No frozen pipes for this rearranged game, the only casualty of a hard winter. But on the field, no Phil Neville, who went off at Newcastle with a hamstring problem; Tony Hibbert continues at right back with Johnny Heitinga introduced in midfield, the only change from St James Park; Saha and Beckford up front for a 4-4-2 formation.
Arteta tried to feed Saha through the middle after 3 mins but it didn't come off. But it led to a dangerous free-kick going the other way from Larrson and Jerome put in a good header that forced an equally good save from Howard, down low to his left. But 6 mins in, and disaster for Arteta, who was just coming good, but came up short as his hamstring went, an audible groan all round Everton as he limped off, no doubt for an extended absence. Unbelievable bad luck... Coleman replaced him. Bentley tweaked a groin muscle for Brum and he went off early too.
Osman headed straight at Foster from a lofted cross by Hibbert. Beckford got a good run in on goal, turning well off a great feed from Rodwell, and fired wide of Foster but the keeper got down and saved well. Everton won their first corner off an innocuous Hibbert cross, and Osman delivered it too deep. Rodwell, tried to set up a clever one-two with Beckford but the striker's return ball was horribly wayward. Osman fired from distance but a little low and Foster was able to save after an extended period of Everton possession and some good shots on goal.
And of course, wouldn't ya know, Birmingham waltzed up the other end and scored, poor marking, and Beasejour headed home with ease, despite the attentions of Hibbert having to play centre-back. So the script is written: star player lost, goal given away... now 70 mins of trying to dislodge one parked bus on a cold and windy night at Goodison Park.
Coleman got a nasty ball in the face off Hibbert but recovered well enough to beat his man and cross, albeit a little high for Saha. Rodwell did well to power a ball in for Beckford who elected for a bizarre strike with his back to goal that flew well over. From a throw-in that came to Beckford, he should have done better but could only clip the ball lightly to Foster who fumbled the ball on the line.
Osman won a corner from nothing, and swung it over dep again, where it was cleared straiht to Heitinga who strode in an curled a beautiful shot into the top corner for a superb first goal for Everton, over the despairing Boywer and well away from Foster, for an absolutely top class equalizer.... on 36 mins. Game On!
Rodwell was next to have a pop along the ground, then a great header from Coleman off a great cross from Baines but Foster anticipated it well and was down to save well. Mutch was the first entry in in Peter Walton's book, although mit required a wonderful piece of comedy improvisation form the ref, who had incredibly left his yellow card in the dressing room!
A Baines corner and free-kick punctuated the 4 mins added time at the break, Everton showing enough to promise better stuff in the second half.
Everton were lucky when Karanjeck dispossessed Saha but was called back, and then they wasted the free-kick. The real yellow card came out for Ridgewell for a tug on Coleman. Baines and Osman combined well but Osman's final acute-angle ball was too close to Foster. Heitinga got booked for a nothing foul from behind.
A couple of Everton attacks, ending in a good corner by Osman that Saha would have scored from but for being strongly molested by Ridgewell... why no penalty? Coleman was getting more and more excited and his final ball showed it, careening toward the corner flag,
Bowyer and Heitinga went at each other after Osman went down inside the area following a sustained attacking spell, but it was frustrating as Saha was reduced to clipping a hopefully poke well over from distance. Past the hour, Saha got a glorious opportunity to run in and shoot but he delayed a second too long and lost a glorious chance.
It was getting more physical as Everton upped the pressure, Bowyer and Osman doing a WWF exhibition in the middle of the park. But the game was largely shapeless and lacking in much structure, Rodwell again failing to take another golden shance to be dominant in midfield. Mutch was given room to shoot but finished well wide.
Beckford time a penetrating run well to get behind the defence but failed to go direct for goal and ended up passing the ball into Foster's grateful clutches as he got crowded out, while Birmingham had simply given up attacking, clearing aimless balls forward Another Coleman run won a comer and a couple of great deliveries from Baines but no real chance developed..
Everton were starting to use the long ball over the top, but timing is everything, while Birmingham looked happy with the point despite bringing the big Zigic on for Jerome. Que Anichebe replace Beckford, to less than overwhelming welcome from the Goodison crowd stultified by yet another ridiculous Operation Goodison Exercise.
Osman did really well to fire a good shot in the Foster tipped over but Saha failed to nail a beautiful Baines corner. Coleman delivered a good ball for Saha that Juranek claimed as time ticked away relentlessly... It was looking increasingly unlikely that Everton could secure their third win on the trot?
Anichebe got an unorthodox shot on goal, but they seemed increasingly frustrated. Baines's corner from the left were not as good as those from the right, as Heitinga was replaced by Bilyaletdinov with less than 5 mins left. Huff and puff from the depleted Blues with too much sideways passing to effectively penetrate an obdurate Birmingham defensive wall.
A chance came near the death for handball on Ridgewell; a good position for Baines but he pulled off his best Arteta impression, bruising the Birmingham wall fair and square. Three added minutes as Osman was incredibly denied a free-kick off a poor challenge by Bowyer. Crosses started going way too deep and came to naught it was yet another disappointing result against clearly inferior opposition.
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
We have a real paucity of squad members and our reserve team are virtually beaten every week. I really hope that Osman can pick up the reins and play consistently well in the absence of both our creative players, Pienaar and Arteta.
Fellaini will be badly missed as he provided strength and height. Cahill will be out for the rest of March and then it's getting him fit enough to play full games. It seems that Bily and Anichebe are not up to it so let's really hope we do not have any more injuries or suspensions.
14 pts dropped which would have us level with Chelsea I think. So near yet so far away in a depressing season. As Phil says so well on #3...
Hibbert 6 ? Looked better in the second half, hit some decent crosses in and got his tackling form back;Jagielka 5 ? His distribution was awful in the second half, on many occasions we lost all the momentum due to his hoof;Distin 6 ? He wasn't really needed in the second half due to our possession dominance;Baines 7 ? Not his best game but still very good. He controlled proceedings and his delivery was reliable, creating our best moments;Osman 5 ? First half was alright, but he was abysmal in the second. Always leaving Baines to fend for himself;Heitinga 7 ? Best game in a while from him, hard and in your face, which countered Bowyer... cracker of a goal;Rodwell 5 ? Has no confidence, too readily losses possesion and seems to be positionally unaware;Arteta N/A ? Let's hope it's not to bad;Beckford 6 ? Competed better in the air this time, had a few bright moments, but sometimes his touch let him down;Saha 5 ? Really out of sorts, gave away possession too cheaply and missed our best chances in the second half;Coleman 6 ? Worked had, but drifted in and out of the game, his distribution lets him down far too much though;Anichebe 5 ? Stayed on his feet most of the time, and came closest to scoring, via an accident..., how is he in the team??Bily N/A ? Not enough time.
No-one has any idea of Moyes's best 11, be that 4-5-1 or 4-4-2 or any idea of who should play in every single midfield position. To add to this we have one of the poorest defences in the league that for some reason never gets changed, yet everyone still expects us to turn over all before us and go on some unassailable charge towards Europe.
I'll admit I was fooled into believeing all the pre-match hype too. Should know better by now.
The midfield has been ripped apart, thought the team did well inspite of this and battled back from losing Mikel.
Osman was the best player tonight, though. More chances for Saha and Beckford, no sign of any partnership developing, however.
Come on, lads, judge the team on tonight's performance and not on any past let-downs. Difficult as it is, I grant you that.
Rodwell & Heitinga (great goal) played a safe conservative game & Coleman played with a lot of drive but too little direction. Both Saha & Beckford had a couple of decent efforts on target, but on other occasions they wanted too many touches & blew chances.
Without Arteta & Fellaini I reckon it's going to be the same story for the rest of season. The fact that Bily only got a token gesture 5 mins means that his number is almost certainly up.
David #12 gives Heitinga a 7 when he was dreadful and cost us a goal. For £60k a week I'd expect more from him. Like tracking back. And gives Osman a 5. Beckford a 6!! His touch is like a steam train. And Victor a 5!! Same as Osman! Same old tonight I'm afraid. We lack quality in the final 3rd and gave away a terrible goal. We can't break teams down when they sit for 45 mins.
Another year of top flight, hopefully (!) but what nightmares await next year...
CHANGE PLEASE! ? Taxi for Blue Bill!
A strong squad has adequate cover for all positions and we palpably do not!! If Saha gets injured its Becks and Vic, if Arteta is injured its Osman, if Fellaini is injured its Rodwell if Baines is injured GHU !!
We have NO players coming through to shove the first team for places and our secret weapon Magaye is as obvious as Sadaam Hussein's weapons of mass destruction??
We have to play Vic or Bily because we have no alternative. We lost Gosling, sold Pienaar and put six players out on loan including Yak and Vaughan.... so it's no good crying over spilt milk... our squad has been decimated!!
Yet another frustrating game; I never thought that i would say this but I can't wait for the season to end
My ratings: Howard 6, Hibbert 7, Jags 6, Distin 6, Baines 7, Osman 8, Rodwell 7, Heitinga 6, Coleman 6, Saha 5, Beckford 4, Anichebe 2.
I think all season, I'd throw a number like 5% out there for the amount of substitutions I've seen him make and thought "Good move". The same number would be for the amount of times I feel he has selected the best side for any given match. I know this is all negative criticism, but seriously, even the most staunch Moyes supporters would struggle to say that he's earned his money this season. As I've done before, I challenge anyone to defend Moyes's position at the club without citing the financial issue.
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
» Log in now
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
About these ads
Get rid of these ads and support ToffeeWeb
Bet on Everton and get a deposit bonus with bet365 at TheFreeBetGuide.com
View full table
We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.