Good Signs in the Undergrowth

Martin O'Connor 18/10/2018 14comments  |  Jump to last
Following the Premier League 2 Title in 2016-17, Everton’s Under-23 squad had a season of transition in 2017-18, finishing 7th in the 12-team league. A number of reasons contributed to this mid-table finish.

Firstly, a number of the players in the title-winning team moved on to the first team squad. Tom Davies, for example, became a first team regular in the second half of the 2016-17. Jonjoe Kenny and Beni Baningime – mainstays of the title-winning team – were promoted to the first team squad during 2017-18. Dominic Calvert-Lewin, and Ademola Lookman also flitted between the first team and the Under-23s, Calvert-Lewin cementing a first-team spot on a number of occasions along with Mason Holgate.

Secondly, a batch of players from the title-winning team were sent out on loan in 2017-18, Kieran Dowell (Nottingham Forest), Joe Williams (Barnsley), Antonee Robinson, Harry Charsley (both Bolton Wanderers), Matthew Pennington (Leeds United), while Liam Walsh was sold in January 2018 to Bristol City. Robinson, Walsh and Pennington are again out on loan this season at Wigan Athletic, Bolton Wanderers and Ipswich Town along with Callum Connolly also at Wigan.

Thirdly, the Club signed a batch of young players in the Summer 2017, Josh Bowler from QPR, Boris Mathias from Metz, Nathangelo Markelo from FC Volendam, Lewis Gibson from Newcastle United and Dennis Adeniran from Fulham.

Finally, we had the Under 23 Manager David Unsworth taking charge of the first time on a temporary basis in the interregnum between the sacking of Ronald Koeman and the appointment of Sam Allardyce, which disrupted the work of the Under-23s.

In essence, we had a title-winning team which had lost a number of players promoted to the first team squad or sent out on loan, while also bringing in a number of young players, who at such a young age would take time bedding in at there new club. When you add to the mix David Unsworth disappearing to the first team for a period following the sacking of Koeman, it is clear the Under-23s would find it difficult to hit the heights of the 2016-17 season. Losing Captain Morgan Feeney and Denis Adeniran to injury in the second half of the season also did not help. All in all the 7th place position which the team finished in 2017-18, reflects the great change which had taken place following the title-winning season.

The gaps created by the loss of a number of players during 2017-18 did have its plus points. During the season, a number of the Under-18s squad were given game time for the Under-23s. Con Ouzounidis, Alex Denny, Anthony Gordon, Michael Collins, and Fraser Hornby all stepped up to the Under-23s and acquitted themselves well at points during the 2017-18 season. Most supporters will have gained at least one look at these players, as a number of the Under 18’s and Under-23s got first team experience in the dead rubber Europa League 3-0 win at Apollon Limassol in December 2017.

As the season progressed a number of players brought to the Club in the Summer started to improve. Nathangelo Markelo, who was brought in to take the place of Benni Baningimme, was played out of position at right-back for virtually the whole season, were he did well. Only in the second half of the penultimate game of the season against Liverpool and in the final game away at Manchester United was he played, and very impressively, in the midfield position he was originally signed for.

Midfielder Denis Adeniran started to show signs of progress before his season was cut short by injury, while in the last couple of months of the season, winger Josh Bowler started to show the promise he was brought to the Club for. Add to this the good form from Anthony Evans and Morgan Feeney (until his season was cut short), and it could be seen, that for 2018-19 season, David Unsworth had the seeds of a good team.

Which leads us to the start of the 2018-19 Under-23s season. As this is written every team has played seven games, Everton stand top of the league from Arsenal on goal difference having won four drawn two and lost one of there opening seven games. Next up in the league is a top of the table clash away at Arsenal on 22 October.

Added to the league form are the results in the International Cup, a 2-2 draw at Brighton and Hove Albion and a 2-0 home win against Benfica, with Bayern Munich still to play in December, plus a 3-0 win over Doncaster Rovers in the Premier League Cup. The only reverse so far in cup games has been the opening group stage Checkatrade Trophy defeat at Bradford City, were after a 1-1 draw, Bradford equalising with virtually the last kick of the match with Everton down to ten men, we went down in a penalty shoot-out.

Clearly, the season of transition in 2017-2018 is now bearing fruit. A new batch of promising youngsters are emerging. Josh Bowler, Nathangelo Markelo and Dennis Adeniran, after a season at the Club, are starting to show real form this season, while stalwarts Morgan Feeney, Anthony Evans, Nathan Broadhead, Harry Charsley and Matty Foulds are putting in good performances and Bassala Sambou is improving up front.

The name on most Evertonians lips though is Fraser Hornby. Moved up from the Under-18s during last season, Hornby is a centre-forward who probably in stature most resembles Duncan Fergusson. He led the line well for Scotland’s Under 21’s during the Summers Toulon Tournament and scored five goals in two games for Scotland’s Under-21s in October. He has even been mentioned by some Scottish pundits for a call up to the full national team. Unfortunately, due to an ankle injury he will be out for the next two months, which is a blow to the Under-23s.

Meanwhile further below Paul Tait’s Under-18s have started the season in devastating fashion winning the first seven league games before being held to a 3-3 draw at home to West Bromwich Albion in their eighth game. The Under-18s are a point clear on top of the league from the shower across the park. At such a young age there is still a lot of learning for these youngsters to do, but centre-back Ryan Astley, who played at Sunderland for the Under-23s last season, looks a real prospect while Ellis Simms is banging in goals for fun.

The first aim of any Academy is to produce players for the first team, results are secondary to this. In the last few years we have seen Tom Davies, Jon jo Kenny, Benni Baningimme and recruits Mason Holgate and Dominic Calvert-Lewin become part of the first team squad while Ademola Lookman and Kieran Dowell are now also on the fringes of the first team.

After a season of transition, the start of this season seems to point to a batch of young players in the Under-23 squad who may have a chance at the Club, while also hopefully having a good chance at winning some silverware this season. When one sees the talent making its way in the Under-18s as well, it seems clear that the Everton Academy system is still in good health. Both the Under-23s and the Under-18s may actually have a chance of winning some silverware this season, which if not the first priority is always nice and something to aim for.

Share this article



Reader Comments (14)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
1 Posted 18/10/2018 at 18:33:54
Great write-up on the Everton Academy, Martin. Much appreciated.

I have updated our season records for both the Under-23s and the Under-18s, with line-ups and brief match details on all the games so far this season.

Ellis Simms and Kieran Phillips seem to be the ones tearing things up for the Under-18s — 17 goals between them so far!!!

Dave Abrahams
2 Posted 18/10/2018 at 18:44:00
Good post, Martin, with plenty of very useful information, although the young Brazillian we signed from Charlton Athletic is not mentioned... I can't think of his name at the moment.

And it is Joe Williams who has gone on loan to Bolton this season, not Liam Walsh.

Steve Ferns
3 Posted 18/10/2018 at 18:48:45
Tony Abrahams
4 Posted 18/10/2018 at 19:04:17
Does this Under-18 squad have a lot of former England schoolboy internationals in its ranks?
Martin Nicholls
5 Posted 18/10/2018 at 19:37:00
As others have said, excellent and very informative article, Martin – thanks to you (and all other TW contributors) for taking the time and making the effort to write it.
Mike Gaynes
7 Posted 18/10/2018 at 22:50:14
Thank you, Martin. Terrific summary, much appreciated.

By the way, Liam Walsh's January move to the Championship has not launched the young man's career at all. He made only eight appearances for Bristol City in the second half of last season, with no goals or assists.

This season he has been named among their subs in all 12 league games, but without even one minute of play. His sole first-team appearance was a League Cup start against Plymouth back in August. Other than that, his only action has been for their U-23s.

Dave Abrahams
8 Posted 19/10/2018 at 15:14:36
Steve (3) thanks for that. I wrote his name down but can't find it. Remember the name: Pedro Neves... now where have I heard that before.
Michael Kenrick
9 Posted 19/10/2018 at 16:02:09
That one caught me out, Dave.

Turns out he has not even been on the subs bench yet for the Under-18s. Fingers crossed he'll be a good'un!

Alasdair Mackay
10 Posted 19/10/2018 at 16:45:07
History dictates that 2-3 members of each successful young team will progress to the first team. 20 years ago it was Hibbert and Osman. In the interim Rooney appeared, then disappeared.

From the 2017 title winners it looks as though Jonjoe Kenny and Tom Davies are going to be the ones, with an outside chance for Joe Williams, Keiran Dowell and Beni Baningime.

So we should be looking at this very strong youth team as an entirely different set of prospects and pat the club on the back for producing 2 good youth teams so close to one another.

My heart would like Feeney and Hornby to kick on, as they look like 'proper Everton players', and they are in key positions for the spine of the team, but in all honesty if we can produce 4-5 first teamers from 3 youth seasons combined, that is a very good sign that we are motoring in the right direction.

Brent Stephens
11 Posted 19/10/2018 at 16:45:58
Really good article. I feel sorry for young Liam Walsh. He was a favourite of mine.
Paul Ellam
12 Posted 19/10/2018 at 19:14:20
Great post.

Always good to read about our other teams, especially when they are doing so well!

Steve Ferns
13 Posted 19/10/2018 at 19:43:02
Michael, Pedro Neves was on the bench last season. Maybe he’s been injured? He looked a prospect on YouTube and seems to be a fast and tricksy left winger.
Michael Kenrick
14 Posted 20/10/2018 at 06:24:32
Thanks for that, Steve. I thought I had most of the games documented but I guess there's a handful where I never got the full teamsheets.

They have short video highlights of those games but I'm not good enough to identify all the players by sight.

Michael Kenrick
15 Posted 20/10/2018 at 23:10:07
I finally found what must have spiked your interest in Neves: his performances in the CEE Cup in Prague back in July. For some reason, I completely missed these, but there are actually (almost) full-length videos of all four Everton matches in the competition, and Neves was exceptional in the first one, which we lost 1-3 to Slavia Prague, but he set up the goal.

He also played in the last match, the 5th-place decider, which we lost 1-0 to Sparta Prague. I haven't watched that one yet.

Links and match details can be found here for anyone interested: Under-19s CEE Cup

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


© ToffeeWeb