Koeman's Change in Tack Reaps Rewards for Everton

How refreshing to see an Everton manager not only have options on the bench but to also have the courage to use them regardless of the stage of the match.

Lyndon Lloyd 21/08/2016 27comments  |  Jump to last

There have been more times over the past few years than most Evertonians would care to remember where they just sat with their head in their hands thinking this just isn’t working. On occasions under David Moyes and, arguably, even more so over the past couple of years under Roberto Martinez, there was almost tangible despair as the minutes ticked by but no action was forthcoming from the touchline or the dugout to address what seemed so obvious from the stands.

Sometimes, of course, there simply were no game-altering options on the bench — in itself a criticism, perhaps, of a failure on the part of the manager to address certain creative needs — but often there seemed to be wilful refusal to change things up. The football equivalent of banging your head against a brick wall.

How refreshing then for an Everton manager to not only have options on the bench but to also have the courage to make significant changes regardless of the stage of the match. If Blues fans needed evidence of Ronald Koeman’s decisiveness, it came seven minutes before half-time of today’s game at The Hawthorns when he withdrew James McCarthy, threw on Romelu Lukaku, abandoned a three-man central defensive formation and, paved the way for a pulsating come-from-behind victory over West Brom.

Make no mistake, what had come before those vital alterations had been dreadfully ineffective from the Everton. With Lukaku held back on the bench because of a lack of match sharpness, Gerard Deulofeu had been tasked with leading the line in a central role, one that soon proved to well beyond him against Tony Pulis’s famously robust back line. The Spaniard had neither the physique nor the desire to use what weight he has to ruffle the likes of Jonas Olsson and Gareth McAuley and it meant Koeman’s side had almost no presence going forward.

Article continues below video content

By contrast, his opposite “number” at the other end, Salomon Rondon, the quintessential “big attacking unit” threatened a difficult afternoon in store for the Everton defence when he easily rolled Ramiro Funes Mori in the penalty in on the eighth minute to chest down, fire goal-wards and force the first of two excellent saves on the day from Maarten Stekelenburg.

And when the Dutch keeper ended up prone as the resulting corner was swung to the back post, impeded perhaps by the combination of Leighton Baines and Saido Berahino in front of him, McAuley rose largely unchallenged to head home a typical Pulis set-piece goal.

Everton’s response wasn’t encouraging. Operating in a narrow attacking unit, too much of their effort was foundering against the “West Brom wall” that frustrated Martinez on more than one occasion during his time at Goodison Park.

Deulofeu had shown an early flash of promise but mis-controlled an excellent Ross Barkley pass in the third minute that took away the chance to challenge Ben Foster one-on-one, his eventual centre prompting vain calls for a penalty on Barkley by Jacob for an apparent trip.

But the Spaniard was generally too willing to go to ground at the first hint of contact and he was a poor target for the direct balls pinged in his general direction from a midfield seemingly lacking in ideas and options. Barkley, meanwhile, was happy to lay off the safe pass in the interests of ball retention rather than daring to take men on in an attempt to make things happen.

It meant that with less than 10 minutes of the first half to go, Everton had had just one tame Gareth Barry shot from a Baines centre to show for their efforts going forward and the Baggies must have felt they were in for a fairly comfortable afternoon.

The arrival of Lukaku and the switch to 4-4-2 changed things almost immediately. The attack now had a focal point and Mason Holgate, accomplished and assured as a centre half, could now provide some width and penetration as a full back and the home defence suddenly had a lot more to worry about.

The tactical shift also created the conditions for the wonderful, quick passing interchange that carved West Brom open in first-half stoppage time, presenting Mirallas with the opportunity to score the equaliser. Gueye, Lukaku, Barkley and Jagielka all combined on the left side of the box before the Belgian forward was released in behind the back line by Barry and drilled a low shot across Foster and into the far corner.

Though Everton had controlled the possession in the first period, their more effective shape in the second afforded them more territorial dominance as well. And after Stekelenburg had done brilliantly to cover more poor defending by saving from Darren Fletcher, and Deulofeu had seen a shot come off the back post following a Mirallas header, Koeman’s men took the lead.

Mirallas was fouled by Olsson after he had robbed the Swede of the ball in a central area and when the resulting free kick was swung in, Funes Mori rose highest to power a header that looked destined for the top corner until Foster pawed it away for a corner. That set-piece delivery found Holgate whose volley bounced back towards the near post and Barry was on hand to nod inside the upright and send 2,800 Evertonians massed behind the goal into bedlam.

Koeman, who was already preparing the obvious change of Yannick Bolasie for Deulofeu, now had the platform of a lead on which to introduce his new signing and the ex-Palace winger might, with better finishing from his team-mates, have walked off with two assists to show for his first outing for Everton.

First, an impressive burst of acceleration took him away from Jonny Evans into space to whip in a right-footed cross that was inch-perfect for Barkley but he somehow headed half a yard wide of goal. Then, after smashing a shot of his own over the bar at the end of a surging run, he pulled the Baggies’ defence apart and slipped the ball in for Lukaku but Foster was off his line quickly to block the Belgian striker’s shot.

On either side of that latter chance, Ashley Williams came on to replace Mirallas to make his debut and the defensive resilience that the Toffees would need in the closing stages was exhibited first by Funes Mori as he charged down Ricky Lambert’s shot. Phil Jagielka then shut James McClean down as he tried to work an opening in close proximity to Stekelenburg’s goal, ultimately preventing the Irishman from getting any kind of shot off.

A final heart-stopping moment when Holgate was adjudged to have handled outside his own box and Foster came forward for the last set-piece of the game thankfully ended with Jagielka heading clear and the West Brom keeper half-volleying wide from the edge of the box with Stekelenburg scrambling across to cover.

As Koeman acknowledged after the match, The Hawthorns is never an easy place to come so to have not only take three points but to do so from a 1-0 deficit and the kind of position Pulis’s men love to have opponents in so they can shut up shop, was particularly impressive.

He was miffed that his side didn’t take their opportunities to kill West Brom off but there were plenty at the final whistle who felt that last season under the previous regime, Everton might well have buckled in those final stages.

With Koeman still feeling his way into his new job, his transfer business still not complete and some key players still not 100% fit, every point gained is a bonus. In that sense, this was a big result and one that bodes very well for a season that continues to shape up in very optimistic fashion.

Follow @EFCLyndon

Share article:

Reader Comments (27)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Bob Parrington
1 Posted 21/08/2016 at 07:14:42
Using Optus for the first time here in Australia, I watched the game live on the laptop.

Great turn around by the lads and good response by RK early on. This is the first game I've been able to watch this season and I must say that I was really impressed with young Holgate. Gueye too!. Still not a fan of Barkley, though.

Chris James
2 Posted 21/08/2016 at 07:34:57
Have to say that it really is so far so good for the Moshiri/RK era.

1. Solid management team in place?
Absolutely! We seem to have not panicked and held out for the men we wanted regardless of costs/difficulties.

2. Squad improvement?
Yes - Gueye looks good, Stekelenberg is a fine option (if not quite first place), Williams exactly the sort of leadership needed at the back and Bolassie an exciting attacking option. I'm pretty sure it's not over yet either and if the rumours about a Hart loan, Kone contract come to fruition plus we add another striker this could prove to have been one of our very best transfer windows.
On the flip side of course you also need to make sure you're pruning the squad of those surplus to requirements or potentially problematic. That too appears to be in process with Niasse and McGeady left in no uncertainty there isn't a future here, the Stones situation resolved pretty amazingly (I know opinion is divided but for me despite the ball-playing confidence I'm really not sure he is going to ever cut it as a top-level defender) and others let out on loan (the only things I disagree with really is the Gibson contract, Garbutt left on loan (must be something going on with his attitude because he looked great when he'd played before) and the fact A. Kone is still being considered as a first team option.

3. Tactical development?
Without doubt. This is the most satisfying thing for me not just because we've blasted a hole in the tippy tappy nonsense but that we have already in game 2 proved able to try different tactics (e.g. 3 man back-line) and crucially change them on the fly when they don't work, something Martinez and to a lesser extent Moyes both struggled with.

4. Improved Player Fitness/Attitude?
Getting there! We may only be at 70% at game one (80% now?) but this admission alone speaks volumes for what was allowed to happen under RM where much of Moyes 10 years of solid work on fitness and team unity was basically frittered away in a couple of Martinez seasons.

5. Honest, comprehensible communications?
Praise the lord. We seem to have a manager that actually watches the same matches we do and isn't afraid to be realistic whether it's about the chances of players staying/going or performance issues.

6. Results?
Ultimately it's the scores on the board that matter in the end and although it is super early, I think it's hard to be unhappy with a draw against a decent Spurs team and a win vs tricky and defensively tight Baggies on their patch.

Report card from me reads B+ overall.
Still super early days and room for improvement - we need to push these other signings over the line, find a new home for Niasse and McGeady and continue with performances/results against Stoke and Sunderland - but the right attitude and a very encouraging start that deserves a pat on the back.

Phillip Mark
3 Posted 21/08/2016 at 08:38:41
We've lost all our last ten games where we've gone a goal behind. Great to see we now have a manager with a Plan B for games.
Bobby Thomas
4 Posted 21/08/2016 at 09:17:11
Cover up top is in the shape of someone who can lead the line, net, and preferably has some pace in behind is ESSENTIAL. They do tend to be expensive though.

Due to the changes at the club this is a short transfer window for us. If we can't get a top player in, and with January being a tricky window, if push came to shove I'd be happy with something like Charlie Austin in. Knows the division, leads the line, knows where the net is, to get through the season. But we need something. Hopefully Walsh and Koeman can identify the player they want and we get it done.

Thank God Martinez was sacked. Not only was Niasse a total dud, but even if he hadn't have been totally useless, the type of player he was/is meant that he wouldn't even have been effective cover for Rom anyway, as he seems more of a support act/wide striker, so we still wouldn't have had direct Lukaku cover anyway. Clown. Manager not the player who I actually feel sorry for.

We need to sort that out. Mason Holgate may have solved the right back depth issue. I think we need to sort the options in mid, but other than that we are looking in reasonable shape for a good run at the European places now we havd someone professional in charge.

Finally, I can't see Koeman having Funes Mori. If we can get him off to Spain for no loss at some point in the next couple of windows that would be great.

John Crook
5 Posted 21/08/2016 at 09:25:32
Great assessment, Chris, and difficult to argue against. Let's hope we do manage to snare Kone, Hart and another striker as this will give us the resilience required to make an impact.

Unfortunately Deulofeu proving to be little more than a bit-part winger. He's been given the chance to prove himself so can't complain when he's moved aside. RK is utterly ruthless and has shown he will replace anybody if another option exists. The future's good, in fact it's very good.

John Codling
6 Posted 21/08/2016 at 09:44:03
Just refreshing to see a manager that makes the changes when things are not going to plan. This man at least watches the same match as the rest of us.
Trevor Lynes
7 Posted 21/08/2016 at 10:09:12
Bringing Lukaku on totally changed the game as he fully occupied the West Brom defenders.I am not convinced by Barkley though, I hope he has not yet reached his full potential as his place would be under threat if we signed a real play maker.Maybe he would be better as an impact sub as his stamina is still a problem IMO. Mirallas played well but Deulofeu did not have the strength to be a true front man. All the signings so far have been excellent and Bolasie is an exciting addition with his direct pace and strength.Having a few bob has made all the difference though and lets hope that Koeman continues to use it well and bring real optimism to the club and fans.
Jon Withey
8 Posted 21/08/2016 at 10:42:23
We seemed to have a lot more joy from set-pieces recently - who was taking them ?
Eric Holland
10 Posted 21/08/2016 at 11:53:13
"I'd be happy with something like Charlie Austin"

Those days are now over I would like to think.
No more championship quality journeymen for me.

Bobby Thomas
11 Posted 21/08/2016 at 13:19:27
Eric #10

Nice slight of hand Eric however the immediate words before those you shadily lifted from mid-sentence were:

"Due to the changes at the club this is a short transfer window for us. If we can't get a top player in, and with January being a tricky window, if push came to shove I'd be happy with something like Charlie Austin in."

Thats if we strike out on someone of better quality. Plus Austin is better than you make out.

Stan Schofield
12 Posted 21/08/2016 at 13:45:52
Austin, or any other player, is fine if (and only if) RK thinks he'd fit into his setup.
Michael Polley
13 Posted 21/08/2016 at 14:01:22
I think once our fitness levels are reached and Ronald brings in the other players he needs we could have a very good season.Like what I see and in young Holgate we've got a gem. COYB
Colin Glassar
14 Posted 21/08/2016 at 14:19:13
I think we might get in Hart and Kone this week which will sort out the defence leaving a creative MF player (I'd love us to gor for Cabaye) and another striker to find. Get these four players in and we will be a serious threat this season.

Btw, is that our Adam Forshaw playing for Middlesbrough? He's having a cracking game. Poor old ginger looks doomed already.

Jamie Barlow
15 Posted 21/08/2016 at 14:23:38

Absolute twat and not that good either.

Barry McNally
16 Posted 21/08/2016 at 14:25:08
Pienaar on as a sub for Sunderland - 'God Is Great'!
Colin Glassar
17 Posted 21/08/2016 at 14:29:02
He is and he is Jamie. Peanuts was one of my favourite Everton players of recent times Barry. I wish him all the best.
Anton Holmes
18 Posted 21/08/2016 at 14:36:01
The stepping "stones" to the next stage... building in style, the academy as well. Feeling quality positive.


12 months from now Coyb

Tony Abrahams
19 Posted 21/08/2016 at 14:38:17
That's fair enough Colin, but I think my little soft spot for anything Sunderland, has disappeared now that "THE DECEITFUL ONE" is now in-charge!

Shouldn't really feel like that I know, but Moyes, showed his true colours, once he got behind the desk at United, and it will always be the reason, I want the false fucker to fail!

Barry McNally
20 Posted 21/08/2016 at 14:38:17
Colin, agreed he was one of our best players in recent times but he's not PL quality now, certainly not Everton - he might prove me wrong. Worth putting in a cheeky bid for Fabregas?
Colin Glassar
21 Posted 21/08/2016 at 14:47:44
Oh I agree Barry, his time was up probably about two seasons ago. Fabregas is, like Jamie said, an absolute twat. Good player though when he's not cheating.
Barry McNally
22 Posted 21/08/2016 at 14:53:55
Different class to Cabaye. Doesn't look like he's part of Conte's plans - think he'd put us in Top 4. Fairly sure his wife is English so might be happy to move up north and be part of Operation Goodison.
Gareth Clark
23 Posted 21/08/2016 at 15:44:38
Schweinsteiger for £2 mil anyone?
Do we need him though?

L Kone

Which leaves us very very competitive:

Hart / Steklenberg // Hewelt

Coleman / Holgate // Browning
Kone / Jagielka // Pennington
Williams / FunesMori // Galloway
Baines / Oviedo // Garbutt

Idrissa / McCarthy // Gibson (Besic)
Barry / Davies // Cleverley

Deulofeu / Lennon // Tarashaj
Barkley / Ghezzal // Dowell
Mirallas / Bolasie // Grant

Lukaku / Chicarito // Kone (replace with a youngster ASAP)

Eric Holland
25 Posted 21/08/2016 at 19:42:03
Bobby #11
No slight of hand Just stating that I would not have deemed "someone like Charlie Austin" as good enough to play for the new Everton or any of the teams challenging for the top 6 places
But that's just my opinion..
Bob Parrington
26 Posted 21/08/2016 at 23:20:28
Please NO to Charlie. We've moved on!
Michael Farrelly
27 Posted 22/08/2016 at 02:59:54
I thought one head shaking negative from the game and there were not to many, was Oviado given a place on the bench in front of the obviously talented Tom Davies.

Agree we need a back - up for Rom probably Bony would be closest like for like available. I wondering about the option of Wesley Schneider as well realise his best years are behind him but he would be a great mentor for Ross over the next two seasons.
Brian Furey
28 Posted 22/08/2016 at 10:26:36
Looks like Bony will be going to China in January with a possible loan move for him from West Ham now until then. I think a lot of fans underestimate what a good striker we have in Lukaku. When I go to matches I also get very frustrated with him but if you look through the league and abroad there are not that many options that are better than him. For too long we had strikers who yes work hard for the team but didn't score enough goals. In his first year with us he scored 16 in total, then 20 goals in 2015 and last season 25 in all competitions. He played in 37 league games last year and 36 the year before. Look at how many games other strikers miss through injury.
RK as we have seen is no mug and doesn't put up with much nonsense but he knows Rom is worth giving some leeway to as goal scoring strikers are hard to come by as we will see when buying our next one.
Paul Hay
29 Posted 22/08/2016 at 14:00:43
Great article Lyndon. Summed it up extremely well and I think your last paragraph hit the proverbial nail.

Keep the faith.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.

About these ads

© ToffeeWeb