Drama to the end of the shoot-out

A crazy penalty shoot-out that finished 9-8, Naismith and Robles both missing to give West Ham the tie.

Michael Kenrick 13/01/2015 220comments  |  Jump to last

West Ham United 2 - 2 Everton [aet]

West Ham win 9-8 on penalties

With a long list of injured or otherwise indisposed players unavailable for selection, it limited any tinkering with the team line-up Roberto Martinez could select and he stuck with the starting XI who performed well enough on Saturday to deny Manchester City the win their high-value stars spolit fans demanded to keep them snapping at the heels of Chelsea at the top of the Premier League.

But for this evening, its the romance of the FA Cup, and a replay at Upton Park as Everton cling onto the hope of a decent run in the old competition, a fine rendition of Bubbles welcoming the home side with a large contingent of Everton fans in the crowd.

With both sides in changed strips, it was Everton who showed the greater intent, but McGeady, with acres of space to cross, took the extra touch to draw his man, and struggled to retain possession, Barkley not getting the call when clearly fouled by Carroll. After that, it was the home side who surged forward with pace, getting into wide open spaces, and putting in a number of crosses that were thankfully non-threatening.

Everton then applied some pressure that included a really abysmal corner delivered by Baines. At the other end, Stones made the decsiosn to play out of the Dee and made a dreadful hash of it, Valencia getting a golden chance but Robles defelcted his shot up and onto Carrolll at the far post but his header was called offside with the Everton defence all over the place. But at the other end, Lukaku seemed to have a great chance with a ball over his shoulder but he too was called offside.

Article continues below video content

Barry smacked one long that Lukaku chased down but McGeadys shot was driven hopelessly wide with the goal at his mercy. It was end-to-end stuff, West Ham getting a soft free-kick that was header away by Jagielka as The Hammers took a more direct approach. Stones did well to shepherd Carroll and the ball out for a goalkick but the quality of play generally was getting a little scrappy perhaps befitting a blood-and thunder cup-tie the crowd was hoping they were witnessing.

Barry jumped in high and caught studs on his thigh, leading to a good free-kick that was played in too wide for Jagielka to get much power but it led to a corner and another McGeady shot, this one blocked away, and West Ham straight down the other end. Naismith tried a slide-rule pass to Lukaku that didnt come off but he almost got a return-ball shot on goal. Coleman then crossed well from the right but it did not reach Lukaku who then got himself offside yet again to end the next attack.

Stones was the next to bang it long, but Lukaku did not fight for it, as West Ham had a good spell without really threatening. The Blues/Whites tried to build again with smart passing through the middle ad out to Coleman but Barry wasted the good build-up with a lazy cross to nobody. Jagielka played a brilliant ball right to Lukakus feet and the Big Man somehow contrived to kick it behind him! Astounding! At the other end, Downing sized up to shoot but drove it a yard or so wide with Robles covering.

Everton looked to build with close-quarter passing but it all fell apart when Naismith passed to where Besic was standing a second earlier and West Ham were gamboling forward, winning a corner that Robles plucked out of the air at the far post, Everton having dealt competently with the variety of crosses incoming so far.

McGeady laid on another nice ball for Lukaku but the West Ham defender, who seemed to have no chance, somehow ended up with the ball at his feet when it shouldve been the Big Mans McGeady finally picked up the first card for a rather silly challenge and thankfully nothing came of the free-kick. Naismth did well to win a corner of what seemed a nailed on goal kick and it was delivered better but Stones was called for climbing as he headed goalwards.

Lukaku did brilliantly to win the ball in the centre-circle and drive forward, the ball falling nicely for McGeady but the goalie was out quickly to force his shot wide as he snuffed out the chance. At the other end, Jagielka had to pull off a Row Z clearance to deny Jenkinson. So ended the first half, lots of huff and puff plenty of effort and intent but nothing of any substance to really test Adrian in the West Ham goal.

Barkley tried to run in on goal after the break but Jarvis had the measure of him. At the other end, Stones tackled Valencia brilliantly, but it was given as a corner, Collins lashing high over the Everton bar.

Lukaku gave the ball away horrendously just outside the West Ham area and it was a mad scamper for all to get back. Going the other way again and a beautiful ball seemingly to Lukaku's feet but it came off him backwards and he was incredibly offside again!. From the free-kick, three simple West Ham passes up-field and a simple goal for Valencia, the Everton defence apparently switching off completely.

Lukaku made space at the other end and stroked his shot straight at Adrian as Everton struggled to respond after edging things on points, and it only got worse after another silly challenge by McGeady, leaving his leg high, saw a quite needless second yellow and red from a somewhat reluctant Neil Swarbrick.

So, in control of the tie one minute, Everton were suddenly a goal down and a man down, with a noisy home crowd now in full voice. As West Ham sat deep, Everton had to resort to backwards and sideways nonsense passes until Besic gave the ball straight to a defender and seconds later Valencia was taking a potshot at goal. Martinez thought about things for a while, then decided on a double switch, Mirallas and Oviedo on for Barkley and Besic. But not before Carroll fouled Lukaku, giving Baines a chance to curl one in that Collins headed clear.

Barkley looked to get off a shot but just gave up possession cheaply and at the other end there was almost a sight of goal for West Ham. The changes were made and Everton regrouped with a little over 20 mins to get an equalizer, or meekly say goodbye to the FA Cup for yet another year.

Naisimth and Lukaku combined to force the issue, but not enough to win the corner their play deserved, while at the other end, Carroll could only head over at the far post. Mirallas saw yellow for clipping Tomkins's heels. And it was Tompkins who denied Mirallas the equalizer from 4 yards after some fine work by Lukaku to beat Collins for a high ball. At the other end, Coleman and Baines had to combine to save a Valencia goal before Collins powered in a superb header from the corner, and it brought the very best out of Robles who kept Everton in the game with an excellent one-handed save.

Five minutes of brilliant cup-tie football had been a long time coming and it continued as Lukaku was fouled on the corner of the West Ham area, Mirallas curling in an absolutely stunning free-kick round the outside of the wall and just inside the post. A completely brilliant execution of a set-piece. Fantastic stuff!

West Ham came very close to the winner after Stones was called for handball outside the area when it was really ball to hand inside the area, Robles kicking the ball off the line, then saving the follow-up. West Ham finally used their extra man to squeeze Everton near the end and it was all hands at the back, Robles pulling off another miraculous one-handed parry to push Nolan's shot over.

There was a certain inevitability as the clock ticked through 4 mins of added time before the two sides set up for extra time but the pace and tempo of the game was unrelenting, West Ham winning a late corner that Carroll met in heavy traffic. But Everton could not clear their lines, as it kept coming back relentlessly until the final whistle brought brief respite.

Naismith created a marvelous chance via Coleman and Lukaku incredibly missed an open goal, the ball rolling impossibly under his foot. But in the next attack, a brilliant curricular run by Mirallas teed up the Big Man again, and although he did his best to scuff it the ball had enough power to roll over the line from close range to give 10-man Everton a priceless go-ahead goal.

Mirallas went on another incredible 60-yard run but was unable to lay it off at the end and Everton looked more confident with the one-goal lead to protect. 15 mins of extra time left to survive...

Mirallas was like a man possessed at times, driving at West Ham again and winning a corner that he took short to Barry. From that, another run into the area, this time blocked for a clear penalty. Yet again, Swarbrick bizarrely gave a free-kick outside the area that Oviedo powered into the wall and Mirallas failed to profit after being clear for a header at the far post. Mirallas then tried to curl one in but it was off-target.

10 minutes left and Everton kept pumping the ball forward to put what pressure they could on the increasingly demoralized home side, who made their final change, Cole on for Collins. At this point The Blues tried using the sideways passing to waste time but an offside pass saw West Ham get up the other end and win a corner that Cole followed up to poke home off the far post header, almost impossible to defend.

So more work still needed in this tremendous game; with two goals in extra time and penalties looming, West Ham winning another corner, Carroll steamrolling in but fouling as he headed wide. But another corner, this time gathered by Robles. It was horribly ragged at times.

Lukaku finally took things into his own hands, powering into the area but incredibly driving across goal when it seemed easier to burst the net!!! What a maddening performance from him today... Another brilliant save was required by Robles as Amalfitano went for glory. Then Nolan and Noble laid into Tompkins in an amazing scene.

An unbelievable scramble at the end defies descriptions as Valencia and Cole somehow managed not to score the winner for West Ham and the game incredibly went to penalties... almost an anti-climax after a crazy-crazy end-to-end game in the fashion of the very best FA Cup ties of old...

And so to the penalty shoot-out, Everton with the first kick:.

Mirallas: scored down the middle 0-1
Noble: sends Robles the wrong way 1-1
Naismith: straight at Adrian, saved 1-1
Nolan: sends Robles the wrong way 2-1
Lukaku: sends Adrian the wrong way 2-2
Carroll: sends Robles the wrong way 3-2
Baines: Adrian almost saves 3-3
Cresswell: Down the middle 4-3
Oviedo: Down the middle 4-4
Downing: Robles saves low to his left!!! 4-4
Barry: Smacks it home! 4-5
Cole: sends Robles the wrong way 5-5
Stones: only just! dreadful penalty... 5-6
Valencia: sends Robles the wrong way 6-6
Jagielka: slides it home nicely 6-7
Amalfitano: sends Robles the wrong way 7-7
Coleman: sends Adrian the wrong way 7-8
Jenkinson: smacks into the roof of the net 8-8
Robles: Smacks the bar with ridiculpous power - 8-8
Adrian: sends Robles the wrong way 9-8

You had to laugh at the end... Robles, who had done so well during the game, could not resist putting his entire massive frame behind blasting the ball goalwards, hitting the underside of the bar and bouncing back.... GAME OVER!

Scorers: Valencia (54'), Cole (113'); Mirallas (83'), Lukaku (97').

Everton: Robles; Coleman, Stones, Jagielka, Baines; Barry [Y:85'], Besic (67' Oviedo); Barkley (67' Mirallas [Y:78']), McGeady [Y:40; YR:56'], Naismith, Lukaku.
Subs: Griffiths, Garbutt, Alcaraz, , McAleny, Kone.

West Ham United: Adrian, Cresswell, Tomkins, Jarvis (69' Amalfitano) , Carroll, Downing, Noble (c), Jenkinson, Collins, Song (61' Nolan [Y:72']), Valencia.
Subs: Jaaskelainen, Vaz Te, O'Brien, Cole, Burke.

Referee: Neil Swarbrick

Share article:

Reader Comments (220)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Andy Crooks
1 Posted 13/01/2015 at 18:56:33
This line up should be good enough. It also suggests that we are going to lose a striker whose name this kindle won’t let me type.
Terry Davies
2 Posted 13/01/2015 at 18:55:14
I presume Mirallas must have broken both legs. How the hell is McGeady in there ahead of him. I hate criticising players but McGeady was AWFUL last match (which was a huge improvement). But I must stick with Roberto - he must know what he's doing. Doesn't he?????
Lyndon Lloyd
3 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:00:26
If Mirallas isn't 100% then it's wise not to push him, Terry.

We've had enough problems rushing McCarthy and Barry back already. So as much as I want Mirallas in the team, it shouldn't be at the expense of his long-term fitness.

Terry Davies
4 Posted 13/01/2015 at 18:59:44
Andy - talking about he who can't be written, Roberto says he's not going anywhere so (if he is, why the hell not get out of him what we can). What game is Roberto playing?
Terry Davies
5 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:03:54
Fair point, Lyndon
Jim Bennings
6 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:07:53
Why not replace McGeady with Kone and be bolder and braver?

West Ham look really strong with Song back in the middle (one of themost unsung players for me this sseason, no pun intended)

Baines and Coleman will need big games tonight up against Downing and Jarvis, if we allow them two wingers to feed Carroll we will no doubt at some point suffer.

Eto'o surely looks on his way out now..shame.

Barry McNally
7 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:10:23
Don't usually look at the opposition but they are missing Reid which is a big loss for them.
Craig James
8 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:07:47
I can’t understand why Bobby is keeping faith in McGeady. Surely if Super Kev is not 100%, Oviedo is the better option.

I believe Eto’o’s agent is setting him up for another big pay day but I could be wrong.

We need the defence to push 10 yards further up the pitch and ensure someone is infront and behind Carroll at every set piece. That with a high tempo, along with more direct passing forward, not sideways, should see us through.

Time will tell but, regardless of how the Hammers have started this season, we should be beating these sort of teams.

Denis Richardson
9 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:03:33
So big Samuel is off after all....guess that was to be expected.

Back 7 pick themselves. I really wonder what Oviedo has to do to get into this side. I'd have him in there as AML instead of McGeady or Naismitn. Martinez needs to start using the players available better. He can't have three senior LBs in the squad and only ever play them at LB. Oviedo and to an extent Baines can both play MF. Oviedo showed last season that he's got a lot more in his locker than just playing LB. Certainly can't be worse than playing Eto or Barkley out wide. Would bring a much better balance down the left and give us better defensive cover.

Tonight all depends on how much West Ham want this. If they're up for it with a fit again Carroll, it's going to be tough to day the least. Hoping for the best but no idea what to expect.

Terry Davies
10 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:11:21
great shame, Jim and would love to see Kone in there with Rom: he's a really good footballer and can score
Mike Oates
11 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:12:02
Obviously both teams committed to FA Cup, no reserves here at all. Will be one tough game with the outcome I suspect who gains the midfield , Song and Noble vs Barry and Besic.
Anyone think we'll walk this , I doubt it very much.
Bill Gall
12 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:17:02
Finally starting with the same team twice. I understand that some supporters are not to happy with McGeady starting but with Mirallas not fully fit McGeady is a better defender for away game.
Ian Burns
13 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:17:01
Although I have lost all confidence in RM I am still obliged to support him because he is the manager of EFC. However we need to show Oviedo (and Garbutt) they are valued and what they must be thinking seeing a team including McGeady must have them shaking their heads
Ian Burns
14 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:24:31
Incidentally I am not jumping on the McGeady bandwagon when he was first mooted as a possible signing I posted on TWITTER on numerous occasions that he was a waste of somebody's place because he has the ability to dribble the ball up his own arse and nothing else!
Jim Bennings
15 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:24:08

I'm not sure how McGeady constitutes as a better defender than Oviedo for away games.

Ian Burns
16 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:26:54
For Twitter read TW
Bill Gall
18 Posted 13/01/2015 at 19:28:33
Oviedo is more left sided and with Barry giving cover down the left side I think McGeady is just a better choice down the right. But then we all have our own opinions.
Jim Bennings
20 Posted 13/01/2015 at 20:27:16
We are totally tepid going forward these day's.

Thank God Robles managed to save our skin thanks to Stones doing our usual per game self destruct job.

Tommy Coleman
21 Posted 13/01/2015 at 20:32:05
We are very unbalanced on the left. Naismith keeps cutting inside and taking up Barkleys space, it's also stopping Baines getting forward.

Doing alright though.

Terry McLavey
22 Posted 13/01/2015 at 20:33:25
'Kinel they're worse than us! And there for the taking!

Why do they have to try and get the ball through to Rom in the box all the time? Have a go yourself FFS!

Brian Hennessy
24 Posted 13/01/2015 at 20:35:42
Pretty good first 45 mins, we seem to be continuing from the good work we put in against City.

Only negative point in Barry seems to be back to his usual self after raising his game at the weekend against the club that got rid of him.

Several really poor lazy passes from him.

Chris Gould
27 Posted 13/01/2015 at 21:14:57
Can everyone all pull together and please accept that Martinez is shite?!
All this crap about turning the corner because we had two home draws!!!!!! City could have scored 4 in the first half because Martinez has turned our defenders into a bunch of nervous fairies. You all have eyes, you must be watching this!!!! Do you really believe he is taking us in the right direction? He’s a total looney. He can’t see what everyone else can. He needs to go!!!!!
Tom Bowers
28 Posted 13/01/2015 at 21:33:50
Can we get to penalties maybe? Seems like the best chance given that McGeady got sent off.
Jay Wood
29 Posted 13/01/2015 at 21:37:38
Still hanging in there. Gutsy performance. Robles MOTM at the moment. Oustanding performance by the much maligned keeper.

Not clever by McGeady. There wasn’t much in the challenge, but it gives the WHU player a chance to milk it and the ref a decision to make.

Pity ’cos McGeady was playing well... more than a year since we’ve won from a losing position. It’s gonna take a big effort...

Jermaine Jennings
30 Posted 13/01/2015 at 21:40:51
So harse Jim, Stones has been the only bright light in a terrible season its the other players who have been shite!!!

I do agree though about RM, I think he should stay until the end of the season and then go. We are pants in almost every aspect of our game and its sad to see.

We’ve also gone back to pass sideways again after being more direct which is bloody frustrating.This guy I believe is losing the dressing room and its only a matter to time before something big erupts

Jay Wood
31 Posted 13/01/2015 at 21:43:21
Tommy Coleman
32 Posted 13/01/2015 at 21:39:09
Get in!!
Chris Gould
33 Posted 13/01/2015 at 21:53:19
Although I don’t like Martinez and want him to go.....Get in there!!! COYB!!!!
Jay Wood
34 Posted 13/01/2015 at 21:56:22
So pleased for the 2 Belgian lads following the weekend tragedy of a close mate. Brilliant play by Mirallas.

15 more minutes blues. Hang in there...

Chris Gould
35 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:34:45
Fuck it!!!! Aaaarrrgghhh!!! Goddammitt!!! Spirited performance with 10 men. Great stuff from Mirallas. But Martinez is shite and has done nothing to change my opinion.

Absolutely shitting myself for WBA. Pulis will have them fired up. I hate being negative, I really do, but I just don’t believe in Martinez. But I love this club and just want us all to be able to dream again!!

Nick Entwistle
36 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:38:28
Stunning effort right through to the end. Penalties, what can you do? West Brom at the weekend, or is it Palace... anyway, we need three points, absolutely need it.
Tommy Coleman
37 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:38:11
Gutted. Great spirit and performance.
Keep that going and we’ll be alright. Need to do something about the left hand side balance. Can’t play Naismith and Barkley together.
Michael Kenrick
38 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:39:28
What a crazy game... almost defies analysis!
Jay Wood
39 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:41:08
Brian Waring
40 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:40:57
Well proud tonight of the lads, we’ve been screaming for some passion and it was there in bundles. The plotters won’t see it that way though.
Tony Hill
41 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:36:30
I think we have to look at this as a great match first and foremost. A sore disappointment in the end but I am proud of the team. It is hard to say just now but I would rather have lost this game than WBA. We also still have the EL.

This was sport at its finest and, for us, it’s cruellest. But we should take heart from a wonderful effort by the players after McGeady went.

The other stand out fact is that Barkley has to be taken out of the team for his own benefit apart from anything else.

Brian Waring
42 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:42:39
Agree Tony on Barkley.
Joseph Clarke
43 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:40:11
What does Barkley contribute to the team?

Cold realisation, we have too many poor players. Manager not good enough. Chairman won’t spend.

Jim Bennings
44 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:37:23
Fuck off Everton!!

Just fuck off you useless bastards.

Another chance of a trophy gone and we still can’t win a fucking match.

1 win in 12 matches now fucking appalling.

Yet again two more goals conceded by corners.

Martinez if he’s still here, which I’m very much doubting if this run continues should swallow his pride and go and spend the fucking money on a centre half who can actually go and HEAD THE BALL

Martinez, if he’s still here by the end of the month

Si Mar
45 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:43:35
Barkley looked unfit from the start, great effort from the lads though and I’m gutted we didn’t make it, hope this can kick us on to better performances and a nice run in the Europa.
Mike Childs
46 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:42:30
Best game I have watched in years. What a shame Rom should have won it in regulation. I think RM is done. He looked like he was crying the entire the game.

Great Spirit again by the guys except the favorites.

Steve Orchard
47 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:43:14
So proud of the boys tonight! The thickness of a crossbar decides it. I thought we were the better side even with ten men, certainly the most positive. Shame the right result didn’t happen for Lukaku and Kev as well as everyone.
Tony Draper
49 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:41:09
Heartbroken for Joel......he was magnificent all night.

Everton were brilliant.
Mirallas was brilliant.

But we was robbed, how was
carroll still on the pitch
noble still on the pitch

We play like that to the end of the season..........I’ll be happy

Paul Andrews
50 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:46:49
That performance made me proud to be an Evertonian. The heart and spirit shown by the lads was great to see. They have got their pride back in the Royal Blue shirt.

The best judges of the performance were the 3,000 away fans who stayed to give the team a standing ovation, the players taking their shirts off to give to the fans.

Martinez is so close to putting a very good side together. If we stand by him, we will get our reward.

David Cornmell
51 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:47:58
Just another dagger to the heart. The twentieth year we’re not going to win anything.

I’m getting too old for this shit, and the "rebuilding"project enters it’s THIRD decade.

Give me my club back.

Tony Draper
52 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:48:47
Jim Bennings..............?

Yer Ma wears wellies

Michael Kenrick
53 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:46:08
It will be interesting to have Harold Matthews come on and explain to us no-nothing imbecilles who dare to question McGeady’s ’contribution’, exactly how the hapless Irishman contrived (in what was actually a slightly better but again ultimately useless performance from him) to turn a game that was heading to a mundane home victory into a rip-roaring FA Cup classic that had drama all over the pitch right up to the very end... and still ended up as a home victory.

It’s a funny old game indeed!

Tony Abrahams
55 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:40:42
The fight is back, but we looked a better threat with ten men. Reason, we played much more direct. Barkley needs to play central but he needs to get braver. I take my hat off to the keeper, because I thought he was knowhere near good enough, but he’s proved me wrong. I hope he gets a run in the team after that.

Get McCarthy’s energy back, and a decent wide man and let’s put the last few months behind us.

I hate going out of the FA CUP, fucking hate it, but let’s get a few wins in the league, so we can then concentrate on Europe.

Unlucky Everton, at least you’ve had ago tonight.

Laurie Hartley
56 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:53:02
It was me who said he would turn the game if he started. I am gutted.
I’ll post later after I have finished work.
Jon Miners
57 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:52:24
Terrific effort Blues. Kick on from here.
Darren Hind
58 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:47:26
What a monumental effort from the boys to turn that around, all we had to do was defend a corner and we were home and hosed. . .only our manager doesnt think its worthwhile defending corners, we don’t do the work so so were out.

Proud of the boys, but this season they have been let down by a manager who has never operated at their level until he came here

Martinez has been found wanting this season.

I’m sick as fuck

David Cornmell
59 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:52:09
An "FA Cup Classic" was another failure to hold a winning position against midtable opposition.

Tonight summed us up perfectly – good enough to compete, not good enough to get over the line.

Like the last twelve games in all competitions, home and away. We’ve as much backbone as a jellyfish... Martinez OUT.

Leslie Dunkwu
60 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:50:09
Good performance, though I still think we are weak defensively. Can’t understand some decisions from RM, why take and Besic who was having a great game and allow Barry to play? Robles seems a good keeper, think he just needs more games to boost his confidence. Losing Howard could be a blessing in disguise.
Mike Childs
61 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:52:51
Michael you can’t lay it Harold’s feet for that idiot lifting up his leg. That’s squarely on McGeady with an assist to RM for having him on the pitch in the first place.
David Hallwood
62 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:51:45
Good report, Michael; any stattos out there tell me how many goals we’ve conceded from from set pieces this season. No matter how well the lads did there still is the bald fact that it’s 1 win in 12 and no clean sheet since Wolfsburg.

Worrying times...

Tony Hill
63 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:57:05
A major plus was Robles, his last save in extra time was superb. His kicking and punching were also excellent. If he emerges from this game as a confident keeper then that, in the longer term, will be the most important thing of all.

I also thought Jagielka was particularly good tonight.

Jim Bennings
64 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:58:56
1 win in 12 mate???

Can’t keep a clean sheet for love nor money.


But it’s ok though because now we can concentrate on staying up eh lads?? What a fucking joke!

Barkley should be sent on loan to a Championship club tomorrow and told how to fucking become stronger and learn his trade.

This defeat could totally destroy our season.

Mike Hayes
65 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:01:14
Robles went too early for all but one penalty - kept us in it before that
Ste Traverse
66 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:59:58
Oh how I DESPISE that cunt Kevin Nolan. Utter talentless kicking machine.

Can’t fault the side tonight except McGeady needs dumping. 1 win in 12 is awful with the players we have.

And it’s all down to the manager.

Lee Whitehead
67 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:59:20
Barkley – the MOST over rated player I have ever seen!!!
£50 Million my arse – Snatch there fukin hands off.

McGeady – you are a waste of fuckin’ space!!! Will you please do the right thing and FUCK OFF!!!

Neil Pickering
68 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:03:28
Well, Roberto was right in the pre-game when he said Joel could be the difference if it went to pens...

Jokes aside, I’m immensely proud of all of the lads tonight, they showed fight I never thought they had anymore! Special mention to Robles as well, who I have slaughtered on here. He was great tonight, I just hope that penalty miss hasn’t knocked him back because he looked like he was gaining in confidence.


Brent Stephens
69 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:02:48
Overall, a continuation of the last three games in terms of some passion, mixing it up (Row Z at times from defence when needed; fast balls direct to the front line; use of the wings, behind the full backs and playing to Rom’s strengths).

Disappointed we lost but pleased we are now showing something different. COYB!

Mike Childs
70 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:08:15
Is RM still coaching?
Jamie Crowley
71 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:04:09
McGeady is getting slatted completely with a lack of intelligence and just bullshit vitriol!

McGeady was the ONE player completely UP for this game. He was lively and looked excellent the first half.

He got sent off in a daft challenge, BUT NEVER a yellow card. NEVER! Noble - TWAT that he is, had NO contact whatsoever and went down like Barbie on Ken. Complete cheat and cunt! Always has been, always will be.

NEITHER yellow cards issued to McGeady were cards. But we all need a scapegoat, right?

ANY Blue slagging off our team after THAT effort should be ashamed. We thoroughly deserved to go through and we played with passion, grit, and determination.

I’m sick to the teeth of the crap hurled at McGeady. Some of it may be warranted at times, but it’s WAY over the top.

That kid looked most likely to score in the first half, and that kid was unjustly sent off by a DIVING TWAT of a human being in Noble.

Noble needs to suck on a muffler.

Kunal Desai
72 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:08:36
The performances and commitment from the players has vastly improved over the last three games, this gives us the platform to build on and take into our league games, it’s extremely vital we start picking up wins and start moving away from the clubs at the bottom. One thing that is evident is that Barkley needs to start the next few games from the bench.
Jamie Crowley
73 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:10:49
Jim Bennings -

Your one in twelve comments are so elementary, so devoid of intelligence...

Can you not see the effort? Can you not see the change in style and play? We were down, unfairly, to TEN MEN and we responded fantastically.

Jesus, I wonder how you do it, Mr Bottom Line "We’ve Not Won but 1 in 12". Excellent analysis, Einstein!

Stephen Brown
74 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:08:47
Words can’t describe this feeling! Gutted! Only thing to play for in January is Premier League survival ( Europa apart ???) it feels like the early nighties.

Excellent effort from the players! Never mind us they must be sick!!

On another note: offer Mirallas what he wants for a new contract!

Neil Pickering
75 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:12:31
Anyway, did anyone else notice what a bitter, bitter man David James is?
Brian Waring
76 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:10:57
Ref gave them everything all night Jamie, he was a complete shithouse for not giving us that pen, it was about 2 yards in the box.

Had a good laugh though when some said Allardyce had ’out thought Martinez’ yeah, it must have been really hard to tell your players that the tactics tonight will be to just keep twating it up to Carrol.

Denis Richardson
77 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:08:34
Gutted but my god why the fuck did we not just play like that over the last couple of months! More direct play suits the players, end of.

Doff my cap to Robles, had an excellent game and going by that performance we certainly don’t need to be spending millions on a new GK just yet.

Disappointed to be out but we probably could do without the extra games as we need to focus on getting up the league table and save it all for an assault on the EL.

Top effort, couldn’t ask for more. Take a rest and play like that again on Monday.

David Cornmell
78 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:11:02
Get your shit together, Crowley. It’s football, not Law And Order. The team that deserved to go through went through.

There was no injustice here, just a game where a team that lacked confidence got into a winning position and bottled it.

I’m not ashamed of them, just horrified how they have forgotten how to win. And how are they going to change that?

Dean Barton
79 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:54:38
Great effort from the lads tonight. It’s obvious after the last 3 games that the players are behind RM.

A few grumblings though.

McGeady is shockingly bad. How has he managed to work his way into a PL team! I have seen nothing from this lad in 12 months. One of the worst players to have worn the shirt.

Barkley is just an enigma. This season he has seriously lost his way. He doesn’t deserve to be in the squad at present and I feel he needs dropping. I have a feeling he believes his own hype and wants away but that is just speculation.

Why does Besic always have to be the fall guy? Does RM ever remove Barry or McCarthy?

Why only 2 sub’s? Surely a pair of fresh legs in ET would have helped the team!

Other than a few exceptions the team look like one again. Battling and chasing everything down which they weren’t doing a few weeks ago. Very proud of them tonight after going a man down.

Onwards and upwards!

Kieran Riding
81 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:15:27
We were great tonight. Some pride has been restored.
Jamie Crowley
82 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:12:58
Bennings -

Barkley should be sent to the Championship!

Maybe if we had a winger and he wasn’t played out of position by necessity and could run at defenders from the middle of the pitch you’d change your position?

Barkley is playing in a role that does not suit his skill set or talents. You can’t see that, and I wonder if you can ever see the forest through the trees.

Jamie Crowley
83 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:16:47
Brian Waring 78 -


I’d expect nothing less.

Barry Stevens
84 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:58:36
How anyone can be complaining after playing 65 minutes with ten men is beyond me. There were some great performances out there by our lads. Plenty of positives to be taken.

The much maligned Robles actually looked like a keeper. Stones and Jags stood up well to the Hammers’ constant air bombardment. Besic again quality. What a player he could become. Super Kev showing why so many of us hold him in such high regard.

If you’re looking for downsides, then McGeady is the obvious one. The guy was actually having a good game, but let himself down with schoolboy stupidity. Ross was poor but will come good so let’s not get on his back.

If we carry on playing like we have in the last two, then we will have a good end to the season.

James Marshall
86 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:17:25
Just escaped from the ground, great effort from the blues. Can’t fault them for effort at least from the view at the game.

Song our hearts out. Up the blues.

Jim Bennings
87 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:14:59

If we’d shown this "effort" earlier in the season or for the first 89 minutes last week at home to West Ham we may not be in a relegation battle or out the cup.

Fact mate!

One win in twelve is FACT.

No clean sheet since November is FACT!!

Okay, they fought tonight... but Martinez still makes too many mistakes, game-in & game-out.

Our defence is a shambles on crosses no matter who plays there.

We can gloss over this defeat all we like but the fact is we can’t beat ANYONE at present.

Paul Thompson
88 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:10:19
Still gutted and trying to catch my breath. We deserved to win that. We played positive, intelligent football after going down to ten men. Chances were created, but not enough taken. Lukaku was the culprit but overall he had a good game. Mirallas was exceptional.

Barkley stunk. I don’t know what’s happened to him, but he’s a liability at the moment. He needs a rest and we need a rest from him.

Jags had a great game, but let’s face it, the defence still looks shaky, particularly at set pieces. Stones will be a great player, but his inexperience showed tonight. Compare how Coleman played Valencia in an almost identical situation to the one where he too easily beat Stones for the first goal. And, it appears we may have found a goalkeeper (though perhaps not a penalty taker).

Neil Pickering
89 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:17:21
1 minor gripe. Even though they say there is no pressure to save a pen in a shoot out for a keeper, did anyone notice how early Robles was actually diving for the pens? Literally my Mrs would have slotted all of those pens because he left massive parts of his goal open for players to roll it into. Maybe the camera angle on BT did him no favours?

Look at me – I’m actually a Joel apologist now!

Victor Jones
90 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:03:55
Great game of football for the neutral but, no matter how you dress it up, it’s another defeat for Martinez. I could go on about individual performances (good and indifferent and bad), but we all know the game and we all know who turned up. So I won’t. I’ve seen all this before from Everton.

But on to my point: "What Everton team is going to turn up against WBA? ... And, should we lose, then when is it time to call it a day on Martinez’s "philosophy"?

Here’s hoping that we stuff West Brom but there will be no bravado from me... just praying. And that is the sad fact concerning Martinez’s tenure this season..... we just don’t know what to expect.

Chris Gould
91 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:11:34
We play well when Martinez’s tactics go out the window. If we salvage anything from this season it will be because the players are implementing changes in spite of RM.

Everything decent that we do is direct and anti-Martinez’s philosophy. Everything shite comes from his naïvity, philosophy, tactics, bullshit... he’s gotta go.

Eddie Dunn
92 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:11:14
Marvellous effort from the team. Robles was great, a revelation. Only a shame he didn’t stay central during the pens, as 4 at least went straight.

A cracking game, I was shattered by the end. Let’s hope this doesn’t affect the team’s confidence... I suspect not, watching the lads go to the away end throwing their shirts to the fans.

Let’s push on, Blues.

Jamie Crowley
93 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:20:55
I tell you what’s fact you deep thinker Bennings -

Roberto thought that we had enough talent to stick to his guns and PLAY our way, through possession football, through this malaise.

Through a Come to Jesus meeting with Rom and players, he’s allowed an adjustment.

We are now playing very, very good entertaining yet more cautious football.

But he STILL gets shit from people like you who say only 1 in 12.

FACT! - We are playing with passion and verve.

FACT! - we’ve made an adjustment to our playing style improving the performances.

FACT! - Roberto was FLEXIBLE enough to allow this!

FACT! - Our players have responded because they love their manager.

FACT! - We should have won tonight.

FACT! - Anyone who can’t see that and appreciate it is lacking any foresight or intelligence.

Give you broken record a rest - it’s a shit song you’re singing - full of crap and shite.

Kevin Rowlands
94 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:19:28
JB, seriously mate, calm down, it was a great effort especially seeing that we played more than an hour with only 10 men, we’re going to be fine, smoke a joint, pop a valium, drink a six pack, drink a herbal tea or whatever rocks your boat, everything is going to be okay, Jim!
Colin Gee
95 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:22:15
Gutted... we didn’t deserve to lose on Pens; saying that neither did West Ham. Should have been back to Goodison next Tuesday night for another go. (With the West Brom game scheluled on Monday to be re-arranged for another night.)
Brian Waring
96 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:25:22
Chris Gould, somehow I don’t think the players are taking it upon themselves to play the tactics they want to play, I think it’s more a case of Martinez doing what good managers do, listening to his players.
Jamie Crowley
97 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:26:17
Jim -

I simply can’t take your glass half empty crap any longer. I’ve every right to post as such.

If you can’t see how beautiful a game of footy tonight’s game was and you insist on focusing on the negatives - after we played with such heart and passion with TEN MEN, I think your negative contributions should be directly taken to task.

David Cornmell
98 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:20:29
We just got knocked out the cup by Big Sam’s Hammers. Yeah, we battled and competed and were somewhat unlucky. But not enormously. Collins should have sealed the game in the eightieth minute, and we went down the other end and scored. Then we got in the lead and fucked it.

You can talk about performance and character and positives and moving forward... but we haven’t won a game of football for a long time. I don’t want performances and effort and guts and heart. I want a result. A straight up, old fashioned win. P> How long am I going to wait? February? March? April We can be the gutsiest, toughest, best performing side in the Championship. At this pace, that’s where we are going.

Jamie Crowley
99 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:28:27

Waring at 98 spot on.

Ray Roche
100 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:21:29
Great effort tonight, but it just shows how important it is to defend dead ball situations, corners, free kicks, all of them. Makes you realise what a stupid attitude our "coaching staff" must have when they say that there is no need to practice defending against them. Pathetic.

Jamie Crowley #73.
"Noble needs to suck on a muffler"
Good to see the spirit of Noel Coward lives on....

Andrew Laird
101 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:13:30
Jamie #73, both McGeady yellows were as clear cut as you are ever likely to see. The first he took for Barry’s misplaced pass then he lost his common sense and slid for 10 yards and raised his studs to knee height for good measure!

I agree, McGeady was much improved and looked lively, he was also providing defensive cover that Barkley does not ever look interested enough in providing on the other flank, time for a few games on the bench so he can watch Oviedo.

Naismith might just be the new Cahill, a player who will run through brick walls for 90 minutes, is great in the air, has great movement off the ball but unfortunately does not have the close control or touch needed for a team who rely on creativity. He scores, thank goodness, as we have needed his goals but moves break down a lot of the time when he fails to find a blue shirt and when he does not score it really does highlight this.

Colin Gee
102 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:27:10
Jamie #73

Spot on, I watched in on a stream on the PC but the first thing I thought watching it was McGeady looks up for it tonight! I am not his greatest fan.

The first yellow card was one those that gets given in the modern era. The second one, yes he slid in but it wasn’t a yellow.

Neil Pickering
103 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:24:10
Chris #93 I don’t necessarily think that the players have ditched his philosophy; I saw plenty of overplaying in around their penalty area and also ours as well which is obviously Martinez’s influence.

I think there is no harm at times keeping the ball as it takes the sting out of teams and, to be honest, even though West Ham pressed us, I can think of only one glaring error in possession made by Stones, the rest of the passing I thought was good up until the final third.

We do look better when we mix it, in particular, Lukaku, who really appears to like the ball forward quickly and into space. Barkley needs to come out though, his awareness for a lad who is lauded as the next big thing is nothing short of appalling for a central midfielder. His range and choice of pass is shocking.

Jay Harris
104 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:24:26
For once, I’ve got to give it to the lads a magnificent effort that, with a bit of luck and better refereeing, we could have won.

The only negatives for me: We cannot defend corners under this manager and if Kev was fit for the second half and extra time why wasn’t he fit to start the game and go for the early goal?

Carroll had far less right to stay on the pitch than McGeady but we can’t seem to find a referee who favours us.

Jamie Crowley
105 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:31:09
Andrew -

I respectfully - and I do mean respectfully - disagree re McGeady’s second yellow. Watch it again. Noble dove. Simple as. No contact.

Was McGeady’s boot high? Yes. Was there any contact whatsoever? NO!

Any ref worth his salt (and this ref was complete crap, missing a ton of calls even many that went OUR way) he’d of never pulled a second yellow for that challenge.

First one, okay I’m a bit pissed right now fair enough. Second? Never in a MILLION YEARS.

Noble is a cunt twat diving douche bag.

Kevin Rowlands
106 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:26:54
Er, Colin, not sure if you’ve been on the piss but next week was never an option, mate. It finished on pens pal, don’t think a tie and a replay is happening at that point.
Ray Roche
107 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:31:56
Andrew, I don’t agree with you about McGeady’s two yellows. The second one, when McGeady slid in, it appeared to me that that cheating tool Noble wasn’t touched but stayed down long enough for the ref (spit) to get his card out.

I also think McGeady was having one of his best games for us, full of running but, sadly, a bit too energetic in his tackling for this referee.

Colin Glassar
108 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:30:03
Positives from tonight?

Robles - excellent. Coleman and Baines getting back to their best. Stones and Jags starting to gel. Barry and Besic fought like lions. Mcgeady was playing well but.... Ross, very poor. Needs to be played centrally or dropped. Nessie bit wasteful but what a battler. Lukaku, grew into the game and got stronger as the game progressed. Bryan and Kevin gave us balance and width.

Roberto made the changes and was almost rewarded. He’s certainly getting his act together again.

David Cornmell
109 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:29:03
Jamie, you don’t get points for trying.

Jim’s big problem is one win from twelve.

You watch the "magnificent phenomenal amazing performance" of a team at Reading, Wigan and QPR. The rest of us might mourn what we’ve lost.

Jamie Crowley
110 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:34:06
Chris Gould, you’re delusional.

Martinez is the manger of Everton Football Club. He got us a record points total of 72 last season and a memorable season it was!

The players are not calling the shots. They approached their leader and suggested changes. Anyone in a leadership position knows you need to listen...

Roberto did, and allowed the changes to happen. Not the other way around.

And we’re better off for it, so well done Roberto.

Chris Leyland
111 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:36:28
Colin, I agree that things seem to be improving. Question is, is it because the manager is rooting out the ’bad apples’ and improving morale as a result?
Chris Gould
112 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:31:33
Brian Waring, I’d like to think that too. But I don’t. We were shite until the sending off. This forced a change in the way we played.

Ironically, if McGeady hadn’t been sent off, I don’t think we would be writing anything positive about tonight’s performance. Showing guts with 10 men was admirable and filled me with pride, but how we were playing with 11 was worrying.

What I don’t understand on this site is how people take other people’s opinions so personally. As if it’s a direct attack on themselves. Jim Bennings is correct. 1 win in 12 is absolute shite, and people saying we have turned a corner because we have drawn 2 at home and now lost 1 on pens.... well, er... I respectfully disagree.

Willy Russell
113 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:35:21
I could give you a few facts about Jim Bennings and I don’t even know him – thankfully...
David Hallwood
114 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:25:25
Re Barkley: I’m sure some of the people on here are new to the game. FFS Barkley’s going through a lean period and he looks like his confidence is shot to pieces, but there’s the old cliche of form and class, and he’s the same player that ran the length of the field v Barcodes to score last season, who scored the MotD goal of the month, who came on against Citteh and neutralised Toure.

IMHO, Martinez should partner Barkley with either Besic or McCarthy, and keep him there for the rest of the season, rather than switching between the 3 AMs and ask him to do a Fabregas box-to-box job.

The 2 holders in midfield isn’t working defensively nor are they creative enough. Time for a change but RM seems to love Barry.

Anthony Jones
115 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:32:48
Great game to listen to. Obviously a disappointing outcome. Perhaps the players were more relaxed knowing that we didn’t absolutely have to start winning tonight (whether you like it or not the league is where the money is). Roberto has mentioned more than once that the players need to enjoy playing again.

Still, didn’t hear much of Barry and really not getting his constant inclusion, nor the playing of Naismith/Barkley/Eto’o in the same position.

Oliver Molloy
116 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:03:27
A very brave performance from our 10 men. McGeady was just plain stupid sliding in when he already is on a yellow card - unbelievable! The game is all about taking your chances and big Rom should have won it for us.

I said after the Man City game, I would take going out of the cup if it meant us getting the right results in our next couple of league games. Nothing more than 3 points will do against West Brom at our place and then on to Palace. We will need the spirit shown tonight by our lads come next Monday night, let’s hope they bring it!

The cup is gone and West Brom was always a bigger and more important match than tonight anyway given our current league position – IT IS A MUST WIN.

So, 3 points against West Brom, draw or win against Palace and of course 3 points against our biggest rivals is what we need!

Tony Hill
117 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:33:10
The ref was an utter shambles. I noticed some of our players though having a proper go at him, including Jagielka. Another promising sign.

If I have criticism of RM tonight it would be for the removal of Besic, as others have said. Didn’t understand that. I also think Kone probably should have come on for Naismith.

David Cornmell
118 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:39:41
Hear, hear, Chris Gould!

Two home draws and a loss from a winning position do not a turnaround make. What the fuck do I know... let’s give Roberto another twelve games and see where we are, aye?

Sean Byrne
119 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:28:18
We were more balance in midfield with Oviedo and Mirallas. I would have taken Barry off instead of Besic. Too many poor passes from Barry tonight. However, great effort from Everton tonight and hopefully we can kick on from here.

Neil at 77, I agree entirely with your comment. David James was never a great keeper and his views are frankly irrelevant. At least Steve McMannaman offered some impartial and objective analysis.

Mike Corcoran
120 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:41:26
Is Barkley scared to get stuck in due to former injuries? I’d love to see him showing some energy off the ball.
Jamie Crowley
121 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:40:28
Chris -

It’s indisputable fact we’ve won 1 in 12.

But can you not see the adjustments? The complete change in approach and play?

How is that not a positive and how can you see that run of form continuing?

ps: Sorry about the "delusional" comment. I respectfully disagree. That was out of line.

Andrew Laird
122 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:36:27
McGeady runs full pelt and then slides while raising his studs to knee height this – would easily fall within the laws of the game for being reckless. I agree that Noble absolutely made a meal of it but there was a coming together of limbs for which McGeady is miles away from the ball.

I agree the ref was shocking and he seemed hell bent on letting Carroll elbow his way through our team. Maybe at Goodison McGeady might have got away with it but it was a ridiculous full-speed sliding challenge which had the crowd baying for blood.

Paul Smith
123 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:37:45
On my way home from the Boelyn. The lads were amazing tonight and the players weren’t too bad either. Great atmosphere, great determination, effort and Stamina, they look much fitter.

Stand out performers – Kev and Rom. The latter was getting the fans up for it when all seemed lost at 1-0 and 10 men. I think Rom may be with us for along time.

Clive Rogers
124 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:28:08
Some heroic performances(Jags, Robles), but I thought Naismith was very poor. Just plodded about all night and should have been pulled off instead of Besic.
Jim Bennings
125 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:39:58
Here’s a question, then: What if we get to a stage where we have won 2/3 matches from 20?? Relegation form... then what??

Everton fans are too easy pleased. The Redshite are having a teat of a season yet are in a cup semi-final whilst we have slumped out of both cups first time of asking again and we are in a dire league position to add to it.

Jon Cox
126 Posted 13/01/2015 at 22:57:45
MK, I wrote this before, I write it now with regards to McGeady. I hope it will become apparent:

"My girlfriend came over 3/4 of the way through the first half. I said to her that McGeady was Everton’s Man of the Match so far. I mean down that right flank he was tearing WHU a new arsehole. It was so obvious to me that he would be the one to be sent off. Did anyone else notice how many fouls that Carroll shite got away with? Elbows in faces. Why was that twat afforded so much protection and given so much leeway??"

There’s only so much of a game can be bent before it becomes obvious. Tonight was one of those games...

Chris Gould
127 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:39:54
Jamie Crowley, please don’t call me delusional. I disagree with much of what you say and with good reason. I was very proud of our efforts last season, but believe that RM has made countless mistakes since March. If you can’t or refuse to see that then that’s fine. We see things differently and that’s fine too.
Jamie Crowley
128 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:45:34
Chris -

I concur at 129 and again my apologies. Defo hit the "return" button far too quickly.

You’re 100% correct.

Colin Glassar
129 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:40:51
David, I’m not criticising Ross, I’ve even nominated him for future captain, but there’s something wrong with him. He doesn’t look happy or confident.

Tonight, he went on a few runs and just glided past opponents but, while I was screaming for him to shoot, he just seemed to be unsure of himself, stopped and either passed or lost the ball.

I’d take him out for a few games. It did Rom the world of good.

Gavin Johnson
130 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:34:23
A great performance barring the result. Martinez got his substitutions bang on. (Mirallas was exceptionally good and a good shift from Oviedo.)

I thought that the lads heads would sink once we conceded and McGeady was sent off. But there was a lot of fight tonight. I’ve got absolutely no fear about being sucked into a relegation battle after the the last three games.

I’m really pleased for Robles too. It seems his confidence is growing and so are his performances. Irrespective of whether we buy our new GK this window. I find it hard to see Howard automatically getting his place from Robles for the remainder of the season. Which is a very good thing IMO.

Chris Gould
131 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:45:22
Jamie, I posted that before I saw your last. Now I apologise, and thanks for yours.
Jamie Crowley
132 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:46:53

Yes, our league position is perilous. But it’s form and quality that matter.

When you consider that and look at our recent games and effort applied, how can you even go down that road?

Jim, when we lose, I understand your frustration. But the constant drum of The Sky Is Falling is just over the top.

James Joseph
133 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:35:44
Despite the result, it’s performances like this that make me proud to be an Evertonian.

Sadly, though, I’ve uttered that phrase too often during the last 40 years as we bow out of another cup competition. Oh for a lucky win!

James Marshall
135 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:47:27
Big applause for Robles from the blues when he came over and gave his shirt to a kid. Good lad, good keeper.
Brian Waring
136 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:45:56
Think Barkley needs a spell on the bench because all this Man City interest is turning his head.

As soon as he stops thinking he is better than he really is, and gets his head down and works for the team, he may start showing how good he can be.

Andrew Laird
137 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:47:23
Lukaku was benched for 2 games and came back a much improved player in form and application; this could also work with Barkley. With McGeady suspended, he might not get a rest, Besic (unless carrying a knock) should not be being pulled first anymore.
Colin Glassar
138 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:47:16
Chris, Jamie, that’s better. I can feel the love.

Jim, Jim, Jim. We are NOT going to get relegated. Get that out of your head once and for all. Once you overcome this psychosis, you will feel a lot better and, I promise you, enjoy the rest of the season.

I’m gutted we lost the game but a corner has definitely been turned. Like some have already said, for me, the WBA game is far more important than tonight’s match. The league is our bread and butter. We need to start moving up the table as each place is worth a lot of money.

Let’s concentrate on the league and, hopefully, enjoy a good run in the EL.

Gavin Johnson
139 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:51:49
I’d normally be really gutted about going out in the 3rd round. But I’ll make an exception after that performance from a 10-man team.
Neil Wood
140 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:53:46
Brian @138 ....

I’m a massive admirer of Barkley and feel he has the potential to be up there with the very best but I can’t disagree with you. I think he needs a rocket up his arse and some desire to put a proper shift in.

I don’t mind the ball being lost in certain areas of the pitch and with players like him, that is always going to happen. But watching him closely in his last few games and I get so frustrated seeing him give up so easy on things and fanny into tackles. The lads a big strong unit and needs to use that so much more.

Kevin Rowlands
141 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:58:33
I agree, Brian, not sure if all the hype has gone to Barkley’s head but at 20 Rooney was a far, far better player.

£45M? you must be joking, snap their hands off!

Jay Wood
142 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:49:39
With respect, both Jim Bennings and Jamie Crowley both need to step back from the keyboard for the rest of the evening.

There is some legitimacy in both your points of view, though you both have a poor grasp of the differences between fact, opinion, pure fabrication and speculation.

Your differing views are clearly polarized, but any coherent point you are trying to make is drowned in banshee-like screaming hysteria. This effectively diminishes or even totally invalidates whatever point you are trying to make.

Jamie Crowley
143 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:58:47
I agree with Colin at 140.

Feel the love.

GROUP HUG! (even though you Englishman think that’s rather "faggoty")

I’m just pissed we lost. Pissed Rom didn’t finish that chance on 118 minutes! Pissed some people are slagging off players unfairly in my opinion. Pissed we are not through because the way we are now playing I could see us making a "proper" run at silverware in the FA Cup.

I’m gonna go home, keep drinking, and slosh myself to sleep.


Kristian Boyce
144 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:58:13
In regards to McGeady, the second tackle was a bit rash for being on a yellow, but what was the reason for the first yellow?

He was taking one for the team for yet another poor Barry pass.

Chris Gould
145 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:50:11
For what little it’s worth, I desperately want to see RM succeed. I would love him to prove me wrong and I wish I felt more positive. The thing is, I do see a slight improvement, but we’re still struggling and that just goes to show how truly shite we had been.

I took my young sons to Goodison for the first time on Saturday and I was shitting myself. The players are a bag of nerves and it fills me with no confidence.

Jamie Crowley, I do accept there has been improvements. But, I don’t think they’re down to RM. I think we’re witnessing a bit of player power. I’m just thankful that the players are showing fight and determination. Long may that continue.

Brent Stephens
146 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:50:04
Jim Bennings, there’s a difference between how we were playing up until three games ago and how we are playing now. We’re now seeing more passion, a mix of tactics, more flexibility, more directness, more individual performances of quality.

Please, Jim, tell it as it was if you must, but also acknowledge how it has been over the last few games, otherwise you make yourself an easy target for "nobhead" comments.

Colin Glassar
148 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:03:15
None of that ’group hug’ bullshit, Jamie. We are British and we don’t do touching. Except in sports for some reason.
Jamie Crowley
149 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:06:05
I concur, Colin. Believe me when I tell you that was a feeble attempt at humor.

Group hugs are never to be considered. Minimally a hand shake. Past that... nope.

Chris Gould
150 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:05:33
Jay Wood at 144. The voice of reason. Incredibly rational and calming.
Kevin Rowlands
151 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:05:09
Was I imagining this or did Besic look more ’beefed’ up or bigger tonight?
Joe Clitherow
152 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:50:34
Brian 78 the ’out thought’ comment comes mainly from the clear fact that at half time you can bet a ton of money that Allardyce would have given his players specific instructions to get carded players sent off, with the prime candidates for his winding up being Barry, Besic and McGeady - the hapless McGeady being the head and shoulders standout.

You could see that coming a mile off. I would suspect that Martinez did not specifically warn McGeady about these standard (you can see them every week actually) Allardyce tactics, as generally exemplified by his most horrible players, Nolan and Carroll (in a team which also has Tompkins and Collins).

Although if he had we may well have seen us going out with a whimper rather than like the lions we turned out to be. Plus, can I remind you that before you gloss over the whole match and rewrite history, prior to the sending off we had a single shot on target compared to a hatul of good chances which the outstanding Robles fended off.

Yeah, I would say the Allardyce tactics were working much better and the character of the players came through when they threw any game plan out of the window after the sending off and had to rely on character alone.

Plus Barkley needs a lot more stick rather than endless carrot he seems to be getting right now. Shocking ill-disciplined performance from a very talented kid who needs proper coaching right now.

Colin Glassar
153 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:11:03
A nod and a wink is more than adequate Jamie.

Kevin, Besic has admitted he needs to beef up a bit. The lad is going to be a monster, our own Matic if you like.

I think Roberto made the right movie bringing on Kev and Bryan to give us more width but Besic was superb once again tonight.

Paul Tran
154 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:05:56
Much better again tonight. No-one can go overboard about going out of the cup. If you can’t see the improvement in the last three games, please remove your anti-Martinez spectacles. We keep playing like that, the wins will come. The spirit looked like it was back - long may it continue.
Gavin Johnson
155 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:05:38
On the case of McGeady, I thought he was having a good game up until he went off. There was a lot of nice ball control and he was tracking back whenever they had the ball. To say he’s the worst player to ever wear the shirt is complete nonsense. A silly boy for making that challenge when he was already on a yellow though.
Jamie Crowley
156 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:13:33
Jay at 144 -

I can take your point, but the condescending, "though you both have a poor grasp of the differences between fact, opinion, pure fabrication and speculation" makes me wonder if you feel you’re judge and jury.

Or maybe Jesus?

Derek Thomas
157 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:57:23
I want Everton to do well and I want Martinez to do well (after all, I did moan long and hard enough about Moyes).

I was, overall, quite impressed with last season and maybe a little disappointed we didn’t do better.

No point in listing all the events, facts, none facts, rumours and allegedlies here, but we all have seen them and believe as much or little as we do or do not. Something, for what ever reason, ’seemed’ to change in the last 3 games.

The only thing that hasn’t changed is we are still not winning.

We are out of the cup. We are 1 point NEARER the relegation group than we were after Hull.

If we keep up with the ’ Changed Attitude ’ we may see a slow climb out of out tailspin. Is it ’papering over the cracks’ or ’green shoots’ Like I said; I want Martinez to do well, but for now it will have to be the old stand by of...

’ One game at a time ’

Andy Crooks
158 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:19:38
Michael Kenrick, I deliberately avoided the result tonight and just logged on and read this report. It is the best match report I have ever read, passionate and exciting. I am gutted at the result, really gutted.
Jay Wood
159 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:18:02
Jamie @ 158, I am sturdy enough and open minded enough to welcome all points of view.

I don’t presume that my opinion is the only valid one. I do not consider my opinions or standards superior to others.

I enjoy genuine debate, though I admit to having little patience with strident voices resorting to ad hominem insults once the premises of their arguments have been undermined or merely challenged.

The comments you consider condescending are justified. A quick scan of your own and Jim’s posting post match reveal this quite clearly.

And whilst I respect all religions and their devotees, as a non-believer of any faith, I certainly would not regard myself as JC.

May peace be upon you ...

John Daley
160 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:12:40
Better effort, endeavour and fight throughout the last three games but it’s still not been sufficient to turn the tide.

The next two games are massive for the manager now. If, god forbid, results go the wrong way in those then where is the light at the end of the tunnel?

It saddens me to say it, as Martinez banked a lot of credit with me for the way he managed us for the majority of last season, but how long do you let the situation drift? Defeats quickly rack up, winning becomes a rarity and draws aren’t really enough.

One thing I don’t agree on though is that the shambles this season is ’solely’ down to the manager.

Take tonights game for example. One of the better performances in the last few months but still way too many unforced mistakes. You can talk all day about it being entirely predictable that West Ham would score from a set piece, but it was equally as predictable (and frustrating) that a goal would come from the players sloppily switching off and not being alert to danger. A quick turnover in possession, a long ball down the pitch, and it was panic stations once again with players plodding back into position, seemingly unprepared for the possibility of a pacey counter. Inexcusable, no matter what instructions you’re playing to.

Lukaku had two gilt-edged chances that a gimp with a glass eye could have converted into goals. Stones was uncharacteristically slow to react for both of their strikes. McGeadey showed he possesses all the mental capacity of that big fucking monkey Clyde that used to be bezzy mates with Clint Eastwood, bounding into a wild and reckless challenge after already being booked. Shithouse stupidity of the highest order that was. Leaving your teammates to try and overturn a deficit with ten men when you’re down on your luck and desperate for a result.

Yes, the players battled to the end, but shouldn’t that be the least we expect from someone in the blue shirt? It’s only being lauded so loudly right now because, for much of the season so far, it has looked like any last vestige of fighting spirit had long since fucked off. It’s something to grab on to but it’s certainly not a sure sign that a turner has been turned.

Main positives to be taken from the game: Mirallas looked right up for it after his recent half-hearted efforts and Robles proved himself to be undeserving of the scarlet letter Phil Walling prematurely smeared on his shirt. Thought they were both superb tonight.

Tony Marsh
161 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:29:11
Why did Naismith take an early pen in the shoot out? There are far better spot kickers in the team than Naismith. I knew when he stepped up he would miss, He is a shocking footballer. McGeady also needs bombing out to Luton or Morecombe.
Colin Glassar
162 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:27:35
Andy, you missed the game? Despite losing you’d have been impressed with the fight and spirit we showed. Even with ten men we were the better team but were unlucky to lose on pens.
There’s definitely a will to learn from past mistakes which is what we all wanted. We can only get better now.
Joe Clitherow
163 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:21:46

I really like your passion, but going too overboard is just as bad as the incessant doom and gloom. Apologies if that comes over as patronising, not what I intend at all.

For me, all we answered tonight were some questions about the character of our lads, which was terrific and a real ray of light in the gloom. Plus we learned I think that there is a keeper somewhere there in Robles who really can challenge the complacent Tim Howard.

We still did not play very well tonight I think, and we have had (technically) two draws and one loss in the last three and only really have a single point in the FOR column from all three games. As well, I don’t think you can draw any conclusions about Martinez from tonight in my opinion, that was a magnificent roll your sleeves up effort from the players. Still too many off their game though.

However, that level of performance if carried through to the league is what is necessary to compensate when your form is off and is what can grind out the necessary wins, and more than anything that is what we have lacked all this season.

Big test to see if we get that commitment on Monday, we’ll be fine if we do. But I am still convinced RM is not for us. If only he had practiced defending in general and defending from corners specifically rather than taking pride in saying it is not in his philosophy, we may have held out the last 10 mins or so and actually be celebrating a famous victory now rather than a plucky little Everton loss. I am much more gutted at not holding on to the lead than losing on the lottery of penalties.

Kevin Rowlands
164 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:38:25
DT 159, seriously I looked at your post and I thought a fucking robot had posted it, I am half pissed btw so that might explain that, COYB!
Mike Gwyer
165 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:46:13

Well that was totally unbiased, I mean that twat of a ref should of put on a hammers top and sung I’m blowing fucking bubbles, or whatever shite it is that they sing at West Ham.

The officiating over the past few games has been as one sided as I’ve ever seen and if Pulis has been watching us play, then he will know that this club is getting seriously turned over by the men in black.

What the fuck is going on when the ref refuses to see Carroll doing GBH to any player wearing a Chang shirt, then you have that fuck wit Noble diving about two hours before McGeady got near him and finally, Nolan, walking round like one of the Kray twins dishing out his usual anti-Everton tackles. Oh yeah, the creme-de-la-creme, we even had our compulsory penalty fucked off when Mirallas was upended whilst trying to play football.

I thought the officiating at Man City was bad but Stoke and Newcastle were equally as shite. As for tonight?? Fuck me, we need help, I mean all 4 games were as close to being fixed as you can get.

Wenger telling all and sundry that AJ was a diver was bad enough but why do ref’s have it in for us?? Why?? For me RM needs to take a fine and say something to the media about the officiating, yeah, something like "Fuck off and die you totally biased twats".

Ross Hutchinson
166 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:36:29
Absolutely gutted about the result. Thought we deserved it.

I have to tip my hat to Robles. He was terrific. I slated him after the first game against West Ham for his aerial ability but he was very impressive tonight all round. He was claiming crosses and catching the ball but also punching when required and making several excellent saves.

It was a total shame he missed the last penalty. He didn’t deserve that.

Jamie Crowley
167 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:46:55
Jay -

The comments you consider condescending are justified. A quick scan of your own and Jim’s posting post match reveal this quite clearly.

Says who? You?


Peace be with you, and with your Spirit.

Joe Clitherow
168 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:54:39
I would just like to point out that Jamie Crowley *is* JC.

As am I

Kevin Rowlands
169 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:47:23
If Robles stays fit, I don’t think Howard will ever play for us again, the EPL and ’soccer’ in general is starting to get very big here in the US, I’ve a feeling TH sees his future in broadcasting.
Jamie Crowley
170 Posted 14/01/2015 at 01:03:31
Two peas in a pod Joe, no question about it!


Paul Ferry
171 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:58:51
It was the commitment and guts shown when the chips were down that most pleased me and for the life of me surely all of us can take heart and cheer from that?

But the other thing I take from that match which niggles away at me is thinking about their equalizer in the context of Graeme Jones’s startling comments when some players went to speak with him about the lack of training on defending set-pieces: oh we need to do other things coz there’s only two or three set pieces to defend each match.


Jones should be symbolically strung up for that unprofessional crap and his words should forever be imposed on a video of that Hammers’ leveller that is played every fecking day at Finch Farm.

Chuffed to bits for Robles who I never bad-mouthed for the simple reason that I had never seen enough of him. I’m beginning to now and I’m as I say chuffed yet startled to see him still getting hammered by a few on the live forum tonight!

Andrew Laird
172 Posted 14/01/2015 at 01:07:52
Kevin#171. Every cloud....
Jon Cox
173 Posted 14/01/2015 at 01:06:57
As am I... but that’s enough of Joan Collins.
Brett Jonathan
174 Posted 14/01/2015 at 01:35:24
Sickening result but to take a big positive away was the form of Robles. He kept us in the game and was unfortunate to miss his penalty. For mine, I come away thinking much more of the lad as a possible number 1 keeper going forward. Great effort and onward and upwards from here fellas.
Bobby Thomas
175 Posted 14/01/2015 at 01:40:45
We did look better with 10 men.

Worrying thing is it was because Martinez was forced into setting us up with more shape & balance. Instead of the shapeless, impotent, attacking full-back nullifying (ours), Barkley-destroying mess he prefers.

And Oviedo needs to play.

Bobby Thomas
176 Posted 14/01/2015 at 02:04:37
John Daley (162)

A large part of the individual error thing is unfortunately the coaching and the emphasis on what is important.

Individual responsibility, ethic and the idea of the collective has diminished. This manager doesn’t place any or enough emphasis on the dirty work. Play with arrogance. The centre backs play not as a pair but as individuals.

He was loading teams all wrong at the beginning of the season and they are still unbalanced.

Wigan led the league in errors to goals when they went. It’s not a coincidence.

Jay Harris
177 Posted 13/01/2015 at 23:51:23

Form and quality count for nothing.

It’s results that count.

Ernie Baywood
178 Posted 14/01/2015 at 00:48:46
Real shame. You couldn’t fault the spirit and they showed character in the way they played.

McGeady will deservedly cop dog’s abuse for getting sent off but, up to that point, he was probably having his best game this season. He’s got talent and could do with a run of games to find his form... real shame.

I’ve defended Barkley to the hilt but tonight was the tipping point. Yes, he has something special but we just aren’t going to see it. If someone will pay big money and can help him have a great career then we should consider it... I just can’t see someone as low on energy ever being a success at Everton.

Mirallas was truly exceptional when he came on. God please keep him fit.

I hope that game was the making of Robles. He was brilliant tonight. I was saying to my Dad when the final whistle went that the story was set – Robles the unlikely hero but then when he stepped up it was clear it was a different story playing out. The best bit about his performance was watching his confidence build after he caught Carroll the first time... every time he came out he went a bit harder at the ex-RS streak of piss. That’s what a proper goalkeeper does!!! I’ll be amongst many eating my entire hat collection if he turns out any good.

So real shame. I love the FA Cup but I guess we now concentrate on climbing the league and going all out for the EL. Really feel that my Everton is back. Everything about that game was pure Everton.

Harold Matthews
179 Posted 14/01/2015 at 02:09:16
Cheers Laurie and Jamie. Don’t know how Michael managed to dig my name up. The only suggestions I made before the game were.... Avoid conceding corners, close down the crosses and play with width.

I’m certainly not getting into any more discussions on you know who. For some he tries hard and does a job, for some he is totally useless and never plays well and for some he’s not the sharpest pencil in the box. Opinions are set on this lad and I have other things to worry about in my life.

We certainly didn’t deserve to lose this game and Robles and Mirallas were a class apart. Not so Barkley who continues to struggle. No excuses for Lukaku missing two absolute sitters and for several of his team-mates to concede needless corners and not defend them properly. Sorry, Mr Martinez, but set pieces are an important part of a football match.

Richard Gough reckons Barkley, Stones and others were missing real leadership and he might be right. Imagine Stones trying to dribble his way out of the box with Stubbs and Weir next to him. No chance.

Paul Ward
180 Posted 14/01/2015 at 06:16:59
David Hallwood116, I would think most regulars on this site are not new to the game and remember the 3 or 4 fetes of absolute genius Barkley has performed. Because of his terrific potential he has been given far more games to prove that potential than most young players we have had.

The problem is he believes his own hype and has contributed virtually nothing to team in this latest bad run. As some of our poster’s have said he should be on the bench watching players who put in real shift.

Amit Vithlani
181 Posted 14/01/2015 at 07:40:58
Gutted by the result, heartened by the fight shown once Mirallas and Oviedo entered the pitch.

The take away for me is that Barks has to be replaced by a harder working wide player such as Oviedo and if Mirallas’ ankle is up to it, McGeady to be benched.

Martinez and his stafd have still not got to grips with basic defending. In the first minute Coleman played Valencia on side and continually the back line was all over the show positionally.

Our set piece defending is a shambles and we never look like keeping a clean sheet.

One win in 12, no clean sheets tells its own story. I can’t see how we will put a consistent run together until the management and coaching staff instill organisation, leadership and discipline into our defending.

Mark Andersson
182 Posted 14/01/2015 at 07:52:17
So Ross has another bad game. Looking at him closely I think he is thinking too much and not playing his natural game. Maybe the coaching staff are filling his head with to much information.

A drop to the bench maybe good for him. He is half hearted in his attempts to tackle, well he just doesn’t. Shame really as I think he would thrive in a team playing with confidence.

Onto the next game and pressure is mounting. Make no mistake even playing with all the fight in the world will not stop you going down if you don’t win.

Tony Draper
183 Posted 14/01/2015 at 08:00:11
If practicing defending is considered such a low priority that it doesn’t take place, then why bother playing a ’Keeper ?
After all the ’Keeper is the most defensive position of all.

Surely having eleven outfield players would set opposing teams a tactical mystery whilst offering us an extra attacking option ?

Nope, doesn’t make sense to me. Practice defending please and stop shipping goals for free.

Also, if you don’t practice defending......who do the attackers practice against ?

Bob Heyward
184 Posted 14/01/2015 at 07:53:07
With one win since November, last night’s performance was hardly the nirvana that the apologists are trumpeting. Far from it. Three points off relegation, out of the Cup in the Third Round, second worst goals against record, no Premier League win or clean sheet since October 18th, and one win in twelve for all competitions. And people are hanging out the bunting... it is literally bizarre.

Was there a plan last night? From my seat it looked like the players had plenty of passion and character. ’Bobby’ offered characteristically little, except his usual tosh at the end of the match.

End-to-end entertainment... very reminiscent of Newcastle with Keegan. Not what we need for the relegation fight we are now in.

Sadly, Bob and his merry band of acolytes have bought another couple of weeks for BK to procrastinate – just enough time to lose any incumbent the opportunity of a transfer window.

One day, soon, we will deeply regret this... I hope I’m wrong, but the evidence is undeniably strong.

Jim Knightley
185 Posted 14/01/2015 at 07:56:41
The team did us proud last night..there is no doubt about that, and Mirallas and Lukaku were fantastic. The game demonstrated, especially when we had a man less and had to adjust how game, just how much effective we are with a more direct approach. Martinez has listened, and he must continue to listen, because our players suit this style. I also think Oviedo should be a regular starter on the left, with Naismith playing instead of an out of sorts Barkley for the moment.

Luckily, our players showed more determination than Jim and Chris, who gave up during the second half, and threw their toys out of the pram in the process. Congratulations, you do not like the manager, and you are in a pretty full club at the moment. But guess what, United fans didn’t like Ferguson. Spurs fans were calling for Pochettino’s head a few weeks ago, in response to their poor form. Multiple people on here lambasted Naismith, because he was useless and not of Premier League quality. Robles has been written off by most of the Everton fanbase. Sometimes fans are wrong..sometimes a little patience is needed.

Martinez will not be a Ferguson, but he deserves a little time to turn things around because of last season. Dismissing our recent ’draws’ is missing the point, because those draws demonstrated a return of the spirit, and performances, which will take us clear of trouble. It also demonstrated that our players will stand up when things are not working, and that our manager will listen. This team will not go down, and I’ll be winning to take the money of anyone who thinks they will. We have had a shit season, and we unfortunately have to accept that. We need to continue to play with more directness, and to play to the strengths of Lukaku and Mirallas, because they are our best attacking assets. We need to get a few wins on the board, and then kick on in the Europa, because that, and finishing as high up the table as we can, is all we have left now.

Duncan McDine
186 Posted 14/01/2015 at 08:18:15
jim, that perfectly sums up my thoughts too. we’ll win on monday night and things will get much better from here on.
Nathan Goulart
187 Posted 14/01/2015 at 08:41:42
I blame McGeady. Been Poor this game and most of the season and poor exit with his red card. Thanks.
Andrew Ellams
188 Posted 14/01/2015 at 08:35:19
Lukaku is finally proving me right. I have been backing the lad all season and he is starting to look like thr player we expect and will get better.

McGeady deserved to go, you make a challenge like that in 2015 and the intent gets you the yellow.

How can a referee get away with bottling two major decisions like that in 1 game (yes two, if the Stones handball had been the other way round we would have been demanding a pen).

Everybody going to the game on Monday needs to be singing Robles’ name and let the lad know just how well he did his proper job last night (needs to practice facing penalties though).

How come so many people knew how bad Naismith was at penalties before he took his? I’ve never seen him take one before, did I miss something?

Laurie Hartley
189 Posted 14/01/2015 at 07:26:58
Well Michael @ 53, I was wrong. Contrary to what I predicted on another thread, McGeady didn’t turn the game and he won’t be turning the next one either for obvious reasons.

As far as "no-nothing imbecilles" is concerned they are your words. Your post was a bit over the top in my opinion. I never have or never will call anyone who has a different point of view from me that, on this site or off it for that matter. I don’t think Harold would either.

I will however, disagree with anyone’s point of view or give them a roasting if I think they are wrong or out of order.

What Harold did do, was challenge Lynden on another thread, regarding what he considered an unfair criticism of McGeady. That’s part of what ToffeeWeb is all about isn’t it?

As far as McGeady’s performance last night and getting sent off is concerned, it seems that yet again, that there are diametrically opposiing views as posted above. I can’t comment as I didn’t see the game - I was at work.

I’ll record it tonight, watch it tomorrow night, and post again.

Joe Clitherow
191 Posted 14/01/2015 at 09:12:04
So Jim when does the clock start and finish on the "little time" you want to give Martinez? I’d argue he has had it already past half a season and the very basic and glaring flaws have still not been addressed yet. Sure we have shown a bit more fight which is encouraging but even last night we played on guts alone after we went to 10 men. Yeah that was great to see but sorry but that’s not a game plan for me.

Still the basics of no covering defenders leaving multiple one on ones with the last man. Players jogging back after an attack breaks down. If Robles had not had the game of his life so far we could easily have been out of sight in normal time, whilst up to the sending off we had one shot on target. The reason I get so angry is these things are the first that even a mediocre manager could fix an Martinez seems to refuse to do so. These things are not being fixed - where is the magic wand then if he does not apply discipline and organisation? This, by the way, is despite Martinez saying we had to get back to basics a while ago. He needs to walk the walk.

Yes it was a great effort but yet again we shipped soft goals and could not close out a game which is a Martinez trademark.

If only we could win ugly now and again

Jay Wood
192 Posted 14/01/2015 at 09:22:50
Jamie Crowley @ 169.

I hope you’ve calmed down and are less hysterical after a good night’s sleep.

To respond to your last post to me. Yes, I do say you and Jim Bennings in your squabble last night, although there was some legitimacy in both your points of view, you both showed a poor grasp of the differences between fact, opinion, pure fabrication and speculation.

There were many examples in your multiple posts last night, but I’ll focus on just one – post 95 – in which you listed 6 FACTS alongside other comments.

"Roberto thought that we had enough talent to stick to his guns and PLAY our way, through possession football, through this malaise." Speculation and fabrication.

"Through a Come to Jesus meeting with Rom and players, he’s allowed an adjustment." Speculation.

"We are now playing very, very good entertaining yet more cautious football." Opinion

"FACT! - We are playing with passion and verve." Opinion – passion yes, verve no. More like nerve.

"FACT! - we’ve made an adjustment to our playing style improving the performances." Opinion.

"FACT" - Roberto was FLEXIBLE enough to allow this!" Speculation.

"FACT! - Our players have responded because they love their manager." Fabrication and speculation.

"FACT! - We should have won tonight." Opinion.

"FACT! - Anyone who can’t see that and appreciate it is lacking any foresight or intelligence." Opinion.

"Any ref worth his salt (and this ref was complete crap, missing a ton of calls even many that went OUR way) he’d of never pulled a second yellow for that challenge." Opinion and speculation.

"The players are not calling the shots." Speculation.

"Roberto listened, and allowed the changes to happen. Not the other way around." Speculation.

"And we’re better off for it, so well done Roberto." Opinion.

So in your long list of claims there is not one single indisputable fact. But there is lots of opinion, speculation and fabrication.

To be fair, I did find two examples of fact stated by you in 2 other posts. @ 123 you said "It’s indisputable fact we’ve won 1 in 12" and @ 134 when you said "Yes, our league position is perilous."

I hope this clarifies things for you and gives you a better grasp of what constitutes fact, opinion, speculation and fabrication.

Paul Burns
193 Posted 14/01/2015 at 09:29:47
Another nail in the coffin of a disgraceful season. We’ve just been knocked out of the FA cup in the third round by a club who’ve made losing into an art form. And I’ve heard people on here mentioning "heroic".

Our club shapelessly stumbles from one pathetic performance to the next, soon to depart from our last remaining cup competition no doubt, and it’s no consolation that Kenwright know has a fellow bullshitter running the show.

It’s not good enough and Martinez must be told that the next 2 games are MUST WIN, no excuses, or you walk.

The consequences of anything else are frightening.

Chris Gould
194 Posted 14/01/2015 at 09:28:38
Jim, I fail to see how I am supposed to display determination? I wasn’t playing. If you mean that I lacked optimism and belief, then guilty as charged.

I was thrilled with the display when we went down to 10. Surely you could see that we were shite when we had 11? You believe that Martinez changed his tactics, I believe the players showed guts and passion and played the only way they could with 10 men. They worked hard and became more direct.

The same shite tactics and mistakes were there for all to see until the sending off. Does this not concern you? As I said last night, I would love for Martinez to turn it around. But for him to do this he has to accept that his system doesn’t work. He’s struggling to do that as it is everything that he stands for.

I feel for the guy. But I believe we need a manager who can implement change when Plan A isn’t working. I don’t think Martinez is that man. I don’t believe a top class manager would make the same mistakes over and over again.

Stating that other managers turned things around when given time is pointless as there are many other examples of managers staying in a job too long and taking their team down... such as Martinez.

I don’t believe in him but applaud all that do. I hope that you’re right and I’m wrong. I truly do.

Andrew Ellams
195 Posted 14/01/2015 at 09:47:11
Roberto’s reactions during and after the game last night were not of a manager whose players are calling the shots, and after at least 3 60-yard diagonal hoofs from Jagielka, no way were we playing purely possession football last night.

Anybody else think Jagielka and Stones had each others boots on last night?

Jay Wood
196 Posted 14/01/2015 at 09:36:27
Joe @ 193

I know (and understand why...) there are plenty calling for Roberto’s head, but I honestly don’t think Bill will pull the trigger any time soon.

That is not to say Bill will NEVER pull the trigger this season if, say, come March or April we are in an even more precarious position than now, à la mode of Walter Smith pre-Moyes.

Bill WILL protect Everton’s best interests if it comes to that, rather than shield the individual, Roberto Martinez. And for those saying we can’t afford to pay off Roberto in such a scenario, the response is easy: we can’t afford to lose our PL status. There is no comparison between the two as to which would be more costly.

I don’t hold with Jim Knightley’s (and others) view that Roberto "deserves time" based on last season’s performance. It’s only the here and now that counts.

And as enthralling as last night’s game was and as evident as the improvement has been in commitment in the last 3 days, the stark facts remain ...

* we are still awaiting our first win in 12 games since mid-November
* we have failed to keep a clean sheet in all those games since the win in Wolfsburg
* we have managed only 3 clean sheets in the league all season

And for all the encouragement we may draw from the last 3 performances, the bottom line is ...
* we are out of the FA Cup at the first hurdle (having had the advantage of a home draw)
* those games won us just 1 point in the league
* we have gleaned a miserly 5 points from a possible 27 in our last 9 league games
* every other club in the league in that run has gathered more points than Everton, as the ever closing gap at the bottom reveals

Yes, in the last 3 games we have finally seen what should ALWAYS be a bare minimum requirement when playing for Everton: fight and commitment.

But equally, behind that, we can still see evidence of core problems that have plagued and undermined our season since August.

The triumphalism of some, so desperate are we to take joy from Everton’s results at this time, is premature.

We need wins. And FAST!

Peter Morris
197 Posted 14/01/2015 at 10:00:33
Roberto has clearly not been taking any notice of my TW posts. After he single-handedly cost us the game at Newcastle with appalling distribution in a dangerous position, I pleaded with Roberto to get shot of McGeady in the January window.

Then, on Saturday, he was by some distance the poorest performer in our side in what was a generally much better team performance.

Last night, again, a personal contribution that only draws accusations of costing the team. the second tackle would put a pub player to shame – just simply naïve and stupid.

That aside, thanks lads for showing pride in the shirt. It’s all most of us ever want and expect.

Paul Dark
198 Posted 14/01/2015 at 10:04:20
Yes, another fighting performance. We feel far from stamping our authority on a game, but let’s hope that comes with some victories. The game against WBA is now our most important to the season.

It really saddens me to see McGeady in the same side as Mo (Besh) and Rom: these are two footballers of rare distinction by our recent standards and what they must think of our manager putting the utterly, absolutely hopeless (that is a polite understatement) McGeady in the side before Oviedo, Mirallas and even Atsu, inter alia, I shudder to think.

My favourite moment of last night was Rom’s penalty – just such class, from the run-up to the poised body movement and position, to the hesitation at the right moment, to the assured strike of the ball.

On another note: really sad to see that Sam is probably on his way. I feel his departure marks a major defeat for Martinez and his (doctrinaire) ideals. McGeady stays but Eto’o goes. I shall be sad to see him go. He has class (and he is not a winger). The episode does Everton’s name no good in world football – and that saddens me further.

Nigel Gregson
199 Posted 14/01/2015 at 10:04:15
@JayWood 194. Here are a few facts (not opinions) Could you please include these facts along with your one stat of 1 win in 12 ? :

1. FACT: We held the champions and the #1 equal team which had won several on the trot to a 1-1 draw
2. FACT: We forced a West Ham team in good form (7th Place) to a replay and then fought back from a 1-0 deficit and a 1-man disadvantage at their home ground and nearly won.
3. FACT: We have had our key players in McCarthy, Stones, Mirallas injured for a very long time in the last 12 games. McCarthy is in fact still out injured.
4. FACT: We have been hurt in at least one game in the last 12 by a player who should have been red carded (he was fined later for an elbow incident on Seamus).
5. FACT: We have changed our style in the last 3 games. We mix the passing with balls and long balls more frequently now. (I can dig up the statistics if you insist.)

Chris Gould
200 Posted 14/01/2015 at 10:47:48
Nigel, I appreciate what you are trying to say, but...
We held City to a draw because they spurned chance after chance in the first half.

We forced a replay with West ham?!!!! Uh, how is that a positive? We scraped a draw at home and then lost the away tie.

We’ve had injuries?! So have every club. And many believe that our injuries are due to the way our players are managed.

Fact 4 is basically saying that refereeing decisions have gone against us. Again, all teams can say that. Especially the teams in the bottom half of the table.

Fact 5 we mix our style. And thus far still haven’t won a match.

All of these facts can be highlighted in any way you please. The indisputable fact is that we need to get results and fast.

Dave Abrahams
201 Posted 14/01/2015 at 10:39:43
I said a few weeks ago that I wasn’t really bothered about the FA Cup because of our league position but, once the game came round, I wanted Everton to win as much as I have always wanted them to win.

I was proud of the team last night, prouder still of that wonderful support; I think we are on the mend and the improvement will continue.

I’ve criticised Mirallas in the past for his lack of effort; last night, he was excellent. Notice he was playing from a more central position and was involved more in that role; maybe that’s his best position... he was signed as a striker.

Tony Hill
202 Posted 14/01/2015 at 10:36:19
Jay 198 I think that’s a fair case for the prosecution. I think it needs noting though that our last 3 games have not merely shown increased effort, they have also shown increased pace in our approach play and that is absolutely critical. We had been terribly ponderous before that of course.

Some of our work last night was particularly incisive and we only lacked the finishing.

Defensively, Stones was frankly poor last night. It should be acknowledged that he is still raw and will inevitably make mistakes of positioning and closing down. He is not yet the finished product by any means and nor should we expect him to be.

I agree that Kenwright will back RM and at the moment he is right to do so. But I also agree that he will act if we are truly threatened with relegation. I think that would apply if we were to lose the next two games, with Liverpool then to follow. On the evidence of last night, I believe the team is good enough to win through and to steady the ship for the rest of the season.

We will know much better where we stand by the end of this month.

Andrew Ellams
203 Posted 14/01/2015 at 11:05:23
Kenwright needs to back Martinez with a new wide man. We were so unbalanced last night and that could easily have tipped the balance our way. Plus Baines didn’t seem to be in the game at all, but he still covered so much ground being the only man on his side his legs had gone by the time penalties came around.
Martin Barron
204 Posted 14/01/2015 at 10:37:51
Really proud of the effort last night and the second half on Saturday. We are getting there but in my opinion still have one major weakness (I did say major!).

While I agree McGeady looked good in the first half last night, his end product was very poor. What I think we are badly missing is somebody to unlock opposition defences. Barkley can do it but its not happening for him at the moment. Nasimith tries but does not seem to have the ability.

Going forward I am concerned by the pressure on us to beat teams such as West Brom, that will park the bus, with the players we have. Mirallas can certainly be a huge threat (especially looking at last night performance) but we always seem to setup with a threat like his on only one side of the pitch. This makes it a lot easier for teams to close us down.

Maybe Oviedo in front of Baines on the left and Mirallas on the right is the answer but I am not sure its good enough. I think this is the position we badly need to look to fill in this transfer window – not easy to do but I think it would balance the team better and make us much harder to defend against.

Brian Hill
205 Posted 14/01/2015 at 11:23:51
Paul Dark, on another thread John Daley compared your favourite player to Clyde the orangutan. What an insult to Clyde.
Nigel Gregson
206 Posted 14/01/2015 at 11:24:03
Chris - 202 - Man City spurned chance after chance, but from what I remember, we also had the best chance in the first half - hitting the cross bar, so actually we should have beaten City.

We need to get results yes, but a lucky win with poor play and referee giving us some breaks is not going to show any turn around (e.g. the QPR win). The players attitude / tactical changes on the pitch, which leads to visible (but perhaps statistically meaningless) performances that will bring about a turn of form.

Jay Wood
207 Posted 14/01/2015 at 11:22:43
Ehrm ... Nigel @ 201... I don’t know if you realise, but my post @ 194 was quoting Jamie Crowley who got a bit into a tiz last night. Not a single one of Jamie’s ’facts’ came from me ...

But - hey-hoy! To respond to you.

1. A good result, which I celebrated on TW, declaring if we continue to show the same commitment wins will follow.

2. Equally factual is that we had home advantage over West Ham and - again! - didn’t win, which led to the replay and ... defeat and exit from the FA Cup at the first hurdle.

Plenty of praise from me last night about fighting back with just 10 men, but you make like to review your claim that WHU are a team in ’good form.’ Are you aware that is their first win in seven games since beating the mighty Leicester City on 20 December?

It’s happened a lot to Everton lately, hasn’t it? Enabling struggling out of form sides to break their duck? A ’nearly win’ isn’t ’nearly enough’ right now, is it Nigel?

3. Yup! We have injuries ... and other clubs don’t?

4. Yup! And again, we are the only club that suffers injustices at the hands of refs?

Shall we list the penalty Swansea should have got when Alcaraz imitated Big Nev in his prime, which would have turned a 0-0 draw into a 1-0 defeat? Or the fact Romelu’s goal against WHU in the league game was offside and a 2-1 win should have been a 1-1 draw? Or the penalty that should have been awarded against Barry at Hull in the first 3 minutes? As he was booked later in the game, perhaps he was lucky not to have been on a second yellow card and dismissed before Alcaraz actually was? Or even the penalty not awarded against John Stones last night?

It’s a silly game, isn’t it Nigel? This revisionism lark, but - hey! You started it!

5. Yes, we have changed our style in the last 3 games. And...? It hasn’t resulted in any wins yet, has it?

I think right now Nigel, the facts, data and statistics on this season are overwhelming in favour of just how poor Everton have been and how precarious our ever-worsening position is becoming.

Brian Waring
208 Posted 14/01/2015 at 11:46:33
Bobby Thomas (#177) "Barkley-destroying mess he prefers."

Bobby, is it Martinez’s fault when Barkley picks the ball up and runs into a dead end by trying to take everyone on?

Is it Martinez’s fault when Barkley gives the ball away and then just stands there as the opposing team break away?

Is it Martinez’s fault when Barkley once again makes a half-hearted tackle to win the ball?

Is it Martinez’s fault that Barkley just walks round the pitch looking like he doesn’t give a fuck?

What is Martinez’s fault is he’s not benching Barkley to give him a kick up the arse.

Paul Dark
209 Posted 14/01/2015 at 11:46:40
Brian, 207: :)

I don’t have a pet or irrational dislike of ’Geads’. It’s a very rational response to his appalling play. He plays consistently (I mean: invariably) badly for my team and loses them points. This is what I dislike, not him.

On a painfully comical note: I don’t know if anyone else saw this, but I perceived an uncanny similarity (really!) between that twitter clip of the horse (was it?) falling over a ball clumsily and McG’s fall (also over the ball/player) in the build-up to Rom’s equaliser at the week-end against Citeh.

St Aiden is painfully comical - but his performances are tragicomedy.

Brian Harrison
210 Posted 14/01/2015 at 11:58:00
I have only seen highlights but I don’t think you can fault the effort and desire of the players last night. Yes it is still only 1 win in 12 games, but I haven’t seen the desire they showed last night in most of the previous 12 games.

I am sure if they show the same level of intensity to win a game against West Brom as they did last night then tyhere is a good chance of all 3 points next Monday.

I don’t know whether the new approach is being dictated by the players, or if RM is going along with the new approach. But I fear that when we are safe he will return to his style of football.

I really do think it is time to take Barkley out of the team at present, to keep playing him when he is so out of sorts doesn’t help him and I think the fans are beginning to get annoyed with him and the last thing a young player needs is for the fans to turn on him. I am far from being convinced that Ross is going to be this great player I hear people saying even respected pundits.

He certainly doesn’t ever want to put his foot into a challenge and when he receives the ball on some occasions you can see him thinking "What should I do next?" were most great players know instinctively what to do. And I don’t think you can coach that into a player – he either has that ability or not. I do think his biggest asset is running at the opponents, something he hasn’t done enough of lately.

Nigel Gregson
211 Posted 14/01/2015 at 12:27:31
Jay Wood 209 - another perspective :

We sit 12th on the table despite this being all disaster leading to so much feet stamping. We have changed tactics and we have not lost yet (at least not without the opposition having to resort to their 10th penalty kick).

West Ham are a team that are doing well this season - facts show that they sit 7th , table doesn’t lie. They have only lost 2 games in their last 9 premier league games (those to Chelsea and arsenal).

Our injury problems have been bad enough for there to be an overhaul of fitness staff. Other teams have had injury issues too but relatively speaking ours have been far worse. Care to name another team with 20 hamstring injuries this season? Or another with key players like McCarthy, Stones, Mirallas (and Osman) for such lengthy periods?

It’s good that you brought the earlier refereeing decisions that went in our favour leading to wins. Because that would mean that you need to include all those games in your analysis and not the last 12 game 1 win stat where the breaks didn’t go our way.

Furthermore you say there was plenty of praise from you last night. But maybe I’m confusing you with someone else making massively subjective comments like Sam has completely out-thought Martinez etc. during them game, even before the game was over. If so I apologize.

Like is said in my post at 208. We need to win, but we need to show that our play and effort levels will win consistently. Otherwise, like that QPR lucky win (where the breaks went massively in our favour), we will just lose more games further down the line.

Kevin Tully
212 Posted 14/01/2015 at 12:44:03
Jay Wood, (QC) let’s not go down the road of requesting someone can’t post something worthwhile on a footy forum, just because it’s only their ’opinion’. Otherwise, what’s the point of these boards? You sound like you’re summing up for a judge & jury.

Jay Wood
213 Posted 14/01/2015 at 13:08:58
Kevin Tully (WC) @ 214

Do please show me where I’ve requested ANY ONE, ANY WHERE not to post their opinion on this forum?

On the contrary, I’ve had to defend my right to do just that against people who rather than engage in debate don’t want to hear alternative opinions to their own fixed positions.

If you’re so interested - at it appears you are as you’ve been moved to comment - read the relative posts in context. The posts I believe you are referring to have been addressed to a single individual. That is, a personal exchange between A.N.Other and myself.

Do you not see the irony of your final sentence? I’d hate to appear in front of a beak like you in your kangaroo court on completely fabricated charges...

Kevin Tully
214 Posted 14/01/2015 at 13:25:38
Jay - you say ; "That is, a personal exchange between A.N.Other and myself."

The irony of that sentence is clearly lost on you my friend. Especially after posting this little beauty:

"With respect, both Jim Bennings and Jamie Crowley both need to step back from the keyboard for the rest of the evening.

There is some legitimacy in both your points of view, though you both have a poor grasp of the differences between fact, opinion, pure fabrication and speculation.

Your differing views are clearly polarized, but any coherent point you are trying to make is drowned in banshee-like screaming hysteria. This effectively diminishes or even totally invalidates whatever point you are trying to make."

Apologies if you are part of the editorial team.

Jay Wood
215 Posted 14/01/2015 at 13:19:00
Nigel @ 209

"We sit 12th" is not the significant data. The number of points is. And the cold hard facts are we are 5 points above bottom club Leicester, 3 points above Hull and QPR in the other 2 relegation spots, 2 points above Burnley and Palace, 1 point above WBA and Sunderland, equal on points with Villa.

What do all these sides have in common? They are all touted (quite rightly...) as being in the mix for relegation. All of them have gained ground on us since mid-November. Like it or not, we are in amongst them. We have absolutely no wriggle already.

To rub it in a bit more, 9 games ago we were above both Spurs and the ’poo. Now, Spurs are 12 points clear of us in 6th and the ’poo 10 points above us in 8th. We have gathered just 5 points from 27 in that time.

THESE are the significant numbers ... not the fact we are sat in ’glorious 12th position.’

You then repeat yourself ... yes, we have changed tactics, and no we have not won, but yes - despite your best efforts of denial, we have lost and our participation in the FA Cup is already over for the year.

I don’t deny West Ham are doing well this season. As you say, "facts show that they sit 7th, the table doesn’t lie."

May I repeat that ...? "the table doesn’t lie." Yes ... exactly ... I hope I don’t have to point out the obvious to you Nigel.

Your next point. Hmmm ... "Our injury problems have been bad enough for there to be an overhaul of fitness staff." A bit of tautology going on there methinks. Taking what is known, adding what is not definitively known and reaching a conclusion that cannot be proved one way or the other.

And you claim that our injuries "have been far worse" than other teams. Factually wrong. We have failed to top even that table all season!

Your claim that we have had 20 hamstring injuries this season is factually wrong. It was reported as 20 in the last 18 months since ... Roberto Martinez arrived. Opps!

Now, is it beyond the realms of possibility that it is his training methods that are to blame..?

Reference to long term injuries to our players is repeating something already previously addressed - other teams have them too.

I really don’t understand what point, if any, you are trying to make about "earlier refereeing decisions." Again, I have already highlighted that such revisionism as YOU originally offered is nonsensical. It cuts both ways - for and against us.

We can agree on one thing Nigel - we need to win. And I for one don’t care how it comes. We need a win. BADLY.

Oh! And when you are ready, you can apologize. I made no such comment you attribute to me, EVER! Not before, during or after the game.

Nor have I ever called for Roberto’s head. On the contrary, I have repeated many times my desire for him to succeed. Because if HE is successful, so is Everton.

And THAT is why my core allegiance lies, not with transient managers or players.

Jamie Crowley
216 Posted 14/01/2015 at 13:58:04
Jay -

I’ve not calmed down in the least, but was never as hysterical as your Highness believes. But I did get a very good sleep last night, thank you.

I usually fall asleep on the couch as I like to read at night, and don’t want to keep the Mrs. up. I actually closed the Ipad and crawled into bed and slept very well.

I digress...

Jay, the reason I used the word "FACT!" so much was poking fun at / mocking Jim Benning’s use of the word in reference to the 1 in 12 comment he made. It was not used to tell the world, "hey everyone! here comes a certifiable fact buckle up!" Kinda thought you would have figured that out on your own.

It’s a footy forum full of opinion, not a college thesis replete with footnoted material. [Please note I do believe that to be a fact, but can not provide evidence as such]

Now I hope we agree to disagree and can move on.

Go have yourself a rockin’ day you good fella you!

Jay Wood
217 Posted 14/01/2015 at 13:53:23
@ Kevin 216

And...? Your point being..?

Did you see the first 2 words ’with respect’? Do you know the context of that post? It was getting very heated and vitriolic between 2 posters. Others also advised them to cool their heels.

My point in saying to you in my previous post "That is, a personal exchange between A.N.Other and myself" was not (as you maybe are trying to misinterpet or imply) an order to you or anyone else to ’butt out’, but to counter your earlier claim that I was somehow trying to stifle debate and deny others a platform for their opinion.

You have attempted - and failed - to marry two disparate premises and, as a result, arrived at a false conclusion.

Will Firstbrook
220 Posted 14/01/2015 at 13:42:35
Some unsolicited observations from last night:

1) GK is not as big a worry as first thought. Robles was imperious last night and growing in confidence. One could argue he might have done better in the penalties but that process is really a crap shoot and he will take the experience of it for next time

2) Club must do everything in it’s power to keep hold of Kev. Talismanic when he came on and one of the few (if not only) real game-changer we have the squad. When he’s up for it, he is nearly unstoppable.

3) Barkley needs a seat on the bench. Seems completely lost at the moment void of confidence. Potential is there but the execution is not. Played out of position too frequently; believing the over-hyped press - not sure the reason for the poor form but it is evident that he needs to take a seat

4) While McGeady exercised extremely poor judgement going in on Noble (I think) to pick up his second booking (the first was a joke - see observation #5 below) he was likely the most effective Blue in the first half. Does his feet move faster than his brain at times? Definitely. Is he as shite as most make him out to be? I don’t believe so. He’s not a regular starter but he is a worthwhile squad member. Clearly he has taken over the whipping boy mantle from Osman.

5) The officiating in this league has really gone to pot. The clown running the show yesterday was a disgrace. Carroll ran amok without so much as a peep yet we were punished for the slightest of contact. How bad is it when many would love to see Howard back in yellow and black!?

6) the match play drama that unfolded yesterday was rivaled only by the blood-letting that went on in the Forum! The passion is back!!!

Dave Pritchard
222 Posted 14/01/2015 at 14:59:58
Interested on people’s views on Stones last night. Probably culpable for both of their goals. If that had been Distin or Alcaraz they would be getting a lot of grief. I prefer Stones to both of those players and think he is a great prospect but for me he still needs time to develop into a commanding centre-back who can dominate centre-forwards on a regular basis.
Andrew Ellams
223 Posted 14/01/2015 at 15:22:21
Stones didn’t have his best game for Everton but he won’t get the grief that the other two get because it was just an off night and there is every chance he will be top drawer again in the next match.
Michael Kenrick
224 Posted 14/01/2015 at 16:05:38
Re Stones... did he really have an off night? I'd prefer to say he had one mistake early on.

I think he contributed tremendously thereafter, as far as I recall. His defensive presence, timing, and skill in the tackle were breathtaking at times.

I was freaking, however, at the prospect of him replicating his cute Juve chip in the penalties. Thankfully he took a more direct approach this time.

Andy Meighan
225 Posted 14/01/2015 at 16:04:31
That twat Noble was pulling the Suarez face before the tackle was made and you all know what I mean by that. Yes it was a silly challenge but there was absolutley no contact whatsoever.

Now I can sort of understand a South American with buck teeth doing that sort of thing because they’re cheating bastards but coming from a so-called Hammers legend, honest-to-goodness-guvnor type... well it left a bitter taste.

But anyway, he actually did us a favour because we were better with 10 men. But still it’s a defeat. Regardless of the manner but still a defeat and the WBA game is massive going to be some night at the Old Lady.

Dave Pritchard
226 Posted 14/01/2015 at 16:26:06
Ha ha me too Michael about his pen. Mind you I was freaking about every one of our and their pens.
Andrew Ellams
227 Posted 14/01/2015 at 16:26:49
MIchael, I do recall one outstanding tackle where he slid out to the touchline, but he certainly didn't appear to be at his composed best last night
Kuli Maingi
228 Posted 14/01/2015 at 16:31:27
Michael, I think Stones was at fault for letting Tomkins get a run on him for the equalizer too, so not a bad game, but not one of his best either.

I also recall Martinez going mental (well as mental as I've ever seen him) at Stones, and clapping his hands telling him to concentrate a bit more just after that.

Bobby Thomas
229 Posted 14/01/2015 at 22:34:17
Brian #210

My main point was regarding the shape and set up of the team, which seems to hinder nearly all our big players. Barkley included.

We have very little threat and its been that way for ages. I’m tired of the shapeless mish mash of nothingness he keeps selecting. We have no cohesion or fluidity.

Lukaku & Barkley have both been dying on their arses at various points this season, due to a set up that does nothing to bring the best out of some of our biggest talents, full backs included.

As for Barkley’s current form, I think his confidence has virtually gone and he needs a break. I don’t think Martinez has handled him too well, changing position frequently from game to game and being benched in between so its difficult to get a rhythm formwise.

I am concerned by his apparent inability to get to grips with playing left half. He’s a ball playing attacking mid he should be able to do it, or at least look like he has an idea, & it asks big questions about his football brain.

However, as I say I don’t believe the set up helps anyone & as we are essentially utterly shite atm it can’t be easy. Barkley is suffering and needs taking out. He is young and ups and downs happen. I’ve seen Wilshere have some belters and utter shockers.

Oviedo needs some football and getting him in would actually help the balance of the side.

Michael Jones
231 Posted 15/01/2015 at 13:11:48
Bring back the golden goal rule in extra time!
Darren Hind
232 Posted 15/01/2015 at 18:45:23
Brian waring # 210.

It was Martinez who played Barkley out on tbe left.

It was Martinez who isolated him out on the right.

It was Martinez who heaped Idiotic pressure on the kid by labeling him "another Micheal Ballack" or a "very special player"

It was Martinez who had him strapped up and injected him with pain killers and sent out to battle at Anfield.

it is Martinez who has perservered with him when he was clearly out of form and struggling for fitness.

It was Martinez who rewarded his last good performance by benching him.

It is Martinez who plays him as a number 10 then suffocates his game by putting two other number tens in
there with him.

It is Martinez who has taken a boy who's development has already been stunted by injury and confused the fuck out of him by asking him to perform in 5-6 different roles already this season.

When Moyes dropped this boy you people screamed that he was killing him, now your screaming for Martinez to do the same.

What chance does the kid have ? he may have been blessed with supreme talent, but he must feel cursed, He arrives on the scene When TGT is the manager, He arrives on the international Scene when gormless Woy has the Gig . . .and just when he's thinking it cant get any worse he gets saddled with a guy who hasnt got a fucking scooby what to do with him.

Whiles your Doddesque devotion to this manager is touching, You really do need to start thinking about the credibility of your arguments.

We have a kid who is universally recognised as a massive talent being criminally mismanaged by a guy who has never worked with anybody of that calibre . . . and you blame the kid ?

Apologism in its purest form

Andrew Laird
233 Posted 15/01/2015 at 21:21:53
To all those posters saying there was no contact (contact is NOT needed for a booking by the way) for the second McGeady yellow, watch it again:


Can you explain why there was no contact? If Noble keeps his back foot on the ground then its possible he ends up in hospital with his leg in bits. Both of McGeady's boots are showing studs and he has zero control over them. Also have a look at how far away the ball is from McGeady, the ref was poor but that decision was correct, especially with how many fouls McGeady had "totted up" to that point.

If he flew into Noble with his elbows he might have gotten away with it.

Jamie Crowley
234 Posted 16/01/2015 at 05:08:04
Andrew I disagree. I've re-watched the play 3-4 times and Noble easily could have leapt and landed.

There was no contact and no intent to injure. He was late, it was a foul, but never a yellow.

Did you also see how Noble rolled around and grabbed his completely untouched ankle feigning injury in an attempt to get McGeady booked and sent off?

Andrew Laird
235 Posted 16/01/2015 at 10:35:19
Thanks for proving my point Jamie, you keep banging the "no contact" and "no intent" drum even though they are irrelevant which is a bit desperate or obtuse.

So you disagree but concede it was a foul, which is a 100% backtrack from your first postings... "Noble easily could of leapt and landed".. Why did Noble HAVE to leap?? McGeady has NO control over his tackle = reckless = yellow card.

Jamie Crowley
236 Posted 16/01/2015 at 13:44:21
Andrew what? I never said it wasn't a foul. It 100% isn't a yellow.

It's not irrelevant when determining whether or not an offense is a yellow whether there was contact or intent. In fact both should probably be considered by a ref before he brandishes a card.

How am I backtracking? Let me be clear – in no way, shape, or form was that ever in a million years a yellow card offense.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.

About these ads

© ToffeeWeb