“ he mocked. “We'll be going there to win!”

As you say, Danny, that team's attitude and mental strength was spot on.

John McFarlane Snr
29 Posted 06/06/2020 at 15:31:37
Hi Dave [25],

I said at the time that John Bailey and Kevin Richardson were unfortunate to lose their places to Pat van den Hauwe and Paul Bracewell. I'm still of that opinion, although if Howard Kendall was still around, he would say, "We won the League, didn't we?"

Danny ONeill
30 Posted 06/06/2020 at 15:56:33
Interesting point, John. I said to my son that I didn't think Van den Hauwe was particularly special. But he (bear in mind, my son was born in '94 and knows only the Moyes years on) said from what he saw, every team needs a player or players like that.

Van den Hauwe brought something to the team that Howard must have thought was a missing ingredient. Call it nastiness, call it aggression, but it goes back to what Dave & I were saying, it comes down to winning mentality.

Look at the current Liverpool team / squad. I wouldn't say man for man they are better than Man City, but they have a winning mentality installed into them.

John McFarlane Snr
31 Posted 06/06/2020 at 16:37:57
Hi Danny [30],

As Dave says, we all have our favourites, I suppose it's a case of 'one man's meat is another man's poison'. What saddens me is that some resort to poisonous comments to justify their dislike of certain players.

I have always been of the opinion that, if a lad plays for the poorest team in the Football League, he can play football. Obviously not to the level of Premier League players, but to a considerably higher standard than his detractors

I'm sure no one plays badly on purpose, but then again, maybe I've mellowed with age.

Dave Abrahams
32 Posted 06/06/2020 at 16:46:36
John (29),

I think it is all down to opinions. I liked Kevin Richardson's versatility, same with Alan Harper, and it took me some time to appreciate how valuable Paul Bracewell's ability was to Everton.

It really hit home in the semi-final versus Luton Town, he must have covered every blade of grass in those two hours in that game and I never doubted him after that game. A really bad injury spoiled his very good career.

Kevin Richardson proved his worth time after time for Everton but, to be honest, as good as they were, I preferred Steve McMahon to either of them.

As for Pat van den Hauwe, I thought he definitely strengthened Everton's defence physically and mentally when he came into the squad, but everyone has their own opinion; only the manager gets paid for his.

Danny ONeill
33 Posted 06/06/2020 at 17:12:48
Hi John. I assume you're referring to others' "poisonous" comments. I wasn't criticising Pat or any player, just agreeing with you in that John Bailey was unfortunate as Howard obviously thought he needed something different. That comes out in the documentary and it's a really nice scene when they get together as they clearly established a good relationship despite the rivalry for the same position.

You're absolutely right on 2 counts. Firstly, any player that makes it to football league level is a good player. We underestimate what it takes to make it to that level and there are often fine margins for the majority (forget those who are blessed and destined). Also, as you say, no player goes out to play bad intentionally. I'm also a believer in that mentality in normal life; most people don't intentionally cock up on purpose, so I judge them on how they put things right rather than dwell on mistakes; we all make them right?

Good shout on McMahon Dave. His record speaks for itself. My best friend's Grandfather used to take him to the match as a kid. Sadly, Everton's 80s spike came a couple of years too late for him to hang around, but what a great midfielder.

John McFarlane Snr
34 Posted 06/06/2020 at 18:36:48
Hi Danny [33],

No, I wasn't referring to you, I've always found your posts positive and informative. I have no intention of naming individuals as it would no doubt lead to bad feeling. I believe that there is a way to criticise players; if I wished to express my dislike of certain players, I would do it in a more diplomatic manner.

Danny ONeill
35 Posted 06/06/2020 at 21:59:27
As you always do John; always a balanced view.
Danny ONeill
36 Posted 06/06/2020 at 23:01:06
And it must have been great to have seen Bracewell's pass and that team play from the Upper Bullens, John. I was in the Lower Gwladys in those days, but have always thought the best place to watch and appreciate the football at Goodison is the Upper Bullens.
John McFarlane Snr
37 Posted 06/06/2020 at 23:12:47
Hi again Danny [36],

Sitting in the Upper Bullens stand could be a double-edged sword – tremendous in the Bayern Munich game, horrendous in the 5-0 defeat against Liverpool, when Rush scored four.

Danny ONeill
38 Posted 06/06/2020 at 23:31:31
Yes, I suppose from that position you get to appreciate the best and experience the worst as it unfolds!! Hope you're well.
Brian Wilkinson
39 Posted 10/06/2020 at 02:31:45
Not sure if you are just referring to outfield players, Rick, but astounded you left Neville Southall out in your various player comments, one of best guys we ever made.
Jay Harris
40 Posted 10/06/2020 at 03:17:33
Danny, I used to always say that, even if Psycho Pat was having a bad game, nobody would ever get past him.

He must have been a nightmare for wingers.

Andy Peers
41 Posted 10/06/2020 at 03:51:31
Peter #26... You named your son "Golden Vision"? LOL
Terry White
42 Posted 10/06/2020 at 04:20:21
Brian (#39), why would Rick (#21) mention Neville when his post was making comparisons between players that were not necessarily as good as someone else but you preferred them anyway?

And then he goes on to mention 4 of his favourite Everton players of all who happened to play in the 1962-63 side and he has not changed his opinion since then. Nothing to do with Neville.

David Currie
43 Posted 14/06/2020 at 05:04:22
Kendall made a great signing when he brought in Van den Hauwe who was far better than Bailey as a defender. He was far more athletic, very good in 1 v 1 situations and was very fit. He was also 5ft-11in as was Gary Stevens so he had more height than Bailey to deal with crosses at the back post. Howard also liked right-footed left-backs.

Pat could also fit in really well at centre-back and in 1986 when we beat the RS 2-0 at Anfield, he and Rats were superb. Neil Pointon played left-back that day, I believe we should have played that same back four in the Cup Final in May as Mountfield was taking a fitness test the day before.

Tony Abrahams
44 Posted 14/06/2020 at 10:06:18
I always thought Pat was a better player at centre-back, David. That game at Anfield was brilliant and I thought Van den Hauwe was outstanding that day. I still remember to this day the night before that game, me and my mate going for a walk around Goodison because we'd done it the year before and we'd won, so we were convinced we had to do it again.

My mate's dad was close to Pat and my mate said he'd spoke to him earlier that day. He'd said he was going to take half a sleeping tablet and go to bed early. (I've asked him since, but he couldn't remember!) Otherwise, he'd have difficultly in sleeping, and it obviously worked because him, Ratcliffe and especially Neville Southall were all outstanding in that game.

That's why I'm not sure playing the same back four in that final would have made much difference because, in that league game, Rush was put through twice in a very similar position to the one in which he scored his first goal at Wembley, but twice Southall thwarted him by being exceptionally quick off his line to dive at his feet and force Rush just that little bit too wide, instead of rolling the ball into an empty net like he did in that final on one of the very worst days of my life.

David Currie
45 Posted 14/06/2020 at 19:14:01
Tony, Agree on Pat being a better centre-back and I think Colin Harvey wanted to play him there regularly alongside Watson before he decided to join Spurs.

Any chance you and your mate could walk around Goodison next Saturday before the derby?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.

About these ads

© ToffeeWeb