Season › 2024-25 › News “The first half was not one we’d like to remember” – James Garner after defeat to Wolves Anjishnu Roy 24/09/2025 20comments | Jump to last James Garner was one of the few standout players for Everton in their dismal 2-0 defeat to Wolverhampton Wanderers, leading to an exit in the third round of the EFL Cup. Accepting the poor first half played by his side at Molineux, Garner says he’s “more than certain” Everton can bounce back from their disappointing cup exit. The 24-year-old was only one of four players with continuity from the Toffees’ previous outing against Liverpool at Anfield with David Moyes making seven changes to his side. It resulted in a terrible first half where the Blues failed to exert their authority on a hapless Wolves side and instead, conceded a goal at the half-hour mark when Marshall Munetsi converted from close range. “We weren't at the levels we've shown at the start of the season, especially the first half,” Garner told evertontv. “The first half was not a first half we'd like to remember. Both goals were goals that we could have easily avoided. “We just weren’t at the races tonight. I think when we brought the subs on, we were a much better team, and we looked like we could maybe go on and get something out of the game. “But then, obviously, the second goal goes in and then the game's kind of closed from there. But, yes, I know we need to do better.” Moyes brought on his usual suspects quickly in the second half, but with Wolves defending deep, they couldn’t fashion out an opening. Tolu Arokodare delivered the sucker-punch just minutes before the final whistle, securing the Blues’ exit from one of their two probable chances at silverware this season. Believing Wolves’ second goal involved a foul on him in the buildup, Garner added, “Their second goal was a foul on me. He's literally stood on my kneecap. “I'm not going to go down that easy, but the referee’s mentioned something about it. We were chasing the game and then they go and get the second, so it is tough. “The fact we were so on top in the second half, and like I said, we could have nicked a goal or nicked two goals, gone on to the next round, but I think it all started from the first half. “We weren't good enough; we allowed them to get into their flow and that should have been us.” Despite the bitter disappointment that has sunk in following Everton’s exit from the cup competition, it’s tough to overlook Garner’s positive start to the season. He was the standout player for Moyes’s side at Molineux as well and came the closest to restoring parity. Garner’s free-kick struck the crossbar in the second half and he also brought out a good save off Sam Johnstone from a long-range strike. “I think I played alright tonight,” he explained. “I still need to keep on improving, keep on doing better. I need to start scoring more, I need to start creating more, as well. “There's always room for improvement. There's a lot of positives to take, but we just need to put this behind us now and focus on the league, and that's the most important game.” Everton players will now turn their attention towards West Ham United on Monday night. Returning in front of their home fans at Hill Dickinson Stadium could help the side restore their earlier confidence after consecutive setbacks at Anfield and Molineux over the last few days. Reader Comments (20) Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer () Andy Meighan 1 Posted 24/09/2025 at 18:46:04 I wouldn't say anyone was a standout player.Every last one of them was shite. The trouble is defeat doesn't hurt our players enough... and this isn't a new thing; this has gone on for donkey's years.After all Garner has said there, I didn't see an apology to the magnificent support (yet again), you know the lads and girls who most would have had to have taken time off work to go and see that lot put in another shitshow.Moyes should come out and apologise to the fans actually but I won't hold my breath.Our players, and this has gone on for years dont give a flying one about our support. In fact, reading what Garner said, there it was: all me, me, me.I'll tell you, James, you're not really that good, not at all, but because the manager blew smoke up your arse a couple of weeks back you all of a sudden think you're Zidane.Sick of you treating our support with contempt, you dont deserve us. Andy Crooks 2 Posted 24/09/2025 at 19:02:43 Ah, Garner's turn. Paul Hewitt 3 Posted 24/09/2025 at 19:13:58 The second half wasn't much bloody better. Mike Connolly 4 Posted 24/09/2025 at 19:35:40 is this the same half as leeds and liverpool game James to be fair Garner was one of our better players last night Jim Bennings 5 Posted 24/09/2025 at 19:54:14 Copy and paste from Saturday night?Where have we heard that before Christy Ring 6 Posted 24/09/2025 at 20:14:44 Moyes gave players who have been on the bench, and had limited Premiership minutes, a chance last night, and they didn't perform up to scratch, I would question Coleman starting, with two left backs on the bench, totally the wrong decision, but Wolves made more changes than us? Mike Hayes 7 Posted 24/09/2025 at 20:22:27 Well they should be reminded of it so it never happens again 🤷💙 Jay Harris 8 Posted 24/09/2025 at 20:38:44 Its not one I would like to remember either Jimmy.The last few games have seen us start on the back foot. We had better start on the front foot against West Ham if we want to regain any pride. Mick O'Malley 9 Posted 24/09/2025 at 20:40:19 I must have watched a different game, we had more of the ball second half but we created absolutely nothing again, a decent start to the season doesn't involve losing 3 times in 7 games, we've played well in patches but I honestly can't remember the last time we absolutely dominated a game, we still give up plenty of chances, last night was shocking especially the first half Paul Kernot 10 Posted 24/09/2025 at 21:29:44 We've been here before haven't we? Roll out one of the players to repeat what we all know. I remember it well from school too 'must do better'. James Hughes 11 Posted 25/09/2025 at 02:10:48 Well Mr Garner I think it does need to be remembered so we don't keep having groundhog day, Derek Thomas 12 Posted 25/09/2025 at 07:40:51 'First halfs' are invariably, down to the Manager who picks players A,B,C, to go out and do XYZ.Meet the new Boss (2.0) - same as the old Boss (1.0)?? Jeff Spiers 13 Posted 25/09/2025 at 09:17:38 Derek@12. Could not agree more. But, and it is only my opinion, what about senior players seeing that some plans are not working and "tweeking" the boss's instructions a little. Or would that be seen as a no goer?? Ashley Krotosky 14 Posted 25/09/2025 at 10:40:55 I guess I must be naive to think that back up players would wish to make their appearances and impacts successful, not only to challenge for PL selection, but also to maximise chances of getting further starts in subsequent rounds. And at this rate we'll be using Keane as an emergency CF again, once JB has returned - whenever that is. Jack Convery 15 Posted 25/09/2025 at 16:04:55 As Catherine Tates' nan used to say - "Here we go". Sorry Mr Garner, not listening. We've heard it all before but it keeps happening - EVERY YEAR ! You can beat WHU 6 nil for all I care. Evertonians deserve a trophy asap. Last Tuesday at Wolves proved the Manager and the squad players don't give a flying f*ck. Martin Farrington 16 Posted 25/09/2025 at 16:38:52 The same worn out recording played over and over again."We just weren't at the races tonight."Fu koff Garner.There is 0 excuse at all. For a professional footballer at this prestigious and elite standard to not be in the mood, to not be chomping on the bit and get out there and show what he is about is disgraceful.I played at an ok amateur level. If someone didnt put a shift in they were chewed out by the captain, and if still no effort, the players.You didnt dare let your mates down for effort.All of them, including Saturdays tossers, should parade in front of the fans at the next home game, 20 minutes before kick off, with "I LET YOU DOWN" emblazoned on tshirts.I include Moyes and all the staff. Then no one allowed back into the dressing room at half time and sit down like naughty school boys. Banned from any use of phones or social media.Clean the U21's boots.In every day at the training ground for a month for 12 hours. Doing menial tasks outside of whatever Moyes calls training.Get a minute glimpse of what putting a shift in means.Then next time when a cup comes around, they might, just might 'be at the races'. Jimmy Carr 17 Posted 25/09/2025 at 17:00:23 Martin (16) why don't you send them down the mines while you're at it? At weekends after they've spent 60 hours in training all week! Martin Farrington 18 Posted 25/09/2025 at 17:20:21 I would but Thatcher cemented them all in, master of mirth @ 17I know Escape rooms. No, we'd never see them again. For a few that wouldn't be such a bad thing.They clearly aren't arsed enough to put in 45 minutes of hard work.And there is no excuse. Except if you are a pro footballer, it seems.Training is a breeze. If you watch it on YouTube, and they do a half day. Whoop woo! God forbid they break a sweat day in day out. Ok Jimmy. I will now put my "Winning Management the Brian Clough Way" book back on the dusty shelf and get out Woke. The Footballers Friend.Now where's the cotton wool sheets. Billy Shears 19 Posted 25/09/2025 at 21:25:25 Just like the Derby game then eh...jeez! Bob Boote 20 Posted 25/09/2025 at 21:46:18 And the Leeds game Billy! Add Your Comments In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site. » Log in now Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site. How to get rid of these ads and support TW © ToffeeWeb