Season › 2024-25 › News Everton player ratings vs Wolves Anjishnu Roy 09/03/2025 23comments | Jump to last Everton extended their unbeaten run in the Premier League to eight matches, the longest for the club since February 2017 following a 1-1 draw with Wolverhampton Wanderers at Molineux Stadium. Jack Harrison grabbed his first goal of the season but the Blues saw Marshall Munetsi score at the other end as both sides settled for a point. Following a third draw in succession, Everton climbed up to 14th in the table and are on 33 points – level with Tottenham Hotspur, Manchester United, and West Ham but all three sides will be in action later. However, the Blues have a better goal difference compared to the latter two. Everton surged ahead at the 33rd-minute mark when Harrison trapped the ball on the left-hand side following a pass from Jesper Lindstrom, drove ahead and his shot took a couple of deflections before finding its way into the back of the net. This was the winger’s first goal in 39 appearances but joy was short-lived for the Blues. The hosts found an immediate response as Munetsi was played through in behind the defence by Jean-Ricner Bellegarde and the Zimbabwe international beat Jordan Pickford with his first touch to level proceedings. The second half was a rather subdued affair compared to the extravaganza of the first 45 minutes. Bar the few odd chances mostly created through Carlos Alcaraz coming off the bench, both sides seemed content with a point and the match fizzled out to a draw. Everton will now turn their sights toward facing West Ham at home next weekend. Here are the player ratings from the 1-1 draw at Molineux: Jordan Pickford - 6 Pickford was called into action early on when he had to parry away Munetsi’s far post header from a corner after the Zimbabwean was left completely unmarked. There’s not a whole lot Pickford could’ve done to avoid the goal after he was left exposed by the defence. Distribution was clean throughout the game. Jake O’Brien - 6 He showed plenty of intensity to constantly move up and down the pitch but was pushed back to focus on his defensive duties as the game crept on. Was wasteful with the ball on a few occasions. James Tarkowski - 8 Used his giant frame well and plucked everything out of the air. Tarkowski led the defence with composure and also made vital blocks, including keeping out Rayan Ait-Nouri’s shot. Also won the header from a possession turnover that eventually led to Harrison’s goal. Jarrad Branthwaite - 5 Branthwaite was put in a tough spot as he struggled to sort his feet out and failed to cover Munetsi’s run in behind him that led to the Wolves equaliser. Besides the error, he read the game well and won a majority of his defensive duels. Vitaliy Mykolenko - 6 Mykolenko also failed to close the space that allowed Munetsi’s run in behind the defence and should’ve shown greater awareness in that situation. Defended well when called upon but wasn’t too involved in the game. Idrissa Gana Gueye - 8 Was once again the fulcrum for the Everton side and performed a tidy task in the engine room. Won seven tackles and kept things ticking with intensity. James Garner - 6 While industrious in the middle of the park, Garner failed to influence the game much on either end. Didn’t offer a lot of defensive resilience and set-piece deliveries were not up to the mark either. Jesper Lindstrom - 7 Lindstrom picked up his first Premier League assist of the season when he lifted his head up to find Harrison in acres of space on the left flank. Struggled to get involved in the second half and was subbed off for Iroegbunam after 63 minutes. Abdoulaye Doucoure - 6 Doucoure could’ve put Everton ahead just after 10 minutes when he found the ball in the box, spun around Doherty and fired a left-footed shot but it blocked by the defence. Recalled into the side after missing the Brentford match due to the birth of his son, Doucoure led the press well but the game passed him by on several occasions and was taken off after half-time. Jack Harrison - 8 Harrison finally grabbed his first goal of the season for the Blues with a strong shot that took a couple of deflections before entering the goal. It was one of his brightest displays in a while as his direct runs and exchanges caused headaches for the opposition defence. Beto - 5 Beto was guilty of missing a couple of chances in this game as well. While none as straightforward as the ones against Brentford, he failed to stretch his body from a corner routine in the first half. Was played through by Alcaraz in the second half and despite opening his body up a la Thierry Henry, his shot lacked conviction and was saved by Jose Sa. Subs Carlos Alcaraz (for Doucoure) - 7 David Moyes perhaps missed a trick by not starting Alcaraz after his impressive run in recent weeks. Made a lively cameo and was full of running to capitalise on tired legs in the second half. Created a chance for Beto after leading a strong counter attack and also drew a save off Sa after a lovely dummy to fool his markers inside the box. Tim Iroegbunam (for Lindstrom) - 6 Made a reckless foul on Doherty that saw him get on the referee’s book and had little impact on the game besides that. Ashley Young (for Garner) - N/A Came on for the final few minutes. Matchday Updates Reader Comments (23) Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer () Paul Ferry 1 Posted 09/03/2025 at 09:07:55 Seriously, Anjishnu, you need to firmly limit your erm 'official' appearances on here and let Michael take over.Your player ratings with no real feel for us will be ignored by most of us;I know you mean well, but, erm, ,,'the extravaganza of the first 45 minutes'And, WTF, Jake OBrien – 6 - erm 8Jesper Lindstrom 7 – erm 5Jack Harrison – 8 LLOLLOL 5Jarrad Branthwaite – 5 - 6/7AND ERM MOM GUEYE who was yours?Please stop giving us your player ratings because you have no skill or knowledge to do so. Michael Kenrick Editorial Team 2 Posted 09/03/2025 at 09:33:22 Ignore him, Anjishnu — you are doing a far better job at it than I would. I am far too critical: for me, they all start on a 3 and maybe get to 4 or 5 if they actually do anything worthwhile… Alcaraz was my MotM with a 6 for the only moment of decent footballing skill on offer all night. But then he spoilt it by shooting straight at Sa when a little more guile was needed. Jim Bennings 3 Posted 09/03/2025 at 10:16:04 Alcaraz was the best player.Most of the others I'd give a 5 to.Nobody was absolutely horrendous, but nobody was anything better than a 5.We looked a far greater threat when Charly came on — which is pretty much what we expected. Tommy Gourlay 4 Posted 09/03/2025 at 10:24:32 Paul (#1) – You know that Lyndon who used to do the post-match reports is gone from this site?If Anjishnu didn't write this then no one would and player ratings – like when Paul Trail has done them – have always been debated in the comments sections.I'm just grateful Anjishnu is taking the time and effort to write these articles. Keith Gleave 5 Posted 09/03/2025 at 11:07:37 My view was a poor first half, slightly better second but tailed off. They looked tired and leggy after the warm weather training.My MotM was Gueye, he was everywhere, although he did commit some silly fouls.It was like watching a Dyche game, pumping the ball upfield with no pace whatsoever.Alcaraz should have come on far earlier for Doucoure who was non-existent. Beto was literally on his own again. Ian Burns 6 Posted 09/03/2025 at 11:21:58 My concern watching this game, is that it looked for all the world as if Dyche was still in charge. I hope that was just a tired one-off because I have been both delighted and surprised at Moyes's impact since his return.Gueye was as good as anybody and better than most but Alcaraz looked a cut above the rest when he came on.Just one further comment in that I'm glad TW is alive and well after the recent changes. All the usual suspects still posting, which is great to see and read. Jerome Shields 7 Posted 09/03/2025 at 11:41:49 Anjishnu's rating are a reference point for discussions. I haven't come across anyone's rating that resulted in100% agreement. Experience of the last 30 years deducts 2 points off all the players to start with.I thought the goal was more a team lack of focus rather than the contribution of a player mistake. This is known as a weak area after scoring. Paul Hewitt 8 Posted 09/03/2025 at 12:07:16 PF@1. Anyone can give an opinion, if you agree or not that's up to you. No need to be rude mate. Mark Murphy 9 Posted 09/03/2025 at 12:15:56 Bit harsh that, PF even for a grumpy puss like you. He's new to this - give him a chance. Keep going, Anji baby - you'll get there about ish sooner or later.On saying that… Some of your marks are way off in my opinion, and I agree with PF on that score.I also agree with him that Gana Gueye, whilst not at his best, was MotM. Special mention too for Jake O'Brien, who is fast becoming my new personal favourite and could be our next Seamus – must be an Irish thing…Can't wait to see Alcaraz and Ndiaye in the same team, possibly with Dwight McNeil all supplying and playing of a rejuvenated and re-motivated Calvert-Lewin.And those who see the ghost of Dyche in even that poor performance yesterday have got short memories. We still showed much more attacking intent than under him. Paul O'Neill 10 Posted 09/03/2025 at 14:45:17 Good, concise report and well argued opinions Anjishnu. The first poster really needs to settle down and stop being so needlessly sneering and rude to a fellow Blue, and someone who has given up their time to write a report. As someone with limited technical knowledge of the game, but who loves it, I like a concise, well explained report. Danny O'Neill 11 Posted 09/03/2025 at 15:00:28 We're not always going to agree on player ratings. They are there to be discussed as we will all have a different take on the match.I thought Gana was by far our best player in an uninspiring game of football. When I look back, £7m off the then relegated Aston Villa measured against the value he's added over the seasons in some poor Everton teams in difficult times speaks volumes.Branthwaite wasn't at the consistent standard we've become accustomed to by the expectation he has set. But one game shouldn't judge any player. He's a star and one for the future.And when General Tarkowski starts feeling the legs, I look forward was to seeing O'Brien alongside Jarrad.By the way, for a moment, I thought Tarkowski was going to go all Duncan Ferguson on that Wolves striker last night!! Colin Glassar 12 Posted 09/03/2025 at 15:20:44 Pickers - 6OBrien - 8Tarks - 6Branners - 6Myko - 6Gana - 7Garner - 6Lindstrom - 4Doucoure- 3Harrison - 4Beto - 2Alcaraz - 6Tim - 4Leicester and spurs both losing. God is a Blue.Youre welcome. Sean Kearns 13 Posted 09/03/2025 at 15:30:41 An 8 for Harrisson 🤣 🤣 I want some of what the AI robot is smoking! He was about a 4-5 lets get real. The shot took 2 deflections!!… I cant work out what ToffeeWeb has become. Never ever ever ever under estimate the size and scale of the premier league. The know weve been unhappy the last few years and Im sure the league has been keeping an eye on our fan boards. What with the whole 40,000 people holding up cards at goodison saying “you dont know what your doing premier league”… that wasnt a good look for them and I knew from that point forth we would be under surveillance. Somebody has acquired ToffeeWeb and outsourced all the jobs to India, just as many large companies do these days 🤔 this is wank now. Modern Football Suppresses Emotion…”They” are using the worlds biggest sport as a tool to suppresses the masses emotions. Christy Ring 14 Posted 09/03/2025 at 16:26:52 Let's be honest, we all vary in players ratings, for me, Harrison 4,Beto 4 Doucoure 4, but I find it hard, that some thought it was a Dyche like performance, we did have chances, and players did go forward, which wouldn't happen under Sean. Ged Simpson 15 Posted 09/03/2025 at 16:49:34 Paul. let's see you write the next few! As a trained journo, it is never easy and on a football site, even harder.But often the job is to trigger response. Positive or negative hardly matters...both are readers.So well done Anjishnu Roy with the first response!The game.Bit dull but we are all a bit like kiddies after Dyche era.Player of the match?Oh who cares. Team game.aa Brian Williams 16 Posted 09/03/2025 at 16:57:02 Sean#13.Good one Sean, that made me laugh. 👍🤣 Robert Williams 17 Posted 09/03/2025 at 18:03:46 I suppose these new fellas are trying. I'm sure Mr Ferry finds them trying!!Still it could be worse - I remember listening to the Howard Winston v Salvadar fight in the '60s. It was some meatball called Raymond Glendening I think was commentating and had Winston an odds on winner according to his card – only to find that his card bore no relation to reality.Do we have the same problem here, Houston? Mike Gaynes 18 Posted 09/03/2025 at 18:37:22 Robert #17, I believe Raymond Glendenning was something of a BBC legend. Horse racing commentary and a big black mustache. Mark Dunford 19 Posted 09/03/2025 at 18:50:51 Ratings are always up for discussion, but I find them really reductive; a hostage to fortune and a trigger for stupidity. Beto has missed a few chances recently yet his attitude remains exemplary. Can he have more than one number? I was at Palace and I can't recall seeing a player – for any team – work harder than Beto did that day. He knows his own limitations and his attributes. We need to support the latter whilst acknowledging the former. He'll score again – my guess is that will come just when Broja or Calvert-Lewin are on the cusp – and that will challenge Moyes.Pickford made two excellent saves and we're in danger of taking his seemingly endless ability to do this for granted.Alcaraz also looks like he could be a star turn.Given the position a couple of months ago, Moyes and his players have done a remarkable job. Dave Abrahams 20 Posted 09/03/2025 at 18:56:25 Mike (18), Raymond Glendening was very famous in his day as a radio commentator after the war until the early sixties he was involved in horse racing, as you say, but better known for his boxing, football, including many FA Cup Finals, and tennis commentaries and his huge moustache! Paul Ferry 21 Posted 09/03/2025 at 18:57:31 Ged S, I'd love that job. Happy to oblige. Agree though, I was harsh and in a bit of a strump/strop for another reason, so my apologies to Anjishnu. Pickford 6 O'Brien 8 Branthwaite 6 (7?) Tarkowski 7 Mylolenko 6 Gana 8 (MotM) Garner 6 Lindstrom 4 Harrison 5 Doucoure 5 Beto 5 Rod Harrington 23 Posted 09/03/2025 at 19:15:26 PF (21)Which game did you watch? Paul Ferry 24 Posted 09/03/2025 at 19:16:22 Wolves through my fingers Rod. Who was I harsh on? Add Your Comments In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site. » Log in now Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site. How to get rid of these ads and support TW © ToffeeWeb